Blog
What plan mistakes raise costs for people with asthma or COPD?
Seven plan mistakes that raise costs for people with asthma or COPD, from skipped controller refills to a missing pulmonologist, with a yearly example.
People with a chronic lung condition often meet their health plan in the middle of a flare-up: a pharmacy counter that will not fill an inhaler, an emergency room bill for a night that could have been avoided, a medical-supply company that cannot be reached on a Sunday. Most of the costly surprises come from a handful of plan mistakes, and most of them are easy to make because the plan's rules are written for the average member, not for someone who needs the same prescriptions and equipment every month.
This post covers seven of those mistakes: how each one happens, what it costs and how to avoid it. It is not medical advice. Your clinician decides your treatment and your plan for a flare-up, and nothing here should change what they have told you. If you have severe trouble breathing, call emergency services first and sort out coverage afterward.
Mistake 1: skipping the controller medicine because of the tier
How it happens. A daily controller inhaler is often the most expensive prescription a person with asthma or COPD fills. When it sits on a higher formulary tier with a copay of $40 or more, or when the deductible applies at the start of the year, some people stretch doses, skip refills or switch to a quick-relief inhaler alone to save money.
What it costs. Controller medicine is prescribed to prevent flare-ups. A person who stops it may save the copay and risk a flare-up that sends them to urgent care or the emergency room, where the bills are larger than a year of copays. The illustration later in this post puts numbers on that.
How to avoid it. Do not stop or stretch a controller to save money without telling the prescriber. Instead, try these routes, in order:
- Ask the prescriber whether a lower-tier alternative, a generic version or a different device in the same family would work for you. Plans often cover several inhalers, and the cost differences between them can be large.
- Check the plan's formulary for the tier and for any restriction. The network and drug check worksheet on this site and what my medications will really cost over a full year by tier show how to total a full year of costs.
- Ask whether a 90-day supply, a mail-order option or a preferred pharmacy lowers the copay.
- If the prescriber decides a specific inhaler is necessary, ask for a formulary exception so it is covered at a lower tier. what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need explains the process.
- Ask the manufacturer or the pharmacist about patient assistance programs, and read the plan's rules about whether such help counts toward your deductible.
Mistake 2: not checking the pharmacy network
How it happens. Plans often have a preferred pharmacy tier, a standard network and pharmacies that are out of network. The pharmacy near your home may be in network for one plan and not for another, or in network at a higher copay. Specialty and mail-order requirements add to the confusion.
What it costs. A prescription filled out of network may be denied or reimbursed at a reduced amount. A preferred pharmacy may charge a few dollars a month less per drug, and with several prescriptions, the gap adds up over a year.
How to avoid it. At open enrollment and whenever your plan changes, check that your pharmacy is in the network for the drugs you use, and note whether the plan has a preferred tier. Call the pharmacy and say the plan name and the drug, not just the plan. Ask whether the plan will cover a refill early if you are traveling or if a flare-up uses more doses than expected. For Medicare, Part D plans differ by pharmacy and formulary, so compare them each year.
Mistake 3: going to the emergency room for a problem urgent care could handle, or the reverse
How it happens. A flare-up that is worsening at night can feel like an emergency, and sometimes it is. The mistake is not knowing, ahead of time, what your clinician's action plan says to do, so every decision is made in a panic. Plans charge much more for an emergency room visit than for an urgent care or a telehealth visit, and a person who is not sure goes to the most expensive place.
What it costs. An emergency visit often carries a larger copay, or the deductible and coinsurance, plus separate bills from the facility and the physician. An urgent care visit is typically a smaller copay. See the example below.
How to avoid it. Two points stand together.
- Never delay emergency care to save money. The prudent layperson standard means a plan generally has to cover an emergency visit when a reasonable person with average knowledge would believe the symptoms were an emergency, whatever the final diagnosis. Severe breathing difficulty, trouble speaking, blue lips or no relief from a rescue inhaler call for emergency services.
- Plan the non-emergency path in advance. Ask your clinician for a written action plan that says what to do at each stage of a flare-up, and which numbers to call. Find out whether your plan offers a nurse line or telehealth visits with a low or no copay, and which urgent care centers are in network. Should I use the ER, urgent care, telehealth or my own doctor for this? compares the options by situation.
Mistake 4: missing the supplier rules for nebulizers and oxygen
How it happens. Nebulizers, oxygen concentrators, portable oxygen and some other respiratory devices are usually durable medical equipment. That benefit runs through contracted suppliers, not pharmacies, and has its own approval rules. People who pick up a nebulizer at a retail store, or accept equipment from a supplier that is not in network, find the claim denied or paid at a lower rate.
What it costs. Equipment can be priced in thousands of dollars, and a plan that does not pay can leave the whole amount with you. Some plans rent oxygen equipment, with monthly payments and a supplier who handles maintenance, and others buy it.
How to avoid it. Before you get equipment, ask the plan three things: which suppliers are in network for this item, whether it needs prior authorization, and what documentation the plan wants. For home oxygen, plans typically want evidence from testing that shows a need. Ask the clinic what test results and notes the plan will look for. Keep the supplier's after-hours number handy, because equipment failures do not wait for business hours. For Medicare, How does Medicare pay for a CPAP, walker or wheelchair, and what do I ask? covers supplier rules that apply to equipment in general.
Mistake 5: choosing a plan without checking the pulmonologist and the hospital
How it happens. Plan comparisons focus on premiums and deductibles. A person with a chronic condition may choose a plan with a lower premium and learn after enrollment that the pulmonologist, the pulmonary rehabilitation program or the nearest hospital is out of network. Provider directories can also be wrong; the provider directory might list a doctor who has left the plan.
What it costs. Out-of-network specialist care costs more or is not covered, and continuing with a trusted specialist can mean paying a large share. Starting over with a new pulmonologist costs time and may mean repeating tests.
How to avoid it. Before choosing a plan, write down the specialist, the hospital, the rehabilitation program and the pharmacy you want to keep, then check each against the plan's directory and by phone. how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network explains how to verify network status. Ask the specialist's office which plans it accepts, and check that the specific physician, not just the practice, is listed. If you are already in a plan and your doctor leaves the network, ask the plan about continuity-of-care rules, which may allow a transition period.
Mistake 6: ignoring prior authorization and step therapy for biologics
How it happens. People with severe asthma, and some with other lung conditions, may be prescribed injectable biologic medicines. These are specialty drug products with high prices, and plans usually require prior authorization and sometimes step therapy, which requires a trial of other treatments first. Some are self-injected and billed through the pharmacy benefit, often through a specialty pharmacy. Others are given at a clinic and billed to the medical benefit. The two routes have different cost sharing, different approval processes and different suppliers.
What it costs. A delay in approval can leave a person without the medicine for weeks, and a medicine that is billed to the wrong benefit can cost far more than the same medicine on the other benefit. A missed renewal can restart the process.
How to avoid it. Ask three questions as soon as a biologic is discussed. Does the plan cover it, and under which benefit? What does the plan require before approval, such as documented test results or a history of other treatments? How long is the approval valid, and when does the renewal request need to be sent? Ask the clinic to start the request early and track it with the reference number. If the plan denies the request, the notice should explain why, and how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied and step therapy explained: "fail first" rules and how to get an exception cover the steps, including exceptions to step therapy.
Mistake 7: not using the preventive and follow-up visits
How it happens. People with a chronic condition may avoid visits when they feel well, or may not know which visits the plan covers without cost sharing. The plan covers some preventive services, such as recommended vaccines, at no cost in network. Follow-up visits for asthma or COPD management are usually ordinary specialist or primary care visits with the usual copay or deductible.
What it costs. Missed visits can mean treatment that no longer matches your needs, a controller that is not working or a flare-up that goes unaddressed. A visit that you skip is not a cost saving if it leads to a larger bill later.
How to avoid it. Ask your clinician how often follow-up visits are advisable, and ask the plan which visits and tests carry cost sharing. Check whether the plan covers recommended vaccines for people with your condition at no cost, and ask your clinician which are right for you. Use a plan's disease-management or nurse-line program if one exists, since these are often free to members. Bring a list of the medicines and devices you use so your clinician can check that the plan covers each of them.
A year with the mistake and a year without it
Here is a hypothetical comparison with round numbers invented for this post. Sam has asthma and a plan with a $1,500 deductible, 20% coinsurance, a $40 monthly copay for the controller inhaler, a $30 copay for a quick-relief inhaler, a $50 specialist copay and a $75 urgent care copay. Assume Sam has not otherwise met the deductible.
Year A: Sam skips the controller to save the copay.
- Controller: $0 (saved $480)
- Quick-relief inhalers: 6 fills x $30 = $180
- Urgent care visit: $75
- Emergency room visit for a flare-up, allowed $3,000: the deductible takes $1,500, then 20% of the remaining $1,500 is $300, so Sam owes $1,500 + $300 = $1,800
- Follow-up with the pulmonologist: $50
- Total: $180 + $75 + $1,800 + $50 = $2,105
Year B: Sam fills the controller and attends follow-up visits.
- Controller: 12 x $40 = $480
- Quick-relief inhalers: 2 fills x $30 = $60
- Two specialist visits: 2 x $50 = $100
- Total: $480 + $60 + $100 = $640
The difference is $2,105 - $640 = $1,465 in favor of Year B. The example is not a prediction. Flare-ups can happen to anyone, including people who follow every instruction, and some people have no flare-ups when they skip medicine. The point is narrower: a copay saved on a prescription that prevents problems can be outweighed by one event that falls under the deductible. If Sam's deductible had already been met by other care, the emergency visit would have cost less, and the gap would have been smaller. Run the same arithmetic on your own plan, and ask your clinician and the plan about every lower-cost route before dropping a medicine.
If you have Medicare
For people with Medicare, the structure is different. Drug coverage runs through Part D, and as of November 2026 the standard Part D benefit has an annual out-of-pocket cap of $2,100 in 2026 and $2,400 in 2027, according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' 2027 rate announcement. Plans differ in formularies and pharmacy networks, so the plan you choose in the annual enrollment period, which runs October 15 to December 7, affects your inhalers and nebulizer drugs. Oxygen and nebulizer equipment generally follow Part B's equipment rules. A SHIP counselor can help you compare plans for your medicines and your pulmonologist at no charge.
Key takeaways
- The costliest mistakes are often quiet ones: stretching a controller to avoid a copay, using an out-of-network pharmacy or supplier, or choosing a plan without checking the pulmonologist.
- Do not delay emergency care for cost reasons, because plans generally must cover emergency visits under the prudent layperson standard, but plan the non-emergency path ahead with an action plan from your clinician.
- Equipment such as nebulizers and oxygen runs through a DME supplier network with its own approvals, and biologics usually need prior authorization and may need step therapy.
- In the hypothetical year, a skipped controller saved $480 and was followed by $2,105 in costs against $640 for the year without the mistake. The result depends on your deductible and your care.
- Before open enrollment, list your medicines, devices, pharmacy, specialist and hospital, and check every item against the plan's formulary and directory.