Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists

MediGold: plans, ratings and contacts

Nonprofit Medicare Advantage plans from Trinity Health in Ohio, Iowa, Michigan and New York, sold under several local names. Idaho plan ends for 2027.

Also known as Mount Carmel MediGold, Trinity Health Plan, MercyOne Health Plan, Saint Alphonsus Health Plan, Trinity Health Plan of Michigan, Trinity Health Plan New York

Size99,515 Medicare Advantage members across Trinity Health plans, 64,485 of them in MediGold (CMS enrollment by contract, November 2026)
Where it sellsOhio, Iowa, Michigan and New York (selected counties); Idaho plan, Saint Alphonsus Health Plan, no longer offers Medicare Advantage in 2027

Company

Legal name Mount Carmel Health Plan, Inc.
Ownership Nonprofit; part of Trinity Health, a not-for-profit health system
Parent company Trinity Health Corporation

Where and what

Where it sells Ohio, Iowa, Michigan and New York (selected counties); Idaho plan, Saint Alphonsus Health Plan, no longer offers Medicare Advantage in 2027
Plan types Medicare Advantage HMO and PPO plans (HMO only in Michigan and New York)
Network types HMO, PPO

Size

Members 99,515 Medicare Advantage members across Trinity Health plans, 64,485 of them in MediGold (CMS enrollment by contract, November 2026)

Fit

Best suited to People with Medicare in a Trinity Health region who want a plan tied to that health system and its local hospitals and doctors.

Plans and products

  • Medicare Advantage HMO
  • Medicare Advantage PPO

Brands and plan names

  • Mount Carmel MediGold
  • MercyOne Health Plan
  • Saint Alphonsus Health Plan
  • Trinity Health Plan of Michigan
  • Trinity Health Plan New York

MediGold is a name for the Medicare Advantage plans owned by Trinity Health, a not-for-profit health system. The plans carry local names in each region: Mount Carmel MediGold in Ohio, MercyOne Health Plan in Iowa, Trinity Health Plan of Michigan, Trinity Health Plan New York and, until the end of 2026, Saint Alphonsus Health Plan in Idaho. They sell only to people with Medicare.

Overview

Medicare Advantage, also called Part C, is the private-plan way to get Medicare benefits; see Medicare Advantage and Medicare Advantage explained: how Part C plans work. Trinity Health's plans are a health-system-owned insurer, which means the plan, its hospitals and many of its doctors share an owner. The plan website, thpmedicare.org, describes the plans as part of a not-for-profit health system and presents them under the Trinity Health Plan name. According to the federal monthly enrollment file for November 2026, Trinity Health plans had 99,515 Medicare Advantage members, of whom 64,485 were in the MediGold contract.

History

The plan sites this profile opened give no founding date or detailed history, so none is stated. They do show that the plans carry several names. Trinity Health's Medicare page describes its wholly owned plans as "powered by MediGold" and lists a different local name in each state, and the plan site's legal notices show that the insurance entities behind them include Mount Carmel Health Plan, Inc., Mount Carmel Health Insurance Company, Mount Carmel Health Plan of Idaho, Inc. and Mount Carmel Health Plan of New York, Inc. Anyone with an older card or paperwork under the MediGold name should check the current plan name and contract number.

Plans and products

The plan site lists one plan family per state:

State Plan name
Idaho Saint Alphonsus Health Plan
Iowa MercyOne Health Plan
Michigan Trinity Health Plan of Michigan
New York Trinity Health Plan New York
Ohio Mount Carmel MediGold

According to the plan's legal notices, the Iowa and Ohio plans are HMO or PPO plans, and the Michigan and New York plans are HMOs. The same notices list Medicare contract numbers H3668 (Ohio, Iowa and New York) and H1846 (Ohio and Iowa). A health maintenance organization generally covers care from its network, while a preferred provider organization allows out-of-network care at higher cost; see HMO and PPO. The pages this profile used did not mention special needs plans, so none are stated. Premiums and benefits change every year; this profile quotes none.

Where it sells

For 2026 the plans are offered in select counties of Idaho, Iowa, Michigan, New York and Ohio. The plan's local-plans page announces two changes for 2027:

  • Idaho: Saint Alphonsus Health Plan will no longer offer Medicare Advantage plans in 2027. Members there would need to choose another Medicare Advantage plan or Original Medicare during open enrollment; see How to leave a Medicare Advantage plan: dates, options and risks.
  • Ohio: Mount Carmel MediGold will no longer be offered in Northwest Ohio counties after December 31, 2026.

Trinity Health's own Medicare page describes availability as "select counties," and its text was not consistent about Michigan, so the Medicare Plan Finder is the reliable way to see what is offered at an address. See Ohio for the Ohio market.

Networks and how its plans work

Each plan is built around the hospitals and doctors of the local Trinity Health region, with additional contracted providers. As with any Medicare Advantage plan, members should confirm that their doctors and hospitals are in the network before scheduled care, and some services may require approval from the plan in advance.

Ratings and reputation

This profile found no Star Rating for these contracts in a source it opened, so none is stated. CMS rates every Medicare Advantage contract from 1 to 5 stars each October, and the Medicare Plan Finder shows the 2027 rating for each plan. Nationally, CMS said about 71% of Medicare Advantage drug-plan enrollees were in contracts with 4 or more stars for 2027; see medicare star ratings. The Idaho plan's exit and the withdrawal from Northwest Ohio, which the plan's own site announces, are changes in service area, and the site does not say why they were made.

Enrolling and member service

The plan lists a separate phone line per state, each with TTY 711, and says one number serves both prospective and current members: Idaho 866-614-2418, Iowa 866-615-9157, Michigan 866-619-4838, New York 866-614-4046 and Ohio 866-613-4920. Trinity Health's Medicare page lists a general number, 866-761-3348. The annual enrollment period runs October 15 to December 7, and a Medicare Advantage open enrollment period runs January 1 to March 31 for people already in a plan; see Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: October 15 to December 7. Complaints can go through the plan's grievance process or to Medicare at 1-800-MEDICARE.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: nonprofit ownership tied to a health system; local plan names; HMO and PPO choices in Ohio and Iowa.
  • Trade-offs: service areas are limited to select counties and are shrinking in Idaho and Northwest Ohio for 2027; networks center on one health system's region; the brand names have changed, which can confuse members and doctors.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Ohio (Mount Carmel MediGold) 866-613-4920
Iowa (MercyOne Health Plan) 866-615-9157
Michigan (Trinity Health Plan of Michigan) 866-619-4838
New York (Trinity Health Plan New York) 866-614-4046
Idaho (Saint Alphonsus Health Plan) 866-614-2418
Trinity Health general Medicare line 866-761-3348
Website https://www.thpmedicare.org/

Sources

  1. thpmedicare.org/about-us
  2. thpmedicare.org/our-local-plans
  3. thpmedicare.org/legal
  4. trinity-health.org/my-benefits/medicare-social-security/find-a-medicare-advantage-or-sup…
  5. cms.gov/data-research/statistics-trends-and-reports/medicare-advantagepart-d-contract-an…

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states