Glossary
Peer-to-peer review
A phone call in which your treating doctor discusses a denial or pending request directly with the insurer's physician reviewer, usually within a short window.
Also called: peer to peer, P2P, peer-to-peer call, doctor-to-doctor review
A peer-to-peer review is a conversation between your treating doctor and a physician working for the insurer, held to discuss why a service was denied or is being questioned. The doctor can explain the clinical picture, answer questions the reviewer has and point to records or studies that may not have been in the original request. If the reviewer is persuaded, the plan can reverse its decision, sometimes the same day.
It is generally informal and separate from a formal internal appeal. Plans often allow a peer-to-peer only for a short period after the decision, commonly measured in days, though this varies by insurer, and the denial letter or the insurer's provider line should state the window. Your doctor, not you, makes the request, and the call generally takes place through the doctor's office. As a labeled hypothetical, a surgeon's office learns a procedure was denied on Monday and is told the peer-to-peer must be requested within five business days.
The common mistake is treating the call as a substitute for the appeal. A peer-to-peer does not necessarily stop the appeal clock, so keep the written deadline in mind and ask the plan whether the call counts as an appeal. If the reviewer upholds the decision, the formal internal appeal and then external review remain available.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026