Blog

Why might my anesthesiologist be out of network at an in-network hospital?

Why hospital-based physician groups can be out of network at an in-network hospital, what the No Surprises Act covers for planned care, and what to ask first.

A hospital is not one business. It is a building and a license, plus a set of doctors who work in it under many different arrangements. When your plan says a hospital is in network, it is describing the hospital's contract with the insurer. The anesthesiologist who puts you to sleep, the radiologist who reads your scan and the pathologist who examines your tissue may each work for a separate group that signs its own contract, or none at all. That is how a person can have a scheduled operation at an in-network hospital and still receive a separate bill from someone the plan treats as out of network.

Federal law now blocks most of the resulting balance bills for care at an in-network facility. It does not remove every surprise, and it does not tell you which planning steps are worth taking. This post explains the structure first, then the law, then the questions to ask before a scheduled procedure.

How a hospital is actually organized

Most patients meet three kinds of professionals at a hospital:

  1. Employees of the hospital or its system. Nurses, technicians and often hospital-employed doctors. Their services are usually billed under the hospital's contract and appear on the facility bill.
  2. Independent doctors with admitting privileges. Your surgeon may run a private practice and operate at the hospital as a guest, billing through the practice.
  3. Hospital-based physician groups under contract. These are groups that staff a department and bill on their own. The hospital signs an agreement under which the group provides, say, anesthesia coverage for the operating rooms, and the group negotiates with insurers separately.

The third arrangement is the one behind most unexpected out-of-network bills. A group has its own tax identification, its own billing office and its own decisions about which insurers to contract with. A hospital can sign an agreement with an insurer on a Tuesday without the group changing anything it does. The hospital and the group share a building and a patient, but not necessarily a contract.

Which services are most often billed separately

The services most often billed by a separate group, on a separate statement, include:

  • Anesthesiology, including the anesthesiologist and the certified registered nurse anesthetist.
  • Radiology, meaning the doctor who interprets an X-ray, CT or MRI, as distinct from the technician who takes it and the facility that owns the machine.
  • Pathology, the doctor who examines a biopsy or a sample. Laboratory work may also go to an outside lab.
  • Emergency medicine, the physicians staffing the emergency room.
  • Hospitalists and intensivists, doctors who manage hospitalized patients or those in intensive care.
  • Neonatology, the newborn specialists who may see a baby whose delivery has complications.
  • Assistant surgeons, who help the lead surgeon and bill on their own.

There is a second category worth knowing about: the facility fee and the professional fee for the same visit. A hospital outpatient department may bill a facility fee for the room and equipment and a professional fee for the doctor's work. Those two bills can come from different entities even when the doctor is employed. See Why did I get two bills for one visit: facility fee and doctor fee? for that pattern.

Why a group might stay out of network

Groups and insurers describe the reasons differently, and both accounts deserve a hearing. Physician groups say that insurers offer rates that do not cover the cost of staffing round-the-clock coverage, and that staying out of network keeps their payment from being set by a single insurer. Insurers say that a group that is the only one staffing a hospital's operating rooms has leverage to demand high rates, and that the rates would raise premiums for everyone if they accepted them. Before the federal law, the patient was the person caught between the two positions, because the balance bill was the way the dispute landed on the member.

Hospitals are also part of the picture. Some require the groups they hire to contract with the same insurers the hospital does; others do not. The contracts are private, and neither the plan's directory nor the hospital's website is likely to tell you which arrangement applies. This is the reason a directory search for the hospital cannot answer the question about the anesthesiologist, and why the questions at the end of this post are about the groups by name.

What the No Surprises Act does and does not do

The No Surprises Act, effective in 2022, applies to most health plans and protects patients from many out-of-network surprise bills. As of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' consumer guidance, it covers emergency care, non-emergency care by out-of-network providers at an in-network hospital, hospital outpatient department or ambulatory surgical center, and air ambulance services.

For a planned procedure at an in-network facility, the practical result is this: if an out-of-network provider treats you there, you generally owe only your in-network cost sharing, the same deductible, copay or coinsurance an in-network provider would have charged you. That amount counts toward your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum. The provider generally may not balance bill you for the rest. The plan and the provider work out the remaining payment between them, and a process called independent dispute resolution exists for them to settle disagreements. The patient is not a party to that process.

Here is a hypothetical with round numbers. Say your plan has a $1,000 deductible, you have met none of it, and the in-network rate for a procedure's anesthesia is $2,000. An out-of-network anesthesia group bills $6,000. Under the protections:

  • You owe your in-network share of the plan's recognized amount, for instance $1,000 deductible + 20% of the remaining $1,000 = $1,000 + $200 = $1,200, if your plan's rate and your coinsurance work out that way.
  • You do not owe the difference between $6,000 and the amount the plan and group settle on.

The actual amounts depend on your plan's recognized-amount calculation, and your explanation of benefits shows what the plan used.

The limits for planned care

The protections have edges, and planned care is where they show most:

  • The facility must be in network, or the situation must be an emergency. If you choose a hospital that is out of network for a planned procedure, the protections generally do not make it in network for you.
  • A provider's own office is not covered. The protection is for services at the facility. A pre-operative visit at the surgeon's office, which is out of network, is billed under ordinary out-of-network rules.
  • Some providers can ask you to waive protection. For certain non-emergency services, an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility can give you a written notice and a consent form that, if you sign it, lets them bill you more. The law keeps a list of services where this is not allowed, and that list includes the ones most often billed by hospital-based groups, such as anesthesiology, pathology, radiology, neonatology, assistant surgeons, hospitalists and intensivists, so a consent form for those services should not be taken at face value. It can be used for other specialists, such as a surgeon you choose who is out of network. A provider also cannot use the form if no in-network provider is available for the service at that facility.
  • The waiver is voluntary. Whether to sign it is your decision. Should I sign the form that waives my surprise-billing protection? covers the choice. If a form is presented, ask for time to read it and ask the plan whether an in-network alternative exists.
  • Ground ambulances are not included in the federal law, though some states protect against them.
  • Coverage type matters. The federal protections apply to most health plans, with other rules for Medicare, Medicaid and veterans' and military coverage. For those, the program's own rules apply.

What this looks like in practice: a scheduled knee surgery

Say Tomas, 55, has a knee arthroscopy scheduled at an in-network surgical center. He asks his surgeon's office whether everyone involved is in network and hears "the hospital is in your plan." He does not ask about the anesthesia group. On the day, an anesthesiologist from an independent group that does not contract with his plan treats him.

Under the federal rules, the group generally cannot send him a balance bill for the difference between its charge and the plan's payment. He should receive an explanation of benefits showing in-network cost sharing for the anesthesia. If a bill arrives for the full balance, the next steps are a call to the group's billing office to say the service appears covered under the No Surprises Act, a call to the plan asking it to confirm how the claim was processed, and, if that fails, a complaint to the state insurance department or the federal help line for these protections. The guide Surprise medical bills and the No Surprises Act: what is protected explains how to proceed.

The better outcome, though, is that nothing needs fixing. Asking before the procedure keeps the paperwork simple, and the questions below are short.

Questions to ask before a scheduled procedure

Call the surgeon's scheduling office and the hospital or surgery center's patient financial services line. Ask:

  1. Which professionals will be involved in my procedure, beyond my surgeon? Ask specifically about anesthesia, radiology, pathology and any assistant surgeon.
  2. For each one, who employs them, and what is the name of the group that bills for them?
  3. Are those groups in network with my plan, under this exact plan name? You will need to confirm with the plan, because the office's answer reflects what it knows.
  4. Will I get a good faith estimate or a cost estimate, and does it include the professional fees as well as the facility fee? A good faith estimate is mandatory for uninsured and self-pay patients, and plans and providers may also offer estimates to insured patients on request.
  5. Will anything be sent to me to sign before the procedure? If it is a notice about out-of-network providers, ask which provider it concerns and why.

Then call your plan with the group's name and ask whether it is in network for your plan. Write down the date, the name of the person and the reference number. The surprise bill protection checker helps you decide whether a particular bill falls under the federal protections.

If an in-network anesthesia group is available, ask whether you may request it. Hospitals do not always let patients choose the anesthesiologist, since the coverage is arranged by schedule, but asking costs nothing and the answer tells you whether the question is moot.

When a bill arrives anyway

Keep every bill and explanation of benefits. Compare the provider's bill with the plan's explanation of benefits to see whether the service was processed as in network or out. how to get an itemized medical bill and spot billing errors explains how to request an itemized bill. If an out-of-network balance bill arrives for a service that appears to be covered by the protections, a related post, i got a bill that should have been protected: my step-by-step dispute, covers the dispute steps in order. For individual questions about whether a specific bill is protected, the state insurance department and the federal help line for the No Surprises Act are the people who can look at your documents.

Key takeaways

  • A hospital's network status describes its contract, not the contracts of the physician groups that work in it, such as anesthesia, radiology and pathology.
  • For planned care at an in-network facility, federal law generally limits out-of-network providers to your in-network cost sharing and bars balance billing for most services.
  • The protections do not cover a hospital you chose that is out of network, a pre-operative visit at an out-of-network office or ground ambulances.
  • Out-of-network providers can sometimes offer a waiver form for certain services, but the law bars it for anesthesia, radiology, pathology and several other hospital-based services, and signing is always your decision.
  • Before a scheduled procedure, ask who beyond the surgeon will be involved, name each group to the plan and keep a dated record.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic