Tools

Health insurer comparison tool

Choose up to three profiled health insurers and compare size, ownership, financial ratings, plan types and where they sell, side by side.

Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.

How to use it

  1. Narrow the list if you like. Type part of a company name or a brand, choose a type (for example Blue Cross Blue Shield companies or Medicare Advantage specialists), or set a minimum AM Best rating.
  2. Select up to three companies by pressing their buttons. A selected button is highlighted and says so to screen readers. Press it again to remove it. A fourth choice is ignored until you remove one.
  3. Read the table that appears under the list. Each column is one company, each row one fact: size, type, ownership, parent company, headquarters, ratings, plan types, where it sells, network types, customer service number and who it tends to suit. A row appears only when at least one of the chosen companies has the fact, and a blank cell says "Not listed".
  4. Open a company's profile from the bottom row for the full picture, or the written comparisons for a head-to-head.

How the math works

There is no formula. The tool places the facts from each company's profile in the same row and, for the rating filter, puts AM Best grades in order: A++, A+, A, A-, B++, B+, B and B-. "A or better" keeps the first three. A company whose profile has no AM Best grade is dropped when you set any minimum, because the tool cannot say it meets it.

Plan types and states come from the profile's machine fields. The plan-type codes are shown in plain words (for example "aca-individual" appears as "ACA individual" and "medicaid-managed-care" as "Medicaid managed care"). The footprint shows "All states" when the profile says ALL, otherwise a count and the postal codes. A worked example with hypothetical profiles: a company listing "TX FL GA" and codes "aca-individual part-d" appears as "3 states: TX, FL, GA" and "ACA individual, Part D".

What it assumes

  • Every figure is as it stands on the company's profile. Ratings, sizes and member counts are dated there, and the profile says where the number came from. This tool does not refresh them.
  • The companies are those profiled on this site. They are not every insurer, and the comparison cannot include a company without a profile.
  • Ratings from different agencies measure different things. AM Best rates an insurer's financial strength. NCQA, CMS star ratings and J.D. Power measure quality or satisfaction for particular products or regions, and a company can score differently on each.
  • Plan types and states describe where a company sells something. They do not say a plan is available in every county or in your price range.

Where it stops being right

  • A strong financial rating says the company is likely to pay claims. It says nothing about whether its network includes your doctors, whether its prices are fair or how it treats members when a claim is denied.
  • Size is not quality. A larger company has more members and more complaints in absolute terms, so compare complaint rates from your state regulator, which the state lookup lists.
  • The tool compares companies, not plans. Two plans from the same company can differ a great deal, and the same company's plans can vary by state.
  • It does not recommend a company. The right choice depends on where you live, what you need covered, which doctors you see and what the plans cost, all of which this tool cannot know.
  • A company profile can lag a change such as a merger, an exit from a state or a new rating. Check the company's own site and the marketplace for the current position.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Related guides

Terms used here

Latest on this topic