Guides

How to compare health insurers: ratings, complaints and service

Use public sources that measure different things: financial strength, quality ratings, state complaint data, appeals records and your own network check.

To compare health insurers, use several public sources and keep in mind that each measures something different: financial strength (can the company pay claims), quality ratings (how plans score on care and member surveys), complaint records kept by state regulators, and service details you can test yourself, such as whether your doctors are in the network. No single score settles it. Compare insurers that actually sell in your county, then compare their specific plans, because the same company can offer a strong plan and a weak one.

Start with who sells in your area

An insurer's brand name can be nationwide while its plans are available in only a few counties. Build the list of companies you can really buy from first, using HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace for individual coverage, Medicare.gov for Medicare plans, your state Medicaid agency for Medicaid plans, and your employer's benefits portal for job-based coverage. The how to find which health insurers sell plans in your state guide walks through those lists. Comparing a company you cannot buy from wastes effort.

The public sources and what each one measures

Source What it measures What it leaves out
Financial strength ratings (AM Best and similar agencies) An insurer's ability to meet its financial obligations Service, networks, prices, care quality
NCQA Health Plan Ratings Clinical quality measures, member experience surveys and prevention, for plans that report to NCQA Plans that do not participate; your specific doctors
CMS Star Ratings Quality and member experience for Medicare Advantage and Part D contracts Employer plans, marketplace plans, individual plans within a contract
Marketplace quality ratings A quality score shown for many marketplace plans, where the marketplace displays it Plans too new to be rated
State complaint data Consumer complaints to the state insurance department, sometimes as a ratio to size Complaints never filed; how fairly each was resolved
Medical loss ratio reports Share of premium spent on care and quality efforts versus overhead and profit Whether the care was good

The Insurer ratings explained: AM Best, NCQA, CMS stars and J.D. Power guide covers each rating in detail. The short rule: a rating is evidence about one dimension, with a date, and rating methods change over time.

Reading complaint data fairly

Complaint counts are easy to misread because large insurers have more members and so more complaints. Use a ratio when your regulator publishes one, or make your own. The national association of state regulators, the NAIC, runs a consumer search tool that points to company information, and most state insurance departments publish complaint records or a complaint index for companies licensed there.

A labeled hypothetical shows the arithmetic. Say Insurer X had 300 complaints and 1,000,000 members, and Insurer Y had 60 complaints and 100,000 members. Per 10,000 members, X had 300 / 1,000,000 x 10,000 = 3 complaints and Y had 60 / 100,000 x 10,000 = 6. Y has fewer complaints in total but twice the rate. The totals alone would have pointed the wrong way. Also note what the complaints were about: billing mix-ups, denials and network problems are different signals.

Test service yourself

Public data lags. Before you enroll, you can check service directly:

  • Search each plan's provider directory for your doctors, hospitals and pharmacies, then confirm by phone with the provider's office, since directories can be wrong.
  • Look up your regular drugs in the plan's formulary and note any prior authorization or step therapy rules.
  • Read the plan's appeal and grievance procedures in its documents, and note the deadlines.
  • Call the member line with a plain question and see how long it takes to reach a person.
  • Ask the plan how it handles referrals and out-of-area care if either matters to you.

Keep price and value separate

A lower premium is not a better insurer, and a higher premium is not either. Premium, deductible, copays and out-of-pocket maximum belong in a plan-level comparison, which is covered in how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs. For a rough look at how much of premium dollars an insurer spends on care, the medical loss ratio reports are public, but a high ratio is not proof of good service and a low one is not proof of poor service. It reflects how costs are classified as well as what is spent.

Treat reviews and ranked lists with care

Online reviews and magazine-style rankings can show how members feel, but they come with limits. People who had a denial or a billing dispute are more likely to post, and a review of one employer plan may say little about the individual plan you would buy. Rankings built on a company's own marketing materials, or on a method the publisher does not explain, deserve less weight than a rating with a published methodology and a date. When a list ranks insurers across the whole country, remember that your choice is local: networks, rates and even which company sells differ from county to county.

Put the pieces together

  1. List the insurers that sell your plan type in your county.
  2. Note each one's financial strength, with the rating date.
  3. Check quality ratings that apply to your plan type, with the year.
  4. Pull complaint data from your state and compare rates, not totals.
  5. Test networks, drugs and service for the plans you are considering.
  6. Choose among specific plans on cost and fit.

The health insurer comparison tool on this site lines up profiles from public sources side by side. If something looks wrong, your state insurance department or a licensed broker or navigator can help with the individual question, and how to file a complaint with your state insurance department explains how to file a complaint of your own.

Key takeaways

  • Each source measures one dimension; combine financial strength, quality ratings, complaints and your own network check.
  • Compare complaint rates per member, not raw complaint totals, and note the date of every rating.
  • Compare only insurers that sell your plan type in your county.
  • Narrow the insurers first, then compare specific plans on cost and fit, because one company sells both strong and weak plans.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic