Blog

Why are my health premiums pre-tax, and how much does that save me?

How a Section 125 cafeteria plan takes your premium share out before income and payroll taxes, a worked example of the savings, and when the rules differ.

Look at a pay stub and you will often see the health premium listed under "pre-tax deductions" or marked with a code. That label means the money came out of your pay before income tax and payroll tax were figured, so you are taxed on a smaller wage. The legal mechanism is a Section 125 cafeteria plan, named for the section of the tax code that allows it. It is one of the few places where the tax code treats your own money more kindly because of how you route it.

This post explains how that mechanism works, what it saves in an example with invented round numbers, why you usually cannot change it mid-year, what shows up on your W-2, and why the self-employed and marketplace buyers get different treatment. For a repeatable calculation with your own pay, the companion worksheet how much do pretax payroll deductions really save on my health premium? walks through it step by step.

What a Section 125 plan is

A cafeteria plan lets an employer offer employees a choice between taking pay in cash or taking certain benefits, such as health insurance premiums. Because the employee could have taken cash but chose a qualified benefit, the tax code lets the benefit be excluded from taxable wages if the plan follows written rules. Most employers that offer group health coverage run one, often as a "premium only" plan that does nothing except convert your share of the premium into a pretax deduction.

The same umbrella usually covers other benefits:

  • dental and vision premiums;
  • a health FSA and a dependent-care FSA;
  • payroll contributions to an HSA, when the employer offers that route.

Your employer's share of the premium is not a pretax deduction. It is a business expense paid on top of your wages, and it never enters your pay. A Section 125 plan affects only the part you pay.

Which taxes it reduces

Three taxes are generally affected:

  1. Federal income tax. Your taxable wages drop by the premium, so the income tax withheld and owed drops as well.
  2. Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes (FICA). These are normally 6.2% and 1.45% of your wages, together 7.65%, and a Section 125 deduction generally reduces the wages they apply to. This is a large part of why the saving is bigger than many people expect.
  3. State income tax, in most states. Some states do not follow the federal treatment for some benefits, so your state's tax agency or your payroll department can say how yours works.

Your employer also saves the employer-side payroll tax on those wages, which is one reason employers like running the plan. That is neutral information, not a criticism; it explains why the plan is almost always offered.

A worked example (invented numbers)

Say Jordan, a hypothetical employee, earns $60,000 a year and pays $250 a month toward a health plan, which is $3,000 a year. The figures below are illustrations chosen to be round.

Assume a 12% federal marginal income tax rate, and 7.65% for payroll tax. Ignore state tax for now.

Line Amount
Annual wages $60,000
Pretax premium $3,000
Wages subject to income and payroll tax $57,000
Federal income tax saved ($3,000 times 12%) $360.00
Payroll tax saved ($3,000 times 7.65%) $229.50
Total tax saved $589.50
Net cost of the premium ($3,000 minus $589.50) $2,410.50

So the $3,000 premium reduces Jordan's take-home pay by about $2,410, because the tax system returns about 20 cents on each dollar of premium.

Change one input and the answer moves. At an assumed 22% federal marginal rate, the income tax saved would be $660 ($3,000 times 22%), the payroll tax saved would still be $229.50, and the total would be $889.50. If Jordan's state taxes income at an assumed 4%, add $120 ($3,000 times 4%). Higher earners generally save more per dollar of premium, up to the point where they pass the Social Security wage limit, above which the 6.2% part no longer applies to marginal wages. Your rate depends on your filing status, your income and your state, and a tax professional or the IRS withholding estimator can supply it.

The saving is real but proportional: it is a discount on the premium, not a refund of it. A $3,000 premium still costs a lot even after a $589.50 tax effect.

Why you usually cannot change it mid-year

Section 125 elections are generally locked for the plan year. You choose at open enrollment, or when you are first hired, and the election stays in place until the plan year ends unless you have a qualifying change. The reason is anti-abuse: if employees could turn pretax deductions on and off at will, they could time them to their medical bills.

The usual permitted reasons are what the rules call changes in status, which line up with a qualifying life event:

  • marriage, divorce or legal separation;
  • birth, adoption or placement of a child;
  • a death in the family;
  • a change in your or your spouse's employment, or in hours that changes eligibility;
  • a significant change in the cost or coverage of the plan, if the plan allows it;
  • loss of or gain in other coverage, or eligibility for Medicare or Medicaid.

The change you make must generally be consistent with the event. A new baby supports adding the baby to your plan; it does not by itself support dropping coverage entirely. The plan document says which events it recognizes and how long you have to ask, and the window is often as short as 30 days. If you miss it, you generally wait until the next open enrollment.

This is separate from your right under other laws to enroll when you lose other coverage; the two overlap but are not identical. The guide how employer health insurance works: premiums, plan choices and rules explains the enrollment side.

How it shows up on your pay stub and W-2

On the pay stub, pretax deductions appear in their own section, and your taxable wages for the period are lower than your gross pay.

On your W-2:

  • Box 1 (wages for income tax) excludes the pretax premium. That is the saving, shown as a smaller number.
  • Boxes 3 and 5 (Social Security and Medicare wages) generally also exclude it.
  • Box 12, code DD shows the total cost of employer-sponsored coverage, including both your share and the employer's. It is informational and not taxable; it is not a pretax deduction amount.
  • Box 12, code W appears if employer contributions, including payroll HSA contributions through a cafeteria plan, were made to an HSA.

You do not claim anything on your return to get the Section 125 benefit; it is already built into your W-2. And because the premiums were pretax, you cannot also deduct them as an itemized medical expense. The post which medical costs count for the tax deduction, and which are gray areas? covers that and other edge cases.

The small effect on Social Security

Because the premium reduces wages subject to Social Security tax, it also reduces the wages credited to your Social Security earnings record for the year. Your future benefit is based on your average indexed earnings over your highest-earning years, so a smaller recorded wage can lower the benefit very slightly. For most workers the effect is small, because one year's reduction is spread across decades and many people have other years that matter more. The exact effect depends on your earnings history, and the Social Security Administration's own calculators and statements are the place to see it. Whether the tax saving today outweighs a very small change later is a personal call, and few people decide against pretax treatment for that reason.

Other effects to know about:

  • Loan applications and some benefits are measured by gross or taxable wages. Pretax deductions can make taxable wages lower than your gross pay, so ask which figure a lender or program uses.
  • Employer retirement plan contributions are sometimes calculated on a wage definition that may or may not exclude pretax benefit deductions. The plan document defines it.

A second example: family coverage and a raise

Pretax treatment matters more as premiums grow. Say Priyanka and her spouse, hypothetical employees at different companies, cover their family on her plan, and her share is $600 a month, or $7,200 a year. Assume her federal marginal rate is 22% and payroll tax is 7.65%, with no state tax.

  • Income tax saved: $7,200 times 22% is $1,584.00
  • Payroll tax saved: $7,200 times 7.65% is $550.80
  • Total saved: $2,134.80
  • Net cost of the premium: $7,200 minus $2,134.80, or $5,065.20

Now suppose she gets a raise that moves part of her income into a higher bracket. The saving on that slice of premium grows, because the tax rate applied to the premium is her marginal rate, the rate on her last dollars of income, not her average rate. The reverse is also true: a person whose income drops into a lower bracket saves less per dollar. This is why the amount on a pay stub never tells you the saving by itself.

When pretax is not clearly better

For nearly everyone who cannot itemize, pretax treatment is simply better than paying with after-tax money. A few situations are less clear, and fairness requires saying so:

  • Large medical costs and itemizing. After-tax premiums can be part of an itemized medical deduction, but only for the amount above 7.5% of adjusted gross income, and only if itemizing beats the standard deduction. For most workers the pretax saving is larger and certain, while the itemized deduction is uncertain.
  • Very low incomes. A worker with little income tax liability still gets the payroll-tax saving, but the income tax part may be small.
  • Social Security wages near zero or very low earnings histories. The credited-earnings effect can matter more for a person with a short work record. A Social Security statement shows the record.
  • Benefits that use taxable wages. A few programs measure income by taxable wages, where lower is better, and a few measure it by gross wages. Ask the program which it uses.

None of these is a reason to avoid a Section 125 plan generally; they are reasons to ask a payroll specialist or a tax professional if one applies to you.

Who gets different treatment

Self-employed people

Someone who works for themselves has no employer and no payroll, so there is no Section 125 plan. Instead many self-employed people deduct premiums for themselves, a spouse and dependents on their income tax return, using Form 7206 and the self-employed health insurance deduction. That deduction reduces income tax but, unlike a pretax payroll deduction, does not reduce self-employment tax. It also has conditions, including having net profit and not being eligible for an employer-subsidized plan. See self-employed health insurance deduction explained.

Owners of S corporations who hold more than a small share of the stock are treated under special rules too, and the post I own an S corporation, so how do I put my own health insurance on the books? covers them.

Marketplace buyers

If you buy a plan through the marketplace on your own, there is no payroll to route the premium through, so you pay with after-tax money. The tax benefit comes through a different channel: the premium tax credit, which lowers what you pay for the plan based on income, or, if you do not qualify for a credit, the possibility of deducting premiums as a medical expense when you itemize and clear the floor. The comparison between a job-based plan and a marketplace plan includes this tax difference, which employer coverage vs marketplace coverage: how to decide discusses.

COBRA and former employees

Someone who has left a job and pays COBRA premiums usually pays them directly, with after-tax money, though a particular plan's setup can differ. Your COBRA notice or the plan administrator can say. Those premiums may count as an itemized medical expense, subject to the floor.

Questions to ask your payroll or benefits office

  1. Is my share of the premium taken pretax under a Section 125 plan?
  2. Which other benefits (dental, vision, FSA, HSA) go through the same plan?
  3. What qualifying events does the plan recognize, and how many days do I have to ask?
  4. Can I opt out of pretax treatment? (Few plans allow it, but ask if you have a reason.)
  5. How are my W-2 boxes 1, 3 and 5 affected?

Key takeaways

  • A Section 125 cafeteria plan takes your share of the premium out of pay before federal income tax, payroll tax and, in most states, state income tax.
  • In the invented example, a $3,000 annual premium at an assumed 12% income tax rate and 7.65% payroll tax saved $589.50; at 22% it would save $889.50. Your real figure depends on your rate and state.
  • Elections are locked for the plan year except for qualifying changes such as marriage, birth or loss of other coverage, so ask about the window early.
  • Pretax premiums are already excluded from W-2 box 1, so they cannot be deducted again as a medical expense, and they slightly reduce the wages credited for Social Security.
  • Self-employed people and marketplace buyers get their tax benefits through other channels, such as the self-employed deduction or the premium tax credit.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic