Tools

Deductible vs premium break-even calculator

Finds how much care you must use before a higher-premium, lower-deductible plan costs less than a cheaper plan, and where the difference stops mattering.

Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.

How to use it

  1. Enter two plans: premium (your share), deductible, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximum, the copays you expect for the year, and any employer or HSA/HRA money. It does not matter which plan goes first; the tool works out which one has the lower premium.
  2. Optionally enter the allowed charges you expect this year. The break-even does not depend on it; it only adds a row to the table.
  3. Read the break-even point, the table at several amounts of care, and the note on the most the premium difference can matter.

How the math works

Each plan's yearly cost is twelve premiums plus your share of care, minus any account money. Your share is the deductible, then coinsurance on the remainder, plus copays, never more than the out-of-pocket maximum. As allowed charges rise, the lower-premium plan's cost climbs faster at first because of its higher deductible, and the other plan catches up. The break-even is the amount of allowed charges where the two costs are equal.

The tool finds it exactly rather than by trial and error. Both costs are straight lines between a few bend points (the deductibles and the points where the maximums are reached), so it solves each stretch and reports every crossing.

Worked example with illustrative numbers and no copays or account money. Plan 1: $350 a month, $5,000 deductible, 30% coinsurance, $9,000 maximum. Plan 2: $520, $1,500, 20%, $6,000.

  • With no care, Plan 1 costs $4,200 and Plan 2 costs $6,240.
  • Between $1,500 and $5,000 of allowed charges, Plan 2 is $6,240 + $1,500 + 20% of the amount over $1,500, and Plan 1 is $4,200 + the charges. Setting them equal gives $4,675.
  • When both reach their maximums, Plan 1 costs $13,200 and Plan 2 costs $12,240, so the higher-premium plan ends up $960 lower.

The tool's own starting numbers add $500 of employer money on Plan 1 and $180 of copays on Plan 2, which moves the break-even to about $4,900. Each case was checked by hand and by script.

What it assumes

  • Allowed charges are what the plans have agreed with providers, and they are the same on both plans.
  • Copays count toward the maximum unless you untick that box.
  • The starting numbers are illustrations.

Where it stops being right

  • It cannot know your year. Treat the break-even as a line to compare your expected care against, not a prediction.
  • If you stay healthy the cheaper plan wins by roughly the premium difference; in a very bad year the plan with the lower maximum wins. Where you land depends on care no one can foresee.
  • It leaves out networks, drug coverage, services that skip the deductible and out-of-network charges. The plan documents and your employer's benefits office, or HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace, have the real terms.
  • HSA tax savings are not included. If a plan qualifies for an HSA, the savings are extra and depend on your tax situation.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Related guides

Terms used here

Latest on this topic