Blog

My card names an insurer but my employer pays the claims. What does that mean?

Three hypothetical households with the same insurer logo on the card and different funding show who pays, who decides an appeal and who to call.

Three coworkers at three different companies each hold a card with the same insurer's logo. They use the same network, the same member website and the same toll-free number. Yet behind those cards, the arrangements are different. At one company the insurer takes the financial risk. At another the employer pays every claim from its own funds and rents the insurer's name and network. At a third the employer pays a fixed monthly amount and settles up at year end.

For everyday care the difference is nearly invisible. It matters when something goes wrong: a claim is denied, a bill looks wrong, a complaint needs a home. This post uses three invented households to show who pays, who decides an appeal and who to call in each case. The names and numbers are made up and rounded, and the details of real arrangements vary by contract.

The guide on self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you defines the two main funding models. This post shows them in action.

One plan design, one claim, three funding models

To keep the comparison fair, imagine all three households have the same plan design:

  • Deductible: $2,000.
  • Coinsurance after the deductible: 20%.
  • Out-of-pocket maximum: $6,000.

Each household has the same event: a planned outpatient procedure for which the plan's allowed amount is $12,000, and no earlier claims this year.

The member's share: the first $2,000 is the deductible. The remaining $12,000 − $2,000 = $10,000 is subject to 20% coinsurance, so the member pays 20% × $10,000 = $2,000. The member's total is $2,000 + $2,000 = $4,000, which is below the $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum. The plan pays $12,000 − $4,000 = $8,000.

The member's $4,000 is the same in all three households. What differs is whose money makes up the $8,000.

Household 1: The Garcias, fully insured

The Garcias' employer has a group policy with the insurer. The employer pays a monthly premium to the insurer for each enrolled employee, and the employees pay their share of it through payroll deductions. This is a fully insured plan.

Who pays the $8,000. The insurer, from the premiums it collected from the employer and from other groups. If the company's employees use far more care than expected, the insurer absorbs the loss in that year and raises the group's price at renewal.

Who decides an appeal. The insurer decides the internal appeal, a step described in internal appeal. If it upholds the denial, the Garcias can ask for an external review, which in a fully insured plan generally runs through a process set by the state, with reviewers independent of the insurer.

Who regulates it. The state insurance department supervises the insurer and takes complaints about how it handled a claim. State benefit mandates, which are requirements that insured plans cover certain services, generally apply to the policy.

Who the Garcias call. For a claim question, the number on the card. For an unresolved dispute, the insurer's appeals unit and then the state's complaint and external review process. HR can help with enrollment and eligibility but does not decide claims.

Household 2: The Okafors, self-funded with a third-party administrator

The Okafors' employer pays employees' claims directly from its own funds. It hires an administrator, called a third-party administrator (TPA), to process claims and run the network. The administrator is an insurer here, which is why the logo is on the card, but it is acting as a service company and not as the risk bearer. This arrangement is also called administrative services only, or ASO. The plan is a self-funded plan.

Who pays the $8,000. The employer, from its own money. The administrator checks the claim, applies the plan's rules and tells the employer's account to release payment. The employer usually also holds stop-loss insurance, a policy that reimburses the employer when claims, in total or for one person, pass a set limit. Stop-loss protects the employer's budget. It does not change what the Okafors owe. See why stop-loss insurance quietly shapes my self-funded employer plan for how it can shape the plan in the background.

Who decides an appeal. The plan itself decides, usually through a named plan administrator or committee at the employer, which often delegates the first review to the TPA. The denial notice should say where to send an appeal and by when. If the internal appeal fails, a federal external review process generally applies to plans of this type, and the notice should describe it.

Who regulates it. A federal agency, the Department of Labor, oversees most private employer plans, and state insurance departments generally do not regulate self-funded plans. State benefit mandates generally do not apply, though federal rules do. The post Who do I complain to when my self-funded plan wrongly denies a claim? explains where complaints go.

Who the Okafors call. The number on the card for claims. For a dispute, the appeal address on the denial letter, and HR for who the plan administrator is. If a complaint is needed, the federal agency rather than the state. Because the employer is the one paying, the Okafors may feel awkward about pushing a dispute. The rules give them the same appeal rights, and a benefits advisor or a lawyer who handles employer plan claims can advise on a specific case.

Household 3: The Nguyens, level-funded

The Nguyens' employer is a small company. It uses a level-funded plan, which is a form of self-funding designed to look like insurance. The employer pays a fixed amount each month, and that amount is divided into three parts: money set aside for claims, the administrator's fee and stop-loss coverage.

Say the employer pays $50,000 a month for the whole group, divided as:

  • $35,000 for the claims fund.
  • $8,000 for administration.
  • $7,000 for stop-loss coverage.

Check: $35,000 + $8,000 + $7,000 = $50,000. Over a year the claims fund receives 12 × $35,000 = $420,000.

Who pays the $8,000. The claims fund, which holds the employer's money. If this procedure is the Nguyens' only claim of the month and others are small, the fund covers it easily. If the whole group's claims for the year total $380,000, then $420,000 − $380,000 = $40,000 is left, and under some contracts part or all of that comes back to the employer as a refund. Under other contracts it does not. If claims run much higher than $420,000, the stop-loss coverage is designed to cover the excess above limits the contract sets. These terms differ between products, so the employer's contract is the source.

Who decides an appeal. As with the Okafors, the plan decides, through the plan administrator and the administrator's claims unit, with a federal external review available afterward for covered plans.

Who regulates it. In general, the same as the Okafors' arrangement: the federal Department of Labor and not the state insurance department, with some details depending on the product and the state.

Who the Nguyens call. The number on the card, and HR for the plan administrator's name. A useful extra question for HR is whether the plan is treated as self-funded for appeals and complaints, since the marketing of level-funded plans can sound like insurance.

Side by side

Garcias (fully insured) Okafors (self-funded with TPA) Nguyens (level-funded)
Member's share of the $12,000 claim $4,000 $4,000 $4,000
Whose money pays the other $8,000 Insurer Employer Employer's claims fund
Who bears the risk of high claims Insurer Employer, backed by stop-loss Employer, with stop-loss and a fixed monthly payment
Who decides the internal appeal Insurer Plan administrator, often via the TPA Plan administrator, often via the TPA
Independent external review Usually the state process Federal process for covered plans Federal process for covered plans
Complaint agency State insurance department U.S. Department of Labor U.S. Department of Labor
State benefit mandates Generally apply Generally do not Generally do not

Every row of the table is a general pattern, and your plan's documents control. In every case, the federal protections that apply to employer plans still apply, such as the rules on pre-existing conditions and the protections against many surprise bills.

What stays the same in all three households

The differences above are about money and oversight, and it is just as important to see what does not differ.

  • Your cost sharing. The deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum come from the plan design, so the $4,000 in the example is the same in each household. Whether the employer or an insurer carries the risk does not change it.
  • The network and its discounts. A self-funded employer renting an insurer's network gets the same negotiated rates the insurer's other members get, so the allowed amount can be identical.
  • Your explanation of benefits. All three households receive the same kind of statement, showing the billed amount, the allowed amount, what the plan paid and what the member owes. The guide on how to read an explanation of benefits works for any of them.
  • Many federal protections. The rules against pre-existing condition exclusions, the limits on annual and lifetime dollar caps for essential benefits and the surprise-billing protections apply to both fully insured and self-funded plans, with some exceptions for grandfathered or non-covered plan types.

Other variations on the card

Real life adds twists. Here are three you may run into.

  • Two names on the card. One name may be the network (the doctors and hospitals) and another the claims administrator. The pharmacy benefit may be a third name. This is common in self-funded plans, which assemble services from several companies. Ask HR which company decides appeals for medical claims and which for drugs.
  • A fully insured plan with a rented network. Some insurers use another company's provider network. The financial risk still sits with the insurer on the policy.
  • A change at renewal. An employer can move from fully insured to self-funded, or the other way, with no change in the logo on the card. If your plan switches, the rules for appeals and complaints can change with it, and the employer's notices should say so.

If a bill ever seems to be handled by a company different from the one on your card, the explanation of benefits usually names who processed the claim. That name is the starting point for a question.

The same denial in three households

To see the difference in practice, suppose each household gets a denial for the same $9,000 course of treatment, with the notice saying it was not medically necessary.

  1. The Garcias read the denial letter, which lists the insurer's appeal deadline and cites state rights. They file an internal appeal with a letter from their doctor. If denied again, they request external review through the state process, and they can also file a complaint with the state insurance department.
  2. The Okafors read the denial letter, which names the plan administrator's appeal address. They file with the same doctor's letter. If denied again, they request the federal external review described in the notice, and if the plan seems to have broken its own rules, they may contact the federal agency that oversees employer plans.
  3. The Nguyens do the same as the Okafors, and they also ask HR to confirm, in writing, how the plan is structured so that they send any complaint to the right place.

The steps are alike. What changes is the address on the envelope and the agency that can step in. The guide on how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step describes the common steps, and the question of how to find out which model you have is covered in How can I tell whether my employer's health plan is self-funded?.

Questions worth asking at work

  • Is our plan fully insured, self-funded or level-funded?
  • If I appeal, who makes the decision, and is there anyone outside the company who can review it?
  • Which agency do I contact with a complaint?
  • Where can I read the plan document?

You are entitled to ask, and the answers affect how you handle a dispute. For individual questions, a benefits advisor, a lawyer who handles employer plan claims or, for a fully insured plan, the state insurance department can look at the documents.

Key takeaways

  • The insurer's logo on your card does not tell you whose money pays the claim. The member's share of a given claim is the same either way.
  • In a fully insured plan the insurer pays and decides appeals under state oversight. In a self-funded plan the employer pays, usually with an administrator processing claims, under federal oversight.
  • A level-funded plan is a self-funded design with a fixed monthly payment, a claims fund and stop-loss coverage, and it is usually handled like a self-funded plan for appeals and complaints.
  • Stop-loss insurance protects the employer's budget and does not change what you owe.
  • Ask HR which model you have, in writing, before you need to file an appeal.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic