Blog
My union health plan uses an hours bank, how do I keep coverage?
How hour-bank eligibility works in many multiemployer union health funds, what happens in slow periods, and how to ask the fund office, with invented numbers.
Some workers keep their health coverage by working a certain number of hours. A carpenter, an electrician, a stagehand or a truck driver who moves between employers may find that the coverage does not come from any one boss. It comes from a union health fund, and the fund decides each month or quarter whether the worker has enough hours on the books to stay covered. When work slows, the account that holds those hours, often called an hours bank, is the difference between staying covered and a letter saying coverage has ended.
This post explains how such arrangements generally work, what happens in a gap between jobs, and how to ask the fund office the right questions. The most important caution comes first: these plans differ widely. Each fund writes its own rules in a plan document, and the numbers below are invented to show the mechanics. Nothing here substitutes for your fund's summary plan description.
What the fund is and who runs it
Many union members are covered by a multiemployer plan, sometimes called a Taft-Hartley fund. Employers who sign a collective bargaining agreement agree to pay a set amount into the fund for each hour a covered employee works. The fund is run by a board of trustees, usually with equal numbers of union and employer representatives. A hired administrator, called a third-party administrator, processes eligibility and claims. The money in the fund pays for health benefits for the workers whose hours were reported.
Most of these funds are self-funded plan arrangements. The fund pays claims itself instead of buying a policy from an insurer, and it may use an insurance company's network or claims processing as a service. Federal law, mainly the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), governs how the fund must treat you, including the rules for disclosure and appeals. State insurance departments generally do not regulate self-funded plans, which affects where you complain, covered further down.
The fund can be big or small, and its benefits vary. Some cover only health care. Some add dental, vision, prescription drugs and a death benefit. Some offer retiree coverage with its own rules. All of that is in the summary plan description, which the fund must give you.
How an hours bank works in outline
Think of the bank as a savings account of hours. Employers report your hours to the fund, usually monthly. The fund adds those hours to your account. Each period, the fund subtracts a fixed number of hours as the "cost" of keeping you covered for that period. As long as the balance covers the subtraction, you stay covered. When the balance runs low, coverage is at risk.
Different funds draw the lines in different places. Here is an invented example, for illustration only.
- To become eligible for the first time, a worker must have worked 400 hours in a qualifying period of three months.
- Each month of coverage uses 100 hours from the bank.
- The bank holds a maximum of 600 hours. Hours above that are not saved.
Now follow a hypothetical worker, Dana, through a slow stretch.
| Month | Hours worked | Bank before | Cost of coverage | Bank after |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Start of layoff | 0 | 450 | 450 | |
| 1 | 0 | 450 | 100 | 350 |
| 2 | 0 | 350 | 100 | 250 |
| 3 | 0 | 250 | 100 | 150 |
| 4 | 0 | 150 | 100 | 50 |
| 5 | 0 | 50 | 100 needed | 50 short |
In this illustration, Dana is covered for four months of no work, because the bank held 450 hours and each month cost 100. In month 5 the bank holds 50 hours and needs 100. Dana is 50 hours short. What happens next depends on the fund's rules: coverage may end at the end of month 4, or the fund may allow a payment to cover the shortage.
If Dana gets a job that reports 120 hours in month 3, the picture changes. The bank goes from 250 plus 120 to 370, minus 100, which is 270. The same account that was running down gets refilled. That is why the order and timing of hours matter, and why people who work in seasonal or project-based jobs watch their hour counts.
Real funds are rarely this simple. Some look back over several months of work and some use dollars or earnings instead of hours. Some have waiting periods before new members get coverage. Some count hours worked in the previous quarter to decide coverage in the next. Some let hours expire after a number of months. The summary plan description spells it out.
Quarters of eligibility
Some funds organize coverage in blocks, such as a quarter of the year. In a quarter system, the hours you work in one period earn coverage for a later period. For example, hours worked from January through March might earn coverage from July through September. This structure creates a delay between working and being covered, and it creates a delay on the other side. If you stop working in April, you may still be covered through September because of the earlier hours. If you start in October, you may not be covered until a later period.
Ask which structure yours uses, and ask the fund office to show you, in writing, your own bank or earned period, with dates. A calendar with the dates you are covered through is better than a conversation.
What happens when you run short
Funds usually have several choices for members who fall short. These are the most common, and funds vary on whether they offer them.
- Self-payment. Many funds let a member pay out of pocket to cover the shortfall for a limited time, at a rate the fund sets. In the invented example, if the fund set the rate at $10 per hour short, Dana's 50-hour gap in month 5 would cost 50 times $10, or $500. This is an illustration, not a rate. Ask for the actual rate and whether it is a monthly or hourly formula, because the cost for a longer gap can add up. Self-payment is not available everywhere and may have time limits.
- A grace period or reserve. Some funds let a member keep coverage briefly while hours are reported late, because employers sometimes report late.
- COBRA continuation. When you lose eligibility because of reduced hours or a job ending, you may have a right to COBRA, which lets you continue the fund's coverage by paying the full cost plus an administrative charge. The cost can be up to 102% of the plan's cost of coverage, and you generally have at least 60 days to elect. The fund's COBRA administrator sends the notice. The guide How COBRA works: eligibility, cost and how long it lasts explains the rules, and the COBRA cost and deadline calculator helps you track the dates. A fund's COBRA premium may be far more than the self-payment, so compare. The post I never received my COBRA paperwork, so what do I do? covers what to do if the notice does not arrive.
- Marketplace coverage. Losing job-based coverage opens a 60-day marketplace special enrollment period in most cases, whether or not you take COBRA. The guide health insurance when you lose your job: your options and deadlines compares the options. A special enrollment period has deadlines, so do not wait.
- A spouse's plan or Medicaid. If your household income drops during a slow period, you might qualify for Medicaid or marketplace subsidies. A navigator can check.
The order matters. If you let the coverage lapse and the dates pass, you may lose several of these options at once. Calendar the deadlines as soon as you suspect a gap.
Why hours go missing
Many "lost coverage" problems are not about the worker's hours at all. They are about reporting.
- The employer reported late or not at all. Employers send reports and payments to the fund. If an employer is behind, the fund may not have credited your hours when it checks eligibility. Funds can pursue delinquent employers and often credit hours once contributions arrive, but the process takes time.
- Hours worked for a non-signatory employer. Hours that do not fall under the collective bargaining agreement may not count.
- Hours that count differently. Some funds count paid time off, travel time or training differently than regular work.
- A mistake in your record. A name change, a new Social Security number record or a misspelled name can scatter hours across two accounts.
Keep your own records: pay stubs, timesheets, a log of hours worked by employer and date. If the fund's total does not match yours, you have something concrete to bring to the fund office. A discrepancy found early costs less than one found when a claim is denied.
Questions to ask the fund office
Ask for the answers in writing, or write down the date, the name of the person and what they said.
- What is the exact rule for becoming eligible, and for staying eligible?
- How many hours are in my bank today, and through what date am I covered?
- How many hours does each month or quarter of coverage use?
- Is there a maximum on banked hours, and do banked hours expire?
- If I am short, can I self-pay, at what rate, and for how long?
- What are the deadlines to elect COBRA, and what is the cost?
- How do I confirm that my employers reported all my hours?
- What happens to my spouse and children if my eligibility ends?
- If I work for a non-signatory employer for a while, does my bank freeze, or do I lose hours?
- How do I appeal an eligibility decision, and by what date?
Ask when you are healthy and in no hurry. People often call after a bill has arrived, which is the hardest time to learn that the bank ran low three months earlier.
If the fund denies a claim or says you are not eligible
A fund's decision that you are not eligible is something you can contest, just as a denied claim is. ERISA requires the fund to give you a written explanation of an adverse decision and the steps to appeal. Group health plans must generally give you at least 180 days from the denial notice to file an internal appeal. The notice states the deadline for your case, and the plan's summary plan description states the process. Read the notice as soon as it arrives, and file within the deadline.
For an eligibility dispute, gather your hour records and the fund's accounting. For a claim denial, the guide how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step explains how to build the appeal. After the internal appeal, an independent external review is generally available for denials involving medical judgment, though the process for self-funded plans follows federal rules rather than a state insurance department's.
Because the fund is usually self-funded and falls under ERISA, your state insurance department generally cannot take your complaint. The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) assists people with questions about ERISA plans, and your union representative may help you talk to the fund's administrator. If the dispute is serious, an attorney who handles benefits cases can advise on the next step.
A few misconceptions to avoid
- "The union has insurance for me." The fund is separate from the union, even when the union's trustees help run it. The fund office, not the local union hall, is the authority on your eligibility.
- "If I am out of work, I am still covered." Only for as long as the bank or the earned period lasts.
- "COBRA is the same price as my coverage." COBRA generally costs the full premium plus up to 2%, without any employer contribution. Compare it with the fund's self-pay rate and with marketplace options.
- "My employer handles this." The employer reports hours and pays contributions. The fund decides eligibility.
For the general picture of how employer coverage works, the guide how employer health insurance works: premiums, plan choices and rules covers the basics. Funds, though, are the part of the world where reading your own plan document matters more than any general rule.
Key takeaways
- An hours bank credits the hours employers report and subtracts a set number each period, so coverage lasts as long as the balance covers the cost.
- Funds differ widely in thresholds, quarters, caps, expiry of hours and self-payment options, so get your own numbers and dates in writing.
- When you run short, compare self-payment, COBRA and marketplace coverage, and note that COBRA and special enrollment deadlines are measured in days.
- Keep your own record of hours, because late employer reports and records errors cause many eligibility problems.
- For eligibility or claim disputes, appeal within the deadline in the notice, and go to the Department of Labor's EBSA, not the state insurance department, for help with a self-funded plan.