Blog
How do I compare plans by how hard they make me get approvals?
How to compare plans on prior authorization lists, step therapy, referrals and appeals access when you already expect an MRI, therapy or a specialty drug.
Two plans can charge the same premium, the same deductible and cover the same hospital, and still differ sharply in how many times you must ask permission before care happens. If you already know your year will include an MRI, a course of physical therapy or a specialty drug, those approval rules are part of the price. This post shows how to find them, how to compare them side by side, and what to do with a table of the results.
The illustrations use invented plans and round numbers. They show a method, not what any real plan does. The rules are different for every plan, so the plan's own documents decide.
What "approval burden" actually means
Plans use a set of tools, together called utilization management, to decide when care will be paid for. Four matter most to you as a shopper.
- prior authorization: the plan must approve a service or drug before you receive it, or it may not pay. It often applies to advanced imaging, planned hospital stays, some surgeries, many specialty drugs and sometimes therapy.
- step therapy: the plan requires you to try one or more lower-cost drugs first and show they did not work or were not tolerated before it covers the one your doctor prescribed.
- referral requirements: in HMO-style plans you need a referral from a primary care physician before seeing a specialist, or the plan may not pay.
- Limits and re-authorization: some plans approve therapy visits in blocks and require a new request for each block.
Each tool creates a place where care can be delayed, and each can result in a denial. A denial is not the end, since most plans offer an internal appeal and an independent external review, but every appeal takes time. The more approval steps your expected care contains, the more likely it is that something stalls.
Why this matters when you are choosing, not later
The time to learn that your MRI needs an approval is before you enroll, not on the day your doctor orders it. Once you are in a plan, you are generally in it for the year unless you qualify for a special enrollment period. An approval burden is invisible in the premium and often invisible in the Summary of Benefits and Coverage. It lives in separate lists, and you have to ask for them.
A second reason: approval rules interact with cost. A plan with a lower premium may use more approval steps as part of how it controls spending. That is a legitimate trade, and some people accept it, but it should be a choice you make knowingly.
Where to find the rules
No single document has everything, so use several. The guide how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied explains the process itself; this is a location list.
- The plan's prior authorization list. Most insurers publish a list of services and codes that need approval, often on a provider or "for providers" page of their website. Search the insurer's site for "prior authorization list" or "services requiring authorization."
- The formulary. Drug lists mark each drug with codes for prior authorization, step therapy and quantity limits. The plan's website has the formulary for next year; use that, not last year's.
- The evidence of coverage or certificate of coverage. This is the full legal document. Look at the sections for each benefit, such as outpatient therapy or imaging, and at the section about services that need approval.
- The plan's member services line. Ask specific questions: "Does an outpatient knee MRI at an in-network imaging center require prior authorization on this plan?" Ask for the answer in writing or take down the date, name and reference number.
- Your doctor's office. The staff who submit authorizations know which plans cause delays. Ask which plans they find easiest and hardest to work with, though a single office's view is not data.
- Public reports. Under a federal rule on prior authorization (CMS-0057-F), certain payers, including Medicare Advantage plans, state Medicaid and CHIP managed care plans and plans sold on the federal marketplace, had to begin publishing prior authorization statistics, with the first due on March 31, 2026. Where a plan has published them, they may show how many requests were approved and how long decisions took. As of November 2026, look on the insurer's website for the report; the information may be easier to find for some plans than others.
What the federal rule does and does not do
The same rule (CMS-0057-F) set several requirements that began on January 1, 2026 for the payers it covers. They must give a specific reason when they deny a prior authorization request, and, except for plans sold on the federal marketplace, they must decide within 72 hours for expedited requests and seven calendar days for standard ones. A set of electronic data-sharing tools, called application programming interfaces, is due by January 1, 2027. Drug prior authorization is outside this rule. Many employer plans fall outside it too, because it applies to specific payer types. In October 2026, CMS and the Department of Labor announced that several large employers had signed a statement of support for extending electronic prior authorization improvements to self-funded plans; that is a voluntary statement, not a requirement. These facts are as of November 2026, and the CMS website is the place to check for updates.
The practical point: a federal timing rule can help you compare, but it does not make all plans equal. Employer plans and drug approvals follow different rules, so keep asking each plan for its own.
Build the comparison around your expected care
Start from what you expect, not from the plan's list. Say Sam, 46, expects three things next year, using invented details:
- A knee MRI.
- Twelve physical therapy visits after the MRI.
- A specialty drug for a chronic condition, which Sam's doctor expects to prescribe.
For each plan, write down what happens to each of the three items. Then count the approval touchpoints, meaning each time someone has to send a request and wait. Here is a filled-in example with two invented plans next to blank columns for yours.
| Question | Where to look | Example: Plan A | Example: Plan B | Your plan 1 | Your plan 2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Does outpatient MRI need prior authorization? | PA list, member services | Yes | No, if at an in-network imaging center | ||
| Do therapy visits need approval? | Evidence of coverage | Yes, re-approval after visit 6 | No, but capped at 20 visits a year | ||
| Does the specialty drug need prior authorization? | Formulary | Yes | Yes | ||
| Does it require step therapy? | Formulary | Yes, two other drugs first | No | ||
| Is a referral needed to see a specialist? | SBC, evidence of coverage | Yes | No | ||
| How long do standard decisions take? | Plan's published report, member services | 7 days stated | Not stated | ||
| Can I appeal quickly if it is urgent? | Denial notice, evidence of coverage | Expedited review offered | Expedited review offered | ||
| Monthly premium | Marketplace or benefits site | $50 lower | Baseline |
Count the touchpoints for Sam. Plan A: the MRI (1), the therapy re-approval at visit 6 (1), the drug's prior authorization (1), and the step therapy trial (1). That is four touchpoints plus a referral to the specialist. Plan B: the drug's prior authorization only, so one touchpoint, but the 20-visit cap means that if Sam's therapist recommended 24 visits, the last four would not be covered.
The premium difference gives a dollar anchor. If Plan A's premium is $50 a month lower, that is $600 a year. If the four extra approval steps lead to a two-week delay on the specialty drug and a flare-up that costs Sam a day or two of work, $600 might not feel like a bargain. If Sam's doctor's office handles authorizations quickly and Sam does not mind the steps, it might. That is the real comparison: dollars against hassle and risk, entered with eyes open.
Questions to ask each plan
Use these with member services, and note who answered and the date.
- Which of the services I expect to need require prior authorization on this plan this year? Is there a published list?
- If my doctor requests it, how long does a standard decision take and what is the process for an urgent one?
- If an authorization is approved, does the plan still check medical necessity when the claim is processed? (Ask, because the answer differs and this is a source of surprise; see the plan approved it, then denied the claim: how can that happen?.)
- Does the drug I take have step therapy? What is the process to ask for an exception?
- Do I need a referral for a specialist, and is it per visit or per condition?
- How long does an approval last, and how do I renew it?
- Who can request a peer-to-peer review with the plan's medical director, and how soon after a denial?
- What are my appeal rights and deadlines? (For most plans the internal appeal window is at least 180 days from the denial notice, and an independent external review is generally available afterward. See appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have.)
A peer-to-peer review is a call between your doctor and a physician at the plan; asking whether it is offered tells you how accessible the appeals process is before you need it.
Who each kind of plan tends to suit
The table has shown a tendency, but the plan type also sets the pattern of approvals.
- HMO or similar gatekeeper plans tend to rely on referrals from a primary care physician. They suit people who want one coordinating doctor and do not mind a referral step, and they are harder for people with several specialists.
- PPOs often have fewer referral rules, but they can still require prior authorization for imaging, surgery and drugs. They suit people who want to see specialists directly.
- Medicare Advantage plans use prior authorization for many services, and the Medicare Advantage rules differ from Original Medicare. Original Medicare uses prior authorization for a limited set of items and services; Medicare.gov and your SHIP counselor can tell you what applies to the care you expect. Both approaches have supporters and critics, and the best match depends on the care you expect.
- Employer plans vary widely by insurer and by whether the plan is self-funded, so the plan's own documents matter more than the plan type label.
For a broader comparison method that includes premiums, deductibles and networks, see how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs.
What to do with the results
- If your expected care has few approval steps in one plan and many in another, that difference is a real cost; weigh it against the premium gap.
- If a service you are sure to need has no published rule, ask in writing before enrolling.
- If a plan's list may change during the year, save a copy of the list with the date you checked it, so you can show what you were told.
- Keep a log once you are enrolled. The prior authorization and claim tracker gives a simple structure for tracking requests, dates and outcomes.
- If a decision looks wrong, use the appeal route in the denial notice. A related walk-through for imaging is My doctor ordered an MRI: does it need prior authorization first?, and the practical effect of the newer rules is covered in new prior authorization rules: what they mean for my next request.
If you cannot get a straight answer from the plan, a licensed broker, a navigator, your employer's benefits team or your SHIP counselor can often help find it. For a complaint about how a plan handled an approval, the state insurance department is the regulator for most plans.
Key takeaways
- Approval steps are part of what a plan costs you, even though they never show up in the premium.
- Build your comparison from the care you expect: list each service, then find out whether each plan needs prior authorization, step therapy or a referral for it.
- Look in the plan's prior authorization list, the formulary, the evidence of coverage and the member services line, and get the answers in writing.
- Federal rules on denial reasons and decision times apply to some payers (Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP managed care, and, for denial reasons, plans sold on the federal marketplace), not to all plans or to drug approvals.
- Ask how appeals work before you need one; the internal appeal window is at least 180 days for most plans, and external review is generally available.