Blog
Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained
Attained-age, issue-age and community-rated Medigap policies rise for different reasons. A ten-year illustration, other causes of increases, questions to ask.
A Medigap premium can rise for two separate reasons, and the pricing method printed in your policy decides which one dominates. One reason is that you are getting older. The other is that the cost of claims, medical prices and the insurer's experience with its policyholders rise over time. Under attained-age pricing both push the premium up. Under issue-age pricing, age stops mattering after you buy. Under community-rated pricing, age never matters. Every method still rises with the second reason, which is why even the "stable" policies get letters from their insurers.
Knowing which method you have turns a vague annoyance into something you can predict, and it tells you whether switching is likely to help. This post explains the three methods with a ten-year illustration using invented round numbers, then covers the other causes of increases, how states differ, and what to ask before you buy.
The three methods in plain terms
Attained-age. The premium is set by your age now. You start with a low premium at 65 or 66, and the insurer increases it as you move up in age. Premiums for a 75-year-old are higher than for a 66-year-old because claims costs rise with age. This is the most common method on many policies sold to people at the start of Medicare, and it often has the lowest starting price.
Issue-age. The premium is set by the age you were when you bought the policy. A person who buys at 66 pays a rate based on being 66, and getting older does not raise it. The starting premium is usually higher than an attained-age policy from the same insurer, because the insurer is pricing in the decades to come. The premium can still rise for other reasons.
Community-rated (sometimes called no-age-rated). Everyone pays the same premium for the same policy in the same area, regardless of age. The starting premium is typically higher than the other two methods for a younger buyer and lower for an older one. Community rating is required or common in a small number of states, and some insurers choose it elsewhere.
The method is stated in the policy and on the quote, though the label may vary. If you cannot find it, ask the insurer or agent to point to it in writing. The guide Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N covers the standardized letters, and none of these methods changes what a given letter pays.
A ten-year illustration
The numbers below are invented to show a pattern, not to describe any insurer or state. Say three versions of the same plan letter are quoted to a 66-year-old. The age-related component is all that varies in the first table: no inflation, no claims trend. Premiums are monthly.
- Attained-age: starts at $140 and rises by $10 each year as the person ages.
- Issue-age: $170 a month for as long as the person holds the policy.
- Community-rated: $200 a month for everyone.
| Year (age) | Attained-age | Issue-age | Community-rated |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (66) | $140 | $170 | $200 |
| 4 (69) | $170 | $170 | $200 |
| 7 (72) | $200 | $170 | $200 |
| 10 (75) | $230 | $170 | $200 |
| Ten-year total | $22,200 | $20,400 | $24,000 |
The totals are the sum of twelve monthly premiums in each year. For attained-age, the monthly amounts are $140, $150 and so on up to $230, which add up to $1,850, and $1,850 × 12 = $22,200. For issue-age, $170 × 12 × 10 = $20,400. For community-rated, $200 × 12 × 10 = $24,000.
Three things stand out. First, the attained-age policy is the cheapest starter and, in this ten-year window, the middle one in total cost. Second, it crosses the issue-age price in year 4 and the community price in year 7, and from then on it is the most expensive per month. Third, the picture over a longer horizon is different. Extend the same invented pattern to twenty years, to age 85, and the totals become $56,400 for attained-age, $48,000 for community-rated and $40,800 for issue-age. The lowest first-year price is not the lowest lifetime cost. Real age curves are not straight lines, and the steps are usually bigger in some years than in others, so treat the pattern, not the figures, as the lesson.
Adding the second cause
Now add a general rate increase that applies to everyone. Say claims costs and medical prices push every version up by 5% a year, compounded. By year 4 the multiplier is 1.05 × 1.05 × 1.05, or about 1.158; by year 7 about 1.340; by year 10 about 1.551 (1.05 to the ninth power, because year 1 has no increase yet).
| Year (age) | Attained-age | Issue-age | Community-rated |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (66) | $140 | $170 | $200 |
| 4 (69) | $197 | $197 | $232 |
| 7 (72) | $268 | $228 | $268 |
| 10 (75) | $357 | $264 | $310 |
| Ten-year total | $28,528 | $25,659 | $30,187 |
Look at the issue-age column: the premium goes from $170 to $264, an increase of about 55% in ten years, with no help from aging at all. That is the point of the second table. If your premium keeps rising after the age-based steps are priced in, the pricing method is not the whole story.
What else pushes premiums up
Claims experience. Insurers set rates based on what they expect to pay for the group of people holding the policy. If more of them use care, the rate goes up. An old policy block can also get older as a group when new, younger buyers choose other policies, which raises its average claims cost. This affects all three methods.
Medicare's own cost-sharing amounts. Medigap pays the amounts Original Medicare leaves behind, such as the Part A deductible and the Part B coinsurance. When Medicare raises those amounts each year, the Medigap policy pays more in claims, and the premium follows. The Part B deductible in 2026 is $283, up from $257 in 2025, and the Part A inpatient deductible in 2026 is $1,736, up from $1,676 in 2025. Those increases flow into Medigap claims.
Medical prices and use. Higher prices, more outpatient surgery and new treatments all raise what Medicare and the supplement pay out.
Rate filings. In most states, insurers file their Medigap rates with the state insurance department, which reviews them. See rate review and state insurance department. Federal law also sets minimum loss ratios for Medigap, which require insurers to spend a set share of premium on claims. A regulator reviewing the filing can ask for support, but it cannot always prevent an increase.
Insurer decisions. Some insurers raise rates to keep pace with costs in small steps every year. Others hold rates for a time and then raise them sharply. The history on the same policy is a better guide than a sales promise, so ask for it.
To give the market context, KFF reported that Medigap premiums rose by about 7% on average between 2024 and 2025, and that the average Plan G premium in 2025 was $194 a month, with a range from $164 in New Mexico to $257 in New York. Your own premium, state and insurer will differ.
Working out which method you have
If the policy paperwork is long gone, your premium history can give you a first guess. Pull out the last three or four renewal notices or premium statements and write down the date and amount of each change. Then look at the pattern.
- Increases that land on or near your birthday, in similar steps each time, suggest attained-age pricing. The step is the age component, with the general increase layered on top.
- Increases that land on the policy anniversary or on January 1, and that are the same percentage for every member of the policy block, suggest issue-age or community rating. A letter will usually describe them as a rate adjustment for all policyholders.
- No increase for several years followed by a large one suggests an insurer that holds rates and then catches up, which is a different problem from the pricing method.
This is a guess, not an answer. The policy, the outline of coverage and the insurer's customer service line can confirm it. A short worked check helps decide whether the question is worth the effort. Say you pay $210 a month this year and last year paid $196. That is a $14 increase, which is $14 ÷ $196, or about 7.1%. If the notice says the general rate change was 4%, then 4% of $196 is $7.84, and the remaining $6.16 a month would be the age step. Subtract the general part first, and what is left is the effect of getting older. If nothing is left, your policy is not age-rated, and a quote for a different method is the only way to change the trend.
Two neighbors can pay different amounts for the same letter from the same insurer for exactly this reason. One bought at 65 on an attained-age basis and has watched the premium climb. The other bought a community-rated version and has seen only the general increases, at a higher starting price. Neither is a mistake. They bought different shapes of cost over time, and the shape is what the three methods describe.
How states differ
State law shapes which methods are available. A few states require community rating or limit age rating, so there the premium varies with where you live but not with how old you are when you buy. Many states allow all three methods. Some states have extra rules on when and how much a premium can rise, and Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin standardize their policies differently from the national model, which can change what is being compared.
A second difference is the switching rights described in medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue. Some states give existing policyholders a window around their birthday or another date to move to a different policy. The post Switching Medigap insurers to pay less without losing coverage lists those states. If you live in one of them, a rising premium is more fixable than it would otherwise be.
For the current rules where you live, ask the state insurance department or a SHIP counselor, because states revise their Medigap laws.
Is a rising premium a reason to switch?
Sometimes. The test is whether a new quote for the same letter, from an insurer that will accept you, is lower after you account for the pricing method and the future. Three cautions:
- A new attained-age quote at your current age may be higher than what you pay now if your current policy is issue-age.
- A new policy outside a protected window usually involves medical underwriting, and you could be declined or charged more.
- You may be giving up good history. A policy you have held for years, with a stable insurer, has value that a lower first-year quote does not show.
For the step-by-step version, read Switching Medigap insurers to pay less without losing coverage and use A checklist for comparing Medigap quotes from different insurers to line up quotes.
What to ask an agent before buying
- Which pricing method does this policy use, and where is it stated in the policy and on the quote?
- What is the premium now, and what would it be at ages 70, 75 and 80 if only age changed?
- How much has the premium on this exact policy increased in each of the last five years, and how much of that was general rather than age-related?
- Does the premium change on my birthday, on the policy anniversary or on January 1?
- Which other rating factors apply, such as tobacco use, gender, ZIP code, household or payment discounts?
- Does the insurer file rates with the state, and where can I see the filing or the complaint record?
- Is the same letter sold under a community-rated or issue-age version, and what would that cost today?
Write down the answers rather than relying on conversation. If an agent cannot say which method applies, treat that as information. The state insurance department can tell you whether an insurer's rate history or complaint record is public, and how to compare health insurers: ratings, complaints and service explains how to read it.
Key takeaways
- Attained-age policies start cheap and rise with age; issue-age policies start higher and stay flat for age; community-rated policies ignore age; all three rise with claims and medical costs.
- In the invented ten-year example the attained-age policy was cheapest at first and became the most expensive per month by year 8, and over twenty years it cost the most.
- Even a policy that never changes with age can rise by half in ten years from general increases, so ask for the rate history, not just the pricing method.
- States differ on which methods are allowed and on switching windows, so the state insurance department and a SHIP counselor are the people to ask.
- Compare quotes on the same letter, the same pricing method and a 10- to 20-year view, not only the first-year price.