Blog

Is a small or new health insurer safe to buy from? Checking financial strength

A checklist for a plan from an unfamiliar company: licensing, filings and ratings, reserves, guaranty coverage and signs of an unlicensed product.

If you are choosing among marketplace plans and one of them comes from a company whose name you have never heard, two separate questions are mixed together. The first is whether the company is a real, licensed insurer. The second is whether it is financially strong enough to pay claims through the whole plan year. A new or small company can be perfectly legitimate on the first question and still be a thinner bet on the second, and a company that sounds established can be a different kind of product altogether.

This post is a checklist. It gives you the items in order, the reason for each, and the place to find the answer. None of it requires you to read a balance sheet. It does not tell you which company to pick; it tells you what to check before you do.

Start with the question that settles the most: is it licensed?

Health insurance in the United States is regulated primarily by states. An insurer that sells coverage in a state must hold a license (often called a certificate of authority) from that state's state insurance department. Licensing means the department has reviewed the company's capital, management, plan documents and rates, and that it keeps examining the company afterward.

Checklist items

  • Find the company on your state insurance department's website. Most departments have a license or company lookup. Search for the exact legal name printed on the application, not the brand name in the advertisement.
  • Match the legal entity to the product. A brand can be sold by several legal entities in different states. Make sure the licensed entity is the one that will issue your policy.
  • Check the line of business. A company can be licensed to sell life insurance or property insurance and not health insurance.
  • If you are on the marketplace, note that the exchange has already screened the plan. Plans listed on HealthCare.gov or a state exchange are certified to be sold there, which includes state licensing. A plan found elsewhere carries no such screen.

Why it matters. Everything else on this list, including guaranty fund protection, depends on the company being licensed. An unlicensed seller is not an "insurer with weak finances"; it is something else, and the protections described below do not apply to it.

Item 2: Look at how long it has operated, and what that does and does not mean

A new insurer has no claims history, and the first years are the riskiest. Insurers set premiums a year ahead based on estimates of how sick their members will be and how much providers will charge. A new company has the least data to make those estimates, and a company that grows fast can attract more sick members than it priced for.

Age does not guarantee strength, though. Large companies have also left markets or been taken over. The more useful question is whether the company has the resources behind it to survive a bad year.

Checklist items

  • Who owns the company? Many newer plans are backed by a larger insurer, a hospital system, a physician group or an investor group. Ownership is stated in the company's filings and often in its profile on the state department's site.
  • How many members does it have, and how fast is it growing? Fast growth can strain reserves and customer service at the same time.
  • Is it new to your state, or new to insurance? A company expanding from a neighboring state brings operating experience; one that started selling last year does not.
  • Does the company have a history in this product? A company can be new to the individual market but not to employer plans, or the reverse.

Several of the nonprofit Consumer Operated and Oriented Plan plans created under the Affordable Care Act were small and new, and many closed in the years after they opened. That history is a reminder that size and age matter, not a rule that every new plan will fail.

Item 3: Check the solvency filings and the ratings

Every licensed insurer files detailed financial statements with its state regulator, usually every year and often every quarter. The NAIC, the association of state insurance regulators, sets the standard formats. Part of the review is a measure called risk-based capital: a comparison of the insurer's capital with the amount regulators think is appropriate for the risks it takes. If the capital falls below set thresholds, the regulator has the power to step in at levels that escalate with the gap.

You do not need to calculate risk-based capital yourself. But two sources make the result visible.

Checklist items

  • Ask the department whether the company is under any supervision, corrective action or other restriction. Departments publish some orders and will answer direct questions. Ask whether the company has a financial plan it must follow.
  • Look for a financial strength rating. Independent rating firms, such as AM Best and S&P Global, rate insurers' ability to pay claims. A new or small company may be unrated, which means the firm has not reviewed it, not that it failed. An unrated company is not necessarily weak, but it gives you less outside confirmation. The guide Insurer ratings explained: AM Best, NCQA, CMS stars and J.D. Power describes what each rating measures and what it ignores.
  • Read the rating's date and its outlook. A rating is a snapshot. A stable outlook and a recent date are more meaningful than a high letter from several years ago.
  • Look at the plan's medical loss ratio reports. The medical loss ratio shows the share of premium spent on care. Federal rules set a floor of 80% for individual and small-group plans and 85% for large groups. An extremely high ratio can signal that claims are running close to premiums; an extremely low one suggests the insurer is keeping a lot of margin. Neither is a verdict by itself.

A worked example with round numbers

Say a hypothetical new insurer collects $200 million in premiums in a year. It pays $170 million in claims (a loss ratio of 85%: 170 ÷ 200) and spends $22 million on administration and taxes. That leaves $8 million (200 − 170 − 22 = 8), or 4% of premiums.

Now say claims come in 10% higher than the insurer priced for. Claims become $187 million (170 × 1.10). The result is $200 − $187 − $22 = −$9 million. The company lost $9 million, more than its entire expected margin. It must cover that gap from reserves or from its parent.

This is an illustration with invented numbers, not a forecast. The point is that thin margins mean a small estimating error is larger than the profit, and reserves are what stand between that error and unpaid claims. Larger companies spread the risk over more members and more lines of business; a small insurer with one product is more exposed.

Item 4: Understand reserves and reinsurance in plain terms

Reserves are money the insurer sets aside to pay claims it has already incurred but not yet paid (a doctor visit this month is billed and paid weeks later). Regulators require reserves and test them. Capital and surplus is the cushion beyond that.

Reinsurance is insurance the insurer buys for itself. A health insurer can arrange for a reinsurer to pay a share of very large claims (for example, a single patient's multi-million-dollar claim) or a share of losses above a set total. This lowers the chance that one bad year ends the company. Reinsurance is not the same as a state reinsurance program that lowers marketplace premiums; the word is used in both senses.

Checklist items

  • Ask whether the company has reinsurance or a parent that guarantees its obligations. The answer will not usually be in a brochure, but the department or the insurer's customer relations team can often say.
  • For an employer plan, find out whether it is self-funded. If your employer pays the claims and the insurer only administers, the insurer's solvency matters less and the employer's matters more. The employer usually carries stop-loss coverage for large claims. See how to compare health insurers: ratings, complaints and service for how to compare the pieces.

Item 5: Know what guaranty fund protection is, and what varies

Every state has a guaranty association for life and health insurers. If a licensed insurer is placed in liquidation, the association steps in to pay covered claims up to limits set by state law, funded by assessments on the other insurers doing business in the state. It is a safety net, not a substitute for choosing a sound company.

What varies by state is substantial:

  • The dollar limits per person.
  • Whether health maintenance organizations (HMOs) and other managed care organizations are covered, or have their own separate arrangement. Some states cover them within the guaranty system; others rely on different rules.
  • Whether certain types of products are excluded.
  • How quickly claims are paid and how long coverage continues after a liquidation order.

Checklist items

  • Look up your state's guaranty association. Its website lists what is covered. If your product is not clearly covered, ask.
  • Do not assume. The existence of a guaranty system does not mean every plan or every claim is protected.
  • Find out how an insolvency would work for your coverage. The companion post what happens to my claims and coverage when a health insurer fails? lays out the order of events.

Guaranty protection does not apply to anything that is not insurance, and it is not available for products sold by unlicensed entities.

Item 6: Compare complaints and service

Financial strength is not the only way an insurer can fail its members. A well-capitalized company can still process claims slowly or make appeals difficult.

Checklist items

  • Check the state's complaint data. Many departments publish complaint counts or ratios. A newer or smaller company will have fewer complaints in absolute terms, so look at the ratio to its size and at trends over more than one year.
  • Read the plan's grievance and appeal process in the plan documents. The documents should explain how to file and the deadlines.
  • Ask whether the company has a local or state-based customer service team. Some do, some do not.
  • Check the network for your own providers. A financially sound plan is no help if your doctors are not in it.

The guide how to compare health insurers: ratings, complaints and service shows how to combine these sources.

Red flags that point to an unlicensed product

Some offers that look like insurance from a small or new company are not insurance at all. The signs are worth knowing because the protections above do not apply.

  • The seller cannot be found on your state's license lookup, or gives only a post office box and a toll-free number.
  • The materials say "not insurance," "membership" or "discount." A health care sharing ministry is not insurance, and a discount card is not coverage. Neither is covered by a guaranty fund. See fake health plans and discount cards: how they differ from insurance.
  • The plan says it is "ACA compliant" but is not listed on your marketplace and the seller has no state license. A plan that counts as minimum essential coverage is sold by a licensed insurer, in the marketplace or through a state-approved channel.
  • The price is far below comparable plans, with no clear reason, or the plan excludes major categories of care.
  • Pressure to pay immediately, to pay by gift card or wire transfer, or to sign before you can read the full policy.
  • No written policy, only a summary, and a refusal to send the full contract.
  • A claim that the card is "accepted by" thousands of providers, with no network directory you can check.
  • An unsolicited call or text, especially one claiming to be from "the marketplace" or "Medicare."

If you meet any of these, the guide how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it covers what to do next, including reporting to your state department.

A short decision list

  • If the company is not licensed in your state for health insurance: do not buy it, and report it to the state department.
  • If it is licensed and on the marketplace, but new or unrated: read the filings and the department's response; compare the network, drugs and total cost with the established options; and weigh how much the lower premium or better network is worth to you against the extra uncertainty.
  • If it is licensed, backed by a larger parent or hospital system, and rated or well documented: treat it like any other plan and compare on cost, network and service.
  • If you have an ongoing condition or an upcoming procedure: the cost of a plan failing mid-year is higher for you, so give the continuity question more weight.

Specifics for your situation come from a marketplace navigator, a licensed broker or your state insurance department, which can tell you what is on file for a given company.

Key takeaways

  • Start with licensing: look up the exact legal entity on your state insurance department's site, because the other protections depend on it.
  • Newness and small size raise the odds of a financially stressful year, but they are not disqualifying; check ownership, growth, filings and any outside rating, and treat "unrated" as "less information."
  • A thin margin means a modest estimating error can exceed profit, so reserves, reinsurance and a financially strong parent are what to ask about.
  • State guaranty associations are a safety net with limits that vary by state and product, so look up what yours covers instead of assuming.
  • Products labelled as memberships, discounts or "not insurance" are a different category with no guaranty protection; report suspected unlicensed sellers to the state.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic