Guides

How to work with a health insurance broker or navigator

What brokers, agents, navigators and certified counselors do, how each is paid, how to verify one, and how to protect your application.

Three kinds of people help with health insurance enrollment, and they are paid differently. Navigators and certified application counselors work for organizations funded to help you enroll and are free to you. Licensed brokers and agents are paid by the insurers whose plans they sell, usually through commissions, and generally do not charge you separately for marketplace plans. Whoever you use, check their license or certification yourself, keep control of your own account, and confirm the result after you enroll.

Who is who

Helper Who they work for How they are paid Typical scope
Navigator A marketplace-funded community organization Grants; not paid by insurers Free, impartial help with marketplace plans, Medicaid and CHIP referrals, subsidies
Certified application counselor A health center, hospital, clinic or nonprofit Their employer; not paid by insurers for enrolling you Help with marketplace applications and eligibility
Broker or agent Themselves or an agency, licensed by the state Commissions from insurers Marketplace and off-marketplace plans, Medicare plans, small-group and employer plans
SHIP counselor A State Health Insurance Assistance Program Federal and state funding Free, unbiased help with Medicare

Navigators are required to give impartial information and cannot take payment from an insurer for helping you enroll. Brokers are licensed salespeople: many are knowledgeable, and some work with plans from several insurers, but they are paid for plans they sell, and an agent who represents only a few companies may not show you the whole market. That is not a reason to avoid brokers; it is a reason to ask questions.

What each can do

Navigators and counselors can explain plan types and terms, help you estimate income, complete the marketplace application, compare plans (see how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs), and connect you to Medicaid or CHIP if you may qualify. They cannot give legal or tax advice, and they cannot recommend a particular insurer's plan over others.

Brokers and agents can do the same for the plans they are appointed to sell and can also sell plans outside the marketplace and Medicare plans. A broker can enroll you in a marketplace plan only if they have registered with the marketplace. Premium tax credits are available only for plans bought through the marketplace, not for off-marketplace plans. Ask a broker which insurers they represent and which they do not.

SHIP counselors are the neutral help for Medicare questions, and are the right call for Medicare plan comparisons. See SHIP.

None of them can tell you whether you are eligible for a particular subsidy with certainty; only the marketplace's eligibility determination, your tax return and a tax professional can.

How to find help

How to verify someone before you share anything

  1. Ask for their name, license number and the state where they are licensed. Look the number up in your state insurance department's license search. A licensed broker has a license number; a navigator has an organization and certification.
  2. Confirm that they are registered with the marketplace if you want them to enroll you in a marketplace plan.
  3. Be wary of unsolicited contact. A call, text or ad offering "free" or "government" plans, or a person who asks for your Social Security number before you have agreed to work with them, deserves caution. how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it lists the common warning signs.
  4. Ask who is paying them, and which companies they work with.
  5. Do the enrollment with you present. You should see the application, choose the plan and agree to the income figure; an application filed without your knowledge can leave you with an unwanted plan or a tax bill.

Why this is in the news

In September 2026, according to KFF, HHS cancelled about 760,000 enrollments that it called "phantom" (made without the person's knowledge) and flagged about 1.2 million more for insurer review; some cancelled enrollees were later reinstated. CMS also froze registration of new brokers on the federal platform until February 2027, and on November 16, 2026 proposed a rule (called CRUSH) that would tighten broker and agent access to the marketplace, with comments due January 19, 2027. These are policy developments, not a verdict on any individual broker. They are a reason to check your own account.

After you enroll

  • Log in to your marketplace account directly, not through a link someone sends you, and confirm the plan, the premium, the credit amount and the start date.
  • Confirm that the income and household members listed are yours.
  • Keep the application confirmation and a copy of the plan documents.
  • If you see a plan or a change you did not authorize, call the marketplace and ask for it to be reviewed. Navigators can help you escalate, and the state insurance department takes complaints about licensed brokers.
  • Never let anyone else control the email address or phone number tied to your account.

Working with a broker for employer or Medicare coverage

A small business owner or a person new to Medicare may use a broker for plans outside the marketplace. The same checks apply. For Medicare, remember that the plan you pick may restrict you to certain doctors and the broker's commission may differ between plans; ask them to show you more than one plan and to explain the premium, the drug costs and the network. A SHIP counselor gives you a second opinion at no cost.

Key takeaways

  • Navigators and certified counselors are free and impartial; brokers and agents are paid by insurers and are licensed by the state.
  • Verify a broker's license with your state insurance department, and verify marketplace registration if they will enroll you.
  • Be cautious with unsolicited contacts or anyone who wants your Social Security number before you have agreed to work together.
  • Take part in the application, and check your account afterward for the plan, credit and start date.
  • Use a SHIP counselor for neutral Medicare help.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic