Compare

Mutual of Omaha vs Physicians Mutual

Two Omaha-based, policyholder-owned insurers selling Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and add-on coverage, compared on size, states and products.

Verdict

Mutual of Omaha and Physicians Mutual are both Omaha, Nebraska, insurers owned by their policyholders, and both sell Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies alongside dental and other supplemental coverage. Neither sells ACA marketplace or employer major medical plans, and Medigap has no provider network: you can see any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare.

Mutual of Omaha is much larger in Medigap, with about 1.3 million members and second place by enrollment at the end of 2025, according to Mark Farrah Associates. Physicians Mutual's profile gives no enrollment figure, and notes it sells in about 30 states, according to a third-party review. Mutual of Omaha says its plans cover the nation but vary by state, and its own profile could not verify a state list. For either company, confirm availability, plan letter and the issuing company in your state's outline of coverage. Premiums are not compared here, since they vary by plan letter, age, state, tobacco use and rating method.

Choose Mutual of Omaha if

  • You want the larger Medigap book among the two, and a company that reports an AM Best rating of A+ (Superior) from April 2026.
  • You want a plan from a list that includes Plans A, C, D, F, G, M and N, including high-deductible Plan G or Plan F.
  • You may want add-ons such as hospital indemnity, critical illness, cancer or long-term care coverage from the same company.
  • You want to request a quote online, through an agent or by phone.

Choose Physicians Mutual if

  • You are in one of the 30 states listed in a September 2026 third-party review, and prefer to buy directly by phone or online.
  • You are looking at Plans A, B, F, G and N, high-deductible F and G, or its Innovative Plan G rider, as that review described them.
  • You want dental insurance from the same company, with annual maximums and waiting periods.
  • You value a recent AM Best upgrade to A+ (Superior), announced in November 2025.

Key differences

Topic Mutual of Omaha Physicians Mutual
Ownership Policyholder-owned mutual; holding company since April 1, 2026 Policyholder-owned mutual
Headquarters Omaha, Nebraska Omaha, Nebraska
Founded 1909 1902
Medigap members About 1.3 million, 9.4% of the market (December 2025) Not stated
States Most states; varies by state About 30 states per one review
Plan letters named A, C, D, F, G, M, N A, B, F, G, N, and high-deductible F and G
Plan F or C eligibility Only those first eligible before January 1, 2020 Plan F only for those first eligible before January 1, 2020
Dental Yes Yes
Other products Hospital indemnity, critical illness, long-term care, life, annuities, group benefits Cancer coverage, life, pet insurance, funeral pre-planning
AM Best A+ (Superior), April 2026 A+ (Superior), November 2025
Complaint data None found Fewer than the industry average per NAIC, via a third-party review

See Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N and medigap open enrollment period for how the six-month window works.

Side by side

Mutual of Omaha Physicians Mutual
Type Medigap and senior market carriers Medigap and senior market carriers
Member services 800-775-6000 —
New members and sales 888-981-5642 —
Website mutualofomaha.com physiciansmutual.com
Headquarters Omaha, Nebraska Omaha, Nebraska
Founded 1909 1902
Ownership Mutual insurance company (policyholder-owned); since April 1, 2026 organized under Mutual of Omaha Holding Company Mutual (policyholder-owned)
Parent company Mutual of Omaha Holding Company —
Where it sells Medicare Supplement plans in most states; plans and policy forms vary by state About 30 states per a September 2026 ValuePenguin review; not available in every state
Plan types Medicare Supplement (Medigap), hospital indemnity, dental, critical illness, cancer, heart attack and stroke coverage, long-term care, group dental and vision, life insurance and annuities Medicare Supplement (Medigap), dental insurance, supplemental health and cancer coverage, life insurance, pet insurance, funeral pre-planning
Members About 1.3 million Medigap members, 9.4% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) —
AM Best financial strength A+ (Superior) A+ (Superior)
Best suited to People on Original Medicare who want a standardized Medigap plan from a mutual insurer, and people shopping for add-on benefits such as dental or hospital indemnity. People on Original Medicare, or looking for dental or supplemental coverage, who prefer to buy from a mutual company directly by phone or online.
Plans and products
  • Medicare Supplement
  • hospital indemnity
  • dental
  • critical illness
  • long-term care
  • life insurance
  • annuities
  • group benefits
  • Medicare Supplement
  • dental insurance
  • supplemental health insurance
  • life insurance
  • pet insurance
Brands and plan names
  • Mutual of Omaha
  • Omaha Supplemental Insurance Company
  • United of Omaha Life
  • Companion Life
  • Physicians Mutual
  • Physicians Life

Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest news on both companies