Health care sharing ministries (not insurance)

Liberty HealthShare: plans, ratings and contacts

Canton, Ohio sharing ministry, not insurance: members pool monthly shares toward each other's medical bills. Regulators and the press have scrutinized it.

Also known as Liberty Healthshare, Gospel Light Mennonite Church Medical Aid Plan, Liberty HealthShare Ministry

Size185,900 families helped, cumulative (company website, 2026)
Where it sellsOffered nationally by its own account; sold under the name Liberty HealthShare, with state regulators disputing its status in at least New Mexico
Member services855-585-4237

Contact

Member services 855-585-4237
Website libertyhealthshare.org
Headquarters address 4455 Hills and Dales Rd. NW, Canton, OH 44708

Company

Legal name Gospel Light Mennonite Church Medical Aid Plan, Inc.
Headquarters Canton, Ohio
Founded 1995
Ownership Religious medical aid plan (nonprofit); legal entity Gospel Light Mennonite Church Medical Aid Plan, Inc.

Where and what

Where it sells Offered nationally by its own account; sold under the name Liberty HealthShare, with state regulators disputing its status in at least New Mexico
Plan types Health care sharing programs (Freedom, Rise, Essential, Connect, Unite, Assist), dental and vision sharing for existing members

Size

Members 185,900 families helped, cumulative (company website, 2026)

Fit

Best suited to People who accept a faith-based, voluntary cost-sharing arrangement and understand that it is not insurance and does not guarantee payment.

Plans and products

  • Health care sharing programs
  • dental sharing
  • vision sharing

Brands and plan names

  • Liberty Freedom
  • Liberty Rise
  • Liberty Essential
  • Liberty Connect
  • Liberty Unite
  • Liberty Assist

Liberty HealthShare is not health insurance. It is a Christian health care sharing ministry based in Canton, Ohio, in which members send monthly contributions that the ministry directs toward other members' eligible medical bills. Nothing in that arrangement is a promise to pay, and the ministry says so on its own site. This page describes the organization, its programs and what regulators and reporters have said about it, so a reader can weigh it against real coverage.

Overview

Liberty HealthShare is a name used by the Gospel Light Mennonite Church Medical Aid Plan, Inc., which describes the program as a healthcare sharing ministry. A health care sharing ministry is a membership group, usually faith-based, whose members share bills voluntarily. There is no insurance contract, no network and no legal duty to pay a claim. See health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? for the general picture.

The home page says more than 185,900 families have been helped since the ministry began, and that more than $87 million was shared toward eligible medical expenses in 2025. The first figure is cumulative, not a count of current members. In its 2023 report on Colorado's health care sharing data, KFF Health News said Liberty had more than 131,000 members nationwide in 2021.

History

By the ministry's account, it began in 1995 when five families who started the Gospel Light Mennonite Church in Virginia set up a congregational plan to share medical costs. New Mexico regulators recorded that the Virginia corporation was incorporated on or about June 24, 2014 and that Liberty HealthShare became a registered trade name in Ohio effective November 15, 2014. The ministry told reporters it received federal recognition as a sharing ministry that year, which at the time exempted members from the ACA individual mandate penalty; that penalty has been zero since 2019.

MinistryWatch reported that a new chief executive joined in 2021, that the ministry is not a member of the Healthcare Sharing Accreditation Board and that it says it is considering accreditation options.

Plans and products

The company's website lists several sharing programs: Liberty Freedom (for people under 35), Liberty Rise (ages 18 to 29), Liberty Essential, Liberty Connect and Liberty Unite, and Liberty Assist for people 65 and older who have Medicare Parts A and B. The middle three differ in the share of each bill the member covers first: Essential lists a 10% co-share, Connect 5% and Unite none. Liberty Dental and Liberty Vision are offered to existing members. Amounts and eligibility change, so read the current guidelines before relying on any of this.

Liberty does not sell ACA marketplace plans, Medicare Advantage or Medigap, and membership is not minimum essential coverage.

Where it sells

The ministry markets nationally. State law varies: many states have statutes saying a ministry is not insurance, and others do not. New Mexico is one that does not, according to the findings described below. Residents of any state can ask their state insurance department how it treats sharing ministries.

How sharing works

Members pay a monthly share according to their program, submit eligible bills and wait for the ministry to decide what to share. The ministry says eligible expenses are shared in an average of 30 to 45 days, a figure it gave MinistryWatch. Guidelines typically limit sharing for pre-existing condition items and for services the ministry does not consider eligible, and the member stays responsible for any bill that is not shared.

Ratings and reputation

Liberty is not rated by AM Best or NCQA, because it is not an insurer. What exists is a record of regulatory and press scrutiny, summarized here as reported and not as a finding about intent.

Ohio and ProPublica. In a report published February 25, 2023, ProPublica said the ministry was controlled by members of one Ohio family, that more than 70 members described unpaid bills, and that the Ohio attorney general's charity division had investigated; it reported a 2021 settlement in which the family agreed to pay $6.4 million, mostly toward member expenses, with no defendant admitting wrongdoing. ProPublica said the family's lawyers described the business dealings as arm's-length and at market rates. The ministry's chief executive said it was reducing its claims backlog and had ended a contract with a family-linked marketing firm. MinistryWatch later wrote that the ministry disputes the reporting.

New Mexico. On November 23, 2021 the state's Office of Superintendent of Insurance issued a cease-and-desist and show-cause order (docket 2021-0085). Liberty requested a hearing on December 10, 2021. In its proposed findings of October 2022 the office said Liberty holds no certificate of authority to transact insurance in the state; Liberty maintains its program is a sharing ministry exempt from insurance regulation. MinistryWatch reported in January 2024 that the state had fined it $10 million, later reduced to $2.1 million, and that the case was on appeal. Bloomberg Law reported on February 27, 2025 that the Tenth Circuit affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction in a challenge to the order, in a nonprecedential opinion. Current status should be checked with the New Mexico regulator.

Costs and savings

Monthly shares depend on program, age and household and are published on the ministry's site; they are not quoted here. Compare them with the total you could owe in a bad year, including the part of each bill not shared. The ministry reported revenue of about $163 million in 2024, according to a spokesperson quoted by MinistryWatch.

Enrolling and member service

Enrollment is online or by phone through the ministry. Because there is no insurer, there is no legal appeal right or external review of a sharing decision; complaints can go to the ministry and to the state insurance department or attorney general. See how to file a complaint with your state insurance department.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: Faith-based community, lower monthly amounts than many insurance premiums, free choice of providers, and dental, vision and Medicare-age programs.
  • Weaknesses: No guarantee of payment, no ACA protections, limits on pre-existing conditions, and a documented record of regulator and press scrutiny.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Phone (listed on home page) 855-585-4237
Website https://www.libertyhealthshare.org
Mailing address 4455 Hills and Dales Rd. NW, Canton, OH 44708

Sources

  1. libertyhealthshare.org/
  2. ministrywatch.com/amp/liberty-healthshare-ministry-grows-membership-expands-plan-options/
  3. propublica.org/article/liberty-healthshare-healthcare-sharing-ministries-obamacare
  4. edocket.osi.state.nm.us/api/documents/5708-081
  5. news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/health-ministry-loses-appeal-against-new-mexico-insurance-a…
  6. ministrywatch.com/health-share-group-sues-new-mexico/
  7. kffhealthnews.org/health-care-costs/health-sharing-arrangements-ministries-protections-r…

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states