Guides
Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even
How to compare a lower-premium, higher-deductible plan with a pricier one, and compute the level of care at which the pricier plan starts to pay off.
The break-even is the amount of care, measured in allowed charges for the year, at which a plan with a higher premium and lower cost sharing costs the same as a plan with a lower premium and higher cost sharing. Below that amount the cheaper-premium plan wins; above it the pricier plan wins. You find it by writing each plan's yearly total as premiums plus the cost sharing you would pay at different levels of care, then finding where the two totals meet.
Why the cheaper plan is not always cheaper
A plan with a low premium and a high deductible saves you money every month and costs you more when you need care. A plan with a higher premium moves some of the cost from the day you receive care to the twelve monthly payments. Neither is better in general. What matters is how much covered care you will probably use, and how much risk you can absorb if you need much more than you expect. The shorter way to say it: you are paying a price, the extra premium, for a lower deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum, and the break-even tells you whether the price is worth it for a given amount of care.
The method
- For each plan, multiply the monthly premium by 12.
- Write down the deductible, coinsurance rate and out-of-pocket maximum.
- Pick several levels of allowed charges, for example $1,000, $5,000, $10,000 and $20,000.
- For each level, calculate your cost sharing: everything up to the deductible, then the coinsurance share of the rest, stopping at the out-of-pocket maximum. See how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan for the full steps.
- Add the premiums to get each plan's total at each level.
- The break-even is where the two totals are equal.
A labeled example
Say Plan A has a $300 monthly premium, a $5,000 deductible, 30% coinsurance and an $8,000 out-of-pocket maximum. Plan B has a $450 monthly premium, a $1,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance and a $4,000 out-of-pocket maximum. These are round numbers for illustration, not market prices. Premiums for the year are $3,600 for Plan A and $5,400 for Plan B, so Plan B costs $1,800 more up front.
| Allowed charges | Plan A: premiums plus cost sharing | Plan B: premiums plus cost sharing |
|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | $3,600 + $1,000 = $4,600 | $5,400 + $1,000 = $6,400 |
| $3,250 | $3,600 + $3,250 = $6,850 | $5,400 + $1,450 = $6,850 |
| $10,000 | $3,600 + $6,500 = $10,100 | $5,400 + $2,800 = $8,200 |
| $20,000 | $3,600 + $8,000 = $11,600 | $5,400 + $4,000 = $9,400 |
Here is where the numbers come from. At $10,000 in charges, Plan A makes you pay the $5,000 deductible plus 30% of the remaining $5,000, which is $1,500, so $6,500. Plan B has you pay the $1,000 deductible plus 20% of $9,000, which is $1,800, so $2,800. At $20,000, both plans hit their out-of-pocket maximums: $8,000 for Plan A and $4,000 for Plan B.
To find the break-even, look at the range where Plan A is still within its deductible and Plan B is past its own. Plan A's total is $3,600 plus the charges. Plan B's total is $5,400 plus $1,000 plus 20% of the charges above $1,000, which is $6,200 plus 20% of the charges. Setting them equal: $3,600 + C = $6,200 + 0.20C, so 0.80C = $2,600 and C = $3,250. At $3,250 each plan costs $6,850 for the year.
So in this example, if you expect less than $3,250 in covered allowed charges, Plan A is cheaper; if you expect more, Plan B is. The worst case also differs: Plan A's worst year is $3,600 plus $8,000, or $11,600, and Plan B's is $9,400.
How the answer shifts for different households
The same two plans lead to different choices for different people, because the care level is personal.
- A person with a chronic condition who sees a specialist monthly and takes brand-name drugs will probably exceed $3,250 in allowed charges every year, so Plan B is likely the cheaper one for them.
- A couple planning a birth knows they will reach the out-of-pocket maximum, so what matters is the maximum itself: $4,000 for Plan B against $8,000 for Plan A, a $4,000 difference that is larger than the $1,800 premium gap.
- A healthy person who rarely sees a doctor may stay under $3,250 and save money on Plan A, as long as a cushion of savings could cover an unexpected bill up to Plan A's $8,000 maximum.
Each of these is a way of answering the same question: what is the probable range of your care, and what is the cost if you land at the top?
What the break-even does not capture
- Uncertainty. The calculation treats your care level as known. In practice a surprise, such as an accident, can push you well past the break-even; the maximum protects you, but a high maximum can still be a hardship. Consider how you would pay the larger amount.
- Copays and drugs. Many plans pay for office visits and generic drugs with a flat copay before the deductible. Add those separately.
- Preventive care. Recommended preventive services are covered without cost sharing on most plans, so they do not belong in the allowed charges.
- The HSA. If a plan is a HDHP that qualifies for a HSA, contributions are tax-deductible, which lowers the effective cost; a tax professional can say by how much for you. See High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) explained: pros and cons.
- Networks and drugs. A plan that excludes your doctor or drug can cost more than its numbers suggest.
- Cost-sharing reductions. If your income qualifies you for silver-plan cost-sharing reductions, a silver plan can have much lower cost sharing than its premium suggests, which changes the comparison; see bronze, silver, gold and platinum plans: what the metal levels mean.
Practical ways to estimate your care level
Last year's explanations of benefits show your actual allowed charges. Add anything planned: a surgery, a pregnancy, a new drug, therapy visits. If your care is steady, the break-even is easy to apply. If it is hard to predict, compare the worst cases and decide how much risk you can carry. The deductible vs premium break-even calculator runs the calculation for any two plans, and how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs covers the non-price factors.
Key takeaways
- The break-even is the level of covered care at which a higher-premium plan costs the same as a lower-premium one.
- Compute each plan's yearly total at several care levels, and look for where the lines cross.
- Below the break-even the cheaper-premium plan wins; above it the pricier plan wins.
- Compare worst cases too: premiums plus the out-of-pocket maximum.
- Network, drug coverage, copays and HSA tax savings can move the result.