Blog

After a divorce, who covers the kids' health insurance and how does it work?

Three hypothetical divorced households show how orders, plan rules, a second plan and Medicaid or CHIP decide whose coverage the kids use and what it costs.

Two things decide a child's coverage after a divorce: what the court order says and what each parent's plan allows. They do not always agree, and when they do not, the plan wins on the question of who is covered while the order wins on the question of who must pay for it. A child can end up on one parent's plan, on both, or on public coverage, and each choice has a cost that is easy to compute once you know the rules.

This post works three labeled hypothetical households through those rules. The names and dollar amounts are invented round numbers. The rules they illustrate are the common ones, and your plan documents, your court order and your state decide the specifics.

The rules that apply to every case

The child stays eligible. Federal rules require a plan that covers children to cover a child until age 26. A divorce does not take a child off a parent's plan, and the child's eligibility does not depend on which parent has custody. The guide on Health insurance options for children: employer, CHIP and marketplace lays out the routes for children of any age.

The order sets the duty, the plan sets the mechanics. A divorce decree or child support order commonly says which parent must provide health coverage and how the cost is shared. States set their own formulas. In many, the cost of the child's portion of the premium is counted in the child support calculation, and some orders use "cash medical support" instead of coverage when affordable insurance is not available. A family-law attorney or the state child support agency can say how your state does it.

A qualified medical child support order lets the plan be told what to do. If a parent does not enroll the child as the order requires, the other parent or the child support agency can send the employer plan a medical child support order. When the plan administrator decides it meets federal requirements, the order is called a qualified medical child support order, or QMCSO. The plan must then enroll the child, even outside the usual enrollment window, and in many cases the employer begins deducting the premium from the paycheck of the parent named in the order. If the parent is not enrolled, the plan may have to enroll the parent as well so the child can be covered. A plan generally cannot refuse to enroll a child covered by a qualified order because the child lives with the other parent, though the network may still not reach where the child lives. The plan's claims paperwork also generally lets the custodial parent file claims and receive payment directly.

Two plans have a payment order. When a child is on both parents' plans, one plan pays first and the other pays what is left, by a process called coordination of benefits. Insurers generally follow a common order: if a court order makes one parent responsible for the child's medical costs, that parent's plan pays first. Without such an order, the plan of the parent the child lives with usually pays first, then a stepparent's plan, then the other parent's. For parents who are not divorced, the plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year is usually first. The post on my child is on both my plan and my spouse's, so which plan pays first? covers the birthday rule in detail.

Case 1: both parents have job coverage

Say Dana and Sam divorce, and their daughter Maya, 9, lives mostly with Dana. Both parents have employer plans. Adding a child to Dana's plan costs $180 per month more than employee-only coverage, and to Sam's plan, $210 per month more. The decree says Dana covers Maya and Sam sends Dana $100 each month toward the premium.

The decree does not forbid Sam from keeping Maya on his plan too, and a human-resources form he signed last year left her on it. So Maya has two plans. Here is what that looks like in a year.

One claim, two plans. Maya has an emergency room visit for a broken wrist. The allowed amount, the price the plans agree to, is $2,000.

  1. Dana's plan is primary, since Maya lives with Dana and the decree makes Dana responsible. Say its rules are a $500 deductible and 20% coinsurance, and the deductible has not been met. Maya's share under Dana's plan is $500 plus 20% of the remaining $1,500, which is $500 plus $300, or $800. Dana's plan pays $1,200.
  2. Sam's plan is secondary. Suppose it has a $1,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance. If it were primary it would leave Maya with $1,000 plus 20% of $1,000, which is $1,200, so it would pay $800.
  3. Under a traditional coordination rule, the secondary plan pays the lesser of what it would have paid ($800) and what remains of the bill ($800). The family owes $0.
  4. Under a "non-duplication" rule, the secondary plan pays only the amount by which its normal benefit exceeds what the primary plan already paid. Its normal benefit is $800 and the primary paid $1,200, so it pays nothing and the family still owes $800.

The plan's coordination-of-benefits clause says which rule applies, and the plan can tell you which it uses.

Is the second plan worth the premium? Sam's premium for the extra coverage is $210 per month, which is $210 times 12, or $2,520 per year. Say Dana's plan alone leaves Maya owing $800 for the year, all of it from the wrist. The second plan could save at most that $800, which is less than it costs. The second plan could be worth keeping if Maya has a condition that creates thousands of dollars of costs every year, but for a typically healthy child it is a net loss. Some families keep a secondary plan for a specific reason, such as a specialist who is in one plan's network and not the other's.

What to do. Decide on purpose whether Maya will be on one plan or two. If one, tell Sam's HR office to drop her at the next permitted time and confirm that the decree is satisfied. If two, keep the plan information current, because each insurer sends a coordination questionnaire to learn about other coverage, and claims can be held until it is answered.

Case 2: one parent has coverage, the other does not

Say Priya and Marcus divorce, and their son Eli, 6, lives with Priya. Priya works part-time and has no employer coverage. Marcus has a plan at work: employee-only coverage costs $200 per month, and employee-plus-child coverage costs $380. The decree orders Marcus to provide health coverage for Eli.

The added cost of Eli's coverage is $380 minus $200, which is $180 per month, or $2,160 per year. Some of that cost may be treated as part of the child support calculation, depending on the state.

Three things deserve attention.

  1. Does the plan reach Eli? If Marcus's plan has a network only in the county where Marcus works, and Eli lives two hours away, the coverage exists on paper but may be useless for routine care. The post on My child lives with the other parent out of state. What plan covers both homes? covers what to ask when a child lives in another state. Within the same state the same question comes up for a plan with a narrow local network. Ask for the provider directory and check Eli's pediatrician.
  2. Is Marcus doing what the order says? If he does not enroll Eli, Priya or the child support agency can send the plan a medical child support order. The plan administrator reviews it and, if it qualifies, enrolls Eli and begins collecting the premium.
  3. What does Priya need? Priya has no coverage. She may qualify for marketplace coverage or Medicaid on her own income, and her own plan does not depend on Eli's. If she buys a marketplace plan, the premium tax credit depends on her tax household, and the parent who claims Eli as a dependent is generally the one whose return carries him. The decree should settle who claims Eli, because it affects Priya's credit.

If the cost of Marcus's coverage is a hardship for him, the order can be modified, but only by the court. An agreement between the parents that is not in the order does not bind the plan.

Case 3: the child qualifies for Medicaid or CHIP

Say Lena and Omar divorce, and their twins, 5, live with Lena, who earns about $30,000 a year. Omar's job has no family coverage. In many states a household with a parent and two children at this income can qualify the children for Medicaid or CHIP, although the income limit for children varies by state, so the figure that applies to Lena comes from her state agency, not from this post. The guide on CHIP explained: low-cost health coverage for children describes how the program works.

Four rules matter for a divorced household:

  • Whose income counts. Medicaid and CHIP look at the income of the household the child lives in, using the tax-based rules for counting income. Child support received is generally not counted as income for that purpose, and alimony under a decree made after 2018 is generally not counted either. The state agency applies the household rules to your facts, including which parent claims the child.
  • Public coverage can be secondary. If a child has both private insurance and Medicaid, the private plan pays first and Medicaid pays what it covers of the rest. That can be helpful for a child with a private plan that leaves large copays, and the post on Can I have Medicaid and private insurance at the same time? explains the combination. CHIP rules differ by state, and some states do not allow it alongside other coverage.
  • The order may still require coverage. A decree that says Omar must provide health insurance does not go away because the children have Medicaid. Many states allow the order to be changed to cash medical support, which makes Omar pay a set amount toward the children's costs, or to name the public program. Lena should ask the child support agency and the family-law attorney, not decide on her own.
  • Coverage follows the child's home. Medicaid and CHIP are run by states. A child who moves to another state with the other parent must apply there. The children's coverage in Lena's state does not follow them.

The primary plan question in one place

When a child is on two plans, this is the usual order:

Situation Plan that pays first
A court order makes one parent responsible for medical costs That parent's plan
Divorced or separated, no such order The plan of the parent with custody, then the custodial parent's spouse, then the other parent
Parents not divorced or separated The plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year
A parent who has the child through an employer plan and a child who also has Medicaid or CHIP The private plan pays first; public coverage is generally last

The plan's coordination-of-benefits provision confirms the rule. The glossary entry on dependent coverage to age 26 explains why age alone does not change the picture.

Ways to avoid paying twice

  1. Decide the structure first. Choose one plan for each child unless there is a clear reason for two, and write it into the decree.
  2. Check the end date of any old plan. A child dropped from a plan in the decree may stay on it until the employer processes the change, and premium may still come out of a paycheck.
  3. Keep a copy of the cards. Each parent should have an identification card for each plan the child is on, and should know which is primary.
  4. Answer insurer questionnaires. A coordination questionnaire left unanswered can delay payment of claims.
  5. Review each year at open enrollment. A change in a parent's job, a move or a child's new condition can change the best structure.

Key takeaways

  • A child stays eligible on a parent's plan to age 26 whatever the custody arrangement. The court order decides who must provide and pay for coverage, and the plan decides how it works.
  • A qualified medical child support order can force a plan to enroll a child, and it is the usual tool when a parent ignores a coverage requirement.
  • With two plans, the primary plan is set by the order, then by custody, then by the birthday rule. A second plan helps only if the secondary plan pays what is left, and that depends on its coordination rule, so compare its premium with what it would actually save.
  • A child who qualifies for Medicaid or CHIP may still be subject to a coverage requirement in the decree, and the order may need to be changed to match.
  • A child who lives in another state may need a different plan or public coverage there, and the network on a parent's plan may not reach that far.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic