Guides

Insurer ratings explained: AM Best, NCQA, CMS stars and J.D. Power

AM Best rates financial strength, NCQA and CMS rate plan quality and member experience, and J.D. Power reports satisfaction surveys; none rates your own plan.

Each insurer rating answers a different question. AM Best rates whether a company is financially able to pay claims. The National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA) and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) rate how plans perform on quality of care and member experience. J.D. Power publishes consumer satisfaction research based on surveys of members. None of them rates the specific plan you would buy, none tells you whether your doctors are in the network, and every rating has a date and a method that can change.

AM Best: financial strength

AM Best is a rating agency that specializes in insurance. Its financial strength rating is an opinion on an insurer's ability to meet its ongoing obligations to policyholders, including paying claims. It uses letter grades, from the A range at the top (for example A++, A+, A and A-, described with words such as Superior and Excellent) down through B and lower grades. Other agencies, such as S&P Global and Moody's, publish their own financial strength ratings with their own scales.

What it tells you: how likely the company is to stay solvent and pay what it owes. What it does not tell you: whether claims are paid quickly, whether the network is wide, how good customer service is, or what the premium is. A highly rated insurer can have a narrow network and a lightly rated one can run an efficient plan. Financial strength matters most for products where you pay in advance and claim later, and for small companies; a rating is a snapshot, so check its date.

NCQA Health Plan Ratings: quality and experience

NCQA is a nonprofit that sets standards for health plan quality. Its Health Plan Ratings score plans that report their data, using a scale that tops out at 5. The scores draw on clinical measures from the HEDIS data set, member experience surveys from the CAHPS survey family, and NCQA accreditation standards for how plans run quality and consumer-protection processes.

What it tells you: how a plan performs on measures such as preventive screenings, chronic disease management and member-reported experience. What it does not tell you: whether a plan participates (participation is voluntary for some products), how your local network performs, or prices. NCQA ratings are given to a plan's product line in a defined area, so look up your actual plan.

CMS Star Ratings: Medicare Advantage and Part D

CMS rates Medicare Advantage and Part D plans on a one-to-five-star scale each fall, ahead of the Annual Enrollment Period. The rating draws on clinical quality measures, member survey results, plan-reported data about customer service and appeals, and drug plan measures. The rating attaches to a contract, which can cover several plans in different counties, rather than to each plan. Under the medicare star ratings system, higher-rated plans receive more favorable payment treatment from CMS, which is one reason plans pay attention to the measures.

CMS reported on October 8, 2026 that about 71% of Medicare Advantage drug plan enrollees were in contracts rated 4 stars or more for 2027, with 15 five-star contracts and an enrollment-weighted average of 3.99, down from 4.01 in 2026. CMS also finalized changes that will remove some measures starting with the 2028-2029 ratings, so ratings are not directly comparable over time. For more on Medicare Advantage itself, see Medicare Advantage explained: how Part C plans work.

What stars tell you: contract-level performance on measures CMS selects. What they do not tell you: whether your doctors are in the plan, how your county's network compares, or what you would pay.

J.D. Power: member satisfaction research

J.D. Power is a consumer research firm that publishes health plan satisfaction studies based on surveys of members, often reported by region and plan type. The results rank or score companies on member experience themes such as communication, coverage and cost, and customer service. Because the studies are survey-based, they capture how members felt about the company rather than clinical outcomes or finances. They also depend on who was surveyed and when, so look at the study year and the region before applying a result to your market.

Other sources that complement the ratings

A labeled hypothetical

Say Plan A's company has an AM Best rating of A, an NCQA rating of 4 out of 5 and a satisfaction ranking in the middle of its region, while Plan B's company has an A+, an NCQA rating of 3 and a satisfaction ranking in the top third. These figures are illustrations. A shopper could read them many ways: Plan A has the stronger quality score, Plan B the stronger finances and satisfaction. Neither pattern says which plan has your doctor, your drugs or a premium you can pay. The useful move is to use the ratings to spot red flags, then compare the plans' networks and costs directly.

Key takeaways

  • AM Best measures financial strength, NCQA and CMS measure quality and member experience, and J.D. Power reports member satisfaction surveys.
  • A rating covers a company, contract or product line, not the individual plan, and it has a date and a method.
  • Ratings do not tell you about your network, your drugs or your price; check those yourself.
  • Use ratings to screen out concerns, then compare specific plans and ask your state insurance department about complaints.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic