Blog

I'm hiring my first employee, do I have to offer health insurance?

A new employer's questions: the 50-employee mandate, state rules, pay versus benefits, the marketplace, small-employer credits and offer-letter wording.

For most businesses with one employee, the federal answer is no: the Affordable Care Act's employer requirement applies only to larger employers. That is the short version, and it is only the start of the questions a first-time employer actually has. Below are the ones that come up when someone moves from working alone to putting a first person on the payroll, with the reasoning behind each answer and the person to ask when your situation is specific.

Everything about dollar amounts here is either labeled as an invented illustration or taken from the 4HealthInsurance facts sheet, with its year.

What the law requires

Does the federal law make me offer coverage to my first employee?

Not at this size. The federal employer shared responsibility rules (the "employer mandate") apply to an applicable large employer, which the statute defines as one with an average of at least 50 full-time employees, counting part-timers as fractions to reach "full-time equivalents." A business with one or two workers is nowhere near that line, so there is no federal penalty for leaving group coverage out. See employer shared responsibility for the mechanism and Do employers have to offer health insurance? The ACA employer rules for the full picture.

The distinction matters because the mandate is a tax penalty on large employers, not a right that an employee can enforce. Even above 50 employees, the rule does not say "you must provide a plan." It says that if you do not offer coverage that is affordable and meets a minimum standard to nearly all full-time workers, you may owe a payment when a full-time worker gets a marketplace premium tax credit.

How large could the penalty be if I grow past 50 later?

For calendar year 2026 the two penalty amounts are $3,340 (the "no offer" penalty) and $5,010 (the "offer was not affordable or not good enough" penalty). For calendar year 2027 they are $3,780 and $5,670. Those figures come from IRS revenue procedures for each year and are indexed annually, so check the current IRS figure if you ever approach the threshold. They are included here only for scale: a business hiring its first employee is years away from them, and the mandate counts full-time-equivalent employees over a year, not on a single day.

Two traps are worth knowing in advance. Seasonal and variable-hour workers are counted by special rules, which the post on i work seasonal hours, will my employer ever have to offer coverage? explains. And related companies under common ownership can be combined into one employer for the count. If you own more than one business, ask an accountant before assuming each stands alone.

Do any state laws require me to offer a plan?

Some do, and this is the question where "no" is least safe. A handful of states have their own employer coverage rules, some states require employers above a certain size to offer a plan or pay into a fund, and many have rules about what a plan sold to small groups must include. Whether any of that reaches a business with one employee depends on the state, so the federal answer is not enough.

The practical check is short. Call the state department of labor or the state insurance department and ask two things: whether an employer of your size must offer or contribute to health coverage, and whether the state has a continuation law for small employers (federal COBRA generally applies at 20 or more employees, so smaller employers often fall under state continuation rules instead). A local SBA office, a chamber of commerce or a licensed broker who sells small-group plans in your state can usually answer faster than reading statutes.

Pay, reimbursement and the real choices

If I do not offer a plan, can I just give the employee extra pay for insurance?

Higher wages are lawful and common, with one important caution. Paying more in wages and letting the employee buy their own coverage is the simplest arrangement: the extra pay is ordinary taxable compensation, and the employee chooses a plan on the marketplace or elsewhere.

What generally does not work is a side arrangement in which the business reimburses the employee's individual premiums tax-free without a qualifying program. Federal rules treat that as a group health plan that fails ACA requirements, and it can trigger excise taxes. The lawful ways to reimburse individual coverage are specific programs, such as a QSEHRA (a qualified small employer health reimbursement arrangement) or an ICHRA (an individual coverage HRA, which CMS began calling a CHOICE arrangement in September 2026). Those arrangements have notice, documentation and eligibility rules. A benefits adviser or tax professional should set one up, not a handbook line.

The facts sheet gives the QSEHRA ceilings for reimbursement: $6,450 for self-only coverage and $13,100 for family coverage in 2026, rising to $6,700 and $13,550 in 2027. Those are ceilings, not suggestions, and a QSEHRA is meant for employers that do not offer a group plan.

What are the real choices for a one-person payroll?

There are four, and each has a cost and a catch.

  1. Offer nothing, pay a higher wage. Lowest administrative burden. The employee shops alone and may qualify for a premium tax credit if no affordable employer offer exists.
  2. Reimburse through a QSEHRA or ICHRA. You set a monthly allowance; the employee picks a plan. You carry compliance duties, but your cost is capped and predictable. Read ICHRA explained: employer allowance for individual health insurance.
  3. Buy a small-group plan. In many states a business with one common-law employee who is not the owner or the owner's spouse can qualify for a small-group plan, but insurers may impose participation or contribution minimums and the rules vary. A broker can tell you what is available where you live.
  4. Offer a defined contribution toward the marketplace plan the employee picks, in whatever form your adviser says is lawful.

The broader comparison from the worker's side is in employer coverage vs marketplace coverage: how to decide, and the owner-side tradeoffs are in Health insurance for small business owners: group plans, ICHRA and credits.

Pointing the worker to the marketplace

How do I tell an employee, fairly, to look at the marketplace?

Tell them plainly what you offer and where the rest of the information lives, and avoid steering them to a particular plan. A neutral statement that "we do not offer group coverage; you can compare plans and see whether you qualify for financial help at HealthCare.gov or your state's marketplace, and free local help is available from a navigator" is accurate and lets the person decide.

Two details help. First, an employee who has no employer offer can generally enroll during open enrollment, which for plan year 2027 on HealthCare.gov runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, with January 1 coverage if the person enrolls by December 15, 2026. State-based marketplaces have their own windows, so point the worker to state marketplace, regulator and help lookup. Second, not being offered an employer plan is not itself a reason to enroll outside open enrollment. A navigator can tell the worker whether a life event gives them an earlier opening.

Can my employee get a premium tax credit if I offer nothing?

Often yes, if their household income falls in the range for credits and they are otherwise eligible. When an employer offers no coverage, the worker is judged on household income and the marketplace benchmark plan alone. For the 2027 plan year the required contribution scale runs from 2.15% to 10.22% of income, and the credit ends above 400% of the federal poverty level, as of November 2026. The enhanced credits that removed the 400% limit expired December 31, 2025, and no law restoring them for 2027 had passed as of that date. Check the marketplace for current numbers rather than relying on this paragraph.

This is a reason some employers feel comfortable pointing workers to the marketplace, and a reason some workers prefer a real employer offer: for a worker above the income range, the marketplace price has no credit to soften it. Neither is a verdict; both are inputs.

Credits, letters and plan tests

Is there a tax credit for small employers that do offer coverage?

There is a federal credit for certain small employers that pay part of employee premiums, but it has conditions: a ceiling on the number of full-time-equivalent employees, a ceiling on average wages, a minimum share of the premium the employer pays, and a requirement about how the coverage is purchased. The limits are adjusted each year and the credit can be claimed for a limited number of years. Because those details change, do not plan around a number you read in an old article. The IRS instructions for the small business health care tax credit form and a tax professional are the right sources, and the post on does my small business qualify for the health care tax credit? walks through how the test works.

If the credit matters to your decision, ask the broker whether the plan you are considering is one that can qualify before you buy.

What should I put in the offer letter?

Say exactly what is true and nothing more. A letter should state whether the company offers group health coverage, and if it does, when the employee becomes eligible and who pays what, with a pointer to the plan documents for terms. If it does not, say so and state the wage. Avoid promises about the future ("we will add a plan next year") and avoid describing coverage you have not bought.

A sample structure, with invented numbers, follows.

Health coverage: The company does not currently offer a group health plan. Your hourly rate of $24.00 is set with that in mind. You are welcome to enroll in coverage through the marketplace in your state. If the company adopts a plan, you will receive written notice of when you become eligible and what it costs.

Or, where there is a plan:

Health coverage: You become eligible for the company's group health plan on the first day of the month after 30 days of employment. The company pays 60% of the employee-only monthly premium. Plan terms are in the summary plan description provided at enrollment.

The 60% and the 30 days are invented illustrations, not recommendations. Waiting periods for a group plan cannot run longer than 90 days, but you can choose a shorter one. Have an employment lawyer or your broker review the letter once and reuse it.

How do I know a plan I offer would count for the employee?

The employee's credit eligibility and the employer penalty use two tests. The plan must meet minimum value, meaning it pays at least 60% of covered costs for a standard population, and it must be affordable, meaning the cheapest employee-only plan that meets minimum value costs no more than 10.22% of household income for plan years beginning in 2027 (9.96% for plan years beginning in 2026). A non-calendar plan year that begins in 2026 keeps the 2026 percentage for its whole term, according to a secondary source, so confirm with your broker. The employer coverage affordability test lets you run an example. The glossary entries on minimum value and affordability give the formal definitions.

For a first employee this matters mostly for the worker: if you offer a plan that is not affordable by that test, the employee may still qualify for marketplace credits. For you, it only becomes a legal exposure above the 50-employee line.

Timing and who to ask

Should I wait until I have more employees?

That is a business judgment, not a legal obligation, and reasonable owners come down on both sides. Reasons to wait: administrative cost, small-group rating, and the option of paying higher wages for now. Reasons to start earlier: recruiting a particular candidate, retaining an employee who already has a medical condition and values stability, and the chance that a small-group plan is cheaper on a pre-tax basis than paying the same dollars as wages.

A rough illustration, with invented figures: say the company can spend $500 a month on the employee's health benefit. As wages, the employee receives $500 less payroll taxes and income taxes. As a contribution to a qualifying plan, a larger share generally reaches the plan because premiums paid through a group plan are generally excluded from income and payroll tax. The size of that difference depends on the employee's tax situation, so it is not a reason by itself.

A broker licensed in your state can quote group options for free and a tax professional can price the tax side. Use both before deciding.

You and your advisers

What do I do about myself as the owner?

If you are a sole proprietor or partner, you are generally not an employee for group plan purposes, and your own coverage is a separate question from your worker's. You may be able to deduct premiums for yourself, which health insurance for the self-employed: marketplace, deduction and options explains.

Where do I get an authoritative answer for my situation?

  • A licensed broker for what plans exist for a group of your size where you live.
  • The state insurance department and the state labor department for state requirements.
  • A tax professional for the small employer credit, reimbursement arrangements and wage-versus-benefit math.
  • The marketplace or a navigator for the employee's options and any credit they may qualify for.
  • An employment lawyer for offer-letter wording and anything involving a union, a contract or a long waiting period.

Key takeaways

  • Federal law requires group coverage only from employers with an average of 50 or more full-time-equivalent employees, so a first hire is not covered by the federal mandate, but check your state.
  • Paying higher wages is lawful; reimbursing individual premiums works only through a program such as a QSEHRA or ICHRA, not an informal side payment.
  • An employee with no employer offer may qualify for marketplace credits, judged on household income, as of November 2026 under the original credit schedule.
  • Offer letters should say only what is true now, and any waiting period for a group plan cannot exceed 90 days.
  • The small employer credit has conditions that change by year, so confirm them with IRS instructions or a tax professional before relying on it.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic