Blog

Medigap Plan G or Plan N: which costs less in a good year and a bad one?

Plan N has the lower premium and Plan G the fewer surprises. A side-by-side table and a worked example show a quiet year, a heavy year and the break-even point.

Plan G and Plan N are the two Medigap letters people choose most often among the plans sold to newly eligible beneficiaries, and they are close cousins. Both pay nearly everything Original Medicare leaves behind. The differences are small and specific, and they point in opposite directions: Plan N usually has the lower premium, but you pay a few fixed copays and any extra doctor charges yourself, while Plan G has the higher premium and leaves you only the Part B deductible. Which one costs less depends on how much care you use and which doctors you see, which is why a single "good year" comparison misleads.

For scale, KFF reported that in 2025 Plan G was held by about 46% of Medigap policyholders, roughly 6.3 million people, and Plan N by about 10%, roughly 1.5 million. KFF also reported an average Plan G premium of $194 a month that year, ranging from $164 in New Mexico to $257 in New York. Premiums differ by insurer, age, ZIP code and state, so every dollar figure below is an invented round number, not a price.

What each plan pays, side by side

Medigap letters are standardized in most states, so Plan G from one insurer pays the same benefits as Plan G from another. (Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin use their own standardized sets, so confirm with the state insurance department if you live there.) The table covers the pieces that matter for this comparison. For the full chart, use the medigap plan comparison chart.

Cost Original Medicare leaves Plan G Plan N
Part A hospital deductible per benefit period Pays Pays
Part A coinsurance after day 60 and lifetime reserve days Pays Pays
Skilled nursing facility coinsurance Pays Pays
Part A hospice coinsurance Pays Pays
Part B coinsurance (the 20%) Pays Pays, except a copay of up to $20 for some office visits and up to $50 for an emergency room visit that does not lead to admission
Part B annual deductible You pay You pay
Part B excess charges Pays You pay
Foreign travel emergency care Pays a share Pays a share

Two rows deserve a closer look.

The Part B deductible. Neither plan pays it. It is $283 in 2026, and Medicare announces a new figure each fall. The 2027 amount had not been announced as of November 2026; check Medicare.gov before you plug in a number. Either way, it is the same under both letters, so it cancels out of the comparison.

Excess charges. A doctor who is enrolled in Medicare but does not accept assignment may bill up to 15% more than Medicare's approved amount. That extra amount is an excess charge. Plan G pays it, and Plan N does not. Many doctors accept assignment, so for some people excess charges are rare. In some states they are prohibited by state law. For others, they depend on the specialties they use. The guide Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N covers the idea, and the post What does it mean when a doctor does not accept Medicare assignment? shows how it appears on a bill.

What Plan N copays look like

The N copays are fixed amounts, not percentages. Up to $20 may apply to a doctor's office visit, and up to $50 to an emergency room visit when you are not admitted to the hospital. If the ER visit leads to admission, the $50 does not apply. These are ceilings: an insurer can charge less, but in practice you should assume the full amount when estimating.

Copays are small per visit and add up with frequent use. A person who sees a primary care doctor, two specialists and a physical therapist regularly could have dozens of qualifying visits in a year. A person who goes once or twice for a checkup pays almost nothing extra.

The arithmetic: a quiet year and a heavy year

Here are two labeled hypotheticals. All amounts are invented round numbers chosen to make the arithmetic easy to follow. Say a Plan G policy costs $200 a month ($2,400 a year) and a Plan N policy costs $150 a month ($1,800 a year) from the same insurer for the same person. The premium gap is $600 a year. In both years, Part A costs are identical under either letter, so they drop out.

A quiet year. The person has six office visits that carry a Plan N copay and no emergency visits. All doctors accept assignment, so there are no excess charges.

  • Plan G: $2,400 premium + $283 Part B deductible = $2,683
  • Plan N: $1,800 premium + $283 Part B deductible + 6 visits at $20 ($120) = $2,203

Plan N costs $480 less.

A heavy-use year. The person has 14 office visits that carry a copay, one emergency visit that does not lead to admission, and a specialist who does not accept assignment on $4,000 of approved services.

  • Excess charge: 15% of $4,000 = $600
  • Plan G: $2,400 premium + $283 deductible = $2,683 (Plan G pays the excess)
  • Plan N: $1,800 premium + $283 deductible + 14 visits at $20 ($280) + $50 emergency copay + $600 excess = $3,013

Plan G costs $330 less. Notice that the $600 excess charge alone equals the entire premium gap, which is why one non-assigning specialist can flip the result.

A hospital year. Suppose either person is admitted for a long stay. Both plans pay the Part A deductible, the daily coinsurance and the skilled nursing coinsurance, so the hospital bill is the same under both letters. The year then comes down to the Part B items above. A hospital year is not a reason to prefer one letter, though it is a reason to have some Medigap letter. The post A 70-day hospital stay with Medigap: who pays on which day? walks through one in detail.

A surgery year. People sometimes assume the Plan N copays apply to anything outpatient. They do not. Say the person has an outpatient procedure with a Medicare-approved amount of $10,000, billed under Part B. Without any Medigap policy, the 20% coinsurance would be $2,000 (after the deductible is met). Plan G pays that $2,000, and Plan N pays it too, because the copay applies only to office visits and to emergency room visits that do not lead to admission. In this year the two letters cost the same except for the premium gap, so Plan N is $600 cheaper before copays and excess charges. The same procedure without a supplement would have cost $2,000 plus the deductible, which shows what both letters are protecting against.

A person who has three or four such events in a year, such as a surgery, follow-up visits and physical therapy, may cross the line from "occasional" to "frequent" use. Count each visit type, because the copay applies to some and not others, and ask the insurer or the Medicare plan chart which of your expected services carry it.

Finding your own break-even

The break-even point is where the extra costs of Plan N equal the premium savings. With a $600 premium gap, the question is whether the copays and excess charges you would pay under Plan N total more than $600.

Here are four combinations, all hypothetical and all against the same $600 gap:

Year Copay visits ER visit Excess charges Plan N extras Result
A 6 ($120) none $0 $120 Plan N saves $480
B 15 ($300) 1 ($50) $0 $350 Plan N saves $250
C 20 ($400) 1 ($50) $150 $600 Break-even
D 14 ($280) 1 ($50) $600 $930 Plan G saves $330

To do your own version, take a recent year of Medicare Summary Notices, count the office visits, note any bill with an excess charge, and write down the real quoted premiums for both letters from the same insurer. Subtract Plan N's premium from Plan G's to get the gap. Then add up the copays and excess charges you would have paid under Plan N. If the extras are well below the gap, Plan N has been cheaper for you. If they approach it, the predictability of Plan G may be worth the difference.

One caution on the gap itself. It is not fixed. Premiums for both letters can change over time, and the gap between them can widen or narrow depending on the insurer's pricing method and claims experience. The post Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained explains why a premium that looks stable at 65 can look different at 75.

Other things the numbers do not capture

Doctor mix. If you have a long-standing relationship with a specialist who does not accept assignment, excess charges can recur every year. If your doctors all accept assignment, the Plan G advantage largely disappears. Call your doctors' offices and ask whether they accept assignment before you decide. Do not rely on a directory alone.

Predictability. Plan G leaves one known cost, the Part B deductible, after the premium. Plan N leaves a variable amount. Some people value the first because it makes budgeting simple. Others are comfortable with variability in exchange for a lower fixed cost.

Switching later. Moving from Plan N to Plan G outside of a protected window usually means answering health questions, and an insurer can decline or charge more. A person who picks Plan N in the six-month open enrollment period and later develops a health condition may find the move to G difficult. A person who starts on Plan G and wants to move to a cheaper letter faces little underwriting risk, because a plan with fewer benefits is usually easy to get. Read medigap timing mistakes: when the six-month window really starts for how the window works.

What neither covers. Neither plan pays for prescription drugs, dental, vision or hearing, or long-term custodial care. See What Original Medicare does not cover: gaps to plan for. Drug coverage needs its own plan.

Limits to the illustration. The example uses one insurer and one person. Real quotes include different pricing methods, discounts and rating factors, so only your own quotes will tell you the gap.

Who each tends to suit

This is a description of tendencies, not a recommendation.

Plan N tends to suit someone who uses care occasionally, whose doctors accept assignment, who has a monthly budget that is tight but a cushion for a few $20 copays, and who is comfortable with a small amount of variability.

Plan G tends to suit someone who sees specialists often, who has providers who do not accept assignment or who may need to travel for care, who wants a nearly fixed annual cost, or who would find a $600 excess charge hard to absorb. The premium is higher, so it also suits a person whose budget can carry that cost.

Neither suits someone who cannot afford either premium; in that case, ask a SHIP counselor about Medicare Savings Programs and other help, and see medicare premiums and deductibles: what you pay in 2026 and 2027.

Questions to ask before choosing

  1. What does each plan cost from this insurer, with the same effective date, and how is the premium rated?
  2. Do my current doctors accept Medicare assignment?
  3. How many office visits and specialist visits did I have last year?
  4. Do I live in a state with limits on excess charges?
  5. Am I inside my six-month open enrollment window, or would I face health questions later if I want to change letters?

A SHIP counselor, a licensed broker or your state insurance department can help check your state's rules. The numbers in this post are illustrations; your own quotes decide.

Key takeaways

  • Plan G and Plan N cover the same hospital costs; they differ on Part B excess charges, which Plan G pays, and on small copays, which only Plan N charges.
  • Plan N's premium advantage can disappear quickly: in the example, a single $600 excess charge equals the whole $600 annual gap.
  • To find your break-even, compare last year's visit counts and any excess charges against the real premium gap from your quotes.
  • Neither plan covers the Part B deductible, drugs, dental, vision or hearing.
  • Moving from N to G later usually involves health questions, while moving to a lower letter rarely does, so the choice you make in the open enrollment window carries weight.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic