Blog

What my doctor has to send for a drug prior authorization to succeed

A patient's view of a drug prior authorization from request to decision: the plan's criteria, what the prescriber submits, how you can help and what to do next.

You leave the appointment with a new prescription and a sentence from the doctor: "The pharmacy may need approval first." A drug prior authorization looks like paperwork between your doctor and your plan, and you may never see it. But it is built from facts about you, and you can speed it up or slow it down. This walkthrough follows one request from start to decision, explains what the prescriber's office has to send, and shows where a patient helps.

The path is the same for most plans. The details, such as forms, portals and time limits, differ, and the plan's own materials rule on any one of them.

What a drug prior authorization is

A prior authorization is the plan's advance review of whether it will pay for a drug. The plan is not deciding whether you should take the drug. It is deciding whether the drug meets its own coverage rules. Those rules, called coverage criteria or clinical criteria, usually come from the plan or the pharmacy benefit manager that runs its drug benefit, and they are written for each drug or drug class.

Typical reasons a drug needs approval:

  • It is expensive, and the plan wants to confirm it is used for the right condition.
  • It has a safer or cheaper alternative the plan prefers, which is the logic of step therapy.
  • It has a history of misuse or is often prescribed for conditions that the label does not cover.
  • It is limited to certain ages, sexes, diagnoses or doses.

The criteria are not secret. Plans publish them or provide them on request. Asking for a copy of the criteria for your drug is the single most useful step you can take, because it tells you what the office has to prove.

Step 1: The pharmacy or the plan tells you

The request often begins at the pharmacy counter. The pharmacist runs the claim and receives a message: "prior authorization required." The pharmacist cannot approve it. They can tell you what the message says and notify the prescriber's office, often electronically.

Ask the pharmacist three things:

  1. What exact message did the plan send?
  2. Can I take a smaller or temporary supply while the approval is pending? Some plans allow an emergency or transition fill for a few days, and some do not.
  3. Has the prescriber's office been notified, or should I call them?

Do not assume the office knows. Offices that handle many requests can be slow to see a pharmacy's electronic alert. A phone call from you, with the drug name and the plan's message, can start the clock.

Step 2: The plan's criteria, in practice

Criteria for a drug approval commonly ask some version of these questions. Your plan's version will differ, and the criteria for your drug are the ones that count.

  • Diagnosis. Does the patient have the condition the drug is approved to treat? The plan wants the specific diagnosis, not a general description.
  • Prior treatments. Has the patient tried other drugs, which ones, for how long and with what result? If the plan has a step therapy rule, this is where it applies.
  • Test results. Are labs, imaging or other measures on file that support the diagnosis or show the need? Examples include a blood test value, a lung function result or a scan.
  • Dose and duration. Is the dose within the label and the plan's limits, and for how long is approval requested?
  • Prescriber. For some drugs the plan requires that a specialist, not a primary care doctor, writes or agrees with the prescription.
  • Safety checks. Are there conditions or other drugs that make this one unsafe?

A request succeeds when the answers to these questions appear in the submission in a form a reviewer can match against the criteria. It fails most often when a needed fact is missing, vague or out of date, not because the drug is wrong for the patient.

Step 3: What the prescriber's office submits

The office assembles the request. In most cases it is a form or a portal entry, plus attached records. The content usually includes:

  • Patient identification. Name, date of birth and member ID, exactly as they appear on your card. A mismatch is a common cause of delays.
  • The drug. Name, strength, form, directions, quantity and the days' supply requested.
  • The diagnosis. Stated specifically, with the diagnosis code the office uses for billing.
  • Drugs already tried. Each one by name, the dates it was taken, the dose, and the result: not effective, caused side effects, caused an allergic reaction or was stopped for another reason. Dates matter, because plans often require a minimum length of trial.
  • Relevant tests. The values and the dates, with the records attached.
  • A clinical rationale. A short statement by the prescriber explaining why this drug is appropriate for this patient, and why alternatives are not.
  • Urgency, if it applies. A statement that waiting for a standard review could seriously harm the patient's health, which allows a faster review.

Prescribers write these statements frequently, and good ones are specific and short. "The patient's blood pressure remained above goal on two other drugs, each taken for at least three months, and developed swelling on a third" is better than "other drugs did not work."

Step 4: How you help as the patient

You are the best source of three kinds of information the office may not have in front of it.

  1. Your treatment history. If you have switched doctors, insurers or pharmacies, the old drugs may not be in the current chart. Write down each medicine you can remember, roughly when you took it, and what happened. Your pharmacy can print a history of fills. Your old insurer's online portal or explanation of benefits statements may list them too.
  2. Your records. Ask previous providers to send the relevant notes and results to the current office. This can take days, so start early. Federal law gives you a right to your records, but providers may take some time and may charge limited fees, so ask promptly.
  3. Your own account of side effects. If a drug caused symptoms, tell the prescriber exactly what you noticed, when, and how long it lasted. A note in your own words, with dates, gives the prescriber something to cite.

Here is a labeled hypothetical. Say Lena's doctor wants to prescribe a drug that her plan covers only after two cheaper drugs have been tried. Lena took the first for five months two years ago with a different insurer and the second for six weeks before stopping because of a rash. The current doctor's chart shows neither. Lena asks her old clinic to send its records, prints her pharmacy history showing the fill dates, and writes a short timeline. The office attaches all of it. The request now answers the plan's question about prior drugs, with dates, instead of leaving it blank. The case may still be denied, but a missing fact will not be the reason.

Keep your own copy of everything the office sends. The prior authorization and claim tracker gives you a place to log dates, reference numbers and calls.

Step 5: The decision and its time frames

The plan reviews the request against its criteria and decides. A pharmacist or nurse often does the first review; a medical director may handle the harder ones, and a denial must be made by a qualified clinician in many programs.

Time frames depend on the type of plan and the kind of request. In general terms:

  • A standard request is decided within a number of days, often a few business days or a week or so, depending on the plan and the rules that apply to it.
  • An expedited request, where the prescriber states that the standard time frame could seriously jeopardize your health, is decided much faster, commonly within about a day or two.
  • Medicare drug plans, Medicaid and employer plans, and marketplace plans each have their own rules. The decision letter or the plan's materials state the deadlines that apply to you.

Ask the office when it submitted the request and what reference number it received. If a decision is not in your hands within the stated time frame, call the plan, quote the reference number and ask for the status.

Be aware that decisions arrive in different ways. The pharmacy may see the approval before you do, and a letter may follow. The reverse is also possible. If the pharmacy cannot see the approval, ask the plan whether it was sent to the right pharmacy.

Step 6: If it is approved

An approval is not always unlimited. Check these details in the approval letter or by calling:

  • The dates. The approval has a start and an end date. Many cover a year; some cover a few months. Put the end date in your calendar and ask the office to renew before it passes.
  • The drug, strength and quantity. The approval is for a specific product. A change of dose can require a new request.
  • The pharmacy. Some approvals apply only at a particular pharmacy, such as a specialty pharmacy.
  • Your cost. An approval means the plan will pay under the benefit. You still owe your copay or coinsurance, and the deductible if one applies. Approval does not make a drug free.

Then fill the prescription and see the pharmacist before you leave to confirm the price.

Step 7: If it is denied

A denial is a decision about the plan's rules, not a finding that you are not sick. The notice must state the reason in terms you can act on and explain how to appeal. Read it for these:

  • The stated reason. Examples include "criteria not met," "missing information," "drug not on the formulary," "step therapy not completed" or "not medically necessary."
  • The deadline. For most plans, the internal appeal deadline is at least 180 days from the notice. Your notice states yours.
  • The criteria. The plan should tell you how to obtain the criteria it used.

Then match the reason to the response.

Ask the prescriber whether a peer-to-peer call is available. In some plans, the prescriber can talk to the reviewing physician before the plan finalizes a denial or as part of an appeal. Not every plan offers it, and it is the prescriber's decision to request.

Step 8: If it is partly approved

Sometimes the plan approves a lower dose, a shorter period, a smaller quantity or a different drug than requested. This is a partial approval, and it is a decision you can question.

  1. Read what was approved and what was not.
  2. Ask the prescriber whether the approved amount works for you. If it does not, the prescriber can request more, and the plan treats that as a new request or an appeal, depending on how it is set up.
  3. If the plan approved an alternative, ask the prescriber whether it is clinically acceptable and whether its cost is the same.
  4. Do not stop taking the drug or change the dose on your own because of what the plan approved.

Mistakes that slow requests down

  • A wrong or outdated member ID after a plan change.
  • A diagnosis stated too generally for the criteria.
  • Prior drugs listed without dates or outcomes.
  • Missing test results, or results older than the plan allows.
  • Sending a request to the wrong place, such as the plan when a pharmacy benefit manager handles the drug.
  • Not asking for expedited review when the delay could harm your health.
  • Not noting the approval's end date, so that the next refill is rejected.

Key takeaways

  • A prior authorization checks whether a drug meets the plan's coverage criteria, so ask the plan for those criteria and compare them with what the office submits.
  • The strongest requests include the specific diagnosis, each prior drug with dates and results, relevant tests and a short clinical rationale.
  • You can help by gathering treatment history, old records and a dated account of side effects, and by keeping your own copy of every reference number.
  • Check an approval for its dates, product, pharmacy and your own cost, because approval does not make the drug free.
  • After a denial or partial approval, match the stated reason to the right response: a corrected submission, an exception request or an appeal before the deadline on your notice.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic