Compare
Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) vs Oscar Health
Medi-Share is a Christian sharing ministry that is not insurance; Oscar is a marketplace insurer whose ACA plans carry federal protections.
Verdict
These are different kinds of products. Oscar Health is an insurer selling ACA marketplace plans, which many people buy with income-based premium tax credits. Medi-Share is a Christian health care sharing ministry: members share one another's eligible bills under written guidelines, and Medi-Share says it is not insurance and that payment is not guaranteed.
The central trade-off is protection versus fit. An ACA plan must meet marketplace rules, including no exclusion of pre-existing conditions, and a denied claim can go to an internal appeal and then external review. A sharing ministry sets its own guidelines, applies faith and lifestyle standards, and limits sharing for pre-existing conditions. Which fits depends on your health, income, faith and risk tolerance; a licensed broker, the marketplace or your state insurance department can answer your individual questions.
Choose Medi-Share if
- You hold the Christian faith, will sign the Statement of Faith and accept the ministry's lifestyle standards.
- You understand that bills not shared remain your responsibility and that sharing is voluntary.
- You want a choice of Annual Household Portion levels, from $1,000 to $12,000 for Medi-Share Complete, and are comfortable with pre-existing condition limits.
- You are 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B, where Medi-Share 65+ is designed to sit alongside Medicare.
Choose Oscar Health if
- You want insurance with ACA protections, sold on the marketplace in its states: about 20 for 2026 and 21 for 2027.
- You may qualify for a premium tax credit, which the marketplace calculates from income and household size.
- You want an app-based insurer, condition-focused plans, or Bronze, Silver or Gold levels.
- You are a small employer interested in an individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement.
Key differences
| Topic | Medi-Share | Oscar Health |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Health care sharing ministry, not insurance | Insurer (NYSE: OSCR) |
| Headquarters | Melbourne, Florida | New York, New York |
| Founded | 1993 | 2012 |
| Payment guarantee | Not guaranteed | Insurance contract |
| Pre-existing conditions | Limited sharing, increasing after 36 and 60 months | Marketplace plans |
| ACA minimum essential coverage | No | Marketplace plans are ACA plans |
| Eligibility | Statement of Faith, lifestyle standards | Residence in covered counties; marketplace rules |
| Subsidies | Not applicable | Premium tax credits through the marketplace |
| Availability | Nationwide, with state disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin | About 20 states for 2026; 21 for 2027 |
| Size | More than 350,000 members (2025) | 2,691,885 effectuated members (September 30, 2026) |
See health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? and how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step for how each handles disputes.
Side by side
| Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) | Oscar Health | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Health care sharing ministries (not insurance) | National health insurers |
| Member services | 800-264-2562 (member services) | 855-672-2755 |
| New members and sales | 800-772-5623 (joining Medi-Share) | 855-951-1159 |
| Website | medishare.com | hioscar.com |
| Headquarters | Melbourne, Florida | New York, New York |
| Founded | 1993 | 2012 |
| Ownership | Nonprofit religious ministry | Investor-owned (NYSE: OSCR) |
| Parent company | Christian Care Ministry, Inc. | — |
| Stock ticker | — | OSCR |
| Where it sells | Offered nationally; the site carries state-specific disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, and Maryland members pay providers directly under a Maryland Insurance Administration determination | ACA individual market in about 20 states for plan year 2026 and 21 states (713 counties) for 2027 |
| Plan types | Health care sharing (Medi-Share Complete for individuals and families; Medi-Share 65+ for members 65 and older with Medicare Parts A and B) | ACA marketplace plans (Bronze, Silver, Gold), condition-focused plans, small-business and ICHRA offerings, vision and dental |
| Network types | Provider discount network | — |
| ACA metal levels | — | Bronze, Silver, Gold |
| Members | 350,000+ members (Medi-Share's website, 2025) | 2,691,885 effectuated members (September 30, 2026) |
| Revenue | — | $11.7 billion (2025) |
| Best suited to | People who hold a Christian faith, accept the ministry's lifestyle and sharing guidelines, and understand that bill sharing is voluntary and not guaranteed. | Marketplace shoppers in its states who want an app-based insurer with condition-focused plan options, and small employers using an individual-coverage arrangement. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026