Blog
Should I use a drug discount card or my insurance at the pharmacy?
A decision list for when a coupon price beats your copay: what to ask, what each choice does to your deductible, and what you give up on records.
The pharmacist tells you the plan price for your prescription is $40. A coupon app on your phone says the same drug is $11 at the same counter. Both can be true, and the cheaper number is not automatically the better deal. The coupon price is lower today, but paying it can change what counts toward your deductible, what your plan knows about your medicines and what you owe later in the year. This post gives you a short list of questions that settle the choice for most prescriptions, a worked example, and the tradeoffs that do not show up in the price.
Why the cash price can be lower than your copay
It looks strange that a plan would charge more than a stranger with a coupon. There are several reasons, and knowing them helps you ask the right question.
- Before the deductible, you pay the plan's negotiated price. On many plans you pay the whole negotiated price of a drug until you meet your deductible. For a generic that price can be higher than what a discount program has negotiated with the same pharmacy.
- The drug may be on a tier with a flat copay that is more than the generic's real cost. A generic drug on a higher tier can cost the plan very little and still carry a $15 or $20 copay.
- A discount program is a separate contract. The coupon company negotiates its own prices with pharmacies, and pharmacies sometimes set a low price for an inexpensive generic to attract customers. That price does not pass through your plan.
The coupon price is generally available only on a cash basis: you pay the pharmacy directly and the claim is not sent to your plan. A discount card is not insurance, and the fake health plans and discount cards: how they differ from insurance explains how the two differ and how to spot programs that overstate what they do.
The decision list
Work down these questions in order. Stop when one gives a clear answer.
- Ask for both prices. Ask the pharmacist to run your insurance and tell you the price, and then to run the coupon or card and tell you the price. The pharmacy can usually do both in a minute. You can only choose between two numbers you have seen. A pharmacy cannot apply both to the same fill, so you are choosing one.
- Is it a generic? If the drug is a brand-name drug, coupons are often not much lower than the plan price, and the plan price may be dramatically lower once you meet your deductible. For brand drugs, insurance is more often the better choice. For an inexpensive generic, the cash price is more likely to win.
- Have you met your deductible? If you have not, you are paying the plan's full negotiated price, and the coupon is more likely to be lower. If you have, you are paying a copay or coinsurance, and the plan price is more likely to be lower.
- Will you reach your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum this year anyway? If other care, such as a planned surgery, a pregnancy or a chronic condition, will push you past the deductible, then money you spend through insurance is not wasted: it counts, and you would have paid it later regardless. If you are unlikely to get anywhere near the deductible, the credit is worth nothing and the cash price is better. The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker shows where you stand.
- Is this a one-time fill or an ongoing one? A single fill is a small decision. A monthly fill is twelve times as large, and the difference between a $40 plan price and an $11 coupon price becomes $348 a year. Check the price again every few months, because both can change.
- Does the purchase need to count toward your out-of-pocket maximum? If you expect to reach your out-of-pocket maximum, every dollar through the plan brings you nearer to the point where covered care is free for the rest of the year. Cash purchases may not count, though that depends on your plan and, in some places, state law. Ask.
- Will the pharmacy still see your other medicines? If you pay cash, the pharmacy may have no record of the drug in your plan history. Pharmacies run safety checks for drug interactions and duplicate therapy using what they have on file. See the section on records below.
- Is there any chance you will need the plan to cover something related? Some drugs need a prior authorization or step therapy record to be on file to keep coverage later. A drug you buy with cash is invisible to that process.
If most answers point toward cash and none point toward insurance, use the coupon. If a few point toward insurance, use the plan. If it is mixed, do the arithmetic in the next section.
A worked example, with invented numbers
Say Priya, 34, has a plan with a $2,000 deductible. She takes one generic drug each month for a long-term condition. These are illustrations, not real prices.
- Plan price while the deductible is unmet: $40 per fill.
- Plan copay after the deductible is met: $10 per fill.
- Coupon price: $11 per fill, any time.
Case one: Priya is healthy otherwise and will not come close to $2,000. Over twelve months:
- Plan: 12 x $40 = $480, all of it counting toward a deductible she will never meet, so the credit is worth nothing.
- Coupon: 12 x $11 = $132.
The coupon saves $480 - $132 = $348.
Case two: Priya has a procedure in March and will meet her $2,000 deductible whatever she does about the drug. Say the procedure's allowed charges are large enough that she pays the whole deductible, and all of it in the first quarter. After that her copay is $10.
- Through the plan: the January, February and March fills cost $40 each, or $120, and that $120 counts toward the deductible. The procedure only has to supply the other $1,880. After March she pays 9 x $10 = $90. Total for the year, drug and deductible together: $2,000 + $90 = $2,090.
- With the coupon: the drug costs 12 x $11 = $132, none of it counts, and the procedure has to supply the full $2,000. Total: $2,000 + $132 = $2,132.
The plan wins by $2,132 - $2,090 = $42. That figure ignores any coinsurance on the procedure after the deductible; counting it would favor the plan a little more, because the drug credit moves $120 of the procedure's cost out of the deductible phase, where she pays all of it, and into the coinsurance phase, where she pays a share.
The two cases come to opposite answers for the same drug and the same prices. What differs is whether she will reach the deductible. That is the question to answer first. A few simple rules come out of this:
- If you will not reach your deductible, the cash price almost always wins on a generic.
- If you will reach it for sure, insurance wins even when the early price looks higher.
- If you are not sure, a middle path is to use the coupon early in the year and switch to the plan once you know you are headed past the deductible.
What you give up on records and safety
Using a discount card can leave the plan with no record of the fill. That has consequences in three places.
Interaction checks. When a pharmacy runs a prescription, the system checks it against drugs on your profile at that pharmacy, and in many cases against claims that went through insurance. A drug filled for cash at a different pharmacy may not appear. If you use several pharmacies, tell each one all of your medicines, including over-the-counter and supplements, and consider filling everything you take regularly in one place.
Your plan's records. Plans use claims history to decide on prior authorization, step therapy and some safety programs. A drug you pay for in cash is not a claim, so the plan will not see it. For a simple generic that is usually fine. For a drug where your plan requires you to try an alternative first, ask your prescriber how to document it.
Your own records. Keep the receipt. A cash purchase is not a claim, so your plan's online statement will not show it. If you use a health savings account, prescribed drugs are generally qualified medical expenses, and the receipt is your proof; see HSA. A tax professional can answer questions about your own situation.
None of these makes cash a bad choice. They are reasons to be deliberate about it.
What if I am on Medicare?
Medicare Part D has its own rules about coupons and cash purchases, and they affect what counts toward its annual out-of-pocket limit. The short version is that discount cards can be used, but the amounts generally do not count toward that limit, and manufacturer coupons are not allowed for drugs paid by federal programs. Can I use a drug coupon or discount card with Medicare Part D? covers it in detail. A State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor can check the numbers for your specific drugs and plan at no cost.
What if the drug is brand-name and expensive?
Discount cards from coupon services rarely do much for a costly brand drug on an insured plan, and a manufacturer copay card is a different product with different rules. If you are in a high-cost situation, the questions change: does the plan have an accumulator, is there a prior authorization, and is there a manufacturer program? For those, see My copay card ran out in the spring and now I owe the deductible. For a generic, when paying cash for a generic beats using my insurance, shows four household cases with the arithmetic.
A quick routine for the pharmacy counter
- Ask for the plan price and the coupon price every time you fill a new drug, and every few months for ongoing ones.
- If the two are within a dollar or two, use the plan, because the claim record and the deductible credit are worth more than the pennies.
- If the coupon is much lower and you will not reach your deductible, use the coupon, keep the receipt, and make sure your pharmacist knows your other medicines.
- If you will reach your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum this year, use the plan.
- Check how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending for a simple way to know where you stand.
Key takeaways
- Ask the pharmacy to run both prices. You can only choose between two numbers you have seen, and a coupon and your insurance cannot be combined on one fill.
- The key question is whether you will reach your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. If you will, money through the plan counts and usually wins; if not, the cash price on a generic often wins.
- With invented numbers, a $40 plan price against an $11 coupon saves $348 over twelve fills when the deductible will never be met, and loses by $42 when it will be met in March.
- Paying cash can leave your plan and some pharmacies without a record of the drug, which matters for interaction checks and for drugs that need prior authorization or step therapy.
- Keep receipts for cash purchases, and ask your plan whether they count toward your deductible, because the answer varies by plan and state.