Blog

What happens to my claims and coverage when a health insurer fails?

What happens in order when a regulator takes over an insurer: rehabilitation, liquidation, guaranty claims, replacement coverage and lost deductible credit.

A health insurer failing is rare, and when it happens it is rarely abrupt. State regulators watch insurers' finances throughout the year, and a company in trouble usually moves through a series of steps, each with its own effect on members. This post follows those steps in order, so a member who gets a notice that their insurer has been placed in rehabilitation or liquidation knows what the words mean, what usually happens to unpaid claims, and what to do about replacement coverage.

One caution up front: the rules in this area come from state law and court orders, and they differ by state, by type of insurer and by product. What follows describes how the process generally works. The notice you receive, the state insurance department and the state's guaranty association are the sources for your specific case.

The sequence at a glance

Stage Who acts What it usually means for you
Warning signs State insurance department Closer monitoring, a required financial plan, limits on what the company may do. Coverage continues normally.
Supervision or conservation Department, sometimes with a court Regulator oversees or approves major decisions. Claims are usually still paid.
Rehabilitation Court-appointed rehabilitator (usually the insurance commissioner) The regulator runs the company to try to fix it. Claims may be slowed or limited; coverage often continues.
Liquidation Court-appointed liquidator The company is closed. Policies end on a set schedule. Unpaid claims go through the liquidation, with a guaranty association covering many of them.
Aftermath Guaranty association, liquidator, new insurer Claims are paid up to limits; you hold replacement coverage; some deductible credit may be lost.

Not every troubled insurer goes through every stage. Some are sold, merged or recapitalized and never reach liquidation. Others move from supervision straight to liquidation.

Stage 1: Warning signs, before anything is announced

Regulators track insurers through their financial filings and examinations. When the numbers fall below certain thresholds, the regulator has authority to require a corrective plan, restrict new sales, or limit dividends and transfers. These steps are often not publicized widely, and members may notice nothing.

What members may see in this stage is practical: a slower response on claims, a company pulling back from a market, a letter about a new owner or a transfer of policies. None of these means failure. If you are worried, the state state insurance department can say whether it has taken any action against the company.

Stage 2: Supervision, then rehabilitation

If the problems continue, the commissioner may ask a court for an order of supervision (the regulator watches and approves major steps) or rehabilitation (the regulator takes control of the company). The details of the names vary by state.

In rehabilitation, the goal is to restore the company if it can be restored. The rehabilitator may cut costs, seek a buyer, raise capital or restructure. Courts often issue an order that stops creditors from suing or collecting from the company while this happens (an "automatic stay" on legal action). That can affect claims in one way members do not expect: you may not be able to sue the insurer for an unpaid claim during that time, and the regulator or court may set rules about the order in which obligations are paid.

What usually continues. Coverage often continues in rehabilitation, and the company is generally allowed to keep paying claims. The rehabilitator may limit payments in some circumstances, for example by slowing payment of large or non-urgent claims to preserve cash.

What you should do.

  1. Keep all documents. Save every explanation of benefits (explanation of benefits), bill, receipt, authorization letter and call record from the date of any notice onward. These are your proof if a claim becomes part of a liquidation.
  2. Keep paying premiums on time, unless the regulator or the notice tells you otherwise. Coverage that lapses for nonpayment is much harder to repair.
  3. Do not cancel coverage on your own before you have replacement coverage lined up in writing, because you may lose the chance to enroll in new coverage on time.
  4. Read the court or regulator notice for contact information. Rehabilitators often set up a dedicated hotline or page.

Stage 3: Liquidation

If the company cannot be saved, the court issues an order of liquidation. The liquidator takes over the assets and winds the company down. Several things follow, though the exact timetable depends on state law and the court's order.

  • A date on which coverage ends. Some orders keep health coverage in force for a limited period after the order, such as until the end of a paid-up month, so members have time to find another plan. Others set a short, fixed cut-off. The notice states the date, and it is the date that matters. Do not assume your coverage lasts through the end of the plan year.
  • A claims process. The liquidator publishes a deadline for filing a "proof of claim." Claims for services before the cut-off may need to be submitted in this way, in addition to ordinary claim forms.
  • A role for the guaranty association. This is described in the next section.

Employer plans work differently. If your employer bought a fully insured plan from the failed insurer, the employer must find a new insurer, and the employer's notice tells you the new plan's start date. If your employer pays claims itself (a self-funded plan), the insurer's failure may affect only the administrative company and the stop-loss coverage, not your benefits; ask your benefits office.

What a state guaranty association generally covers

Every state has a guaranty association for life and health insurers, funded by assessments on other insurers, that steps in when a company is liquidated. It pays covered claims, within limits, and may help move members to replacement coverage. Here is what to expect, and what varies.

Generally true.

  • It covers claims for care received before the cut-off date, within a per-person limit set by state law.
  • It pays providers or members according to its own claims process, not the failed insurer's.
  • It pays only for what the policy would have covered. Services excluded by the policy remain excluded.

Varies by state.

  • The dollar limit per person, and how it is counted.
  • Whether HMOs and other managed care organizations are included in the same system or protected by a different mechanism.
  • Whether certain types of plans (for example, some employer plans or products sold outside the marketplace) are included.
  • How long coverage continues after the liquidation order.

Do not rely on a general description for any of these. The state's guaranty association publishes what it covers, and the state department can point you to it.

What happens to unpaid claims

Claims fall into three groups.

  1. Claims paid before the failure. Nothing changes. You do not owe the money back.
  2. Claims incurred before the cut-off date but not yet paid. These are the ones to watch. They may be paid by the failed insurer during rehabilitation, or by the guaranty association after liquidation, up to the limits. Submit them as the notice directs and keep copies.
  3. Care received after the cut-off date. The failed insurer's policy no longer covers it. Your replacement coverage will if it is in force.

Can the doctor bill me? The in-network provider's contract with the failed insurer usually said the provider would look to the insurer and not bill you for covered amounts beyond your normal cost sharing. In an insolvency, many states have laws that limit billing members of an insolvent HMO or similar plan, but the protections differ by state and by provider contract. If a provider sends you a bill for amounts an insurer used to pay, do not pay it immediately. Call the guaranty association or the department, send the provider a copy of the liquidation notice, and ask the provider in writing to hold the account while the claim is pending. The guide how to file a complaint with your state insurance department explains how to reach the department.

Getting replacement coverage

Your options depend on where your coverage came from.

Marketplace or individual plan. Loss of coverage when an insurer fails is generally a qualifying life event (qualifying life event) that opens a special enrollment period, which in most cases lasts 60 days, the standard window after a loss of other qualifying coverage. Regulators and the marketplace often add notices and sometimes extend the window or offer a special time to enroll, which the notice will state. Enroll through your marketplace so that you can still receive premium tax credits. The guide special enrollment periods explained: qualifying life events and deadlines covers deadlines, and the tool special enrollment period checker shows whether your event qualifies.

Employer plan. The employer chooses a new insurer; you usually do not need a special enrollment period. If the employer drops coverage and you lose it, you have the standard 60-day windows for marketplace coverage or a spouse's plan.

Medicare Advantage or Medicaid managed care. These are run under contracts with the federal or state government. If a plan ends, the program arranges for members to move to another plan or to the standard program, and there are special enrollment rights. The notice from Medicare or the state Medicaid agency is the source for dates.

Coverage that was never insurance. A product that was not insurance, such as a health care sharing arrangement, is not covered by a guaranty association. See Is a small or new health insurer safe to buy from? Checking financial strength for the licensing questions to ask before buying.

A short sequence to follow

  1. Day of the notice. Find the cut-off date in the notice and put it on a calendar. Write down the date your replacement coverage must start so there is no gap.
  2. Within a few days. Choose a replacement and apply through the marketplace, the employer or the Medicaid agency, depending on your situation.
  3. Before the new coverage starts. Ask the new insurer whether it will credit your deductible, and request records of your spending from the old insurer if you can.
  4. Within the claims deadline. File proof of claim for any pending bills if the liquidator requires it.
  5. After. Review each explanation of benefits for the first months to confirm claims are being processed under the right plan.

Why deductible credit may be lost

Your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum counters belong to a particular plan. When you move to a different insurer in the middle of a plan year, the new insurer is not generally required to count what you paid under the old one. Some insurers, employers or state rules do give credit; many do not. Ask before you enroll, in writing, and keep your records so you can request an adjustment later.

A worked example with round numbers

Say Pat has a plan with a $3,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance. By the end of October, Pat has paid $2,400 toward the deductible. The insurer is liquidated, and coverage ends on November 30. Pat enrolls in a new plan that starts December 1, with a $3,500 deductible and 20% coinsurance, and the new insurer does not give credit for the $2,400.

In December, Pat needs an infusion with an allowed cost of $4,000.

  • If the old plan had continued: $600 of the deductible remained ($3,000 − $2,400). Pat would have paid $600, then 20% of the remaining $3,400, which is $680. Total: $600 + $680 = $1,280.
  • Under the new plan with no credit: Pat pays the whole deductible of $3,500, then 20% of the remaining $500, which is $100. Total: $3,500 + $100 = $3,600.

The difference is $2,320 ($3,600 − $1,280). These are invented numbers for illustration. The point is the mechanism: progress toward the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum can be lost, and a mid-year move can cost more than the premium difference suggests. The guide how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending explains how to keep proof of what you paid.

If the new plan year starts on January 1, the deductible resets for everyone regardless of the insurer, so the effect is largest for a failure in the middle of the year.

Questions to ask in the first week

  • What is the exact date my coverage ends, and what is the deadline to file claims?
  • Is there a dedicated contact for members, and is there a written notice?
  • Does the guaranty association cover my type of plan, and what is its limit in this state?
  • Will my replacement insurer count what I have already paid toward the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum?
  • If I am in the middle of treatment, will the new plan approve continued care with my current doctors? See the post How do I ask for a transition period when my doctor leaves the network? for how to ask.
  • Who do I call if a provider bills me for covered care?

The state insurance department, a marketplace navigator or your benefits office can answer the questions that depend on your plan.

Key takeaways

  • Insurer failure usually unfolds in stages (monitoring, supervision, rehabilitation, liquidation), and coverage often continues until a date stated in the court notice.
  • A state guaranty association generally pays covered claims for care received before the cut-off, within limits that vary by state and by type of plan.
  • Keep every explanation of benefits, bill and notice, and file any proof of claim the liquidator requires by its deadline.
  • Losing coverage this way generally opens a special enrollment period for marketplace plans, and employers must replace a fully insured group plan; check the notice for dates.
  • Deductible and out-of-pocket progress may not carry to the new insurer, so ask for credit in writing before you enroll.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic