Guides
How to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it
Health insurance scams rely on pressure, unsolicited contact and odd payment demands. Learn the warning signs, how to verify an agent, and where to report.
A health insurance scam usually has three features: it reaches you without your asking, it pushes you to act or pay immediately, and it asks for personal information or a payment method before it gives you anything in writing. If a call, text, email or ad does all three, stop and verify before you share anything. Real coverage is sold by licensed agents and companies, comes with written plan documents, and does not disappear when you ask for time. This guide covers the warning signs, how to check who you are dealing with, and what to do if you have already shared information or paid.
The common forms
Scams change with the news, but they tend to fall into a few patterns.
- Fake plans. A company sells something that looks like insurance but pays few or no claims. See fake health plans and discount cards: how they differ from insurance for how to tell the difference.
- Phishing during enrollment. Messages claiming to be from the marketplace, Medicare or an insurer say your coverage will lapse unless you "verify" your Social Security number or pay a fee.
- Impersonated websites. Look-alike sites collect your information, or charge for help that is free through the real marketplace.
- Unauthorized enrollment. A dishonest agent or broker signs people up for marketplace plans, or switches their plan, without their knowledge, to collect commissions. This is a federal enforcement focus: in September 2026 CMS announced it had canceled about 315,000 enrollments covering more than 760,000 people that it identified as unauthorized, and froze new broker registration on the federal platform.
- Medicare cold calls. Callers offer "free" braces, genetic tests or new Medicare cards in exchange for your Medicare number. Medicare plans are generally not allowed to call you out of the blue to sell coverage.
- Lead generators. Sites that look like insurers collect your name and number and sell them to many callers. This is not always illegal, but it explains why one form fill produces dozens of calls.
Warning signs
| What you notice | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| They contacted you first and say the offer ends today | Real enrollment deadlines are published by official sources |
| You are asked to pay by gift card, wire, cryptocurrency or cash app | Legitimate insurers bill by standard methods |
| A premium that is far below what similar plans cost | Real coverage has to be paid for; very cheap often means limited or fake |
| No plan documents, or the documents are vague | A real plan gives a summary of benefits and coverage |
| They ask for your Social Security or bank details at the start | A real plan needs them only to complete a valid application |
| They say you "qualify" for a government plan but must pay them | Applying to the marketplace, Medicare or Medicaid costs nothing |
| No ID card, no member portal, no number for claims | You cannot use a plan you cannot reach |
Check who you are dealing with
- Hang up and call back using a number you find yourself. Use the number on your insurance card, on Medicare.gov, or on the state insurance department's site. Do not use a number from the message.
- Check the license. An agent or broker selling insurance must be licensed in your state. Your state insurance department runs a license lookup. You can also verify whether a company is authorized to sell insurance there.
- Use official enrollment sites. Marketplace enrollment is through HealthCare.gov or your state's exchange. Help from a navigator is free; they cannot charge you. A licensed insurance broker is typically paid by the insurer rather than by you for marketplace plans. See how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator.
- Ask for it in writing. Request the summary of benefits and coverage, the policy, and the total cost, including fees. A scammer will resist.
- Look at your own account. If you buy through the marketplace, log in to your own account and confirm the plan, the agent of record and the monthly amount. Unexpected changes are a red flag.
What to do if you gave information or paid
Speed helps, and the steps are not complicated.
- Stop contact. Do not call back the number in a suspicious message.
- Payment. If you paid by card, call the issuer and dispute the charge. If you paid by wire or gift card, tell the company or bank right away, though recovery is harder.
- Identity. If you shared your Social Security or Medicare number, see medical identity theft and insurer data breaches: what to do for credit freezes and monitoring. A Medicare number can be replaced; ask Medicare.
- Coverage. If you think you were enrolled or switched without consent, contact the marketplace call center or your plan right away. The loss of subsidies or an unexpected tax-credit repayment can follow an unauthorized enrollment, so document dates and who you spoke with.
- Save evidence. Keep texts, emails, call logs, recordings where legal and anything you signed.
Where to report
| Problem | Where to report |
|---|---|
| Any scam | The Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov |
| Insurance sold by an unlicensed person or a fake plan | Your state insurance department |
| Marketplace plan or agent | The marketplace, through HealthCare.gov or your state exchange |
| Medicare | 1-800-MEDICARE; for fraud also the HHS Office of Inspector General |
| Billing abuse in a plan you already have | The plan, then your state regulator |
how to file a complaint with your state insurance department describes the complaint process in more detail.
A scenario
Say a text claims that your marketplace plan will be canceled unless you pay a $49 "reactivation fee" with a gift card within 24 hours (a hypothetical). Three warning signs appear in one message: the message arrived unprompted, the deadline is artificial, and the payment method is untraceable. The right response is to ignore the text, log in to HealthCare.gov or the state exchange yourself, and look at your plan status. If it is active, nothing is owed. If you want a second opinion, ask a navigator.
Key takeaways
- Scams combine unsolicited contact, pressure to act now and requests for unusual payment or early personal data.
- Verify by calling a number you found yourself and checking the license with your state insurance department.
- Marketplace help from navigators is free, and applying to the marketplace, Medicare or Medicaid costs nothing.
- If you were scammed, dispute the payment, protect your identity and report to the FTC and your state insurance department.