Blog

What a denied-claim appeal looks like week by week, to external review

A dated example from a hypothetical denial notice through internal appeal and external review, with the usual federal time limits and the expedited track.

If you are in the middle of a denial, the question under the question is usually "how long will this take, and what happens when?" For a typical non-urgent denied claim in a group or individual plan, the whole path from denial notice to a final independent decision tends to run several months: about a month of your own preparation, up to two months for the plan's internal appeal, and then roughly a month and a half for external review. If the care is urgent, the same path can take days.

This post lays that sequence out in order, using a hypothetical denial notice dated March 2 and the time limits that federal rules set for most non-grandfathered group and individual health plans. Treat every date as an illustration. The notice you received states your real deadlines, and Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and some state-regulated plans run on different clocks. appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have covers the deadline rules in more detail, and the appeal and external review deadline calculator turns your notice date into a calendar.

The clocks that apply, in one table

Several clocks run during an appeal, and they belong to different parties. The table lists the usual federal-rule limits. "Pre-service" means you asked for approval before getting care, and "post-service" means the care has already happened and the claim was denied.

Stage Who has the clock Usual time limit
Plan decides the first request or claim Plan Urgent pre-service: 72 hours. Standard pre-service: 15 days, with one 15-day extension if the plan needs more information. Post-service: 30 days, with one 15-day extension
You file an internal appeal You At least 180 days from the date you received the denial notice
Plan decides the internal appeal Plan Urgent: 72 hours. Pre-service: 30 days. Post-service: 60 days. (A plan with two internal levels splits these between the levels.)
You request external review You Four months from the date you received the final internal denial
Plan does a preliminary review of the request Plan About five business days
You add information for the reviewer You The reviewer's notice gives a window, commonly 10 business days
Independent reviewer decides Reviewer Standard: 45 days from receiving the request. Expedited: 72 hours

Some of these details differ when a state, not the federal government, runs the external review process, and a self-funded employer plan follows the federal process. When your notice gives a different number, the notice controls. Your plan's own rules can also be more generous than the federal minimums, but not stricter.

Separately, certain government-program plans, specifically Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP managed care, and some others, must decide standard prior authorization requests within seven calendar days and expedited ones within 72 hours under a federal rule that took effect January 1, 2026. That rule covers the first decision on a request, not your appeal, and it excludes prescription drugs. Check your plan's materials for which rules apply.

The example: a post-service denial dated March 2

Say Rosa has a medical claim for an outpatient procedure that the plan denied as not medically necessary. The denial notice is dated March 2, and Rosa receives it the same week. Everything below counts from March 2 to keep the arithmetic simple; if the notice arrives later, the count starts when you receive it. This is a hypothetical, not a forecast.

Week 0 to 3 (March 2 to March 22): read, request and gather

The notice is an adverse benefit determination: it should state the reason, cite the plan provision or criterion, describe your appeal rights, and give the deadlines. Rosa reads it in the first days and notes two dates: the internal appeal deadline, at least 180 days from the notice, which here falls no earlier than August 29, and any shorter plan limit stated in the letter.

In these weeks, she does the groundwork that makes the appeal strong:

  1. Requests the claim file and the criteria used, free of charge, in writing.
  2. Asks her doctor for a letter and chart notes, and asks whether a peer-to-peer review call with the plan's reviewer is available.
  3. Gathers her explanation of benefits, bills and call log; build an appeal file: which documents to gather and how to organize them describes how to assemble the file.
  4. Drafts the appeal letter, with help from how to write a health insurance appeal letter that gets read.

Nothing here needs to be rushed to the deadline, but the clock is running, and there is no benefit to waiting. If the doctor's office is slow to supply records, make the request early and note the date.

Week 3 (March 23): file the internal appeal

Rosa files the internal appeal on March 23, day 21. She sends it in a way that leaves proof, by the plan's portal with a confirmation or by mail with tracking, and she writes the date in her log. She asks the plan to confirm receipt. The 180-day deadline is far away, but earlier filing starts the plan's decision clock sooner.

Weeks 3 to 12 (March 23 to May 22): the plan decides

For a post-service appeal, the plan generally has 60 days, here until May 22. Many plans decide faster. During this period the plan may ask for more information, and a request does not always stop the clock, so answer quickly. If the plan has two internal levels, the first level decision would be due in about 30 days, and a second level would then have its own 30.

On May 22, Rosa receives a letter upholding the denial. This is the final internal adverse determination, and it should describe her right to external review and how to ask for it. That letter starts the next clock.

Weeks 12 to 14 (May 22 to early June): decide whether to go external

External review is generally available for denials based on medical judgment, such as medical necessity, and for some other kinds of denials, depending on the plan and state. external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides covers who qualifies. Rosa has four months from receipt of the May 22 notice, until about September 22, to request it. She does not need all of that time. She asks her doctor to add anything missing to the file and files on June 5.

Week 14 to 15 (June 5 to about June 12): preliminary review

The plan reviews the request for completeness and eligibility, usually within about five business days, then notifies Rosa of the result. If it is eligible, the plan assigns an independent review organization that has no tie to the plan, and sends it the file. If the plan says the case is not eligible, Rosa can ask the state insurance department or the federal reviewing agency to look at that decision.

Weeks 15 to 21 (about June 12 to July 27): the independent decision

The reviewer typically has 45 days from receiving the request to decide, which brings the decision to about July 27. The reviewer's notice usually allows a short window, often about 10 business days, to send additional information, so Rosa and her doctor use it. The decision is made by clinicians or other experts who examine the records, the plan's rules and published standards.

If the reviewer overturns the denial, the plan must follow the decision. If it upholds the denial, the process is finished for most plans, though the state insurance department takes complaints about plans it regulates, and a lawyer can advise on other options.

From the March 2 notice to the July 27 decision is 147 days, about 21 weeks. That is the long path for a plain post-service claim, and it assumes no extensions and no appeals to a second internal level.

Pre-service denials move faster

Say a different patient asked for approval of a surgery and was denied before the care. The same structure applies with shorter plan clocks. The first decision is due in 15 days, with a possible extension of 15. A standard internal appeal is decided in 30 days. The external review request window and the 45-day decision window stay the same. Using the same pacing as Rosa's example (appeal filed on day 21, external review requested two weeks after the internal decision), a pre-service path would end about 117 days after the notice, roughly 17 weeks, if every party takes the full time allowed. That is about a month shorter than the post-service path, and sooner still if the plan decides early.

The expedited track: days, not months

Where a delay could seriously jeopardize life, health or the ability to regain maximum function, you can ask for an expedited appeal. The plan then generally has 72 hours to decide, and an expedited external review is also decided in 72 hours. Federal rules allow a person to ask for expedited external review at the same time as an expedited internal appeal in an urgent case, rather than waiting for the internal decision. The doctor's statement that the situation is urgent usually carries the request, and plans must treat the doctor's urgency finding seriously. Expedited appeal: when does my case count as urgent and how do I prove it? describes how to make that case.

An example with invented dates: a patient scheduled for a time-sensitive treatment gets a pre-service denial on a Monday. The doctor's office files an expedited appeal on Monday afternoon with a letter stating that a delay of weeks would risk harm. The plan decides within 72 hours. If it upholds the denial, the expedited external review request goes out that day, and an answer follows in about three more days. Under this path the patient could have a final answer within about a week.

What to do while you wait

The weeks between filing and a decision are not idle time. Keep the following going.

  • Keep treatment decisions with your doctor. An open appeal does not change what care is medically appropriate, and a clinician can tell you whether to wait, use an alternative or seek an expedited review.
  • Ask the provider to hold the bill. A written request that the account not go to collections while the appeal is open protects your credit and your sanity. If the account is already in collections, the same request goes to the collector, and my bill went to collections while my insurance appeal is pending covers that situation.
  • Check in on a schedule. Note the date the plan's decision is due and call a few days before it if you have heard nothing. Ask for the status and for any missing item.
  • Keep copying everything. Every letter, portal message and reference number goes in the file, and a short call summary goes by email on the same day.
  • Know the fallback contacts. If the plan misses its own deadline or ignores a request, the state insurance department takes complaints for state-regulated plans, and a self-funded employer plan answers to the U.S. Department of Labor and the employer's benefits office.

What can stretch the timeline

  • Extensions and missing information. A plan can take extra time at the first decision when it needs more information, and incomplete records slow every later stage.
  • Delays on your side. Waiting for records, a doctor's letter or a form can eat the weeks. Ask early and follow up.
  • Mail time. If you file by mail, send it so you can prove the date, and count from receipt when the notice says to.
  • Two-level internal appeals. Some plans have two internal levels, each with its own deadline.
  • Medicare and Medicaid. Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid each have separate levels and clocks, which the plan or program notices describe.
  • Plan-year and policy changes. A change in coverage during the dispute can complicate it, so keep copies of what applied when the care happened.

A working calendar to build on your own

When your notice arrives, write each of these on a calendar:

  1. The date on the notice and the date you received it.
  2. The internal appeal deadline, at least 180 days out, and your own earlier target.
  3. The date the plan's internal decision is due after you file.
  4. The external review request deadline: four months from receiving the final internal denial.
  5. The date the reviewer's decision is due once the request is accepted.

Use the numbers in your own notice, and when in doubt ask the plan, your state insurance department or a navigator.

Key takeaways

  • For a standard post-service denial, expect roughly 21 weeks from notice to a final independent decision, with about 60 days for the internal appeal and 45 days for external review.
  • Pre-service appeals move somewhat faster, at about 30 days for the internal decision, and urgent cases can be decided in 72 hours at both stages.
  • You have at least 180 days to file an internal appeal and generally four months to request external review, but filing early starts the plan's clock sooner.
  • The dates on your own denial notice control, and Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and some state-regulated plans run on different timetables.
  • Preparing the file and the doctor's letter during the first three weeks is the part of the timeline you control.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic