Blog
What my medications will really cost over a full year by tier
A repeatable worksheet that turns tier copays, coinsurance and a brand-only deductible into a yearly drug cost, and shows where the out-of-pocket cap stops it.
A monthly copay on a plan summary is not a yearly cost. Five prescriptions, four different tier rules, a deductible that applies to some drugs and not others, and an out-of-pocket maximum at the top: the yearly figure only appears when you do the arithmetic one drug and one month at a time. This worksheet shows how, with a fully worked example and blanks for your own numbers.
Every dollar amount in the example is an invented round number chosen to make the steps easy to follow. It is not a price, and it is not any real plan's benefit design. Your plan's summary of benefits and its formulary hold the real numbers, and the plan's member line can confirm how each rule applies to each drug.
What you need before you start
Gather these items for the plan you are testing. If you are comparing two plans, make a copy of the worksheet for each.
- Each drug's exact name, strength, form and fill pattern. Thirty-day or ninety-day supply, and how many fills a year. A drug taken monthly is 12 fills; one taken every 90 days is 4.
- The tier of each drug on that plan's formulary, from the plan's drug list. A formulary tier is the price bracket the plan assigns.
- The cost-sharing rule for each tier: a flat copay, a percentage (coinsurance), or a copay that applies only after the deductible.
- The plan's price for each drug, which is the negotiated price the plan pays the pharmacy, not the sticker price. Many plans show an estimate in their drug-cost lookup tool. When a tier uses coinsurance, the price is what the percentage applies to.
- The deductible and how it works for drugs. Does it apply to all drugs, to brands only, or not at all? Is there a separate drug deductible? Is it combined with medical?
- The out-of-pocket maximum for one person, and which costs count toward it.
The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet has a table for the first two items. The what is an out-of-pocket maximum and what counts toward it? guide describes the cap itself.
The five-drug example
Say Priya, 52, has the following prescriptions. She fills each one every 30 days for the year. The plan in this illustration has a $500 deductible that applies to brand-name and specialty drugs only, and a $3,000 out-of-pocket maximum for one person. Generics are not subject to the deductible.
| Drug | Tier and rule in this example | Plan's price per 30-day fill | What Priya pays per fill |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: generic for blood pressure | Tier 1, $10 copay | $14 | $10 |
| B: generic for thyroid | Tier 2, $25 copay | $40 | $25 |
| C: preferred brand for diabetes | Tier 3, $50 copay after the deductible | $400 | $50 after the deductible |
| D: non-preferred brand for an inhaler | Tier 4, 30% coinsurance after the deductible | $600 | $180 after the deductible |
| E: specialty drug for an autoimmune condition | Specialty tier, 25% coinsurance after the deductible | $2,000 | $500 after the deductible |
The right-hand column is the cost after the deductible has been met. Before it, the plan makes Priya pay the full plan price for the brand-level drugs until she has paid $500 in total toward the deductible. How much of the deductible lands on which drug depends on which prescription is filled first.
Step 1: Price the drugs that skip the deductible
Generics A and B are not subject to the deductible, so their yearly cost is a plain multiplication.
- Drug A: 12 fills x $10 = $120
- Drug B: 12 fills x $25 = $300
Together: $420 a year, or $35 a month. Because a flat copay does not move with the drug's price, nothing changes if the plan's price for either drug drifts up or down a little during the year. The Why is my cheap generic drug on a higher tier than I expected? post covers why a generic can land on a higher tier than expected.
Step 2: Run the first month, when the deductible bites
Say Priya fills C, D and E in January, in that order, on the same day. The plan applies the deductible to each claim in the order the pharmacy sends them.
- Drug C, plan price $400. She owes the full $400, which counts toward the $500 deductible. Deductible left: $100.
- Drug D, plan price $600. She owes the first $100 to finish the deductible. The remaining $500 is subject to 30% coinsurance: 0.30 x $500 = $150. Her cost for D: $100 + $150 = $250.
- Drug E, plan price $2,000. The deductible is already met, so 25% coinsurance applies to the whole price: 0.25 x $2,000 = $500.
January brand-level cost: $400 + $250 + $500 = $1,150. Add the generics' $35 and January costs $1,185.
If she had filled the drugs in a different order, the January total would be different, because the percentage drugs would absorb a different share of the deductible. The year's total is more stable than any one month, and the order matters most when the out-of-pocket maximum is not reached.
Step 3: Price a normal month
From February on the deductible is met, so each drug follows its tier rule.
- C: $50
- D: 30% x $600 = $180
- E: 25% x $2,000 = $500
- A and B: $10 + $25 = $35
A normal month: $50 + $180 + $500 + $35 = $765.
Step 4: Add the months, then apply the cap
Without a cap, the year would be January's $1,185 plus eleven months at $765. That is 11 x $765 = $8,415, and $1,185 + $8,415 = $9,600.
But Priya's plan has a $3,000 out-of-pocket maximum, and in this example all of the copays, coinsurance and the deductible count toward it. Track the running total month by month.
| Month | Priya's cost before the cap | Running total | What she pays after the cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| January | $1,185 | $1,185 | $1,185 |
| February | $765 | $1,950 | $765 |
| March | $765 | $2,715 | $765 |
| April | $765 | $3,480 | $285 (she reaches $3,000) |
| May to December | $765 a month | capped | $0 |
April's bill is the interesting one. She has $2,715 on the board after March, so only $3,000 - $2,715 = $285 of April's $765 is hers; the plan pays the rest. For the remaining eight months the plan pays covered drugs in full.
Yearly cost with the cap: $1,185 + $765 + $765 + $285 = $3,000. Without it: $9,600. The cap is worth $6,600 to her in this example, and it also gives her a planning ceiling: the most her covered, in-network drug spending could cost under this plan is $3,000, no matter what prices do.
What the cap does not cover
The $3,000 figure above is the ceiling for covered drugs at in-network pharmacies on the plan's formulary. It leaves out several costs that are easy to forget, and each one should have a line on your worksheet.
- Premiums. The monthly premium is separate. Add 12 times the premium for the total cost of having the plan. The Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even guide explains why a higher premium can lower the rest.
- Drugs the plan does not cover. A non-formulary drug does not count toward the maximum and is not capped by it, unless the plan approves an exception.
- Out-of-network pharmacies, where the plan may pay nothing or may pay at a lower rate.
- Brand-over-generic price differences. If you choose a brand when a generic is available, many plans charge you the price difference on top of the tier cost, and that difference often does not count toward the cap. The which prescription purchases count toward my deductible and out-of-pocket max? post lists what counts.
- Medical costs. The example isolates drugs. In a plan with a combined limit, doctor visits and hospital stays share the same maximum, so Priya might reach it sooner. In a plan with a separate drug limit, they do not.
Variations worth testing on your own numbers
A worksheet is most useful when you change one thing and watch the answer move. These variations take a few minutes each.
- Drop the specialty drug. Take drug E out of the example. January: C $400, D $100 + $150 = $250 (since the deductible is $500 and C used $400), so brands total $650 and January is $685. A normal month: $50 + $180 + $35 = $265. Eleven months at $265 is $2,915, and $685 + $2,915 = $3,600, which is above the $3,000 cap. Running totals show she crosses $3,000 during month 10, so the year is capped at $3,000 again. A big specialty drug is not the only way to reach the cap.
- Switch drug D to a lower tier. If a covered alternative sits on tier 3 with a $50 copay, a normal month falls by $130 to $635, but you have to ask the prescriber whether the alternative is appropriate. The worksheet only tells you what the change would be worth.
- Use a 90-day supply for the generics. Many plans charge about two to three copays for a three-month supply instead of three. Replace 12 fills with 4 and use the 90-day copay from the plan documents.
- Add a copay card or assistance program for drug E. This one is the least predictable. In some plans, assistance payments count toward the deductible and cap, and in others they do not, so your out-of-pocket total can be different from what you paid. The why one specialty drug fill can use up my whole out-of-pocket maximum post covers how a single high fill can use up the cap.
Where the inputs hide in the plan documents
Most of the work is finding the right number, not the multiplication. Plans scatter the inputs across several documents, and it helps to know which one answers which question.
- The summary of benefits and coverage states the drug tiers and the cost-sharing rule for each in a short table, along with the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum. Look for footnotes: a line such as "deductible applies" or "after deductible" beside a tier is the one that changes the first month. The how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan guide has more on reading that table.
- The formulary lists each drug and its tier, with codes for restrictions such as prior authorization or quantity limits. A quantity limit can change the number of fills that are covered in a year, which feeds straight into your worksheet.
- The plan's drug-cost lookup tool, when there is one, estimates the price per fill. Treat its price as an estimate. Negotiated prices can change during the year, and a drug whose price rises under a coinsurance tier costs you more even though the tier never moved.
- The evidence of coverage or plan contract answers the awkward questions: whether the drug deductible is separate, whether a 90-day supply gets a lower copay, and whether a specialty drug must be filled through a designated pharmacy.
Two habits make the worksheet more reliable. First, keep a date next to every input, so you know when you looked. Second, write the source beside each number, such as "SBC page 2" or "rep on the phone, reference number." If the plan's answer later differs, you have something to point to.
Your blank worksheet
Copy this table and fill it out for each plan you are considering. Use the plan's own numbers.
| Drug | Tier | Rule (copay, coinsurance, after deductible?) | Plan's price per fill | Fills per year | Cost per fill after deductible | Yearly cost before deductible effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | ||||||
| 3 | ||||||
| 4 | ||||||
| 5 |
Then work through these lines:
- Add the yearly costs of the drugs that skip the deductible.
- Run the first month for the drugs the deductible applies to, in the order you expect to fill them.
- Compute a normal month after the deductible.
- Build the running total month by month and stop at the out-of-pocket maximum.
- Add 12 times the monthly premium, and any cost for drugs that are not covered.
- Compare the totals for each plan, and record when each plan's maximum would be reached.
When a plan's drug lookup tool offers an annual-cost estimate, compare it with your figure. A difference usually means one of you has the wrong fill pattern, price or tier. The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker can then help you follow the actual spending through the year, and how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan shows how to add the medical side.
Who can check your numbers
The arithmetic is yours to do, but the inputs need confirming. The plan's member line can tell you the tier and cost-sharing rule for each of your exact products, how the deductible applies to drugs and whether any separate limit exists. A licensed broker or a marketplace navigator can run a comparison across plans for you at no charge to you in many cases. Employer plans have a benefits department. For Medicare Part D plans, a State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor does the same job, and Part D follows its own annual rules for deductibles and the out-of-pocket cap, which differ from the commercial plan in this example.
Key takeaways
- A yearly drug cost is built drug by drug: tier rule, plan price, fills per year, and whether the deductible applies. The plan's price, not the sticker price, drives coinsurance.
- The first month is the costly one when a brand-only deductible applies, and the order of fills changes which drug absorbs it.
- The out-of-pocket maximum turns an open-ended sum into a ceiling. In the example, $9,600 became $3,000, though premiums, non-covered drugs and out-of-network fills sit outside it.
- Change one input at a time, such as a tier, a 90-day fill or a dropped drug, to see which lever matters for your list.
- Confirm tiers, deductible rules and the cap with the plan before you rely on the result.