Regional and provider-owned plans

MercyCare Health Plans (Mercyhealth): plans, ratings and contacts

Mercyhealth's Janesville, Wisconsin health plan, selling individual and employer HMO coverage in southern Wisconsin and northern Illinois.

Also known as MercyCare, MercyCare HMO, MercyCare Insurance Company

SizeNot published in the sources read
Where it sellsSouthern Wisconsin and northern Illinois (Rock, Jefferson, Green and Walworth counties in Wisconsin; Winnebago, McHenry and Boone counties in Illinois)
Member services800-895-2421

Contact

Member services 800-895-2421
New members and sales 608-314-2508
Website mercycarehealthplans.com
Headquarters address 580 N. Washington, Janesville, WI

Company

Legal name MercyCare HMO, Inc. and MercyCare Insurance Company
Headquarters Janesville, Wisconsin
Founded 1994
Ownership Wholly owned by Mercyhealth (Mercy Health System Corporation, owned by Mercy Health Corporation); the state describes the HMO as a for-profit stock company
Parent company Mercyhealth

Where and what

Where it sells Southern Wisconsin and northern Illinois (Rock, Jefferson, Green and Walworth counties in Wisconsin; Winnebago, McHenry and Boone counties in Illinois)
Plan types ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, Wisconsin Medicaid managed care contract
Network types HMO, EPO, POS
ACA metal levels Bronze, Silver, Gold
HSA-eligible plans Yes

Size

Members Not published in the sources read

Fit

Best suited to People in the Janesville, Rockford and Walworth County areas who already use or are willing to use Mercyhealth clinics and hospitals.

Plans and products

  • ACA marketplace plans
  • employer plans

Brands and plan names

  • MercyCare HMO
  • MercyCare Insurance Company
  • MercyCare Silver Health Savings

MercyCare Health Plans is the insurance arm of Mercyhealth, a health system based in Janesville, Wisconsin, with hospitals and clinics in southern Wisconsin and northern Illinois. This profile describes it as of November 16, 2026. The company's own website could not be opened, so details come from a company member guide, state regulator documents and a marketplace summary.

Overview

MercyCare sells HMO coverage to individuals, families and employers. Its own materials say it has provided coverage since 1994. Two licensed companies sit behind the brand: MercyCare Insurance Company, incorporated in Wisconsin in 1993, and MercyCare HMO, Inc., incorporated in 2004. A Wisconsin regulator filing shows that, effective January 1, 2025, the two were reorganized so the HMO became the parent of the insurance company, mainly so a combined point-of-service product could be offered under one certificate. Both are ultimately owned by Mercyhealth.

The roster for this directory described MercyCare as nonprofit. The Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance describes MercyCare HMO as a for-profit group model HMO that is owned by the health system, so this profile does not call it nonprofit. See provider-owned health plans: when the insurer and the hospital are one.

History

The health system behind the plan, Mercyhealth, was formed by the 2015 merger of Mercy Health System and Rockford Health System. According to the regulator, Mercy Health Corporation became the ultimate controlling company on January 1, 2016. The HMO began business on September 30, 2004, and it contracts with Mercyhealth for hospital and physician services.

Plans and products

Individual and family plans. The 2026 guide lists nine individual plans in Wisconsin and Illinois, including gold, silver and bronze levels and a silver plan that works with a health savings account (HSA). Each is a different mix of deductible, copays and coinsurance, so compare the summary of benefits for the plan you are considering. Tax credits and cost-sharing reductions require buying through the marketplace (premium tax credit).

Employer plans. MercyCare sells HMO and point-of-service plans to small and large employers in Wisconsin and Illinois. In Illinois, its 2026 small-group HMO rates were approved by the state for the off-exchange market in Winnebago, McHenry and Boone counties, at an average increase of 4.2 percent for about 219 expected members, with platinum, gold and silver levels.

Medicaid. The 2024 state examination notes that MercyCare HMO holds a Medicaid contract with the Wisconsin Department of Health Services. This profile does not describe that program's coverage in detail.

Where it sells

The company's business plan lists Rock, Jefferson, Green and Walworth counties in Wisconsin and Winnebago, McHenry and Boone counties in Illinois as the HMO's service area. Its 2026 individual guide also shows provider locations in Lake, Ogle and Lee counties in Illinois. Wisconsin's marketplace listed MercyCare among its 2027 insurers, according to healthinsurance.org. See Wisconsin and Illinois.

Networks and how its plans work

The HMO requires members to choose a primary care provider, and care outside the network needs prior authorization except in emergencies. The regulator's examination counted 297 primary care physicians, 1,524 specialists and 11 acute-care hospitals under contract, with Mercyhealth hospitals in Janesville, Walworth, Harvard, Crystal Lake and Rockford among them. Some Jefferson County providers are not in the HMO network, so check the directory (HMO).

Ratings and reputation

No AM Best rating, NCQA rating or CMS rating was confirmed for this profile. The Wisconsin regulator publishes examination reports on the company; the most recent one read, covering December 31, 2024, was dated October 7, 2025. For complaints, contact the plan first, then the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance or the Illinois Department of Insurance (how to file a complaint with your state insurance department).

Costs and savings

Premiums depend on age, county and plan level and this profile does not quote prices. According to healthinsurance.org, the approved 2027 increase for MercyCare's Wisconsin individual plans was 26.9 percent before subsidies, against a weighted average of 21.7 percent across Wisconsin insurers. Subsidies change what people pay.

Enrolling and member service

For 2026 the company's guide gave a November 1 to December 15, 2025 enrollment window; for plan year 2027 HealthCare.gov's open enrollment runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, with December 15 the deadline for January 1 coverage. The guide lists 608-314-2508 for individual sales and 800-895-2421 (Wisconsin) or 877-908-6027 (Illinois) for customer service, Monday to Friday, 8 am to 5 pm.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: a network built around one health system, individual and group plans, and an HSA-eligible silver option.
  • Weaknesses: narrow geography, an HMO structure that limits out-of-network care, and a large approved 2027 increase for individual plans.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Customer service, Wisconsin 800-895-2421
Customer service, Illinois 877-908-6027
Individual plan sales 608-314-2508
Website https://www.mercycarehealthplans.com

Sources

  1. oci.wi.gov/Documents/Companies/FinMercyCareHMO.pdf
  2. oci.wi.gov/Documents/Companies/AcqMCHMORecMemo.pdf
  3. res.cloudinary.com/dpmykpsih/image/upload/mercyhealth-site-398/media/f8cd5a366bf1443d97f…
  4. idoi.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/insurance/consumers/documents/2026-rate-determi…
  5. healthinsurance.org/wisconsin-state-health-insurance-exchange/

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest MercyCare Health Plans (Mercyhealth) news

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states