Blog

Why is my cheap generic drug on a higher tier than I expected?

How plans assign generics to tiers, why a copay can top the pharmacy's cash price, a four-tier example with round numbers and three questions to ask.

Picture a pharmacy counter. The technician says your blood pressure pill, a generic you have taken for years, will cost $25. The same pharmacy's printed cash price for a month of it is $12. You are holding an insurance card, you pay a monthly premium, and the card is making the drug cost more. Nothing is broken. The plan has placed that generic on a tier whose copay is a flat $25, and a flat copay does not shrink when the drug is cheap.

This post explains how a generic ends up on a higher tier than people expect, what a four-tier table looks like with round numbers, and what to ask so you know whether the placement is a plan design choice, a pharmacy pricing quirk or a mistake.

What a tier is, and what it is not

A formulary tier is a price bracket on the plan's formulary, the list of drugs the plan covers. Each tier carries its own cost-sharing rule: a flat copay on the lower tiers, often a percentage of the drug's price (coinsurance) on the top ones. The tier tells you how the plan will charge you. It does not tell you how effective or how expensive the drug is, and it is not a medical judgment about the drug.

Two features of tiers explain most of the surprises:

  • The tier is set by the plan, not by the drug's type. "Generic" describes what a drug is: a generic drug has the same active ingredient, strength and form as a brand-name drug and meets the same approval standard. "Tier 1" describes where one plan chose to put it. Two plans can place the same generic on different tiers.
  • A flat copay is a fixed number. If the tier copay is $15 and the pharmacy's own price is $6, the plan's rules still say $15 unless the plan's terms for that situation say otherwise. Many plans charge the lesser of the copay or the drug's negotiated price, and many do not, so the plan documents are the place to check.

How plans decide where a generic goes

Insurers and their pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) usually run a committee of pharmacists and physicians that reviews drugs for safety and effectiveness, and then a separate commercial process decides prices and tiers. That second step is where generics get sorted. The factors below are the ones commonly described by insurers, PBMs and independent analysts. A plan's own documents rarely lay out which factor applied to a particular drug.

  1. Preferred versus non-preferred generics. Many formularies split generics into two groups. A preferred generic is one the plan or PBM has a favorable contract for, typically because it is among the lowest-cost versions on the PBM's price list. A non-preferred generic may be an older, newer or lower-volume drug, or one where the PBM's contracted price is higher. Non-preferred generics sit a tier up.
  2. The price the plan actually pays. The plan does not pay the pharmacy's cash price. It pays a negotiated rate set in contracts between the PBM and each pharmacy, and generic prices can differ a great deal from one pharmacy chain to the next. A generic that is cheap at a discount retailer can carry a higher contracted price in the plan's network, so the plan places it on a higher tier.
  3. Rebates and contract terms. Manufacturers pay PBMs drug rebates and fees in exchange for formulary placement. Rebates are more common for brand-name drugs, but contract terms can also shape which generics a plan favors. How much weight rebates carry in a given tier decision is not public, and PBMs and critics describe it differently. The what pharmacy benefit managers do and why they matter guide covers the competing views.
  4. Plan design. An employer or insurer that wants a lower premium may use more tiers, raise the copay on a middle tier or use a separate specialty tier. The generic's placement may just be where the plan's design drew a line.
  5. Supply and market changes. A generic that had one or two makers can become pricier when a manufacturer exits or a shortage pushes up the price. If the plan's contracted price rises, the tier may rise with it at the next plan year.
  6. Form and strength. A common drug in tablet form can be on tier 1 while the extended-release version, an oral solution or an unusual strength is on tier 2 or 3. Those are different products on a formulary even when the medicine is the same.

None of this means the plan is doing something improper. It also does not mean the placement is the best deal for you. It means the tier reflects the plan's contracts and design, not the pharmacy's sticker.

A four-tier example with round numbers

The table below is an illustration. The amounts are round numbers invented to show how the pieces fit, not prices or any real plan's cost-sharing.

Tier Typical contents Your cost in this example
Tier 1 Preferred generics $10 copay
Tier 2 Non-preferred generics and some lower-cost brands $25 copay
Tier 3 Preferred brand-name drugs $50 copay
Tier 4 Non-preferred brands, specialty drugs 40% coinsurance

Say Marcus, 46, takes a generic cholesterol drug. In this example the plan has put it on tier 2. His 30-day fill costs him a $25 copay. The pharmacy's printed cash price for the same drug is $12, and a discount-card quote the same day is $9.

  • Through insurance he pays $25 and the claim counts toward his plan's totals under whatever rules the plan sets.
  • Paying cash at $12 saves $13 on this fill. The purchase usually will not count toward his deductible or out-of-pocket maximum, because the plan never saw it. The when paying cash for a generic beats using my insurance post works through when that trade-off favors cash.

Over twelve months at one fill a month, the gap is 12 x ($25 - $12) = $156. A $156 difference is real money, but it is not automatically the winning choice. If Marcus expects a year with little other care, so that he will stay well short of his deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, the lost credit costs him little and cash wins. If he expects a surgery or a string of specialist visits that could carry him to the out-of-pocket maximum, then fills that go through the plan can count toward that limit under many plans' rules, and cash fills forgo that credit. The right answer depends on his year and on his plan's rules, which is why the questions further down matter.

Now suppose the plan's tier 1 copay is $10 and the drug had been on it. Marcus pays $10 instead of $25 and the cash question barely arises. The drug did not change. The plan's placement changed his cost by $15 a fill.

Why the copay can be higher than the cash price

This is the part that feels wrong, so it is worth separating the causes.

  • Copays are fixed amounts set per tier. The tier's copay was not chosen with the price of this one drug in mind. It was chosen for the average of all the drugs on the tier. A plan that uses a $25 copay for all of tier 2 will collect $25 for a drug whose negotiated price is $11 unless a lesser-of rule applies.
  • The cash price and the plan price come from different contracts. Pharmacies set cash prices from their own markups or through discount-card arrangements. The plan's price comes from the PBM contract. They can differ in either direction.
  • Deductibles can sit in front of the tier. Many plans require you to pay the full negotiated price until you meet a deductible, and then the copay applies. In that stretch a generic may cost more or less than a tier copay depending on the drug, and it is the negotiated price, not the cash price, that counts.
  • Coinsurance on a generic is a percentage of the plan's price. If a tier uses coinsurance, a drug with an inflated list price can cost more than its cash-price cousin even when the percentage looks modest.

Pharmacists are generally free to tell you when cash is lower. Contract clauses that once kept them from volunteering it have been restricted by federal law and by many state laws, so it is reasonable to ask: "Is there a lower price if I do not use my insurance?" Asking costs nothing and the pharmacist can usually run both prices in a minute.

Three questions to ask the plan or the pharmacist

Bring the drug name, strength, quantity and the pharmacy you used. Then ask:

  1. "What tier is this exact product on, and what is the cost-sharing rule for that tier?" Name the strength and form. Ask whether the copay is flat, whether it is the lesser of a copay and the drug's price, and whether a deductible applies before it. Ask the representative to put the answer in writing or give a reference number. The summary of benefits and the formulary document should agree with what you are told, and when they do not, the formulary document is the one to quote back.
  2. "Is there a preferred version, a different strength or a different manufacturer's product on a lower tier?" Sometimes a lower-tier generic of the same medicine exists in a slightly different form. The pharmacist can see the plan's pricing on each version at the counter. Your prescriber has to agree to any change in the prescription, and you should not switch strengths or forms on your own.
  3. "Which pharmacy in the plan's network prices this lowest, and does mail order change the cost?" Preferred pharmacies and mail-order programs can carry a lower tier copay for the same drug. The pharmacy lookup tool or the number on the card can tell you. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet has a place to write down the answers for each drug.

If the answers do not fit what you are being charged, the next step is a call to the plan's member line to ask for a claim review, and, if the placement itself is the problem, a request called a tiering exception. A tiering exception asks the plan to charge you the lower-tier cost for a drug on the higher tier. Not every plan offers one, and the prescriber usually must support the request by explaining why the lower-tier alternatives would not work for you. what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need describes exceptions and appeals for drug coverage in general.

When the placement may be a mistake

Most higher-tier generics are intended placements. A few signs point to a plan or data error worth challenging:

  • The formulary document says tier 1 and the pharmacy's claim says tier 2.
  • The cost differs between two pharmacies in the same network, and the lower-priced one is not a preferred pharmacy.
  • The tier changed in the middle of the plan year with no notice. Plans have rules about when and how they may move a drug, and those rules differ by plan type.
  • The drug is the same brand of generic that was on a lower tier last year and nothing in the plan documents mentions a change.

Ask the plan to explain the tier assignment and ask whether the drug was moved. If the explanation does not fit the documents, ask for a supervisor and for the review to be logged. For an employer plan, the benefits department can often escalate to the insurer or PBM. For a marketplace plan or an insured employer plan, the state insurance department takes complaints if the plan does not resolve one.

Choosing a plan when your generic matters

If you are shopping for coverage, the tier of a drug you use every month is worth checking before you enroll, because the premium comparison hides it. A plan with a slightly lower premium and a $25 copay on your generic can cost more over a year than a plan with a slightly higher premium and a $10 copay. The premium, deductible, copay and coinsurance explained simply guide covers how the pieces add up, and the Should I use a drug discount card or my insurance at the pharmacy? post gives a decision list for the counter. Look up the drug in the formulary of each plan you are considering, using the exact strength and form, and write down the tier. Tier placement is set for the plan year in most cases and can be revised for the next one, so check again every fall.

If a generic costs very little in cash, a higher tier is more likely to be a nuisance than a budget problem. If it is a drug you take in large quantities, such as a 90-day supply, or one of several that all sit on tier 2 or 3, the combined effect on a household budget is larger. The question is then whether the plan as a whole fits how you use care, not whether one drug is overpriced.

Key takeaways

  • A tier is a plan-set price bracket, so the same generic can sit on tier 1 in one plan and tier 2 or 3 in another. The tier reflects contracts and plan design, not the drug's quality.
  • A flat copay does not shrink when a drug is cheap. A $25 copay can exceed a $12 cash price, and cash purchases generally do not count toward the deductible or out-of-pocket maximum.
  • Ask the plan for the exact tier of the exact strength and form, whether a lesser-of rule or a deductible applies, and which version or pharmacy is cheapest.
  • Ask the pharmacist to run both the insurance price and the cash price. Do not change the drug or dose on your own: the prescriber has to agree.
  • If the placement conflicts with the plan's documents, ask for a review, and use a tiering exception request or the state insurance department when the plan will not fix it.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic