Blog
Does my small business qualify for the health care tax credit?
A checklist of the conditions for the small employer health insurance tax credit, the reason for each and a worked FTE count, with no dollar thresholds.
Maybe. The federal tax credit for small employers that buy health insurance for their workers is built around a short list of conditions: how many full-time-equivalent employees you have, how much you pay them on average, how much of the premium you cover, where you buy the coverage and what kind of employer you are. Meeting all of them is what counts, and several are close calls that depend on definitions most owners have never had to apply. The checklist below goes through each condition, explains why it exists and shows where owners most often miscount.
This post gives no dollar thresholds on purpose. The wage limit, the credit percentages and the phase-out amounts are adjusted over time, and a wrong figure would send you down the wrong path. Confirm the current numbers on the IRS page for the small business health care tax credit and with a tax professional before you rely on any of it. The examples use invented figures to show the method.
Go through the sections in order. If you answer "no" to a condition that has no workaround, you can stop. If an answer is "not sure," write down what you need to find out and who to ask. The credit is claimed on your tax return with an IRS form for this credit, so a tax professional or your payroll provider will need the same facts.
1. Who counts as an employee
Check: List everyone on your payroll and sort them into those who count and those who do not.
Why it matters: The size test and the wage test both use employee counts, and the credit depends on a particular definition. In general:
- Owners do not count. That includes a sole proprietor, a partner, a shareholder who owns more than 2% of an S corporation and a person who owns more than 5% of a C corporation.
- Family members of owners do not count, within the family relationships the IRS lists.
- Seasonal workers who are employed for a short part of the year are generally left out of the count, with a limited exception.
- Everyone else who is on the payroll is counted, including part-time workers, in a way described below.
Owners and their relatives can still be covered by the plan. They are simply excluded from the numbers that determine the credit. If you are unsure whether a person is an owner or a family member for this purpose, ask a tax professional, because the ownership and family rules are detailed.
2. The size test: fewer than 25 full-time equivalents
Check: Calculate your full-time equivalent employees, called FTEs.
Why it matters: The credit is aimed at small employers, with fewer than 25 FTEs. Part-time employees count in proportion to their hours rather than as whole people, so a business with 30 people on the payroll may still be under the line.
The usual method is to add up the hours of service for each counted employee, cap each person's hours at the full-time number, and divide the total by the full-time number the IRS uses for a year. The result is rounded down to a whole number. For this illustration, assume the full-time number is 2,080 hours, which is 40 hours a week for 52 weeks. Check the IRS instructions for the figure and the rules for each year.
Worked example, with invented figures. A hypothetical studio has twelve full-time employees who each work 2,080 hours, and ten part-time employees who each work 20 hours a week for 52 weeks.
- Full-time hours: 12 times 2,080 is 24,960.
- Part-time hours: each part-timer works 20 times 52, which is 1,040 hours. Ten of them make 10,400 hours.
- Total hours: 24,960 plus 10,400 is 35,360.
- FTEs: 35,360 divided by 2,080 is 17.
The studio has 22 people on the payroll and 17 FTEs, so it passes the size test under this method. The size test also depends on a threshold that phases the credit out as FTEs rise, so being under 25 is a minimum, not a guarantee of the full amount.
3. The average wage test
Check: Total the wages you paid to the counted employees for the year and divide by your FTE count.
Why it matters: The credit is aimed at employers with lower average wages. Above a threshold set by the IRS for each tax year, you do not qualify, and the credit shrinks as the average approaches the limit. The threshold is adjusted annually, so look up the number for the tax year you are claiming.
Continuing the example. Suppose the studio paid counted employees $510,000 in total for the year. The average is $510,000 divided by 17, which is $30,000 per FTE. The question is whether $30,000 falls under the limit for that tax year. The method is the point of the example. The result is for you to compare with the IRS figure.
Note that the wages counted are those of the employees who are counted, and the owner's pay is left out. A business with a few highly paid non-owner employees may fail the test even if most employees earn less.
4. The contribution test: you pay at least a set share
Check: Confirm what share of the employee-only premium you pay for each enrolled employee.
Why it matters: The credit rewards employers who actually contribute. In general you must pay at least a minimum percentage of the premium for employee-only coverage, and the percentage must be the same for all employees who are enrolled. The IRS states the minimum.
Continuing the example. The studio's plan has an employee-only premium of $600 a month, and it pays $300. That is 300 divided by 600, or 50%. If the minimum is 50%, the studio meets it, and if it paid $250, which is about 41.7%, it would not. Check the exact minimum with the IRS page, and make sure the percentage is applied uniformly. A common error is paying more for managers or for people with family coverage without realizing the uniformity rule applies.
The credit is calculated on the premiums you actually pay, subject to a cap tied to average premiums in your state's small-group market. Paying for a pricier plan than the average does not increase the credit beyond that cap.
5. Where you buy the coverage
Check: Confirm whether the coverage was purchased through the small business marketplace, often called SHOP.
Why it matters: The credit is tied to coverage purchased through the small business exchange, with limited exceptions as described by the IRS. An owner who buys the identical plan directly from a carrier outside the exchange may not qualify. This is an easy condition to overlook, because the plan can look the same on paper.
Ask your broker whether the plan you are considering is available through the small business marketplace in your state, and ask how to enroll through it. health insurance marketplace explains the marketplace generally, and your state insurance department or the marketplace itself can tell you how small-business coverage works where you live. If you already have a group plan outside the exchange, a switch may be possible at renewal, and a tax professional can say whether the credit makes the move worthwhile.
An allowance arrangement raises a separate question. The credit is built around employer-sponsored group coverage, so ask a tax professional whether a reimbursement arrangement qualifies before you assume it does. Group plan, QSEHRA or ICHRA for my 10-person shop, how do they compare? compares the options.
6. Taxable or tax-exempt employer
Check: Decide which category you are.
Why it matters: The credit works differently depending on the kind of employer you are.
- A taxable business generally claims the credit against its income tax, and an unused amount can usually be carried to other years under the rules for general business credits.
- A tax-exempt organization, such as a nonprofit, generally claims a refundable credit, with the amount limited by the payroll taxes it withholds and pays. This limit can make the credit smaller than the calculation first suggests.
If you are an owner-operated business that pays little income tax, the credit may be of limited immediate use, and the carryover rules matter. This is a good question for a tax professional, because it turns on your return as a whole. The credit also reduces the deduction you take for the same premiums, so the net benefit is less than the credit amount.
7. How long the credit lasts
Check: Find out whether you have used the credit in earlier years.
Why it matters: The credit can be claimed for a limited number of consecutive tax years, which the IRS currently describes as two. Planning matters: a business that meets all the conditions for one year but expects to grow beyond the size or wage limits soon may get less than a business that will stay small. Ask your tax professional to model the two years, including the phase-out as FTEs and wages rise.
8. Documents to keep
Check: Gather the records the credit needs.
Why it matters: If the IRS asks questions, you need to show how you got your numbers. Keep:
- Payroll records with hours and wages for each employee, and the list of who was counted and who was excluded
- The FTE and average wage calculations
- Premium invoices and proof of payment, showing the employer's share
- Enrollment records for each covered employee
- Proof of enrollment through the small business marketplace
Where owners most often miscount
Three errors come up again and again, and each one changes the answer.
- Counting heads instead of hours. A shop with 30 people on the payroll, most of them part-time, may have well under 25 FTEs, and a shop with 20 full-time people may have more FTEs than it expected once overtime-heavy hours are totaled. Cap each person's hours at the full-time number, as in the example.
- Leaving the wrong people out. Excluding a highly paid manager because "she is practically an owner" lowers the average wage, but only owners and the relatives the IRS names are excluded. Including the owner's own pay, on the other hand, raises the average wage and can disqualify the business by mistake.
- Treating the contribution as flexible. Paying 70% for managers and 40% for everyone else breaks the uniform-percentage requirement, even if the average comes to more than the minimum. Pick one percentage and apply it to every enrolled employee.
Each of these is easy to fix on paper and hard to fix after the return is filed, which is why a tax professional should look at the counts before you commit to a plan year.
Three quick scenarios
These are invented to show how conditions interact.
- Candle shop. Eight employees, all full-time, an owner who is not counted, a plan bought through a broker outside the exchange. The size and perhaps wage tests pass, the contribution passes, and the coverage source fails. Asking about the exchange at renewal is the next step.
- Software firm. Fifteen employees with a high average wage. The size test passes, and the wage test fails. No credit.
- Neighborhood nonprofit. Ten employees, coverage through the small business marketplace, a 60% employer contribution. All tests pass, and the credit is refundable but limited by payroll taxes. The remaining question is the amount.
What to do next
- Gather payroll records and build the FTE and average wage numbers as shown above.
- Look up the current thresholds and credit rules on the IRS page for the small business health care tax credit.
- Ask a licensed broker whether your plan can be bought through the small business marketplace in your state. How do I set up my first group health plan for my small business? covers the steps for a first plan.
- Ask a tax professional to confirm your status and to estimate the net benefit after the lost deduction.
See Health insurance for small business owners: group plans, ICHRA and credits for the wider picture, Do employers have to offer health insurance? The ACA employer rules for the employer rules, and ICHRA vs group plan cost calculator if you are comparing a group plan with an allowance.
Key takeaways
- The credit requires several conditions together: fewer than 25 FTEs, a low enough average wage, a uniform employer contribution above a minimum share, and coverage through the small business marketplace.
- Owners and their relatives are excluded from the counts, and part-timers are counted by hours, which can put a business below the size line.
- Confirm every threshold on the IRS page for the tax year, because the dollar limits and percentages change.
- Taxable employers and tax-exempt employers claim the credit differently, and the credit is limited in number of years and reduces the premium deduction.
- A tax professional can say whether you qualify and what the credit is worth after the lost deduction.