Blog

My child lives with the other parent out of state. What plan covers both homes?

Eleven questions for a parent covering a child across state lines: network types, urgent care, out-of-area rules, and when the other parent's plan fits better.

Say Jordan lives in Ohio and shares custody of a nine-year-old with a former partner in Arizona. The child spends the school year in Arizona and most of the summer in Ohio. Jordan's employer offers three plans, and the cheapest is a local health maintenance organization built around doctors in Jordan's home county. Does it cover a child who is almost never in that county? Usually only for emergencies, and that gap is the heart of this problem.

A plan has to work where the child actually lives and where the child spends meaningful time. This post answers the questions parents in that position most often ask, in the order they tend to come up. Plan rules vary by employer, insurer and state, so the plan documents and the plan's member services line are the authority on any individual answer.

How a plan defines where it works

Why does the plan's service area matter so much for a child who lives far away?

Most plans are sold for a defined geographic territory, called a service area. The plan contracts with doctors and hospitals inside that territory and agrees to pay them negotiated rates. A child who lives outside the service area is not automatically excluded from coverage, but the plan's contracted doctors may be hundreds of miles from where the child needs care.

For a HMO, that distance is the whole story. The plan generally pays only for care from its own network, outside of emergencies, so a child in another state may have almost no usable doctors. The next three questions look at what the different network designs do about that.

Network types and the provider directory

Does it matter whether the plan is an HMO, EPO, PPO or POS?

Yes, more than almost any other plan feature. The short version, which HMO vs PPO vs EPO vs POS: how the four plan types differ explains in detail:

  • HMO: the plan pays for in-network care only, plus emergencies. Usually requires a primary care doctor chosen inside the service area and often referrals for specialists. Typically the worst fit for a child living out of the area.
  • EPO: same in-network-only rule, usually without the referral requirement. Same problem.
  • PPO: pays for in-network care at the lowest cost and for out-of-network care at a higher cost, so care at the other parent's home is usually possible, with a bill that depends on the plan. Many PPOs also contract with a national or multi-state network, which can put in-network doctors near both homes.
  • POS (point of service): a hybrid. Some in-network-only, some out-of-network coverage, usually with a referral requirement. Read the details.

The label is not a guarantee. Some HMOs have guest-member or visitor arrangements that let an out-of-area member see participating doctors in another region for a limited period, and some PPOs have narrow networks. The summary of benefits and coverage and the provider directory show how a given plan behaves. The health plan type finder can help classify a plan whose label is unclear.

How can I tell whether a PPO has doctors near the other parent's home?

Do not rely on the plan's brand name or on a national map in the brochure. Do the search the way the child would.

  1. Open the plan's provider directory, and select the plan name exactly as it appears on your card or enrollment screen, since one insurer may have several networks.
  2. Search by the ZIP code where the child lives most of the year. Look for a pediatrician or family doctor, an urgent care center, the nearest hospital with a children's unit and a pharmacy.
  3. Call two of the offices to confirm that they accept the plan and are taking new patients. Directories are sometimes wrong. A directory that lists a doctor who no longer takes the plan is known as a ghost network problem, and a screenshot of what you searched, with the date, helps if you later dispute a claim.
  4. Ask the plan whether the network at that ZIP code is the same network or a partner network, and whether the cost sharing is the same.

If the directory shows a thin or empty list near the other parent's home, that is the answer, regardless of the plan type.

Urgent care, prescriptions and emergencies in two places

What happens if my child needs care in the other home, and is it covered?

Emergencies are the easy case. Under federal rules, health plans that cover emergency services generally have to cover them without prior authorization and without applying a higher cost-sharing level because the hospital is out of network. The test is the prudent layperson standard: would a person with an average knowledge of health reasonably believe the situation was an emergency? A child with a high fever and trouble breathing at the other parent's home is an emergency anywhere, and the plan covers it as one.

Urgent care that is not an emergency is where plan type matters. A child with an ear infection, a cut that needs stitches or a sprained wrist on a Saturday night is covered in-network by a PPO with doctors nearby, covered at a higher cost by a PPO without them, and often not covered at all by an HMO or EPO outside the service area. Some plans offer telehealth visits that work in any state where the clinician is licensed and the child is physically located, which can be a bridge for minor problems. Ask the plan what it covers and whether there is a visit-by-video benefit.

How do prescriptions work when the child moves between homes?

Most plans use a pharmacy network that includes major national chains, so a prescription filled in either home usually works. The questions are different:

  • Refills too soon. A plan generally limits how early a refill can be filled. If the child's medicine is in one home when the supply runs out in the other, ask the pharmacy and the plan about a "vacation override" or a transfer.
  • Mail order. Some plans require or encourage a 90-day mail-order supply for long-term medicines. That can be sent to either address, but a delivery to a home where nobody picks it up during the school year helps no one.
  • Two sets of everything. A child who needs an inhaler or an auto-injector at both homes may need two prescriptions. Ask the prescriber, and ask the plan whether a second fill within the same period is covered.

Whose plan covers the child?

Which parent's plan should cover the child?

Often the answer is "whichever one works where the child lives," and sometimes both. A few factors decide it:

  • A court order. A divorce decree or a custody or support order may say which parent must provide health insurance. This post cannot say what yours means. A family lawyer in the state that issued the order can. See What should I check about health insurance in my divorce papers before I sign? for questions to take to that meeting.
  • Cost. Compare the child's added premium on each plan. The cost of adding a dependent to an employer plan varies widely, and some employers pay little of the dependent premium.
  • The network near the child. A plan with a strong local network at the home where the child spends nine months of the year may be a better fit than a plan with a lower premium and no doctors nearby.
  • Eligibility rules. Some plans define eligible dependents by custody or residence, others only by the relationship. The plan document states the definition.

A related question is who claims the child as a dependent for tax purposes. That choice affects subsidies and credits, and it follows its own rules. A tax professional can answer it for your situation; this post does not try to.

Can the child have coverage under both parents' plans?

Often yes, and it can solve the two-homes problem. This is called dual coverage, and the two plans coordinate using rules called coordination of benefits. One plan is primary, and pays first. The other is secondary, and may pay some or all of what the first plan left, depending on its own rules. The usual national model rules say that for children of divorced or separated parents, a court order assigning health care responsibility decides which plan is primary, and if there is no such order, the plan of the parent the child lives with generally pays first. For children whose parents live together, a "birthday rule" often applies: the plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year pays first.

Your plan's coordination language controls, and Two health plans? Coordination of benefits decides who pays first explains how it works. Two caveats about dual coverage:

  1. Both plans still have their own networks and rules. A secondary plan does not usually pay for care it would not cover on its own, and an HMO secondary plan may not pay for out-of-network care at all.
  2. The second premium has to be worth what it adds. Ask each plan what it would pay on a sample claim after the other plan pays.

Court orders, the marketplace and Medicaid

What if the other parent has to provide the insurance under a court order?

Some orders require one parent to provide coverage, and an employer plan may be required to enroll a child under a qualifying court or administrative order. That is a legal process with its own paperwork, and a family lawyer or the state agency that handles child support is the right resource, not an insurer. If the order requires the other parent to cover the child under their employer's plan, ask what happens if that plan has no network near the home where the child lives most of the time. An order can be changed, but that is a decision for the court, not for the plan.

If you pay the premium for coverage the order assigns to someone else, or the other parent stops paying, document it and bring it to the lawyer or agency. Nothing in this post tells you how a particular court will treat it.

What if the child gets marketplace or Medicaid coverage in the state where they live?

A parent can sometimes enroll the child through the marketplace in the state where the child lives, which can fit the local network, or through that state's Medicaid or the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) if the household's income qualifies. Medicaid and CHIP are run by states, and they ask where the child lives. The marketplace has its own rules about who is in the tax household, which parent claims the child and when a move opens a special enrollment period. health insurance when moving states: what carries over and what does not and health insurance after divorce: your options and the deadlines cover the outline. A navigator or a licensed broker can tell you what applies to your household.

Before the school year starts

What should I do before school starts or the child moves?

A short list, in order:

  1. Get the current plan documents for every plan that could cover the child, with the service area, the network and the out-of-area language.
  2. Search each provider directory by the ZIP code for each home. Print or save the results.
  3. Ask the plan these questions: Is the child covered for non-emergency care at the other parent's address? Does the plan have a program for dependents who live away? Is there a telehealth benefit?
  4. Check whether an enrollment change needs a qualifying life event. A move, a divorce or a new court order is often one, with a deadline measured in days or weeks. Missing it can mean waiting for open enrollment.
  5. Put a copy of the insurance card, the group and member numbers and the plan's phone number with the other parent, and agree in writing on who calls whom for authorization.

Keep both parents on the same page about the plan. A dispute over a claim is much harder to settle when only one parent has the card.

Who answers the question for your situation

Who should I ask about my own situation?

Several people, each for a different part:

  • The plan's member services answers questions about the service area, the network and coverage at the other address.
  • Your employer's benefits office can tell you about dependent eligibility and the open enrollment window.
  • A navigator or licensed broker can compare marketplace options in the state where the child lives.
  • A family lawyer interprets the order and any obligation to provide coverage.
  • The state insurance department takes complaints if a plan will not explain or honor its terms.

For the broader question of what happens to coverage after a divorce, see after a divorce, who covers the kids' health insurance and how does it work?.

Key takeaways

  • A child's plan has to work where the child spends most of the time: an HMO or EPO built around one county is usually a poor fit for a child living in another state, apart from emergencies.
  • A PPO with a national or multi-state network is the most flexible design, but confirm by searching the provider directory with the ZIP code of each home, not by trusting the label.
  • Emergencies are covered anywhere; the differences show up in urgent care, routine visits, specialists and prescriptions.
  • Dual coverage under both parents' plans is possible, with one plan primary, and a court order usually decides which, so ask a family lawyer for the order and the plans for a sample claim.
  • Check enrollment deadlines when a move or a new order changes who covers the child, because the window to switch is often short.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic