Blog

My copay card ran out in the spring and now I owe the deductible

Three invented patients on one brand drug show, month by month, why a copay card can stop in spring, what you then owe and how to plan the cash flow.

In January and February the pharmacy never asked for money. The drug maker's copay card covered it, the specialty pharmacy shipped the box, and the patient forgot there was a deductible. In April the pharmacy called with a number that looked like a typo: more than two thousand dollars for one fill. Nothing was wrong with the claim. The card had run out, and the plan's records showed that the patient had paid almost nothing toward the deductible all year.

This post follows three invented patients on the same drug, same plan and same card through a full year, with the arithmetic month by month. The point is not to repeat how accumulators work, which copay accumulators and maximizers: why coupons may not count covers, but to show how the surprise arrives, how large it can be and what a patient can do about cash flow before it does.

All the numbers are round illustrations. They are not real drug prices, plan terms or card limits.

The setup all three patients share

Each patient takes a brand-name specialty drug once a month. Here are the hypothetical terms.

  • The plan's allowed amount for the drug is $4,000 per monthly fill.
  • The plan has a $3,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance after it and a $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum.
  • The drug maker offers a copay card for commercially insured patients that pays the patient's share at the pharmacy, up to an annual limit.

Under these terms, the patient's share for the first fill is the full deductible plus coinsurance on the rest: $3,000 + 20% x ($4,000 - $3,000) = $3,000 + $200 = $3,200. Once the deductible is met, the share is 20% x $4,000 = $800 a month. Once the patient's counted spending reaches $6,000, the share is $0 for the rest of the year.

The differences among the three patients are in two places: whether the plan counts the card's payments toward the deductible and maximum, and how large the card's annual limit is.

Patient 1: no accumulator, and the card never runs out

Patient 1's plan counts card payments like any other payment. The card's annual limit is large enough not to matter.

Month Patient's share Card pays Patient pays Counted toward $6,000 maximum (running)
January $3,200 $3,200 $0 $3,200
February $800 $800 $0 $4,000
March $800 $800 $0 $4,800
April $800 $800 $0 $5,600
May $400 $400 $0 $6,000
June to December $0 $0 $0 $6,000

The card pays $6,000 in total and the patient pays nothing. From June on there is no cost-sharing for the drug at all, because the plan considers the maximum met. This is the experience the card is advertised to deliver.

Patient 2: the plan has an accumulator, and the card hits its limit in March

Patient 2's plan has a copay accumulator. It processes the card's payments at the pharmacy, but does not count them toward the deductible or the out-of-pocket maximum. Only money the patient pays counts. Assume the card has a $9,000 annual limit.

Month Patient's share under the plan Card pays Patient pays Counted toward the plan (running)
January $3,200 $3,200 $0 $0
February $3,200 $3,200 $0 $0
March $3,200 $2,600 (limit reached) $600 $600
April $2,720 $0 $2,720 $3,320
May $800 $0 $800 $4,120
June $800 $0 $800 $4,920
July $800 $0 $800 $5,720
August $280 $0 $280 $6,000
September to December $0 $0 $0 $6,000

Check each step. In January and February nothing counts, so the deductible is unmet and each fill carries a $3,200 share. In March the share is again $3,200, but only $2,600 of the card's $9,000 limit remains ($9,000 - $3,200 - $3,200 = $2,600), so the patient pays the other $600, which counts. In April the patient has $600 counted, so $2,400 of the deductible remains: the share is $2,400 + 20% x ($4,000 - $2,400) = $2,400 + $320 = $2,720. From May the deductible is met, the share is $800, and the running total reaches $6,000 in August with a final share of $280.

The patient pays $600 + $2,720 + $800 + $800 + $800 + $280 = $6,000 in total, which is the full out-of-pocket maximum. The $9,000 the card paid never counted. Patient 1 and Patient 2 take the same drug on the same plan, and one pays $0 for the year while the other pays $6,000.

The shock is in the timing. Two months without a bill, then a $600 request, then a bill of $2,720 in April, then $800 a month through July. A person who expected the card to cover the whole year has not budgeted for a payment of more than $2,000 in one month.

Patient 3: no accumulator, but the card has a lower annual limit

Patient 3's plan counts card payments, so each dollar the card pays moves the patient toward the maximum. The card's annual limit is only $5,000.

Month Patient's share Card pays Patient pays Counted toward $6,000 maximum (running)
January $3,200 $3,200 $0 $3,200
February $800 $800 $0 $4,000
March $800 $800 $0 $4,800
April $800 $200 (limit reached) $600 $5,600
May $400 $0 $400 $6,000
June to December $0 $0 $0 $6,000

The card pays $5,000 ($3,200 + $800 + $800 + $200) and the patient pays $600 + $400 = $1,000. The surprise is smaller, because most of the deductible was credited early. It still arrives in April, though, and a patient who did not know the card had a limit may not have known to expect it.

Why the pharmacy suddenly charges a large amount

The pharmacy is doing the same thing every month: billing the plan, collecting the patient's share, and applying the card to that share. Three things can change what it collects.

  • The card's limit is reached. The pharmacy's system now shows no card balance, and the patient's share is due in full. Whether the limit is per fill, per year or per drug depends on the card's terms.
  • The accumulator keeps the share high. When the plan does not count the card, the patient's share stays at the deductible rate for as long as the card is paying. When the card stops, the patient pays what the plan says is still owed, which is far more than the $800 coinsurance a patient with a normal plan would see.
  • A new plan year resets everything. In January the deductible starts again, and a patient who had a $0 fill in December can face a $3,200 share in January. Some cards also reset their limit in January, and some reset on the anniversary of first use.

If the first notice of any of this is the amount at the counter, it is a surprise. It does not have to be, as the questions below show.

Questions to ask before the first fill of the year

Ask them of the plan, the pharmacy and the card program, and write down the date and the answers.

  1. To the plan: "Does this plan count payments made by a manufacturer copay card toward my deductible and out-of-pocket maximum?" The answer may be different for the deductible and the maximum, and may be different for this drug than for others.
  2. To the plan: "Where do I stand today on my deductible and maximum, counting only what I have paid myself?" The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker can record the answer.
  3. To the card program: "What is the annual limit, is it per fill or per year, and when does it reset?"
  4. To the card program: "What happens if my plan does not count your payments? Do you adjust the amount or provide a different program?" Some manufacturers say they do; ask rather than assume.
  5. To the pharmacy: "Will you tell me before a fill if the card will not cover it, and can I arrange a payment plan if the amount is large?"
  6. To the prescriber's office: "Who handles the forms if I need patient assistance or a plan exception?"

A cash-flow plan for the month the card stops

Run the arithmetic early, in January, so there is time to act.

  1. Estimate when the card runs out. Divide the card's annual limit by what it pays each month. For Patient 2 that is $9,000 / $3,200, which is a little under three fills, so the limit runs out in the third month. For Patient 3 it is $5,000 against a first fill of $3,200 and $800 afterward, which gets to about April.
  2. Estimate the amount the plan will ask for next. Under an accumulator, assume the full out-of-pocket maximum minus anything the patient has paid, since nothing the card paid is likely to count. That is the amount a patient needs to be able to cover before the end of the year.
  3. Spread it. If the patient will owe $6,000 over six months, that is $1,000 a month. Putting aside money from January, while the card is covering the bills, makes the later months far less painful. Money in a health savings account or flexible spending account can be used for qualified expenses, if the patient has one.
  4. Ask about payment plans. Many specialty pharmacies, hospitals and clinics will agree to spread a large amount. It costs nothing to ask.
  5. Look for other help. Independent foundations and manufacturer patient assistance programs sometimes help with out-of-pocket costs, with income and other criteria. Copay card or patient assistance program: which one can I use? compares them.
  6. Never skip a dose to save money without talking to the prescriber. If the cost is going to be a problem, the prescriber may have options, including a different drug, a different schedule or a program the office knows about.

How to spot the problem early in your own paperwork

You do not need to wait for the pharmacy to call. Two documents show the gap between what a card paid and what the plan counted.

  • The explanation of benefits (EOB). For each claim the EOB lists the allowed amount, the amount applied to the deductible and what the plan calls your responsibility. If the pharmacy collected nothing from you in January, but the EOB shows the full amount as "patient responsibility" and the deductible tracker has not moved, that is the pattern of an accumulator.
  • The plan's deductible tracker. Most plans show deductible and out-of-pocket progress in the member portal. Compare it to what you have paid yourself. If the portal says you have met $0 of the deductible after two $3,200 fills, the card's payments are not being counted, whatever the pharmacy told you.

A related arrangement is the copay maximizer. Instead of ignoring the card, the plan sets your monthly share so that it drains the card's annual limit evenly over the year, often dividing the limit by twelve. The patient may pay nothing for as long as they stay enrolled, but the plan still does not count the card's money toward the deductible. A maximizer can make the year look smooth until the plan year turns over or the patient leaves the program, so it is worth asking about by name.

If the plan's accumulator seems wrong or unfair

Several states have laws that restrict accumulators in some plans, and rules differ between fully insured and self-funded employer plans. The plan's member services, the employer's benefits office and the state insurance department can tell you what applies to your coverage. If the plan denies the drug entirely, or you cannot get a clear answer, there is a formal route; see what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need. For an upcoming open enrollment, the next post to read is How to find out if my plan has a copay accumulator before I enroll.

Key takeaways

  • A copay card can hide your deductible for months. If the plan does not count the card's payments, the deductible is still waiting when the card stops.
  • In the example, the same patient on the same plan paid $0 for the year with a counting plan, $1,000 with a counting plan and a small card limit, and $6,000 with an accumulator, even though the card paid $9,000.
  • Estimate the month the card stops by dividing its annual limit by what it pays each fill, and estimate the next bill from the out-of-pocket maximum, not from the card's good months.
  • Ask the plan, the card program and the pharmacy the questions in this post before the first fill of the year, and write down the answers.
  • If a large bill is coming, ask about payment plans and assistance programs early, and talk to the prescriber before skipping any dose.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic