Blog

Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket limit: what a bad year costs, in worked numbers

A worksheet and a hypothetical bad year: how the in-network limit caps Advantage costs, what stays outside it, and how Original Medicare plus Medigap compares.

The reason to read about an out-of-pocket limit is the year nobody plans for: two hospital stays, a stretch in rehab, months of therapy and a pile of specialist visits. In a Medicare Advantage plan, the limit puts a ceiling on what you pay for covered, in-network Part A and Part B services in a calendar year. It does not cap everything you pay, and the gap between "the limit" and "the real worst case" is where people get surprised.

This post gives you a worksheet to fill in with your own plan's numbers, then runs a hypothetical bad year through it with invented copays, and sets that year beside Original Medicare with a Medigap policy. All of the plan numbers are illustrations. The Medicare figures are the 2026 amounts; the 2027 limits and some 2027 Medicare amounts were not confirmed when this was written, so use your plan's 2027 documents.

What the limit is, and what is not under it

Every Medicare Advantage plan must set a maximum out-of-pocket amount for services covered under Parts A and B. Once your copayments, coinsurance and deductibles for in-network covered services add up to that amount in a calendar year, the plan pays 100% of the rest of those in-network covered services through December 31. The count starts over on January 1. The general idea is in Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket limit, and the cousin concept for other plans is out-of-pocket maximum.

For 2026, Medicare sets the maximum a plan may use at $9,250 for in-network services and $13,900 for in-network and out-of-network services combined. Plans may choose lower limits, and many do; KFF reported an average in-network limit of $5,421 for 2026. Your own plan's limit is on its Summary of Benefits.

What counts toward the limit:

  • Copayments and coinsurance for covered in-network Part A and Part B services: hospital stays, doctor visits, therapy, outpatient surgery, tests, and Part B drugs given in an office or clinic.
  • Any plan deductible for those services.

What does not count:

  • Premiums. The plan's own premium, if any, and the Part B premium you keep paying to Medicare ($202.90 a month in 2026, which the Part B premium entry explains).
  • Part D drug costs. A plan with drug coverage has a separate cap on drug spending, $2,100 in 2026 and $2,400 in 2027 under the standard benefit. See Part D out-of-pocket cap.
  • Out-of-network costs in an HMO, which may not be covered at all, and in a PPO, which count toward the combined limit but not the in-network one.
  • Services the plan does not cover, such as most long-term custodial care, and anything above the plan's own benefit limits.
  • Anything denied for lack of required authorization, which falls on you.

The worksheet

Copy this onto paper. Use your plan's Summary of Benefits for the blanks. If a service has a copay for the first days and then zero, write that pattern down.

Part 1. The limit

  1. In-network out-of-pocket limit for the plan year: $______
  2. Combined in-network and out-of-network limit, if any: $______

Part 2. Your costs for covered in-network services (one line per kind of service)

Service Cost per unit Number of units Subtotal
Hospital stay (per day or per stay) $____ ____ $____
Skilled nursing facility (per day, after any free days) $____ ____ $____
Specialist visits $____ ____ $____
Therapy visits $____ ____ $____
Outpatient surgery $____ ____ $____
Imaging, tests and Part B drugs $____ ____ $____
Other: ____ $____ ____ $____
  1. Add the subtotals: $______
  2. Counted spending = the smaller of line 3 and line 1: $______
  3. Amount the plan pays because you reached the limit = line 3 minus line 1, if line 3 is larger: $______

Part 3. What sits outside the limit

  1. Part B premium: 12 x $______ = $______
  2. Plan premium: 12 x $______ = $______
  3. Prescription drug costs under the Part D cap: up to $______
  4. Out-of-network costs, non-covered services and unapproved services: $______

Part 4. Your realistic worst case

  1. Add lines 4, 6, 7, 8 and 9: $______

Line 10 is the number to hold up against any other option. Line 4 alone is the number the brochure tends to emphasize.

A bad year, in invented numbers

Say Dolores, 74, has "Plan X," an Advantage plan with no plan premium and an in-network limit of $9,250, the 2026 maximum. Her copays are made up for this illustration:

  • Hospital: $350 a day for days 1 to 5 of each stay, $0 after that.
  • Skilled nursing facility: $0 for days 1 to 20, then $200 a day.
  • Specialist visit: $50.
  • Therapy visit: $40.
  • Outpatient surgery: $500.
  • Imaging and tests: $75 each.

Her year: two hospital stays of six days each, one stay followed by 30 days in a skilled nursing facility, 30 specialist visits, 40 therapy visits, one outpatient surgery and 10 imaging tests or lab panels.

Item Calculation Cost
Two hospital stays 2 stays x 5 days x $350 $3,500
Skilled nursing, 30 days 10 days x $200 (days 21 to 30) $2,000
Specialist visits 30 x $50 $1,500
Therapy visits 40 x $40 $1,600
Outpatient surgery 1 x $500 $500
Imaging and tests 10 x $75 $750
Total before the limit $9,850

The total before the limit is $9,850, which is $600 more than the $9,250 limit. So Dolores's counted spending is capped at $9,250, and the plan pays the remaining $600 of covered in-network cost. If the year's last imaging tests came after she hit the limit, they cost her nothing.

Now the parts outside the limit:

  • Part B premium: 12 x $202.90 = $2,434.80.
  • Plan premium: $0 in this invented plan.
  • Drugs: say her medicines are expensive enough that she reaches the 2026 Part D cap of $2,100.

Realistic worst case, counting premiums and drugs: $9,250 + $2,434.80 + $2,100 = $13,784.80. Without drugs, since both options in the next section carry drug costs, the medical piece is $9,250 + $2,434.80 = $11,684.80.

Side by side with Original Medicare plus Medigap

Original Medicare has no out-of-pocket limit. A Medigap policy, bought separately, fills in most of the gaps. To compare, keep Dolores's year the same and price it under Original Medicare with a Medigap Plan G, a common plan that pays the Part A deductible and coinsurance, the skilled nursing coinsurance and the 20% Part B coinsurance and excess charges, leaving the Part B deductible for you. This is a hypothetical: say the Medigap premium is $200 a month ($2,400 a year). Premiums depend on your age, state, the insurer and its pricing method, so substitute a real quote.

Under 2026 Medicare amounts:

  • Part A deductible: $1,736 per benefit period. If the second hospital stay starts more than 60 days after she leaves the first episode, that is two benefit periods: 2 x $1,736 = $3,472. Plan G pays it.
  • Skilled nursing coinsurance: 10 days x $217 = $2,170 (days 21 to 30). Plan G pays it.
  • Part B deductible: $283. Dolores pays it.
  • Part B 20% coinsurance: Plan G pays it.

Her total: $283 + $2,400 (Medigap premium) + $2,434.80 (Part B premium) = $5,117.80.

For reference, Original Medicare with no Medigap would cost her $3,472 + $2,170 + $283 = $5,925 in the pieces we can compute here, before the 20% Part B coinsurance on every doctor visit, therapy session and test, and with no ceiling.

Bad year, medical costs only Total
Plan X (Advantage, limit $9,250) $9,250 + $2,434.80 = $11,684.80
Original Medicare + Plan G (invented $200 premium) $283 + $2,400 + $2,434.80 = $5,117.80
Difference $11,684.80 - $5,117.80 = $6,567.00

In this invented bad year, Original Medicare with Medigap costs $6,567 less.

Now the good year

The same comparison for a healthy year shows the other side. Say Dolores has three specialist visits and nothing else.

Good year, medical costs only Total
Plan X 3 x $50 = $150, plus $0 premium, plus $2,434.80 = $2,584.80
Original Medicare + Plan G $283 deductible + $2,400 + $2,434.80 = $5,117.80
Difference $5,117.80 - $2,584.80 = $2,533.00

In the good year the Advantage plan costs $2,533 less. That is the real trade. The Advantage plan costs less when you are healthy and carries the risk in the bad year, up to its limit. Original Medicare with Medigap costs more every month and pays most of the bad year. The tool Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage cost comparison lets you try your own numbers.

Where the numbers live in the plan's documents

Plans publish three documents that matter here, and they say slightly different things. The Summary of Benefits is the short version: the in-network limit, the combined limit and the main copays. The Evidence of Coverage is the contract: it explains what counts toward the limit, how hospital and skilled nursing copays are structured, and what needs prior authorization. The Annual Notice of Change, which current members receive in the fall, lists what is different in the coming year from the year now ending. If you are already in a plan, compare the notice's new limit and copays against this year's, line by line, before the Annual Enrollment Period ends on December 7.

Two details deserve a second look. Hospital copays are sometimes per day for a set number of days, sometimes per stay, and sometimes both a flat fee and a daily fee. The worksheet's first row cannot be filled in correctly without knowing which. And skilled nursing copays often start after a number of free days, so a short rehab stay can cost nothing while a long one is expensive.

Using line 10 to compare more than two options

Once you have line 10 for one plan, repeat the worksheet for each plan you are considering, using the same expected year. Run it twice: once for a light year, once for a heavy one. A plan whose light-year total and heavy-year total are close together is a plan with a flat cost; a plan with a low light-year total and a high heavy-year total is one that rewards good health. Neither is better in the abstract. A person who has a chronic condition and a history of hospital stays should weight the heavy year more than a person who has not seen a doctor in two years.

Also decide in advance how much of the gap you could pay in cash if the heavy year came. A limit of $9,250 is a ceiling, but it is paid as bills arrive, not at once. Ask whether your plan has a payment arrangement for large bills, and whether your savings could cover the first months. If not, that belongs in the comparison.

What the worksheet does not show

  • Networks. The limit applies to in-network care. A plan with a limit of $5,000 and a network that excludes your doctor is not a bargain. See How to check a Medicare Advantage network before you enroll, doctor by doctor.
  • Medigap availability. In most states, an insurer can use medical underwriting to decline you, or charge more, if you apply outside your first six-month window or a protected right. KFF estimates that 74% of Medicare Advantage enrollees, about 20.9 million people, have a condition that could lead to a Medigap denial outside protected windows. Original Medicare with Medigap is a bet you can only place easily at certain times. The post Can a Medigap insurer turn me down after my open enrollment ends? explains the rules.
  • Extras. An Advantage plan may include dental, vision or other extras that Original Medicare and Medigap do not. Put a realistic dollar value on the ones you would actually use.
  • Prior authorization and denials. Claims the plan declines do not count toward the limit if you end up paying them.
  • Year-to-year change. Plans can change copays, limits, networks and premiums every January. A bad year in a plan you chose last year may look different this year.

Questions to ask before you rely on the number

  1. "What is the 2027 in-network limit? Is there a separate combined limit?"
  2. "Do hospital stays charge per day or per stay? How many days?"
  3. "Do skilled nursing days past 20 have a daily copay, and for how many days?"
  4. "What counts toward the limit? Do the supplemental benefits count?"
  5. "Where can I see my year-to-date out-of-pocket total during the year?"

If you need help with the comparison, a SHIP counselor can run it at no charge, and the Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two guide explains the structural differences.

Key takeaways

  • The Advantage limit caps in-network Part A and Part B cost-sharing for the calendar year; it does not cap premiums, Part D drug costs, out-of-network costs or non-covered services.
  • In the invented bad year the plan's covered costs were $9,850, the limit reduced the counted amount to $9,250, and the total with the Part B premium was $11,684.80.
  • Original Medicare with a hypothetical $200-a-month Medigap policy cost $5,117.80 in that bad year, $6,567 less, but $2,533 more in a healthy year.
  • The comparison depends on whether you can buy Medigap later, on your doctors being in network, and on how you value plan extras.
  • Fill in the worksheet with the plan's 2027 numbers, including line 10, before you decide.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic