Guides

The mental health parity law: what insurers must treat equally

The federal parity law bars most plans from limiting mental health and substance use care more strictly than medical care. How it works and how to challenge it.

The mental health parity law is a set of federal rules requiring most health plans that cover mental health and substance use disorder benefits to treat them no more restrictively than they treat comparable medical and surgical benefits. "Parity" does not require a plan to cover any particular mental health service; it requires that, where a plan does cover them, the financial costs and the treatment rules are not stricter than those for medical care. The main law is the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008, which the Affordable Care Act later extended to individual and small-group plans by making mental health care an essential health benefit. The regulations that carry out the law have been revised over time, so for the current enforcement position check the Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA), the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) or your state insurance department.

Who the law covers

The parity requirements apply to most employer-sponsored group health plans of employers with more than 50 employees, to individual and small-group plans through the Affordable Care Act's essential-benefit rules, to Medicaid managed care plans and to the Children's Health Insurance Program. Some plans are outside it, for example Original Medicare, some self-funded plans of state and local governments that have opted out, and certain retiree-only plans. Plans that do not offer any mental health benefit are not required by the parity law to add one, although individual and small-group plans must cover mental health under the ACA. Your plan documents or benefits office should say which rules apply to your plan.

The two kinds of limits

Parity covers two kinds of restrictions. In each, the test is whether the limit on mental health and substance use benefits is stricter than the limit on medical care of the same type, such as inpatient, outpatient, emergency care or prescription drugs.

Quantitative limits are the numerical ones: the copay or coinsurance, the deductible, the out-of-pocket limit, visit limits and day limits. A plan cannot, for example, charge $50 for a mental health outpatient visit when a similar medical visit costs $25, if the test for that type of care finds the mental health cost higher. A plan also cannot set a lower number of covered therapy sessions than it sets for similar medical visits without justification.

Non-quantitative treatment limits (NQTLs) are the rules about how care is managed, and they are where most disputes arise. Examples include:

  • Prior authorization and concurrent review requirements.
  • step therapy or "fail first" rules, where a plan requires a person to try one treatment before covering another.
  • Standards for deciding what is medically necessary.
  • Rules for how a plan admits providers to its network, and the rates it pays them.
  • Geographic restrictions, limits on the setting of care, and restrictions based on the provider's type or licensure.

The rule is that the processes, strategies, evidentiary standards and other factors used to apply an NQTL to mental health benefits must be comparable to, and applied no more stringently than, those used for medical benefits. That is a comparison of the process, not only the result.

Why it matters in practice

Here is how a violation might look from the patient side. Say, hypothetically, a plan requires prior authorization for every residential mental health stay, but does not require authorization for comparable skilled nursing or rehabilitation stays on the medical side. Or the plan may require a patient to fail two outpatient treatments before covering intensive care for a mental health condition, while the medical side lets a physician decide directly. The question under parity is whether the plan can justify the difference using comparable evidence and standards. If it cannot, the limit may violate the law. These are illustrations, not findings about any plan.

Another common area is the network. If a plan has far fewer therapists and psychiatrists than primary care or specialists, or pays them under different standards, members may have trouble getting in-network care. how to find an in-network therapist, and what to do when none exist explains the options when no in-network clinician is available.

The comparative analysis

Since a federal law passed in 2020, group health plans and insurers that use NQTLs on mental health and substance use benefits must prepare a written comparative analysis showing how the limit is designed and applied and why it is comparable to medical limits. A plan must give the analysis to federal or state regulators on request, and participants have a right to ask the plan for information about the criteria for medical necessity determinations and the reason for a denial. In practice, a person who suspects a violation can ask the plan in writing for the criteria used to deny the care and for any documents showing how the limit applies. The depth of the answer varies, and regulators, not individuals, usually receive the full analysis.

What to do if you think a limit violates parity

  1. Get the denial in writing. The notice should state the reason and the plan's criteria. If it does not, request them.
  2. Ask for the plan's criteria and limit details. Ask which treatment limits apply to the service and whether comparable medical services have the same limits.
  3. Appeal inside the plan. File an internal appeal and say in the letter that you believe the limit may violate the mental health parity law, naming the limit. Include a statement from your treating clinician about why the care is needed. The claim denial appeal letter builder can help structure the letter, and how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step gives the process.
  4. Request external review if the internal appeal fails and your plan type allows it.
  5. File a complaint with a regulator. For a plan regulated by the state, contact your state insurance department (how to file a complaint with your state insurance department). For job-based plans that fall under federal oversight, EBSA takes complaints and questions through its Department of Labor consumer assistance channels. For Medicaid managed care, the state Medicaid agency is the place to start.
  6. Keep records. Save notices, dates and names of everyone you talk to.

A lawyer who handles health insurance or employee benefits can advise on court action; this guide cannot say whether a specific limit breaks the law.

What parity does not do

The parity law does not guarantee coverage of a specific therapy, does not set the price of care, does not require plans to have a large network, and does not stop a plan from using utilization management at all. It also does not make every difference between mental health and medical care unlawful: plans may impose a limit on both. The question is whether the mental health limit is stricter or applied more strictly. For what plans cover in general, see does health insurance cover therapy and mental health care?.

Key takeaways

  • Parity means plans that cover mental health and substance use care cannot impose stricter financial limits or treatment rules than they impose on comparable medical care.
  • It covers numerical limits (copays, deductibles, visit limits) and management rules (prior authorization, step therapy, medical necessity standards, network admission).
  • It does not require a plan to cover a particular service; Original Medicare and some government plans are outside it.
  • If you suspect a violation, request the criteria in writing, appeal, ask for external review and complain to the state or federal regulator.
  • The regulations have been revised and enforcement positions can change, so check EBSA, CMS or your state insurance department for the current status.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic