Blog

Is a high-deductible Plan G worth it, and who should skip it?

High-deductible Plan G trades a lower premium for a yearly deductible. How it works, break-even arithmetic with invented numbers, and a decision list.

Imagine Marcus, 66, who has just enrolled in Medicare Part B and has not been in a hospital since his thirties. A broker quotes him two versions of Plan G from the same insurer. The standard version costs noticeably more each month. The high-deductible version costs far less, but it makes him pay the first part of the year's Medicare-covered costs himself. Whether the cheaper policy is "worth it" depends on three numbers: the premium gap, the size of the deductible, and how likely he is to have an expensive year. This post works through the arithmetic and then turns it into a decision list.

Plan G is sold in two forms in many states, and the high-deductible form is not available everywhere or from every insurer. The standard form pays nearly all of what Original Medicare leaves behind, except the Part B deductible. The high-deductible form pays the same things only after you meet a separate annual deductible. In 2026 that deductible is $2,950, according to Medicare.gov. The 2027 amount was not in the figures this site had verified as of November 2026, and the deductible is adjusted for inflation each year, so check the current amount on Medicare.gov and in the quote.

How the high-deductible version works

Here is the mechanism in order.

  1. You buy the policy and pay a monthly premium. The premium is lower than the standard Plan G from the same insurer, often by a meaningful margin.
  2. During the year, Original Medicare pays its share first. Medicare pays its part of covered services, and you owe the cost sharing: the Part A hospital deductible, daily coinsurance, the Part B deductible and the Part B 20% coinsurance.
  3. You pay that cost sharing yourself until you reach the Medigap deductible. Medicare-covered cost sharing that the policy would otherwise pay counts toward it. Ask the insurer in writing whether anything else counts, such as Part B excess charges, because the answer matters if you use doctors who do not accept assignment.
  4. After the deductible is met, the plan pays like regular Plan G for the rest of the calendar year. That means 100% of the covered cost sharing. The Part B deductible you paid earlier in the year is part of what counted toward the policy deductible.
  5. On January 1 the deductible starts over.

Two features are worth stating plainly. First, the high-deductible Plan G is a Medigap policy, so it follows the standardized rules: it can be used only with Original Medicare, it does not pay for prescription drugs, and it does not cover dental, vision or hearing. Second, it is not the same thing as a high-deductible health plan paired with a health savings account. People often confuse the two. A health savings account contribution has stopped being allowed once Medicare enrollment begins, which is covered in HSAs and Medicare: when you must stop contributing.

The break-even arithmetic

Here is a labeled hypothetical. Every figure is an invented round number, except the 2026 deductible and the 2026 Part B deductible, which are published amounts.

  • Standard Plan G premium: $200 a month, or $2,400 a year.
  • High-deductible Plan G premium: $100 a month, or $1,200 a year.
  • Premium savings: $1,200 a year.
  • Medigap deductible on the high-deductible version: $2,950 (the 2026 figure).
  • Part B deductible: $283 in 2026. Both versions leave you with it, so it counts as a cost under each.

Cost under each version as a function of the year's cost sharing. Let C be the total Medicare-covered cost sharing Marcus would face in a year, including the $283 Part B deductible.

  • Standard Plan G: $2,400 premium + $283 = $2,683, no matter how large C is.
  • High-deductible Plan G: $1,200 premium + the smaller of C or $2,950.

Where they cross. The two cost the same when $1,200 + C = $2,683, so C = $1,483. If the year's cost sharing is below $1,483, the high-deductible version is cheaper. If it is above, the standard version is cheaper, up to the point where the deductible is reached.

The worst year for the high-deductible policy. When C reaches $2,950 or more, the policy pays everything above. The high-deductible cost is then $1,200 + $2,950 = $4,150, which is $1,467 more than the standard policy's $2,683. That is the most the high-deductible choice can cost relative to standard in a single year, as long as the deductible is the only difference.

What a quiet year looks like. Suppose Marcus has $283 of Part B deductible and two routine specialist visits whose 20% share comes to $120, so C = $403. The high-deductible version costs $1,200 + $403 = $1,603, and the standard version costs $2,683. He is $1,080 ahead. (The standard version's cost counts only the premium and the $283 Part B deductible, because it pays the $120 coinsurance.)

How many bad years can he afford?

A quiet year gains about $1,200 or more; a worst year loses $1,467. The question is how often a bad year would have to come before the cheaper policy loses over time.

Treat each year as either quiet (gain $1,200) or bad (lose $1,467). The policy breaks even when the average is zero. If a fraction p of years are bad, then p × $1,467 = (1 − p) × $1,200, so p = $1,200 ÷ $2,667, or about 45%. In plain terms, in this illustration the high-deductible version comes out behind only if bad years make up more than about 45% of all years. A person who expects one expensive year in ten is comfortably ahead. A person who expects one in two is not.

Check how sensitive that result is to the premium gap, because the gap is the weakest assumption.

Premium gap per year Bad-year loss Break-even share of bad years
$1,800 $2,950 − $283 − $1,800 = $867 about 68%
$1,200 $1,467 about 45%
$600 $2,067 about 22%
$300 $2,367 about 11%

Each loss figure is the deductible minus the Part B deductible minus the gap. Each break-even share is the gap divided by the gap plus the loss. If the quote you receive shows a gap of only $300 a year, the tolerance for bad years shrinks to roughly one in nine.

What the arithmetic leaves out

Premiums rise with age. In many states a Medigap policy is priced by attained age, so the premium goes up as you get older. The post Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained explains the three pricing methods. The high-deductible premium also rises, and the dollar gap between the two versions can widen or narrow over a decade. Ask for the insurer's rate-increase history on both versions and for the pricing method of the policy.

The deductible rises too. It is adjusted each year, so a number that looks manageable at 66 is higher at 76. The break-even logic is unchanged, but the cash you need on hand is greater.

Timing inside the year. The deductible is annual. A hospital stay in February costs you the full deductible in February, and you pay it before the policy starts to cover anything. A stay in December can mean you pay the deductible in one year and again a few weeks later in January. The benefit period rules for hospital stays operate on a different clock than the policy year, so a stay that straddles New Year can touch two deductibles.

You may not be able to move up. If Marcus develops a heart condition at 72, he cannot count on switching to the standard version. Outside a guaranteed window, moving to a richer policy usually involves medical underwriting, and an insurer may decline or charge more. This is an asymmetry: the cheaper choice is easy to make and hard to reverse. The rules for the six-month window are in medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue.

Cash flow, not just cost. Even in a break-even year, a $2,950 bill in a single month is a different experience from paying $100 more a month spread across twelve months.

A decision list

Use this as criteria, not a verdict. Each "if" is something you can check about your own situation.

  1. If you could pay the full deductible from savings without borrowing or cutting essentials, and you have a record of low use, then the high-deductible version is worth pricing seriously.
  2. If a bill the size of the deductible would force you to carry a credit balance or delay other care, then the standard version's predictability is probably worth the premium.
  3. If you see several specialists, have a chronic condition or expect a planned surgery, then your expected cost sharing may sit near or above the break-even level, and the standard version tends to come out ahead.
  4. If your doctors do not all accept assignment, then ask whether excess charges count toward the deductible, and compare using the worst realistic year.
  5. If you are within the six-month open enrollment window and your health is good, then you could take the cheaper version now, knowing that moving up later could mean underwriting.
  6. If the premium gap in your actual quotes is small, then the cheaper policy stops being attractive quickly, because the bad-year cushion shrinks.
  7. If you are on a tight fixed income, then ask a SHIP counselor about the Medicare Savings Programs before you choose a policy, because the best answer may be a different kind of help.

Reading the quote before you decide

A quote is only useful if it answers the same questions every time. When you collect one for the high-deductible version, write down the following next to the standard-version quote from the same insurer:

  • The monthly premium for each version, the pricing method, and the date the quote was produced.
  • The deductible for the current year and the insurer's statement of what counts toward it.
  • Whether the insurer sells the high-deductible version to new applicants at your age in your state, and whether an existing policyholder can keep it.
  • The effective date, because a policy that starts in the middle of a year starts with a full deductible, not a prorated one.
  • How the insurer has changed premiums on each version in recent years, if it will share that history.

The last item matters more than it looks. A cheaper policy with steep annual increases can lose its advantage within a few years, while a stable one can keep it for a long time. The medigap plan comparison chart helps confirm that both versions are the same letter with the same benefits once the deductible is met.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Treating the policy as an HSA-compatible plan. It is not.
  • Comparing premiums only, without a worst-year column.
  • Assuming the deductible resets when a hospital benefit period does. It resets on January 1.
  • Forgetting that drugs need a separate plan. The high-deductible Plan G does not pay for prescriptions.
  • Buying the cheap version and treating the choice as permanent. The right choice at 66 may not be the right one at 74, and the cost of changing rises with age and health history.

Where to get a second opinion

A State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) counselor gives free, unbiased Medicare counseling and can price the policies sold in your state. A licensed broker who sells several insurers' policies can pull quotes, and the state insurance department can tell you whether the high-deductible form is sold and whether an insurer has a complaint record you should read. See Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N for the general picture and the medigap plan comparison chart for a chart of what each letter covers. For the related question of how Plan G compares with a lower-premium letter, read Medigap Plan G or Plan N: which costs less in a good year and a bad one?.

Key takeaways

  • The high-deductible Plan G pays like standard Plan G only after you meet an annual deductible, which was $2,950 in 2026; check Medicare.gov for the current figure.
  • In the invented example, a $1,200 premium savings means the cheaper policy wins unless bad years are about as common as quiet ones, and a smaller gap cuts that tolerance sharply.
  • The cheaper policy is easy to choose and can be hard to leave, because moving to a richer letter later may require health questions.
  • It is not an HSA-qualified plan, and it does not cover drugs, dental, vision or hearing.
  • Test your own quotes with the formula in this post, using the real premium gap and a realistic worst year.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic