Compare

Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) vs Oscar Health

Medi-Share is a Christian sharing ministry that is not insurance; Oscar is a marketplace insurer whose ACA plans carry federal protections.

Verdict

These are different kinds of products. Oscar Health is an insurer selling ACA marketplace plans, which many people buy with income-based premium tax credits. Medi-Share is a Christian health care sharing ministry: members share one another's eligible bills under written guidelines, and Medi-Share says it is not insurance and that payment is not guaranteed.

The central trade-off is protection versus fit. An ACA plan must meet marketplace rules, including no exclusion of pre-existing conditions, and a denied claim can go to an internal appeal and then external review. A sharing ministry sets its own guidelines, applies faith and lifestyle standards, and limits sharing for pre-existing conditions. Which fits depends on your health, income, faith and risk tolerance; a licensed broker, the marketplace or your state insurance department can answer your individual questions.

Choose Medi-Share if

  • You hold the Christian faith, will sign the Statement of Faith and accept the ministry's lifestyle standards.
  • You understand that bills not shared remain your responsibility and that sharing is voluntary.
  • You want a choice of Annual Household Portion levels, from $1,000 to $12,000 for Medi-Share Complete, and are comfortable with pre-existing condition limits.
  • You are 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B, where Medi-Share 65+ is designed to sit alongside Medicare.

Choose Oscar Health if

  • You want insurance with ACA protections, sold on the marketplace in its states: about 20 for 2026 and 21 for 2027.
  • You may qualify for a premium tax credit, which the marketplace calculates from income and household size.
  • You want an app-based insurer, condition-focused plans, or Bronze, Silver or Gold levels.
  • You are a small employer interested in an individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement.

Key differences

Topic Medi-Share Oscar Health
Type Health care sharing ministry, not insurance Insurer (NYSE: OSCR)
Headquarters Melbourne, Florida New York, New York
Founded 1993 2012
Payment guarantee Not guaranteed Insurance contract
Pre-existing conditions Limited sharing, increasing after 36 and 60 months Marketplace plans
ACA minimum essential coverage No Marketplace plans are ACA plans
Eligibility Statement of Faith, lifestyle standards Residence in covered counties; marketplace rules
Subsidies Not applicable Premium tax credits through the marketplace
Availability Nationwide, with state disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin About 20 states for 2026; 21 for 2027
Size More than 350,000 members (2025) 2,691,885 effectuated members (September 30, 2026)

See health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? and how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step for how each handles disputes.

Side by side

Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) Oscar Health
Type Health care sharing ministries (not insurance) National health insurers
Member services 800-264-2562 (member services) 855-672-2755
New members and sales 800-772-5623 (joining Medi-Share) 855-951-1159
Website medishare.com hioscar.com
Headquarters Melbourne, Florida New York, New York
Founded 1993 2012
Ownership Nonprofit religious ministry Investor-owned (NYSE: OSCR)
Parent company Christian Care Ministry, Inc. —
Stock ticker — OSCR
Where it sells Offered nationally; the site carries state-specific disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, and Maryland members pay providers directly under a Maryland Insurance Administration determination ACA individual market in about 20 states for plan year 2026 and 21 states (713 counties) for 2027
Plan types Health care sharing (Medi-Share Complete for individuals and families; Medi-Share 65+ for members 65 and older with Medicare Parts A and B) ACA marketplace plans (Bronze, Silver, Gold), condition-focused plans, small-business and ICHRA offerings, vision and dental
Network types Provider discount network —
ACA metal levels — Bronze, Silver, Gold
Members 350,000+ members (Medi-Share's website, 2025) 2,691,885 effectuated members (September 30, 2026)
Revenue — $11.7 billion (2025)
Best suited to People who hold a Christian faith, accept the ministry's lifestyle and sharing guidelines, and understand that bill sharing is voluntary and not guaranteed. Marketplace shoppers in its states who want an app-based insurer with condition-focused plan options, and small employers using an individual-coverage arrangement.
Plans and products
  • Health care sharing
  • member discounts
  • telehealth
  • prescription discounts
  • ACA marketplace plans
  • HelloMeno
  • RetireEase
  • CHOICE Arrangement
  • Oscar Vision and Dental
Brands and plan names
  • Medi-Share Complete
  • Medi-Share 65+
  • Oscar Insurance Company
  • Oscar Insurance Company of Texas
  • Oscar Health Plan of California

Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest news on both companies