Blog

Our baby is due in December, so how will the deductible split across two years?

A worksheet that totals prenatal, delivery and newborn costs under two sample plans for a December or January birth, with round numbers and blanks for your own.

A due date of December 20 does not tell you which plan year the delivery will fall into. Babies arrive early and late, and a delivery on December 30 and one on January 2 land in different years with different deductibles. Open enrollment for the new year is happening right now, so the plan you pick this month may cover the delivery, or may cover only what comes after it. The way to choose without guessing is to price both outcomes on paper and compare them with the premium.

This post gives you a worksheet to do that. It lists the inputs, the formulas and a worked example with two sample plans. The plans, prices and dollar amounts in the example are invented round numbers chosen so the arithmetic is easy to check. Your plan's documents and your clinicians' estimates supply the real ones. The delivery date itself is a medical decision between you and your care team, and the worksheet is meant to show the financial effect of that date, not to steer it.

Why the plan year matters

Under most plans, a deductible and an out-of-pocket maximum are counted per plan year, and both reset when a new plan year begins. For most employer plans and all marketplace plans that year is the calendar year, though an employer plan can use a different 12-month period. That has three consequences for a December birth.

  1. Costs before the delivery are already in this year's totals. Prenatal visits, ultrasounds and lab work from the spring and summer have probably been applied to this year's deductible, so a delivery in December can be cheap, because much of this year's deductible is already spent, or even free of further cost sharing if you reached the out-of-pocket maximum.
  2. A delivery in January starts from zero. The same delivery, one week later, falls into the new year's deductible, and you pay it again.
  3. Newborn and postpartum costs always come after. Whatever the delivery date, most of the baby's first-year costs, such as the sick visits and any hospital readmission, fall in the new plan year.

A claim that straddles New Year's Day is the gray area. Plans commonly assign an inpatient stay to the year of admission, the year of discharge or split it by the date of service. The plan's member services can tell you which rule applies to your plan, and it is worth asking before the due date, not after.

What goes into the worksheet

Gather these five items before you calculate anything.

  1. This year's plan numbers. Deductible, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximum, and how much you have already spent toward each. The amounts are on your latest explanations of benefits or the member portal.
  2. Next year's plan numbers. For each plan you are considering: monthly premium, deductible (individual and family, and whether the individual amount is embedded), coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum. The summary of benefits shows them.
  3. How the delivery is billed. Ask the obstetrician's office whether it bills a single global fee for prenatal visits, delivery and the postpartum visit or bills each visit separately, and ask the plan which date it uses to place a global fee in a plan year. This one detail can move a large charge across New Year's Day.
  4. Estimated charges. Ask the hospital and the clinician's billing office what they expect to charge, and ask the plan for its estimated allowed amount for a vaginal delivery and a cesarean in network. Treat any estimate as a range.
  5. Expected baby and parent costs for the year. Well-baby visits are preventive, and under non-grandfathered plans they have no cost sharing. Plan for some sick visits and for the possibility of more.

The out-of-pocket formula for one person on one plan, ignoring copays, is:

  • If the allowed charges are no more than the deductible, the person pays all of them.
  • Otherwise the person pays the deductible plus coinsurance times the allowed charges above the deductible, but never more than the out-of-pocket maximum.

For one year on a plan, the total cost is twelve months of premium plus the out-of-pocket amounts for each person. The deductible vs premium break-even calculator does a version of this for one person, and the guide on Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even explains the trade-off.

The example: two plans, two birth dates

Say a couple expects a baby in late December. Both parents will be on the plan for next year, and the baby will be added at birth. Here are the plans they are comparing for the new year.

Plan A (lower premium) Plan B (higher premium)
Premium for the family, per month $900 $1,300
Premium for the year $10,800 $15,600
Individual deductible (embedded) $3,000 $1,000
Family deductible $6,000 $2,000
Coinsurance after the deductible 30% 10%
Individual out-of-pocket maximum $8,000 $4,000
Family out-of-pocket maximum $16,000 $8,000

All care is in network. Both plans are within the federal limits for plan year 2027 of $12,000 for self-only coverage and $24,000 for family coverage. The couple's current plan also matters, and its numbers for the year so far are these: individual deductible $2,000, coinsurance 20%, out-of-pocket maximum $5,000, and $1,500 already spent on prenatal care, all counted toward the deductible.

Birth in late December, under this year's plan

Say the delivery's allowed charges are $14,000 and the baby's newborn care is $1,500.

  1. The mother has $500 of deductible left, since $2,000 minus $1,500 is $500. She pays $500 plus 20% of the remaining $13,500, which is $2,700. That is $3,200. Her total for the year is $1,500 plus $3,200, or $4,700, which is below the $5,000 maximum.
  2. The baby, added from birth, has a $2,000 individual deductible and owes the full $1,500.
  3. The cost of this delivery under this year's plan is $3,200 plus $1,500, or $4,700. It is the same under either of next year's plans, because it falls before them.

Next year's plan then governs everything after the delivery. Say that year the baby has $1,800 of allowed sick-visit and urgent care charges, and the mother has $2,500 of allowed postpartum and specialist charges. Well-baby visits are free and are not counted.

Plan A Plan B
Baby: $1,800 allowed Under the $3,000 deductible, so $1,800 $1,000 deductible plus 10% of $800 = $1,080
Mother: $2,500 allowed Under the $3,000 deductible, so $2,500 $1,000 deductible plus 10% of $1,500 = $1,150
Out of pocket for the year $4,300 $2,230
Plus premiums $10,800 $15,600
Total cost for the year $15,100 $17,830

In this case Plan A costs $2,730 less than Plan B, since $17,830 minus $15,100 is $2,730.

Birth in early January, under next year's plan

Now say the baby arrives on January 5, and the delivery and newborn charges fall in the new plan year. Delivery charges are $14,000 and the newborn's care is $2,000. Nothing else happens that year, to keep the comparison clean.

Plan A Plan B
Mother: $14,000 allowed $3,000 deductible plus 30% of $11,000 ($3,300) = $6,300 $1,000 deductible plus 10% of $13,000 ($1,300) = $2,300
Baby: $2,000 allowed Under the $3,000 deductible, so $2,000 $1,000 deductible plus 10% of $1,000 ($100) = $1,100
Out of pocket for the year $8,300 $3,400
Plus premiums $10,800 $15,600
Total cost for the year $19,100 $19,000

Here Plan B costs $100 less. The result flips: because the January delivery uses up next year's deductible, the plan with the lower deductible and coinsurance now makes up almost all of its premium difference.

The worst case

A third column on the worksheet is the ceiling, the most you could pay in a bad year, with both parents and the baby hitting the family maximum.

  • Plan A: $10,800 in premiums plus $16,000, which is $26,800.
  • Plan B: $15,600 in premiums plus $8,000, which is $23,600.

If a complicated birth or a NICU stay is possible, Plan B's ceiling is $3,200 lower.

What the example says

Summing up the three views for these invented plans:

Scenario Cheaper plan By how much
Delivery in December, ordinary year after Plan A $2,730
Delivery in January Plan B $100
Worst case, family maximum reached Plan B $3,200

Plan A wins when the delivery falls this year and next year is quiet. Plan B wins, narrowly or widely, when the delivery falls next year or things go badly. The choice depends on two things you cannot know in advance, the date and the complications, so the worksheet tells you the price of being wrong in each direction. A family that cannot absorb the ceiling difference may sensibly pay more in premium. A family with savings and a short list of risks may sensibly pay less. Neither is a wrong answer.

Your worksheet

Copy this and fill in the blanks. Do it once for each plan and each birth date.

Step Item Your number
1 Premium per month times 12 ______
2 Mother's allowed charges that land in the plan year ______
3 Mother pays: deductible left, plus coinsurance times the rest, capped at the individual maximum ______
4 Baby's allowed charges that land in the plan year ______
5 Baby pays: same formula, with the baby's own deductible ______
6 Other parent's expected charges and cost ______
7 Add steps 3, 5 and 6 and check against the family maximum ______
8 Total cost for the year: step 1 plus step 7 ______
9 Ceiling: step 1 plus the family out-of-pocket maximum ______

Questions to ask before the due date

A few phone calls turn the worksheet from a rough guess into a usable one. Write the answers next to the matching step.

  1. To the plan's member services: Which plan year does a hospital stay belong to when it starts in one year and ends in the next? Is it the admission date, the discharge date or each day separately? How is a global maternity fee placed, by the delivery date or by the date of each visit?
  2. To the plan: Is my family's deductible embedded, so that each person has an individual deductible, or aggregate, so that only the family figure counts? Does the baby's first-days nursery care go on the baby's claim or on mine?
  3. To the hospital's billing office: Which of the clinicians who will see me at delivery are in the plan's network, including the anesthesia group and the pediatric group? Out-of-network surprise bills for these are limited by federal law at in-network hospitals, but it is easier to confirm in advance.
  4. To the obstetrician's office: What do you expect to bill for a vaginal delivery and for a cesarean, and when do you bill the global fee?
  5. To HR or the marketplace: What is the deadline for adding the baby, and from what date will the baby's coverage start?

Keep a note of who answered, on what date, because plan representatives sometimes give different answers to the same question, and a record of what you were told helps if a claim is later processed differently.

Things the worksheet cannot see

  • Household size and credits. If you buy through the marketplace, a pregnant applicant can generally count the unborn child when giving the household size, which can change the premium tax credit. A navigator or the application can confirm how it applies to you.
  • Changing plans after the birth. A birth opens a special enrollment period, 60 days on the marketplace, and on an employer plan the window commonly runs about 30 days. The marketplace period generally lets the household add the baby or change plans, while an employer plan's rules about changing options depend on the plan. A mid-year switch can mean a new deductible, so ask whether spending carries over before relying on a switch to fix a choice.
  • The global fee. If the plan places the OB's global fee by the delivery date, your prenatal visits in the old year may be billed in the new year.
  • Open enrollment deadlines. As of November 2026, HealthCare.gov's window for plan year 2027 runs through January 15, 2027, with January 1 coverage for those who enroll by December 15. Employers set their own windows, and state marketplaces have their own end dates.
  • A parent's job or income changing. The worksheet assumes both parents stay on the plan and that costs follow the estimates.

If your numbers come out close, the guide on how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan shows how to estimate the other costs in the year, and the post on Why did I get two bills for the birth, one for me and one for my baby? explains why the baby's claim is separate. The guide on adding a baby to your health insurance: deadlines and steps and the newborn and life event coverage deadline calculator cover the deadlines to add the baby.

Key takeaways

  • The deductible and out-of-pocket maximum reset on January 1 for most plans, so whether the delivery claim falls in December or January can change your cost by thousands of dollars.
  • Ask the plan which date it uses for a hospital stay that spans New Year's Day, and ask the OB's office how it bills the global maternity fee, before the due date.
  • In the example, the lower-premium plan was cheaper by $2,730 if the delivery fell this year, and the higher-premium plan was cheaper by $100 if it fell next year, so the ranking turned on the delivery date.
  • Compare plans on three columns: the likely cost, the cost if the delivery date goes the other way and the ceiling with the family maximum reached.
  • A navigator, a broker or the plan's member services can check the numbers for your plans, and your care team decides the timing of delivery.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic