Guides

Pre-existing conditions and health insurance: what the law says

ACA-compliant plans cannot deny you or charge more for a pre-existing condition. See which plan types still can and when you can enroll.

Under the Affordable Care Act, health plans sold to individuals and small employers cannot deny you coverage, charge you more or exclude benefits because of a pre-existing condition, which is a health problem you had before your coverage began. Group health plans from employers of any size are covered by the same ban. The protection applies to ACA-compliant plans. Other products, including short-term plans, many supplemental policies, health care sharing ministries and Medigap outside its protected windows, can still screen for health conditions.

What the ACA changed

Before the ACA, individual-market insurers in most states could ask about your health history, decline your application, charge higher premiums or exclude the condition from coverage, which meant the plan would pay for everything except the condition you needed treated. Employer plans could impose waiting periods for pre-existing conditions under earlier federal rules.

The ACA changed this for pre-existing condition rules in several ways:

  • Insurers must accept every applicant during an enrollment period, a rule called guaranteed issue.
  • Insurers cannot use health status to set premiums. The factors a plan may use are limited to age (with a maximum ratio of three to one between the oldest and youngest adults), tobacco use (up to one and a half to one), where you live and whether the plan covers one person or a family.
  • Plans cannot exclude a condition from coverage or impose a waiting period for it.
  • Plans cannot set annual or lifetime dollar limits on essential health benefits.

This is why insurers no longer ask health questions on marketplace applications. The application asks about age, location, household and income, not diagnoses.

What it does not mean

The law guarantees you the right to buy coverage, not the right to buy it at any time or at any price.

  • You still need an enrollment window. Insurers must accept you during open enrollment or a special enrollment period, not at any moment. The guide on When is open enrollment? Dates for marketplace, Medicare and employer plans explains the calendar. If you miss it and have no qualifying life event, you may have to wait for the next one.
  • Coverage starts on a future date. A condition that needs treatment before the start date is not covered during the gap.
  • Premiums still vary, by age, location and plan. Only health-based pricing is banned.
  • Plans can limit what they pay. Networks, prior authorization, drug lists and cost sharing all still apply, and a plan can decide whether a particular treatment is covered.

One exception sits inside the ACA itself: individual-market plans that are "grandfathered," meaning bought before the law passed in 2010 and kept largely unchanged, are exempt from the ban on pre-existing condition exclusions. Few remain, and your insurer's notice or the plan's documents will say whether yours is grandfathered. Moving to an ACA-compliant plan during an enrollment period removes the exposure, though you would then be subject to the new plan's network, drug list and prices.

Plan types that can still screen

Product Can it use your health history?
ACA marketplace and off-marketplace plans No
Employer group plans No
Medicare Advantage and Part D Generally no, if you are eligible and enrolling in a valid period
Medigap Yes in most states outside its guaranteed windows
Short-term, limited-duration plans Often yes: they may ask health questions, decline you, or exclude conditions
Health care sharing ministries Typically yes: they are not insurance and may limit sharing for existing conditions
Accident, hospital indemnity and critical illness policies Often yes: many ask health questions

A short-term plan may not appear to exclude anything until you file a claim. Insurers can review an application afterward and decide the condition was one you had before. The guides on short-term health insurance: what it covers and what it does not and health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? describe the risks, and the Short-term plan vs ACA plan comparison shows the differences side by side.

Medigap and pre-existing conditions

Medigap has its own rules. During the one-time six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, insurers must sell you a policy at the standard rate without medical underwriting. After that window closes, in most states an insurer can decline you or charge more because of health history, unless a special guaranteed-issue right applies. See medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue. Medicare Advantage and Part D do not use health screening for eligible people enrolling in a valid period.

A worked example with a made-up case

Say Maria, a hypothetical 45-year-old with diabetes, applies for a marketplace plan during open enrollment. The insurer cannot decline her, cannot charge her more than a healthy 45-year-old buying the same plan in the same area, and cannot exclude diabetes care. Now say Maria instead buys a short-term plan because its monthly price is lower. The insurer asks about her health, and it may refuse to cover diabetes-related care, deny her application, or review claims later against her history. The price difference reflects what each plan covers as much as it reflects cost.

Where to check your own situation

The marketplace, a licensed broker, a navigator or your state's insurance department can explain how the rules apply where you live. For a denied claim you believe was wrongly called pre-existing, the plan's appeal process and your state insurance department are the right places to start.

Key takeaways

  • ACA-compliant individual, small-group and large-group plans cannot deny, exclude or price coverage based on a pre-existing condition.
  • You can enroll only during open enrollment or a special enrollment period, and coverage starts on a future date.
  • Short-term plans, sharing ministries and some supplemental policies can still screen health history.
  • Medigap is protected during its six-month open enrollment period and in certain guaranteed-issue situations, but not generally afterward.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic