Guides

Self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you

In a fully insured plan an insurer takes the claims risk and state law applies; in a self-funded plan the employer pays claims and ERISA mostly governs.

In a fully insured employer plan, the employer pays premiums to an insurance company, which takes on the risk of paying your claims and is regulated by your state. In a self-funded plan, the employer pays the claims itself, usually hiring an insurer or administrator to process them, and the plan is governed mainly by the federal law called ERISA rather than by state insurance law. The two can look identical on your insurance card and in your doctor's office. The difference shows up when you want to know which rules protect you, who decides an appeal, and where to complain.

How each arrangement works

Fully insured. The employer buys a group policy and pays a premium, set by the insurer for the group. If employees' claims run higher than expected, the insurer absorbs the loss; if they run lower, the insurer keeps the difference, subject to medical loss ratio rules that require large-group insurers to spend a minimum share of premiums on care. The insurer sells the plan, processes claims and bears the risk. See fully insured plan.

Self-funded. The employer sets up a plan, funds it from company money, and pays claims as they come in. Most employers that do this do not process claims themselves. They sign an administrative-services-only contract with an insurer or a third-party administrator that provides the provider network, runs the claims, and may issue the ID cards. Many also buy stop-loss insurance, a policy that reimburses the employer when individual claims or total claims pass a set amount, so one catastrophic case does not threaten the business. See self-funded plan.

KFF's annual employer surveys have consistently found that a majority of covered workers are in self-funded plans, mostly at larger employers. Smaller employers are more likely to be fully insured, though some use self-funding with stop-loss protection. Your benefits office can tell you which kind of plan you have, and the plan's summary plan description usually says.

A labeled hypothetical

Say a company with 500 employees expects $4,000,000 of claims in a year. The numbers are round and not drawn from any real plan.

Item Fully insured Self-funded
Premium or expected claims $4,600,000 premium $4,000,000 claims
Administration included $300,000
Stop-loss premium not needed $200,000
Expected total $4,600,000 $4,500,000
If claims reach $4,800,000 (ignoring stop-loss payments) $4,600,000 $5,300,000

The self-funded employer saves money in a normal year and bears more of the risk in a bad one. A fully insured employer pays a predictable premium, though a bad year typically raises next year's renewal. Employers weigh the trade-off, and employees rarely see it directly.

Which rules apply

The law that governs the plan is the main practical difference.

  • State insurance rules. In a fully insured plan, state insurance laws apply, including state-mandated benefits, such as coverage for certain treatments, state rules about continuation after job loss, and complaint handling by your state insurance department. Federal law (ERISA) generally keeps state insurance rules from applying to self-funded plans, so mandates that bind insured plans in your state may not bind your employer's.
  • Federal rules. Many federal protections apply to both types: the ACA's ban on annual and lifetime dollar limits on essential benefits, free preventive care in non-grandfathered plans, coverage of children to 26, and the No Surprises Act. Federal mental health parity rules also apply to large-group plans.
  • Who oversees the plan. For a self-funded plan, the U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) enforces ERISA for private-sector employers. For a fully insured plan, your state regulator is the first stop. Government employer plans follow different rules; see health plans for teachers and public employees: how they differ.

Some plans that are exempt from state insurance law still voluntarily follow a state mandate; your plan documents say which.

What an employee notices

Most days, nothing. Differences tend to appear in a few places:

  1. Mandated coverage. A benefit that your state requires insurers to cover may not apply to a self-funded plan, though many employers cover it anyway.
  2. Appeals and complaints. Both types have an internal appeal and, generally, external review by an independent reviewer; for self-funded plans the federal process is used. A complaint to the state insurance department may not reach a self-funded plan. See how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step and external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides.
  3. Who the plan is. The name on the card may be an insurer that only administers the claims. The employer is the one actually paying them, and the plan documents show who the plan administrator is.
  4. Plan changes. A self-funded employer can switch administrators or change networks at its own pace and may not need a state rate filing for premium changes.
  5. Privacy. HIPAA applies to both. The employer's access to individual claims data is limited either way, and self-funded employers typically get reports with names removed.

Questions to ask

  • Is our plan self-funded or fully insured?
  • Who is the plan administrator, and who decides appeals?
  • Which state mandates, if any, does the plan follow voluntarily?
  • Where do I file a complaint if the plan does not follow its own terms?

Key takeaways

  • Fully insured plans shift claims risk to an insurer; self-funded plans keep it with the employer, often with stop-loss insurance.
  • ERISA generally keeps state insurance mandates and state regulators from governing self-funded plans.
  • Core federal protections, including no lifetime limits and free preventive care, apply to both.
  • The name on your insurance card may be an administrator, not the party paying claims.
  • Ask your plan administrator which kind of plan you have before you decide where to appeal or complain.

Terms used in this guide

Latest on this topic