Blog

What is the benchmark plan, and why does my credit follow it, not my plan?

The second-lowest-cost silver plan sets the size of your premium tax credit. A worked example shows the same credit applied to bronze, silver and gold plans.

You picked a plan, and the marketplace showed a credit that seems to have nothing to do with it. The credit is not a discount on the plan you chose. It is a fixed dollar amount worked out from a different plan, the benchmark, which is the second-lowest-cost silver plan sold in your area for people your age. You can then spend that same amount toward any plan in a metal level you like.

That design explains several things that confuse people: why a cheaper plan costs you much less after the credit, why a pricier plan costs you more by exactly the difference, why your premium can jump when you did not change anything, and why the credit can move when your own plan's price stays put. The examples below use invented numbers, labeled as illustrations. None is a real price.

Three numbers decide the credit

The premium tax credit is calculated as a simple subtraction:

  1. The benchmark premium. The monthly price of the second-lowest-cost silver plan for the people in your household, at your address and ages.
  2. Your required contribution. A share of your household income, set by a table the IRS publishes each year. It rises as income rises. For tax year 2027 the table runs from 2.15% to 10.22% of income. It does not depend on which plan you choose.
  3. The credit. The benchmark premium minus your required contribution, but never below zero and never more than the premium of the plan you actually pick.

If the benchmark costs $520 a month and your required share is $200 a month, the credit is $320 a month. Pick any plan, and the marketplace takes $320 off its price (or less, if the plan costs less than $320). The benchmark plan entry gives the short definition, and the guide on How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share covers how income feeds into step 2.

Why the second-lowest silver

The benchmark is a yardstick: a plan the law picks so that everyone in an area measures help against the same reference. The law names silver as the reference metal level and the second-lowest price within it, so the credit is tied to a market price you can look up rather than to a plan you happen to choose.

The yardstick says nothing about quality. The benchmark may be a plan you would not choose, from an insurer you may not want. It only supplies a number. Think of it as a measuring cup: it tells you how much help you get, not what to buy with it.

One credit, several plans: a worked example

Say a single 40-year-old has an income of $40,000 and an illustrative required share of 6%. That is $40,000 x 6% = $2,400 a year, or $200 a month. The county sells these plans (all prices are invented):

Plan Monthly price After a $320 credit
Bronze, low-price $300 $0
Bronze $390 $70
Silver A (lowest-cost silver) $480 $160
Silver B (second-lowest silver, the benchmark) $520 $200
Silver C $640 $320
Gold $610 $290

The benchmark is Silver B at $520. The credit is $520 - $200 = $320. Look at how it plays out:

  • On the benchmark itself, you pay exactly your required contribution, $200. That is how the yardstick works: help is set so that the benchmark costs you the required share.
  • On Silver A, which is cheaper than the benchmark, you pay $160. The credit did not shrink, so you keep the savings.
  • On Silver C and the gold plan, you pay more than the required share by the extra sticker price: Silver C is $120 over the benchmark ($640 - $520), so you pay $200 + $120 = $320. Gold is $90 over, so you pay $200 + $90 = $290.
  • On the low-price bronze plan at $300, the credit of $320 is more than the price, so you pay $0. The extra $20 is not paid to you; the credit cannot exceed the premium.

The ordering after the credit is the same as the ordering before it, because the same dollar amount comes off each plan. The credit changes what you pay in dollars and makes lower-priced plans look much cheaper in percentage terms. It does not reorder them.

The same plans at three incomes

Your income changes the required share, and with it the credit, but never the way the yardstick works. Using the same county, the same invented prices, and illustrative required shares of 4.5%, 6% and 9% (the real percentages come from the IRS table):

Yearly income Required share Yearly / monthly Credit You pay: Silver B You pay: Gold at $610
$30,000 4.5% $1,350 / $112.50 $407.50 $112.50 $202.50
$40,000 6% $2,400 / $200 $320 $200 $290
$55,000 9% $4,950 / $412.50 $107.50 $412.50 $502.50

The benchmark plan always costs you exactly the required share. Every other plan costs the required share plus or minus the gap between its price and the benchmark's: gold is $90 above the benchmark ($610 - $520), so it costs $90 more than Silver B in every row.

A family has a benchmark for every member

For a household, the benchmark is the sum of the benchmark prices for each covered person at their age. Say two adults, aged 45 and 50, and a 10-year-old are covered, and the invented benchmark prices are $560, $700 and $330 a month. The household benchmark is $560 + $700 + $330 = $1,590 a month.

Say household income is $90,000 and the illustrative required share is 8%, which is $7,200 a year, or $600 a month. The credit is $1,590 - $600 = $990 a month. A family plan priced at $1,450 costs $1,450 - $990 = $460. A cheaper family plan at $1,200 costs $210. As children get older or a parent has a birthday, the sum changes, which is one reason premiums move at renewal even for a household whose income and plan are unchanged.

When the credit is bigger than the plan

The $0 line in the table is real. If you are eligible for a large credit and a bronze or low-priced plan costs less than the credit, you can pay nothing in premium. Two cautions go with that.

First, a plan with a $0 premium still has a deductible and cost sharing. A bronze plan covers about 60% of average costs, so you carry more of a large bill than you would with silver or gold. The guide on bronze, silver, gold and platinum plans: what the metal levels mean explains the metal levels.

Second, a cost-sharing reduction, which lowers deductibles and the out-of-pocket maximum, comes only with silver plans bought through the marketplace and only at lower incomes. A $0 bronze plan has no cost-sharing reduction. If your income is in the range where it applies, the silver plan with that help can cost less overall if you use care, even with a higher premium. The post on Silver with cost-sharing help, bronze or gold: which costs less if I use care? works through that.

Why your credit changes when other plans change

Because the credit follows the second-lowest silver plan, it responds to what other insurers do, even when your own plan's price is unchanged. Take the same county and start with your plan, Silver B at $520, and the $200 required share.

The lowest silver plan leaves. Silver A is discontinued. The silvers left are B at $520 and C at $640, so the second-lowest is now $640. The credit is $640 - $200 = $440. Your Silver B now costs $520 - $440 = $80, down from $200. The credit rose and your plan got cheaper after the credit.

A new, cheaper silver plan arrives. An insurer enters with Silver D at $450. The order is D $450, A $480, B $520, C $640, so the second-lowest is A at $480. The credit is $480 - $200 = $280. Silver B now costs $520 - $280 = $240, up from $200. You did nothing and your premium rose $40.

The benchmark's own price rises. Suppose only Silver B's price rises to $572 and nothing else changes. B is still the second-lowest, so the credit is $572 - $200 = $372. Silver B costs you $572 - $372 = $200, the same as before. But the others are cheaper after the credit: Silver A is $480 - $372 = $108, Silver C is $640 - $372 = $268, and the gold plan is $610 - $372 = $238.

None of this means any insurer is helping or hurting you. It is how a formula tied to a market reference behaves when the market moves. It is also why the guide on what to do if your insurer leaves the marketplace in your area tells people to recompare plans at renewal instead of assuming last year's choice is still the cheapest. The worksheet in compare my renewed marketplace plan with the other options: a worksheet is a way to do it.

Where to find your own benchmark

  • On the marketplace. The application's results page, or the plan comparison screen, shows your credit. The benchmark premium may appear in the details of your eligibility. Window-shopping tools show estimated credits for your age, county and income.
  • On your Form 1095-A. After a year of coverage, the marketplace sends Form 1095-A. Column B of Part III lists, month by month, the premium of the second-lowest-cost silver plan used for your credit, and column C lists the advance payment of the credit. Form 8962 uses column B to recompute the credit on your return.
  • In a family. The benchmark is the sum of the benchmark prices for every person in the household who is covered, each at their own age. A family with two adults and children gets a larger benchmark and a larger credit than a single adult, other things equal.

Calculators such as the ACA subsidy estimator do the arithmetic, and the blog post on calculate your own premium tax credit by hand: a step-by-step worksheet shows how to do it yourself, step by step.

For context only: KFF reported, as of November 2026, that the national average benchmark premium for a 40-year-old was $625 a month in 2026 and $703 a month for 2027. Averages hide huge variation by county, age and state. Your benchmark is the one the marketplace shows you.

Four assumptions that lead people astray

  1. "The credit is tied to the plan I enrolled in." It is not. Changing plans within a metal level, or between metal levels, does not change the credit, only the price you pay.
  2. "A cheaper plan lowers my credit." It does not. Choosing a cheaper plan than the benchmark leaves the credit unchanged and lowers what you pay, down to $0 if the credit exceeds the price.
  3. "The benchmark is the plan the marketplace recommends." It is not a recommendation. It is a reference price.
  4. "If my premium went up, my insurer raised my price." Sometimes. But the premium after the credit can also change because the benchmark moved, your income changed the required share, or your age moved you into a new age price. Check each one, in that order.

What to do with this when you shop

Use the credit as a fixed number, find it, and then compare plans on what you pay after it. Compare each plan's net premium, deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, doctors and drug coverage together, not the premium alone; the guide on how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs and the worksheet linked above can help.

If you cannot tell why the credit is what it is, ask the marketplace or a navigator to show how it was calculated. If a tax return is where the question arises, a tax professional can check the Form 8962 arithmetic.

Key takeaways

  • The credit equals the benchmark premium (the second-lowest-cost silver plan for your household) minus your required contribution, which depends on income and not on the plan you pick.
  • The same credit applies to bronze, silver and gold plans, so a cheaper plan costs less by the full price difference, and a pricier one costs more by the same.
  • The credit cannot exceed the plan's premium, so very low-priced plans can cost $0.
  • Because the benchmark depends on other plans in your area, your premium after credit can change when plans enter, leave or reprice, even if your own plan's price does not.
  • Form 1095-A, column B, shows the benchmark premium used for your credit each month.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic