Blog

I live in two states during the year. Which plan type will work for me?

Four hypothetical households that split the year between two places show how HMO, EPO, POS and PPO plans handle routine and urgent care away from home.

The plan type that works for a person who lives in two places is the one whose network and rules still apply when you are in the second place. That sounds obvious, but the difference between an HMO and a PPO is mostly invisible at home and sharp the moment you need a non-emergency visit 800 miles away. This post walks through four invented households to show how the same plan types behave in different lives.

None of the households is real, the premiums are round numbers made up for the arithmetic, and none of this is a recommendation. Each household's decision is the one that fits its own assumptions.

What decides how a plan works away from home

Before the households, four ideas explain nearly every outcome.

  • The network and the service area. Most plans pay in full network terms only for providers they contract with, and most HMO and EPO plans define a service area, a list of counties where you are expected to live and get care. If your second home is outside that area, the plan may have no network there at all.
  • Emergency care is different. For emergencies, the ACA requires non-grandfathered plans to cover emergency services without prior approval and regardless of whether the hospital is in network, at in-network cost sharing. The test is whether a person with an average knowledge of health would believe they had an emergency, which is the prudent layperson standard. The No Surprises Act also protects patients from most out-of-network surprise bills for emergency care, though it does not cover ground ambulances. The follow-up care after an emergency is where plan type matters again.
  • Urgent, routine and follow-up care. An urgent care visit for a sprained wrist, a prescription refill or a check-up are not emergencies. In an HMO or EPO with no network where you are, those visits may be paid in full by you. A PPO has out-of-network benefits, which pay something at a higher cost. A POS plan usually works like an HMO inside the network and allows out-of-network visits at higher cost sharing, often with a referral rule.
  • Where you live is a rule, not a preference. Marketplace plans are sold by service area, and a permanent move opens a special enrollment period in most cases. A long temporary stay does not. If you spend months in two places, the marketplace and the insurer ask where your main home is, and the state insurance department answers questions about local rules.

A summary of how plan types tend to behave in a second location:

Plan type Routine care in the second state Urgent care Emergency care
HMO Usually not covered outside the service area Often limited; check "urgent care outside the service area" Covered
EPO Usually not covered outside the network Often limited Covered
POS Out-of-network allowed at higher cost, often with a referral Usually covered at out-of-network rates Covered
PPO Out-of-network covered at higher cost; some PPOs have a national network Covered, in or out of network Covered

Plans differ even inside one type, so the table is a way of asking questions, not a promise. The longer version of the plan-type comparison is in HMO vs PPO vs EPO vs POS: how the four plan types differ.

Household 1: the winter retirees

Walt, 62, and Joan, 60, retired early and spend about six months of the year in a warm state. They are not yet on Medicare. (If they were 65 or older, Medicare changes the question; see I spend winters in another state: Medicare Advantage or Original Medicare?.) They are looking at two marketplace-style options for two adults, using invented premiums:

  • An HMO costing $900 a month, with a network near their home state.
  • A PPO costing $1,100 a month.

The premium gap is $200 a month, so $2,400 a year ($200 times 12).

In their warm-weather months they expect routine needs: Joan refills a prescription, Walt sees a dentist, and they might each have a minor illness. Say they expect four non-emergency medical visits in the second state at $250 each, which comes to $1,000. Under the HMO they would pay that $1,000 themselves, so on paper the HMO costs $1,400 less ($2,400 minus $1,000) for those visits.

The arithmetic is incomplete, though. They would also have to weigh the follow-up risk: if one of them is hospitalized in the warm state, the emergency itself is covered, but the HMO might expect them to return home for follow-up or require approval for ongoing treatment. They also need to know whether the HMO covers an urgent care visit outside its service area, which some plans do.

Their decision. They compare the $1,400 on-paper difference with the risk of a long follow-up away from home, and they ask the insurer in writing how it handles care after an emergency outside the service area. Because their health is good, they lean toward the HMO but plan to schedule routine visits in the months they are at home. Another household with a chronic condition might read the same numbers and choose the PPO. Neither decision is wrong.

Household 2: a worker with two homes

Aisha works remotely for an employer. She spends eight months a year in State A, where her employer is based, and four months in State B, where her partner lives. The employer offers two plans:

  • A regional HMO with an employee share of $80 a month.
  • A PPO with a broad network and an employee share of $200 a month.

The gap is $120 a month, or $1,440 a year.

In State B she expects four routine visits at $200 allowed each and one imaging test at $800, so $1,600 of care. The PPO plan has a $1,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance. In-network in State B, Aisha would pay $1,000 plus 20% of the remaining $600, which is $120, so $1,120.

  • Under the PPO: the extra premium of $1,440 plus care of $1,120 equals $2,560 more than the HMO's premium alone.
  • Under the HMO: she pays the $1,600 herself for the State B visits and nothing extra in premium, so $1,600.

On these invented numbers the HMO costs about $960 less ($2,560 minus $1,600), as long as she can wait on non-urgent care or take it in State A. If she needed a six-week course of physical therapy in State B, the numbers would change.

Her decision. Aisha's first step is asking the HR team two questions the arithmetic depends on: does the PPO's network count as in-network in State B, and does the HMO have any coverage there beyond emergencies? Employer plans may be governed by the state where the policy was issued or, for self-funded plans, by federal law, so the questions go to the employer's benefits team and the insurer. If the PPO's network really is national, the extra $1,440 buys the ability to schedule care wherever she is. If it is not, the PPO's advantage shrinks. She would also note that her total includes only one State B scenario; a year with an injury looks different.

Household 3: the traveling nurse

Maria is a travel nurse. She takes assignments of about 13 weeks in different states, sometimes with gaps between them. Her pay comes through a staffing agency, which offers a group plan. She also owns a home in her home state, where she returns between jobs. Her main questions are: does the agency's plan have a network where she works, and what happens in a gap?

Say the agency plan is a PPO, but its in-network providers are strongest in her home state. In the state where she is working, many of the local providers are out of network. Plans often have two sets of numbers. Suppose in-network she has a $1,500 deductible with 20% coinsurance, and out-of-network there is a separate $3,000 deductible with 40% coinsurance, and the plan pays on its own allowed amount.

Say she needs an outpatient procedure with a $2,000 allowed amount.

  • In network: she pays the $1,500 deductible plus 20% of $500, which is $100. Total $1,600.
  • Out of network: the $2,000 is entirely inside the $3,000 deductible, so she pays $2,000, and the provider can bill the difference between its charge and the plan's allowed amount unless a law such as the No Surprises Act protects her. The separate deductible also means she starts over.

That is a $400 difference before any extra billing, and it shows why her real question is whether the plan has a network where she works. She might ask three things before accepting an assignment: which network applies in the work state, whether the plan has a travel or national option, and whether there is a waiting period when a new assignment begins. Between assignments, she also needs to know whether coverage continues, and for how long, and what the options are if it ends. Loss of coverage generally opens a 60-day special enrollment period for marketplace plans in most cases, and COBRA may apply to an employer plan. health insurance when moving states: what carries over and what does not describes the logic for moving between states.

Her decision. Maria chooses based on network breadth in the places she is likely to work, not on the plan type label. She would ask the staffing agency for the provider directory for each target state before she signs.

Household 4: the military spouse

Jordan is married to an active-duty service member. Their family is eligible for TRICARE, and Jordan also has a part-time job that offers an employer plan. The service member is stationed in State B, and Jordan stays in State A part of the year because of the children's school. TRICARE has different options, and they differ in whether you need a referral and how care away from your area is handled. The military health system and the TRICARE contractor for each region answer those questions. This post does not describe their numbers.

Where Jordan has other health insurance, the question becomes which plan pays first. The general rule is that TRICARE pays after other health insurance in most cases, with some exceptions, so the employer plan would be primary. Two health plans? Coordination of benefits decides who pays first explains the idea. Take an invented bill of $1,000 allowed. If the employer plan pays 80%, that is $800, leaving $200. Whether a second plan covers any of the $200 depends on the second plan's rules.

Jordan's decision hinges on three numbers Jordan does not yet have: what TRICARE would cost in each state, what the employer plan would cost per year, and how much of the remaining bill the second plan would reduce. If the employer plan costs $120 a month ($1,440 a year) and would save less than that in a typical year, it may not be worth carrying. If a child has a condition requiring frequent visits, the answer may reverse.

Jordan's decision. Jordan calls TRICARE and the employer's benefits team, asks each how they would handle a visit in State A and one in State B, and decides after getting the three numbers in writing. The point is that a program with its own rules, like TRICARE, is a case where the plan type label is not the main input.

A short method that works for any household

  1. List the places and months. Write down where you will be, for how long, and what kind of care you expect in each.
  2. Ask each plan for its service area and network in each place. A directory search by ZIP code in both places is the fastest check; see in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill for the basics.
  3. Find the urgent care and out-of-area rules in writing. Look for the words "outside the service area" in the plan document.
  4. Compute the premium difference and the likely out-of-pocket cost for the care you expect in the second place, as in the households above.
  5. Decide how much you value the ability to schedule routine care anywhere. This is a personal decision about risk and convenience.
  6. Ask the state insurance department if you cannot tell which state's rules apply to your plan.

The tool health plan type finder can help you think through the type; a related post on a specific plan structure is I have an EPO and I'm traveling, so what if I need care away from home?.

Key takeaways

  • A plan type works for two places only if its network or out-of-network benefits reach the second place; check the directory and the service area for both.
  • Emergencies are covered regardless of network under federal rules; follow-up, routine and urgent care are where HMOs and EPOs usually stop.
  • A PPO's higher premium buys flexibility; whether the flexibility is worth the difference depends on how much non-emergency care you expect away from home.
  • Out-of-network care often has a separate, higher deductible and can lead to balance billing, so ask how the plan prices it.
  • Ask the insurer, employer benefits team or TRICARE contractor in writing, and the state insurance department for questions about which state's rules apply.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic