Blog

What happens if I do nothing at Medicare open enrollment?

Seven things that go wrong when a Medicare plan renews on autopilot, what each can cost, and a ten-minute review that catches most of them.

If you do nothing during the Annual Enrollment Period, which runs October 15 to December 7, your Medicare Advantage or drug plan renews for January 1 on whatever terms it has published for next year. That is a perfectly good outcome when the terms are fine, and an expensive one when they are not. The difficulty is that doing nothing does not tell you which of the two you got. The terms are in a notice you may not have opened.

This post goes through the ways autopilot goes wrong, with what each can cost, and finishes with a ten-minute minimum review for people who do not want to spend a weekend on it. The examples are invented, with round numbers. They show how the rules work, not what any plan charges.

What "nothing" actually does

When you take no action, three things happen by default.

  • Your plan renews on its new terms. Premiums, deductibles, copays, the drug list, the network and the yearly limit are all set again each year. The plan's Annual Notice of Change lists the differences, and by renewing you accept them.
  • You are locked in for the year, with exceptions. After December 7 you generally cannot switch plans until the next enrollment period. People in Advantage plans have one change available from January 1 to March 31, and certain events open special enrollment periods, but there is no general right to change in the middle of the year.
  • If your plan is ending, you do not roll over to a similar plan automatically. Sometimes an organization moves members to another of its plans, and the notice will say so. In other cases a plan simply ends, and you are left with Original Medicare, with no drug coverage unless you chose a drug plan.

Doing nothing is a choice with consequences like any other. The sections below take seven of them in turn.

Mistake 1: assuming the cost will be the same

How it happens. Plans reset their premiums and cost sharing every year. A plan you picked because it was inexpensive can raise its premium, add a deductible, or raise copays and still be a valid plan.

What it costs. Say a drug plan charges $20 a month this year and $45 next year. That is $25 more a month, or $300 more over the year, for exactly the same coverage. Say an Advantage plan's specialist copay moves from $40 to $60 and you see a specialist five times: that is $100. Neither of these is catastrophic, which is part of why people ignore them. Together with a new deductible they can add up to a larger sum.

For context, KFF reported in October 2026 that the average premium for stand-alone drug plans was projected to rise from about $34 to about $51 in 2027 if everyone stayed where they were, and that it expected the real increase to be smaller because many people would switch. The Part D premium stabilization demonstration, a federal program that had limited premium increases, ends after 2026. So for stand-alone drug plan members, doing nothing is riskier this year than it was in some recent years. That is a statement about averages, and your own plan's increase could be larger or smaller, which is why you check.

How to avoid it. Read the premium and cost-sharing lines in the Annual Notice of Change and multiply the differences by how often you use each service. The post How to read the Annual Notice of Change: seven lines that change my costs shows how.

Mistake 2: assuming your drugs stay covered at the same price

How it happens. The formulary, the list of covered drugs, changes each year. A drug can move to a higher formulary tier, pick up a rule such as prior authorization or step therapy, or leave the list. Your pharmacy can also move out of the plan's preferred network.

What it costs. Say Dale takes a brand drug every month with a plan price of $400. This year it is on tier 2 with a $15 copay. Next year it moves to tier 4 with 30% coinsurance. His monthly cost becomes 30% of $400, which is $120. The change is $120 minus $15, or $105 a month, and 12 months of that is $1,260. If a deductible applies to tier 4 next year, January costs even more. The change would not have shown up in the premium at all.

The drug benefit has a ceiling, which limits the worst case. For 2027 the Part D standard benefit has a cap of $2,400 on yearly out-of-pocket drug costs, and a deductible of up to $700 (as of November 2026, from CMS's rate announcement). A ceiling of $2,400 is still a great deal of money, and for someone whose costs would otherwise have been $180 a year, an expensive surprise.

How to avoid it. Look up each drug in the plan's new formulary before December 7. If a drug is off the list or in a worse tier, ask the prescriber whether a different medicine would work, or consider another plan. If you stay, ask about a formulary exception. See Medicare Part D explained: drug plans, formularies and costs.

Mistake 3: assuming your doctor or hospital stays in network

How it happens. Networks change at the end of a year when contracts end. An Advantage plan can drop a hospital system or a medical group, and doctors can leave a plan. The notice may not name them.

What it costs. In an HMO, a doctor who is no longer in network may mean you pay the full cost of non-emergency visits, or you have to change doctors in the middle of care. In a PPO you pay more. Either way, the cost is not only money. A person with a long relationship with a cardiologist or an oncologist can lose continuity.

How to avoid it. In the fall, call the offices you rely on and ask whether they will accept your plan next year. Do not rely on a directory alone. A free SHIP counselor can help if the office's answer is unclear.

Mistake 4: not noticing the plan is ending

How it happens. Plans leave counties, and companies exit the market. KFF reported in the fall of 2026 that the average beneficiary has 28 Advantage plans with drug coverage to choose from in 2027, down from 32 the year before, and counted about 4.3 million people whose Advantage or stand-alone drug plan would be terminated at the end of 2026. Those are as-of-November-2026 figures, and the plan list can still change in your county.

What it costs. If a stand-alone drug plan ends and you do nothing, you may have no drug coverage on January 1. A gap of 63 days or more without creditable drug coverage after you were first eligible can trigger a late-enrollment penalty of 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full month, for as long as you have drug coverage. As of November 2026 that base premium is $38.99 for 2026 and $41.33 for 2027, so each month of delay adds roughly 41 cents to a monthly premium for life, by the arithmetic of the rule. A small number, but permanent. If an Advantage plan ends and you do nothing, you will be in Original Medicare. That might be fine, but you will want drug coverage and perhaps Medigap, and Medigap is not always available without health questions. A plan that terminates gives some people special rights to buy Medigap with no health questions for a limited time, so find out whether you have them.

How to avoid it. Look for a separate letter titled something like "non-renewal" or "plan termination," usually by early October. If you have one, you must choose a new plan. A SHIP counselor can tell you whether you have Medigap rights.

Mistake 5: "it worked last year"

How it happens. A plan that fits last year's health and habits may not fit next year's. Over a year a person can start a new medicine, have a surgery, develop a condition, move, or lose a doctor. The plan renews anyway.

What it costs. Say a plan has a $0 premium and a $6,000 in-network limit. A person who had two doctor visits all year was well served by it. After a diagnosis that will bring regular infusions or specialist visits, the same plan means year-round copays, and possibly a network that does not include the treatment center. The plan did not change, but the match did.

How to avoid it. At the notice, ask one question first: what do I expect next year that I did not have this year? A new prescription, a planned surgery or a regular treatment is a reason to reread the plan with that in mind. If you expect heavy care, the Medigap question comes into it, discussed in I may need chemotherapy or dialysis next year. Stay in Advantage or switch?.

Mistake 6: counting on fixing it in the spring

How it happens. People assume they can change plans when they see the first bill. After December 7 the general window is closed.

What it costs. Time on a plan that does not fit. A person in an Advantage plan has the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31, and can make one change, either to another Advantage plan or to Original Medicare with a stand-alone drug plan. That window does not let a person who is in Original Medicare join an Advantage plan, and it does not let anyone buy Medigap if the insurer is allowed to ask health questions. People in Original Medicare with a stand-alone drug plan generally have no window at all in the first quarter. The other options are special enrollment periods that depend on events such as a move or a plan ending.

How to avoid it. Treat December 7 as the deadline for changing a plan for the whole year, not as the first of several chances.

Mistake 7: not reading the mail, then not confirming

How it happens. The notices arrive as thick envelopes or long emails and look like marketing. Some people discard them, and some respond to the phone calls that follow.

What it costs. The notice is where your plan tells you what is changing. Missing it means missing the dates and the choices. Also, anyone who does choose a new plan and does not confirm it in January can find that the pharmacy has no record of the new coverage, or that the plan they thought they joined never started. See A six-week plan for Medicare's Annual Enrollment Period, notice to confirmation for the confirmation checks.

How to avoid it. Put a recurring reminder in your calendar for the last week of September. Open the notice that week.

A ten-minute minimum review

If you will not do a full comparison, do this. It takes about ten minutes and catches most of the problems above.

  1. Two minutes: the summary table. Find the monthly premium, the yearly limit (for an Advantage plan), the drug deductible and the copays for the services you use most. Note any number that went up by more than about $10 a month or $100 a year.
  2. Three minutes: your drugs. Look up each medicine on next year's formulary, in the notice or on the plan's website. Write the tier and any new rule next to each. Check that your pharmacy is still in the network.
  3. Three minutes: your doctors. Call or search for your primary care doctor, your most important specialist and your hospital. Ask whether they accept your plan in 2027.
  4. Two minutes: decide. If nothing important changed, let the plan renew and write the date in your calendar to confirm in January. If something important changed, compare other plans before December 7, with a SHIP counselor's help if you can.

The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: October 15 to December 7 guide gives the dates. The review is a minimum, not a substitute for comparing plans every few years, since the plans available to you change.

Key takeaways

  • Doing nothing renews your plan on next year's terms. That is fine if you checked them and costly if you did not.
  • Premiums, drug tiers, networks and the plan's existence all change from year to year, and a notice does not always name the doctor who is leaving.
  • After December 7, switching in the middle of the year is possible only in narrow situations, and a person in Original Medicare generally has no first-quarter window.
  • A plan that ends can leave you without drug coverage on January 1, and a gap of 63 days or more can carry a lifelong penalty.
  • A ten-minute review of the summary table, your drugs and your doctors catches most problems.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic