Blog

How much should I put in my health FSA? Do the math with last year's bills

A repeatable worksheet for choosing a health FSA election: add known costs, find low and likely totals, convert to tax savings, and test the risk of forfeiting.

The right health FSA election is the amount you are nearly certain to spend on eligible costs, not the amount you hope to spend and not the legal maximum. Choose too little and you leave tax savings on the table. Choose too much and you may forfeit pay that you already earned. The worksheet below turns last year's bills into a low total and a likely total, converts them into dollars saved, and tests what happens if you guess wrong.

For plan years that begin in 2027, the most an employee can have withheld for a health FSA is $3,500, and the most an employer may let an employee carry over from a 2027 plan year into the next is $700 (Rev. Proc. 2026-35, issued November 5, 2026). For 2026 the figures are $3,400 and $680. An employer may set a lower limit than $3,500 and does not have to offer carryover at all. Whether your plan offers carryover, a short grace period, or neither varies by employer, so the plan's summary document is the final word on yours.

How the savings work

A health FSA takes money out of your paycheck before income tax and, in most cases, before Social Security and Medicare payroll tax. You then use the account to be reimbursed for eligible medical costs. A dollar spent through the FSA costs you less than a dollar paid from after-tax pay by about your marginal tax rate.

Rates differ by household, so this post uses two invented ones. The first adds a 12% federal income tax rate and the 7.65% employee share of Social Security and Medicare tax, for 19.65% total. The second adds 22% and the same 7.65%, for 29.65%. State income tax, where it applies, adds to the savings. These are illustrations, not a statement of anyone's real rate.

Two facts shape the risk:

  • The election is mostly locked in. Once the plan year starts, you generally cannot change it unless you have a qualifying life event, such as marriage, a birth or a change in a spouse's coverage.
  • Unspent money may be forfeited. The rule is often called use-it-or-lose-it. If your plan offers carryover, up to the carryover limit survives into the next year. If it offers a grace period instead, you have a short extra stretch to spend the money. The guide FSA use-it-or-lose-it rules, carryover and grace periods describes both.

The worksheet, step by step

Step 1: Gather last year's evidence

Collect the explanation of benefits statements from your insurer, the pharmacy's year-end printout, receipts for glasses and dental work, and any bills you paid directly. Last year's real figures are better than memory, because memory favors the memorable big bill and forgets the small recurring ones.

Step 2: List the near-certain costs

These are costs that will almost certainly recur and that qualify. Examples include monthly prescriptions, regular specialist copays, glasses or contacts, and dental cleanings with a cost-sharing share. See What can I buy with my HSA or FSA? Everyday items sorted by yes, maybe, no for a sort of what is eligible and what is not.

Step 3: List the possible costs

These are costs you can foresee but are not sure of, such as a planned procedure, a test your doctor mentioned, braces, a new prescription or maternity care. Put a figure for your share of each after insurance.

Step 4: Check what changes next year

A new deductible, a new plan, a new drug on a different tier or a family member turning 26 can all change the totals. If you plan to switch to an HSA-eligible plan, a general-purpose FSA would block HSA contributions, which is the subject of My spouse has a general-purpose FSA, can I still contribute to my HSA?. Read the plan's summary of benefits before you assume last year's costs repeat.

Step 5: Total a low and a likely figure

The low total is the near-certain list. The likely total adds the possible costs you think more probable than not. The gap between the two is your uncertainty.

A worked example with invented numbers

Casey (hypothetical) is deciding an election for 2027. These figures are made up.

Item Basis Amount
Prescriptions 12 months at $35 $420
Specialist copays 8 visits at $40 $320
Eyeglasses One pair $300
Dental cost sharing Cleanings and a filling $350
Low total Sum of the four near-certain items $1,390
Sleep study cost share Planned, not certain $400
Over-the-counter medicines and first aid Estimate $150
Likely total Low plus the two possible items (1,390 + 400 + 150) $1,940

Casey's low total is $1,390 and likely total is $1,940, with the maximum at $3,500 well above both. There is no reason to elect near the maximum.

Convert the election to dollars

Elect an amount, then compare what you save with what you might forfeit.

If you spend everything you elect, the benefit is the election times your rate. A $1,500 election at 19.65% saves $294.75 (1,500 × 0.1965). At 29.65% it saves $444.75 (1,500 × 0.2965).

If you spend less than you elect, the benefit shrinks. The general formula for a plan with no carryover is:

Net benefit = amount spent minus (election × (1 minus your rate))

The election reduces your take-home pay by the election times (1 minus your rate), because the withheld money would otherwise have been taxed. Each dollar you spend returns a dollar of care that you would otherwise have paid for with after-tax money. If you spend exactly the election, what is left over is the tax saving. The break-even is spending 80.35% of the election at a 19.65% rate (1 minus 0.1965), or 70.35% at 29.65%.

Election Amount spent Net benefit at 19.65%
$1,500 $1,500 (likely) $294.75 (1,500 × 0.1965)
$1,500 $1,390 (low) $184.75 (1,390 minus 1,500 × 0.8035, which is 1,390 minus 1,205.25)
$1,940 $1,940 (likely) $381.21 (1,940 × 0.1965)
$1,940 $1,390 (low) minus $168.79 (1,390 minus 1,940 × 0.8035, which is 1,390 minus 1,558.79)

Reading the table: electing the likely total pays off if the likely total happens and costs about $169 if only the low total does. Electing slightly above the low total is safe in both cases. Casey's cautious election would be near $1,500; a more confident one near $1,940. Neither is the right answer for everyone, but the table shows what each bet costs.

If Casey's plan offers carryover, the $550 that would be left over (1,940 minus 1,390) is under the carryover limit, so it would roll into the next year instead of being forfeited, and the loss in the last row would not occur. Carryover and a grace period are different features, and an employer generally offers one or neither, not both.

A second household: a large known cost

Riley (hypothetical) has a child who needs orthodontic treatment. The family's share of the treatment is $3,000, paid over the plan year. Riley's other near-certain costs total $700, for $3,700 in all. Assume a combined rate of 29.65%.

The $3,700 is more than the $3,500 limit, so the largest election the law allows is $3,500, and the remaining $200 is paid with after-tax money. The savings from electing the maximum are $1,037.75 (3,500 × 0.2965). That is a clear case where the cost is both known and large, and the risk of forfeiting is low because the bill is a contract. Two questions still need an answer from the plan: how the plan treats orthodontia that is paid in installments (many reimburse as each payment comes due rather than the whole amount up front), and whether a letter or contract copy is required as proof.

Compare Casey: no single large cost, a handful of small ones, and a thinner margin. The same worksheet gives different answers because the inputs differ. A household with a pregnancy expected in the plan year is another example of a large known cost; the insurer's estimate of the delivery cost share and the out-of-pocket maximum for the year give the upper bound.

Mistakes that distort an election

  • Using the maximum as a default. The $3,500 limit is a ceiling. It is not a recommendation.
  • Counting costs that are not eligible. Gym memberships, general-health vitamins and cosmetic items are examples; the post on eligible items sorts them.
  • Counting the full price when insurance pays a share. Only your share after insurance is an FSA expense.
  • Forgetting the deductible resets. If the new plan year starts with a fresh deductible, the first months of care cost more out of pocket, which argues for a somewhat larger election if the care is certain.
  • Ignoring the claims deadline. Money you spent but never claimed is lost just as unspent money is.
  • Assuming a spouse's plan covers you both. Each employee's FSA covers that employee's eligible expenses and those of the spouse and tax dependents, but the limit and the rules are per plan.

Revisiting mid-year

A change you cannot predict at open enrollment can sometimes be handled afterward. A qualifying life event can allow a change to the election, as long as the change is consistent with the event. A birth, a marriage, a divorce, a change in a spouse's job or a loss of other coverage are examples. The benefits office will say what the plan permits and how quickly you must act, which is usually within about a month of the event.

If nothing like that happens and you reach the fall with money left, the useful moves are to schedule eligible care you would have had anyway, to check the plan's carryover or grace rule, and to submit every outstanding receipt before the run-out deadline. The point is not to buy things you do not need. It is to avoid paying twice, once in forfeited pay and once for care later paid from after-tax money.

The blank worksheet

Line What to enter Your number
1 Prescriptions (monthly cost times months) ________
2 Regular copays (visits times copay) ________
3 Glasses, contacts, vision care ________
4 Dental cost sharing ________
5 Other near-certain eligible costs ________
6 Low total (add lines 1 through 5) ________
7 Planned procedures and tests (your share) ________
8 Over-the-counter and first aid ________
9 Other possible costs ________
10 Likely total (line 6 plus lines 7 through 9) ________
11 Your combined rate (federal plus 7.65% plus any state) ________
12 Tentative election (between lines 6 and 10) ________
13 Savings if you spend it all (line 12 times line 11) ________
14 Net benefit if you spend only line 6 (line 6 minus line 12 times (1 minus line 11)) ________
15 Carryover or grace period offered by your employer? ________

If line 14 is negative and your plan has no carryover, consider a lower election. If line 14 is comfortably positive, the tentative election is reasonable.

Other things that change the answer

  • Two FSAs in one household. The limit applies to each employee's plan, so a spouse with a separate plan has a separate limit. The money is not pooled, and each account follows its own plan's rules.
  • The full election is available early. The plan generally has to make the whole election available on day one, even though you contribute through the year. That helps when a big bill comes in January. It also means that if you leave the job, you may have spent more than you contributed, which the post I'm leaving my job with money left in my FSA. What are my options? explores.
  • A limited-purpose FSA. Some employers offer an FSA limited to dental and vision costs, which can sit next to an HSA. Ask your benefits office.
  • A plan with a high deductible. In a year with a HDHP and an HSA, the FSA is usually not a fit unless it is the limited-purpose kind; FSA vs HSA: the differences in eligibility, limits and rollover compares them.
  • Running out the clock. Check the deadline for submitting claims after the plan year ends. Many plans allow a run-out period of a few months, but the length is the plan's choice.

The FSA election planner on this site does the same arithmetic if you would rather enter numbers than fill a table. For the open enrollment calendar and the other decisions that arrive in the same month, open enrollment checklist: what to do before you pick a plan lists them.

Key takeaways

  • Elect the amount you are near-certain to spend, not the maximum; for plan years beginning in 2027 the limit is $3,500 and the maximum carryover $700.
  • Build a low total from recurring eligible costs and a likely total by adding possible ones; the election belongs between them.
  • Spending everything you elect saves roughly your combined tax rate on each dollar; spending less than about 70% to 80% of it can leave you worse off if there is no carryover.
  • Employers vary on whether they offer carryover, a grace period or neither, so read the plan document before you finalize.
  • An election is hard to change after the year begins, so make the numbers match the evidence in last year's bills.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic