Blog

A six-week plan for Medicare's Annual Enrollment Period, notice to confirmation

A week-by-week schedule from the Annual Notice of Change in late September through October 15 and December 7 to the January confirmation checks.

Week 1: the envelope arrives. In late September a thick packet from your Medicare plan lands in the mailbox or the inbox. It is the Annual Notice of Change, and it is the starting gun for an enrollment period that runs from October 15 to December 7. If you read it, you have the details of next year's plan. If you do not, the plan renews on the terms inside it.

This post lays the autumn out as six working weeks, with what to read, price, apply for and confirm in each, and then the checks that belong in January. The weeks are numbered rather than dated, so you can begin when your notice arrives. If you are reading this in mid-November, skip to the section on starting late. Dates below are the federal enrollment dates: the Annual Enrollment Period runs October 15 to December 7, and any change you make takes effect on January 1.

Before week 1: gather what you will need

Spend half an hour assembling these, because every later step uses them:

  • Your Medicare card and the plan's member card, so you have the numbers at hand.
  • A current list of every prescription with the exact dose, how often you take it, and the pharmacy you use. Include inhalers, injections and anything you pay for in cash.
  • A list of the doctors, specialists, hospital and any treatment center you use and expect to use, with the office phone numbers.
  • Last year's paperwork: Medicare Summary Notices and your plan's explanation of benefits, or a record of what you paid in copays, coinsurance and prescriptions.
  • A note of anything you expect next year: a planned surgery, a new diagnosis, a move, a long trip.

The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet is a convenient place to keep the doctor and drug lists.

Week 1: read the notice and decide whether to look further

Your plan must send the Annual Notice of Change by the end of September. It lists what is changing in your plan for the coming year, and it comes with the Evidence of Coverage, the full contract. The companion post How to read the Annual Notice of Change: seven lines that change my costs walks through the lines that matter most. This week, read just enough to answer one question: does anything change that affects me?

The lines to find first are the monthly premium, the deductible, the copays for the services you use, your drugs' tiers, the plan's yearly limit on what you pay, and whether your doctors and pharmacy remain in the network. If every line is acceptable, you may still want to compare, but you now know the baseline. If any line is a problem, you have a reason to shop.

Also look for a different kind of letter. If your plan is ending in your county, you will receive a separate notice that it will not renew, typically early in October. That notice means you will have to choose a new plan, because your current one will not exist on January 1. Medicare's 2027 plan landscape, as of November 2026, includes plans leaving: KFF reported that about 4.3 million people would have their Advantage or stand-alone drug plan terminated at the end of 2026. A plan ending also affects your rights to buy a Medigap policy, which the How to leave a Medicare Advantage plan: dates, options and risks guide covers.

Week 2: run the checks on the plan you already have

Before comparing with anything new, test your current plan against next year's rules. Take the doctor and drug lists you made and check them one at a time:

  1. Drugs. Is each drug on next year's formulary? What tier is it in? Is there a new prior authorization, step therapy or quantity limit? If a drug is at a higher tier, multiply the new copay by the number of fills in a year.
  2. Doctors. Call each office and ask whether they will be in the plan's network for the next plan year. Directories are not always current. Ask for the answer to be specific to the plan name and, if the plan has several, the plan ID.
  3. Pharmacy. Check whether your pharmacy is still in the network and whether it is a preferred pharmacy for next year. The same prescription can have a lower copay at a preferred pharmacy.
  4. Premium and limit. Compare to this year's numbers. Write the change in dollars per year.

By the end of this week you will have one of two results. Everything holds, or something changes by an amount you can put in dollars.

Week 3: October 15 opens, and you price the alternatives

The enrollment period begins on October 15. Information for the coming year's plans is generally available on Medicare.gov's Plan Finder by then, and sometimes earlier. This is the week to enter your information and look at alternatives.

Use the Plan Finder as follows. You can use it without logging in, or log in to your Medicare account so that it can load your drug list. Enter each drug and dose, choose your pharmacies, and look at the results for the plans that are available in your ZIP code. For each plan the finder estimates your total yearly cost, premium plus drug costs, and shows the plan's overall star rating, which is a government measure of quality and member experience that has limits. See medicare star ratings. The How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost guide explains the estimate, and a worked example appears in How to compare Part D plans when you take six medications, step by step.

If you have an Advantage plan or are considering one, you will compare more than drugs. Use the plan's Evidence of Coverage to check the copays for your usual services, the hospital copay, the yearly limit, the network type (HMO or PPO) and the plan's approval rules. Treat the extra benefits as an add-on, not the main reason, and ask whether you would really use them.

If you are in Original Medicare with a Medigap policy, the Annual Enrollment Period does not change your Medigap rights. You can compare drug plans freely. You cannot switch Medigap policies without underwriting in most states, except in the situations that give you guaranteed issue. Your Medigap premium may rise at renewal; the insurer's letter will tell you. Reading your renewal notice belongs in this week.

Write down two or three finalists, with their yearly cost estimates and any restriction that needs a doctor's help.

Week 4: verify the finalists

Never choose a plan on the strength of a website estimate alone. This week turns the finalists into facts.

  • Doctor check, again. For each finalist, call the doctor's office that matters most and ask directly whether they accept that plan next year. If you see a specialist regularly, call that office too.
  • Drug restrictions. Look up how to ask your doctor for a prior authorization or an exception if a drug has a rule. If a rule applies, consider whether your prescriber's office is willing to do the paperwork.
  • Plan phone call. Call the plan's member services number from the Evidence of Coverage. Ask two or three questions you cannot answer from the documents, such as whether the plan covers a specific treatment you expect and what its prior-authorization process is. Write down the date and the name of the person you spoke with.
  • A free counselor. If you have not already, book an appointment with a SHIP counselor. SHIP is the State Health Insurance Assistance Program, and its counselors compare plans at no charge. Appointments fill up in November and early December, which is why this is week 4 and not week 6.

Week 5: choose and apply

If your own plan is still your best option, you do nothing and it renews. If a different plan is better, enroll through Medicare.gov, through the plan's own website or by phone with the plan, or with a licensed agent or broker. Agents are paid by the plans they sell and can sell only the plans they represent, so ask which ones. Be careful with unsolicited calls and ads; Medicare plans generally may not call you without your permission.

When you apply, you get a confirmation. Save it. If you apply online, take a screenshot or print the confirmation page. If you apply by phone, write down the date, time, name and any confirmation number. Remember:

  • You may make more than one choice, and the last one counts. If you enroll in plan A on October 20 and plan B on November 30, plan B is the one that starts on January 1.
  • Moving from an Advantage plan to Original Medicare means you also need a stand-alone drug plan, and you may want a Medigap policy. Do not cancel the Advantage plan until you know whether you can get Medigap; see Leaving Medicare Advantage: the checklist for Medigap, drug plan and dates.
  • Do not cancel the old plan. Enrolling in a new plan ends the old one automatically. If you call to cancel with no replacement, you may end up in Original Medicare with no drug coverage.

Applying in week 5 leaves you more than two weeks of margin before the deadline. If a problem comes up with the application, you will have time to fix it.

Week 6: the buffer, and the last day

Week 6 is for the unexpected: a doctor who gives a different answer than the office staff did, a plan that asks for a document, a counselor's appointment that was only available late. December 7 is the last day to make a choice in this window. If you wait until the last day, you will have to deal with a website that may be slow, phone lines that may be busy and no time to fix a mistake.

If you have made your choice by now, use this week to do two things that cost nothing. Tell your doctor's office and pharmacy which plan you chose, so they can update their records. And file the confirmation with your Medicare papers.

The weeks after December 7: confirm in January

A choice on paper is not the same as coverage that works. In late December and early January:

  1. Watch for the plan's welcome packet and member card. A card should arrive before January 1 or shortly after. If nothing arrives by early January, call the plan.
  2. Check your Medicare account. Medicare.gov shows your current plan. Make sure it shows the plan you chose, with the right start date.
  3. Fill a prescription early. The first fill of the year is the test of the pharmacy, the copay and any prior authorization. If a drug is not on the plan's formulary, ask for a temporary transition supply, which many plans offer to new enrollees for a limited period, and begin the exception request at once.
  4. Check the doctors. If you have an appointment in January, confirm the office has your new plan on file before you go.
  5. Review the first statements. Compare copays and coinsurance with what the plan said.

If something is wrong, you have a second chance for some people. From January 1 to March 31, a person already in an Advantage plan can make one change, to another Advantage plan or to Original Medicare, under the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period. The The January to March Advantage window: what you can and cannot change post describes it. People in Original Medicare with a stand-alone drug plan do not have that window, so for them the December checks matter more. In either case, some life events and plan changes open a medicare special enrollment period.

If you are starting late

If you are reading this in mid-November or later, compress the schedule. You can do weeks 1 and 2 in one evening, week 3 on a weekend, and make calls in the following days. The point is the order: read, check what you have, price alternatives, verify, apply, confirm. If you skip the verification calls, you will be guessing about the single thing the website cannot tell you, whether your own doctors accept the plan. And if you do nothing at all, What happens if I do nothing at Medicare open enrollment? describes what happens.

Key takeaways

  • The notice that arrives in late September starts the process: read the premium, deductible, drug tiers, network and limit lines, and test them against your own doctors and drugs.
  • The enrollment period runs October 15 to December 7, and changes take effect January 1. If you make several choices, the last one counts.
  • Verify the plan by calling the doctors' offices and the plan, not only by trusting a website or a directory.
  • A SHIP counselor compares plans at no charge, and appointments fill up as December nears.
  • Confirmation continues into January: the card, the Medicare account, the first prescription fill and the first statements.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic