Blog
Compare my renewed marketplace plan with the other options: a worksheet
A worksheet for deciding whether to keep the plan you are renewed into, filled in for two hypothetical plans, with a rule for when switching is worth it.
The plan the marketplace has chosen for you is a default, not a recommendation. It is the plan you already have, or the closest one the insurer offers, and nobody has checked whether it is still the cheapest way for you to get the care you expect to use. This worksheet is a way to check in an hour or so, using numbers from your own notice and from the plans listed beside it.
It works the same for a single adult or a family. The example uses two hypothetical plans with round numbers, labeled Plan R (the renewed plan) and Plan N (another plan in the same account). The prices, deductibles and copays are invented for illustration and are not any insurer's actual plans.
Before the arithmetic: the must-pass filter
A plan that costs less is not a bargain if you cannot use it. Check three things before you compare dollars, and drop any plan that fails.
- Doctors and the hospital. Are the primary care doctor, the specialists you see regularly and the hospital you would go to in an emergency in the plan's network? The post Why are marketplace plan networks so narrow, and how do I judge one? has a short test for each, and the doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet helps you record answers.
- Drugs. Is each regular prescription on the plan's formulary, at what tier, and with what restrictions?
- Service area and referrals. Does the plan need a referral to see a specialist, and does it cover care where you actually get it?
If your renewed plan fails the filter, the answer is already to switch. If it passes and a competing plan fails, take the competing plan off the sheet. Only plans that pass go on to the next step.
Step 1: list the figures for each plan
For each plan that passes, copy these figures from the plan page, the summary of benefits or the renewal notice into a table. The first column below is the blank worksheet, and the next two show the hypothetical plans filled in.
| Row | Blank (your plan) | Plan R (renewed) | Plan N (other option) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premium after credit, per month | $____ | $200 | $150 |
| Annual premium (monthly × 12) | $____ | $2,400 | $1,800 |
| Deductible | $____ | $3,000 | $4,500 |
| Coinsurance after the deductible | ____% | 20% | 25% |
| Out-of-pocket maximum | $____ | $7,000 | $8,000 |
| Primary care visit copay | $____ | $30 | $40 |
| Specialist visit copay | $____ | $60 | $80 |
| Generic drug copay, per fill | $____ | $10 | $15 |
| Doctors and hospital in network? | Y / N | Y | Y |
| Drugs on the formulary? | Y / N | Y | Y |
Two cautions about the first rows. First, use the premium after credit for each plan with your own income entered, because credit is tied to the benchmark plan and the same plan costs different amounts to different households. The glossary entry for cost-sharing reduction also matters: if you qualify, the silver version shown for your income has a lower deductible and out-of-pocket maximum than the standard silver plan, so use the variant the account shows you, not the plan's headline numbers. Second, the federal ceiling for the out-of-pocket maximum in 2027 is $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for other than self-only coverage, so any plan's figure should be at or below that.
Step 2: write down the care you expect to use
You are estimating, not predicting. The most reliable source is last year's explanations of benefits, and the post Use last year's EOBs to forecast next year's health costs shows how. Then add what you know is coming: a planned procedure, a pregnancy, a new medication, a child's therapy.
For the example, imagine one adult with three kinds of year.
- Light year: 3 primary care visits and 12 generic fills, with no other care.
- Expected year: 4 primary care visits, 3 specialist visits, 12 generic fills, and one outpatient procedure with an allowed amount of $6,000.
- Bad year: a serious illness or injury that runs up costs past the out-of-pocket maximum.
The "allowed amount" is the price the plan has negotiated, not the hospital's list price. The guide how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan explains how to estimate each type of cost.
Step 3: compute the light year
The light year is the year you hope for. Add the annual premium and the copays. No deductible applies to these services in the example, because the copays do not sit behind the deductible.
Plan R: $2,400 premium + (3 × $30 = $90 for primary care) + (12 × $10 = $120 for generics) = $2,400 + $90 + $120 = $2,610.
Plan N: $1,800 premium + (3 × $40 = $120) + (12 × $15 = $180) = $1,800 + $120 + $180 = $2,100.
In a light year, Plan N costs $2,610 − $2,100 = $510 less. The lower premium wins when you barely use care.
Step 4: compute the expected year
Here the procedure matters. For each plan, the procedure's allowed amount of $6,000 first fills the deductible, then the coinsurance applies to the rest.
Plan R:
- Procedure: the first $3,000 is the deductible. The remaining $6,000 − $3,000 = $3,000 is shared, and you pay 20% of it, which is $600. Your procedure cost is $3,000 + $600 = $3,600.
- Copays: 4 × $30 = $120 primary care; 3 × $60 = $180 specialist; 12 × $10 = $120 generics, for $420 in total.
- Out-of-pocket spending: $3,600 + $420 = $4,020, which is under the $7,000 maximum.
- With the premium: $2,400 + $4,020 = $6,420.
Plan N:
- Procedure: the first $4,500 is the deductible. The remaining $6,000 − $4,500 = $1,500 is shared, and you pay 25% of it, which is $375. Your procedure cost is $4,500 + $375 = $4,875.
- Copays: 4 × $40 = $160; 3 × $80 = $240; 12 × $15 = $180, for $580 in total.
- Out-of-pocket spending: $4,875 + $580 = $5,455, under the $8,000 maximum.
- With the premium: $1,800 + $5,455 = $7,255.
In the expected year, Plan R costs $7,255 − $6,420 = $835 less. The lower deductible more than pays for the higher premium.
Step 5: compute the bad year
For a year in which care costs run past the out-of-pocket maximum, the most you can pay for covered in-network care is the maximum. Premiums, balance bills and non-covered services do not count toward it, and they are paid in addition.
Plan R: $2,400 + $7,000 = $9,400.
Plan N: $1,800 + $8,000 = $9,800.
In the worst case Plan R costs $400 less. The gap is smaller than in the expected year, because both plans end at their maximums, and the premium difference of $600 is partly offset by the $1,000 difference in maximums.
Step 6: put the three years side by side
| Kind of year | Plan R total | Plan N total | Cheaper plan | By how much |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Light | $2,610 | $2,100 | Plan N | $510 |
| Expected | $6,420 | $7,255 | Plan R | $835 |
| Bad | $9,400 | $9,800 | Plan R | $400 |
Now ask how much each kind of year is likely for you. For a person who has a procedure scheduled, the expected year is nearly certain, and Plan R is the better fit. For a healthy person with no planned care, the light year is the likely one, and Plan N saves $510 but leaves more exposure if something happens. The Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even guide explains this trade in more detail, and the post compare two plans' total cost for a light, average and heavy year uses a similar three-year method for any plan type.
A few other items belong on the sheet even though they do not have a dollar figure:
- Whether a plan is eligible to pair with a health savings account, which has a tax value for some households.
- Whether you would have to change doctors, and how much that costs you in time and continuity.
- Whether a deductible is embedded, so each family member has an individual deductible within the family one, or aggregate. In a family it can change the total.
A rule for when switching is worth the effort
Switching has a cost in time and in disruption: new cards, a new insurer's portal, and the risk of missing a detail. So a rule is more useful than a purely arithmetic comparison. This is a rule of thumb, not advice on any individual choice.
- Switch if the renewed plan fails the must-pass filter and another plan passes it. Nothing else matters.
- Switch if the other plan is cheaper in your expected year by about $500 or more, and it also does not leave you materially worse off in the bad year. Choose your own threshold, and use a larger one if you are risk-averse or if a change would disrupt a long relationship with a clinician.
- Stay if the difference is under about $300 in your expected year, or if the savings depend on staying healthy and a bad year would cost you much more.
- Take a second look if the premium rose sharply. A large increase in the full premium may not change what you pay if the credit moves with it, but it may change which plan is the cheapest for you. The post My marketplace premium jumped at renewal: what should I check first? lists what to check.
In the example, a reader who expects the procedure year should stay with Plan R. A reader with a light year in prospect might switch to Plan N, saving $510, if that saving is worth more than the extra exposure in a bad year. A reader who needs a specialist who is only in Plan R's network has no real choice.
A second pass: when one drug changes the answer
The comparison above assumed only generic drugs. Add a single brand-name medication and the result can reverse, which is why the formulary check comes first.
Suppose the reader also takes a brand-name drug every month, with an allowed amount of $300 per fill. Suppose Plan R places it on a tier with a flat $60 copay that does not wait for the deductible, while Plan N applies the deductible to that tier, so the reader pays the full allowed amount until the deductible is met. These terms are invented to show the mechanism; real formularies differ by plan.
- Plan R: 12 fills × $60 = $720 a year.
- Plan N: 12 fills × $300 = $3,600 a year, which is still below the $4,500 deductible, so the reader pays all of it.
Add those to the light-year totals:
- Plan R: $2,610 + $720 = $3,330.
- Plan N: $2,100 + $3,600 = $5,700.
The plan that was $510 cheaper in a light year is now $5,700 − $3,330 = $2,370 more expensive, because a single drug sits behind a deductible there. In a real comparison, the drug's tier, any prior authorization or step therapy, and whether a manufacturer coupon counts toward the deductible all belong on the sheet. The post compare two plans' total cost for a light, average and heavy year and the guide how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan apply the same idea to other costs.
Common mistakes with a worksheet like this
- Comparing the premium alone. The cheapest premium is the answer only in the lightest year.
- Using the full premium instead of the after-credit price. The credit follows the benchmark plan, so each plan's after-credit price has to come from the account with your income entered.
- Forgetting that copays count toward the out-of-pocket maximum but premiums do not.
- Treating a deductible as if it applies to every service. Read the benefit table to see which services sit behind it.
- Skipping the family version. For a household, tally the care of each person, then check whether the deductible is embedded or aggregate.
- Assuming the notice is complete. The notice shows the plan it proposes, not the alternatives; the account lists those.
What to do with the result
Write the figures in the account's notes or on paper, and save the decision. If you decide to switch, pick the new plan in the marketplace account before the deadline for the start date you want. On HealthCare.gov, choices made by December 15 start on January 1, and later choices through the end of the window start a month later. If you decide to stay, confirm it, and keep the worksheet for next year, when the same exercise is quicker.
A navigator or licensed broker can check the entries with you, and the health plan comparison calculator automates the arithmetic. The guide how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs covers the surrounding steps.
Key takeaways
- Run the must-pass filter first: doctors, hospital and drugs. A cheaper plan that does not cover your care is not cheaper.
- Compare total yearly cost in three kinds of year: premiums plus copays plus deductible and coinsurance, and the out-of-pocket maximum for the worst case.
- In the example, the lower-premium plan saves $510 in a light year but costs $835 more in an expected year with a procedure.
- Use the premium after credit with your own income, and use the cost-sharing-reduction silver variant shown for your income.
- Switch when the renewed plan fails the filter or the savings in your expected year clearly outweigh the disruption.