Medigap and senior market carriers

Physicians Mutual: plans, ratings and contacts

Omaha-based mutual insurer selling Medicare Supplement (Medigap), dental and other senior-market coverage in about 30 states, mostly by phone and online.

Also known as Physicians Mutual Insurance Company, Physicians Life Insurance Company

Where it sellsAbout 30 states per a September 2026 ValuePenguin review; not available in every state
AM Best ratingA+ (Superior)

Contact

Website physiciansmutual.com

Company

Legal name Physicians Mutual Insurance Company
Headquarters Omaha, Nebraska
Founded 1902
Ownership Mutual (policyholder-owned)

Where and what

Where it sells About 30 states per a September 2026 ValuePenguin review; not available in every state
Plan types Medicare Supplement (Medigap), dental insurance, supplemental health and cancer coverage, life insurance, pet insurance, funeral pre-planning

Ratings

AM Best financial strength A+ (Superior)
AM Best rating as of 2025-11

Fit

Best suited to People on Original Medicare, or looking for dental or supplemental coverage, who prefer to buy from a mutual company directly by phone or online.

Plans and products

  • Medicare Supplement
  • dental insurance
  • supplemental health insurance
  • life insurance
  • pet insurance

Brands and plan names

  • Physicians Mutual
  • Physicians Life

Physicians Mutual is an Omaha, Nebraska insurer owned by its policyholders rather than by shareholders. It sells dental insurance, Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies and other senior-market coverage, and it does not offer ACA marketplace or employer medical plans. This page describes the group as a whole, with a focus on its Medigap and dental lines.

Overview

A mutual insurer is owned by its policyholders and has no outside stockholders; see mutual insurance company. According to Wikipedia, the Physicians Mutual group consists of Physicians Mutual Insurance Company and Physicians Life Insurance Company, and its products include Medicare Supplement plans, dental, term and whole life, cancer coverage, funeral pre-planning and, since 2022, pet insurance. Wikipedia reports more than $4 billion in assets and more than 1,000 employees, without a date.

A Medigap policy pays part of what Original Medicare leaves to you, such as deductibles and coinsurance. See medigap and Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N. The company's dental product is ordinary dental insurance with annual maximums and waiting periods; see dental insurance explained: plans, waiting periods and annual limits.

History

Edwin E. Elliott founded the company in 1902 as Physicians Mutual Insurance Company in Omaha, initially to sell health insurance to medical professionals. It began offering policies to the general public in 1962, founded Physicians Life Insurance Company in 1970 to enter life insurance, and added funeral pre-planning in 2012. It started an advertising campaign with an actor in 2019 and began selling pet insurance in 2022, Wikipedia says.

Plans and products

Medicare Supplement. ValuePenguin's review, first published July 13, 2023 and last modified September 30, 2026, said the company sells Plans A, B, F, G and N plus high-deductible F and G, and an Innovative Plan G rider, with a different structure in Wisconsin. Plan F is open only to people who first became eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020. The company's pages were not available to this directory for direct confirmation, so check the plan letters and the issuing company named in your state's outline of coverage.

Dental and other lines. The group also sells dental insurance, supplemental coverage such as cancer policies, life insurance and funeral pre-planning. Supplemental policies of this kind are not major medical insurance and pay set benefits; see accident, hospital indemnity and critical illness plans explained.

Where it sells

ValuePenguin's review listed 30 states: Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia and Wisconsin. Other reviews give different counts, and the company's availability depends on product, so confirm for your state and product before relying on the list.

Networks and how its plans work

Medigap has no network: you can use any provider that accepts Medicare, and the policy pays after Medicare. Buying during the six-month Medigap open enrollment period that begins when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B guarantees you can buy without health questions; later, most states let insurers underwrite. See medigap open enrollment period. KFF reported 12.9 million people, 46% of traditional Medicare, had Medigap in 2024. Mark Farrah Associates reported that Medigap enrollment topped 13.8 million in 2025.

Ratings and reputation

AM Best announced in November 2025 that it had raised the financial strength rating of Physicians Mutual Insurance Company and Physicians Life Insurance Company to A+ (Superior), according to press coverage of the rating action, which this directory could not open in full; AM Best publishes the current rating. ValuePenguin said the company has fewer complaints than the industry average on its Medicare Supplement plans, according to the NAIC, and reported a Better Business Bureau rating of 1.64 out of 5. The NAIC complaint index measures complaints against the expected number for a company's size; your state insurance department has current figures.

Costs and savings

Premiums vary by plan letter, age, state, tobacco use and rating method; the company offers issue-age and attained-age pricing on at least one plan, according to ValuePenguin. This page quotes no prices.

Enrolling and member service

ValuePenguin said Medicare Supplement policies are available online or by phone. For dental and other products, check the company's site for current availability in your state. A State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor gives free comparison help for Medigap.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: policyholder-owned company; no provider network on Medigap; the group sells dental and other lines alongside Medigap; a recent AM Best upgrade.
  • Weaknesses to weigh: not sold in every state; premiums can rise over time; Medigap has no drug coverage; third-party reviews differ on where and how it sells.

How to contact

Service Where
Website https://www.physiciansmutual.com
Quotes and member lines See the contact page on the company's site
Free Medicare counseling Your state's SHIP; 1-800-MEDICARE

Compare with Mutual of Omaha and AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare.

Sources

  1. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physicians_Mutual
  2. valuepenguin.com/physicians-mutual-medigap-review
  3. kff.org/medicare/key-facts-about-medigap-enrollment-and-premiums-for-medicare-beneficiar…
  4. markfarrah.com/mfa-briefs/medicare-supplement-enrollment-slightly-up-in-2025/

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest Physicians Mutual news

Head to head

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states