Blog

How state rate review decides whether my premium increase is allowed

Follow one rate filing from the insurer's proposal to the regulator's decision: what reviewers can reduce, what they can't refuse, and where to read it

A renewal letter arrives with a new monthly premium that is far higher than last year's. The first reaction is usually to ask whether anyone checked that number. In the individual and small-group markets, someone did: the proposed rates went through a public review process months earlier. That process is called rate review, and it works differently from what most people expect. It does not hand the regulator a veto over every increase it dislikes. It asks whether the numbers behind the increase are reasonable.

This walkthrough follows one invented filing from start to finish. The percentages and dollar amounts are illustrations with round numbers, not any real insurer's proposal. The steps are real in outline, but the details vary by state, so each step ends with where to look in your own.

Who is covered by rate review

Rate review applies mainly to the markets where an insurer sells a policy at set rates to many people: the individual market (including marketplace plans) and the small-group market, which is coverage for small employers. See small-group plan for the definition. Large employers usually negotiate their rates each year based on their own claims experience, and those negotiations are not the same kind of public filing. Employers that pay claims themselves do not file rates with a regulator at all.

Medicare plans and Medicaid managed care follow different rules, which this post does not cover.

Who does the reviewing depends on the state. Many states review and approve or reject rates themselves through the state insurance department. In states without a qualifying program, the federal government reviews the filings. Either way, the same basic questions are asked.

Step 1: The insurer builds and files a proposal

A year or more before the new rates take effect, the insurer's actuaries start from what its members actually cost. They take its claims experience, project it forward and file the result with the regulator. In most states, filings for the next plan year arrive in the spring or summer, so that final rates are known before open enrollment begins in the fall.

A filing typically explains, in numbers:

  • How much members cost in the past period, and how many member-months that covers.
  • The projected medical cost trend: how much more the same care will cost next year because of price changes and the way services are used.
  • Changes to benefits, networks or provider contracts that would raise or lower costs.
  • Assumptions about the mix of people who will enroll, including whether they are likely to be sicker or healthier than the current members. This is where assumptions about risk adjustment and state reinsurance program programs enter, since both change what the insurer expects to pay.
  • Administrative costs, taxes and fees, and a target margin or contribution to reserves.

Where to look: your state's insurance department website often has a page for rate filings, and the federal government runs a rate review website that links to proposed increases in many states. Another common home for the full filing documents is a national electronic filing system that many regulators use. If you cannot find the filing, the state insurance department can tell you where it is.

Step 2: A worked example of how the numbers stack up

Say a hypothetical insurer, which this post will call the Example Plan, proposes an average increase for its individual-market plans in one state. Its actuaries justify the rise with three pieces:

  • Medical cost trend: 8%.
  • A sicker expected mix of members: 5%.
  • Benefit and network changes: 2%.

These pieces multiply, they do not simply add. Work through it: 1.08 × 1.05 = 1.134, and 1.134 × 1.02 = 1.15668. The filed average increase is therefore about 15.7%, not 15%.

For a member whose plan costs $600 a month before the change, the new premium would be about $600 × 1.15668 = $694.01, or roughly $694. That is the number that will appear in the renewal letter if the filing is approved as submitted.

The next steps show what could happen to that figure.

Step 3: The regulator checks the filing

Reviewers, who are typically actuaries working for the state, test the filing against standards written into state law. Most states ask the same three things in different words: are the rates adequate to pay expected claims so the insurer stays solvent, are they not excessive, and are they not unfairly discriminatory between members?

In practice this means reviewers:

  • Recalculate the base experience from the data in the filing and look for errors.
  • Compare the trend assumption to other filings, public data and their own analysis. If one insurer assumes 8% while the others assume 6%, the reviewer will ask why.
  • Check that the assumptions about the member mix are plausible.
  • Make sure the proposed rates follow the allowed rating factors (age, location, tobacco use for individual and small-group plans, and a few others) and no prohibited ones. Health status and sex cannot be used to set a premium in these markets.
  • Confirm the administrative and margin assumptions are within what the state treats as reasonable. The medical loss ratio floor sets a related backstop, as the post on Where does my premium dollar actually go? A tour of an insurer's costs explains.

Regulators often send written questions. The insurer answers them, and the filing is revised if the answers lead to different numbers.

Step 4: The public has a chance to comment

The federal rules call for public posting of proposed increases above a threshold, and many states post every filing. Several states take written comments from consumers, and a few hold public hearings. Comments cannot change the law, but they put real stories on the record, and a regulator can ask the insurer to explain a point a commenter raises.

If you want to comment, the state insurance department's site normally lists the comment deadline for each filing. For the plan year that starts in January, those deadlines usually pass long before the renewal letter arrives, so the time to act is spring and summer, not November.

Step 5: What happens next: approval, reduction or withdrawal

Three outcomes are common.

  1. Approved as filed. The reviewer finds the assumptions supportable.
  2. Approved with a reduction. The reviewer concludes that one or more assumptions are too high, the insurer agrees to lower them or the regulator has the power to order it, and the final rate is smaller than the proposal.
  3. Disapproved or withdrawn. The insurer refiles with different numbers, or in some cases leaves the market for that area. The guide on what to do if your insurer leaves covers that situation: what to do if your insurer leaves the marketplace in your area.

Take the Example Plan again. Suppose the reviewer's actuary shows, using other insurers' data, that an 8% trend is too high, and the insurer accepts 6%. The recalculation is 1.06 × 1.05 = 1.113, then 1.113 × 1.02 = 1.13526, so the approved average increase is about 13.5%. The member's $600 premium becomes $600 × 1.13526 = $681.16, roughly $681. The review saved this member about $13 a month. The saving is real but modest, which is typical. Regulators usually trim assumptions; they rarely cut an increase in half.

What regulators can and cannot do

Many consumers expect rate review to hold premiums down by decree. The reality is more limited.

What a regulator can usually do:

  • Ask for more data and delay a decision until the insurer provides it.
  • Reduce an increase if an assumption is unsupported.
  • Reject a filing that violates a rating rule.
  • Publish its findings so the public can see them.

What a regulator usually cannot do:

  • Refuse an increase that is supported by solid cost data just because it is large. If claims truly rose, the rates have to cover them, or the insurer may become unable to pay claims.
  • Change the underlying cost of care. Prices set by hospitals and drug makers flow through to claims.
  • Review each person's premium. The filing sets the base rates; your own premium then depends on your age, your area and the plan you chose.

The powers also differ by state. Some states can approve or disapprove a filing before it takes effect, while others can only review it after the fact, challenge it or make recommendations. Check your state's page through how to find your state's marketplace, regulator and local help or call the insurance department to learn which model it uses.

Five numbers worth finding in a filing

A filing can run to hundreds of pages, but a lay reader can get most of the story from five items. Look for a summary page, often called a rate increase summary or something close to it.

  1. The requested average increase and the approved average increase. If they differ, the gap shows what the review changed.
  2. The number of members affected. An increase that touches 200,000 people and one that touches 2,000 are different stories for the market.
  3. The trend assumption. Compare it with the other insurers' filings in the same state. A figure far above or below the others deserves a question.
  4. The expected change in the member mix. If the insurer says its members will be sicker next year, ask what it bases that on. In some recent years, insurers pointed to healthier people leaving after subsidy changes; that is an assumption to test against the enrollment data, not a fact to accept or dismiss on sight.
  5. The projected margin or reserve contribution. It shows how much of the increase is meant to cover claims and how much is cushion.

None of these numbers tells you whether to keep or leave a plan. They tell you whether the increase looks like a change in claims costs, a change in who is enrolling, a correction after a year when rates were set too low, or some mix. An insurer that underpriced one year often asks for a large correction the next, and a reviewer may accept it if the data support it. The post on why an insurer can lose money on marketplace plans, with three example insurers shows how that happens.

Why your own premium may not match the headline number

Three details trip up readers.

The average is an average. An 11% average can mean some plans rise 5% and others 20%, because insurers change plan designs, move people between products and adjust rates by area.

Your net cost may move differently. If you receive a premium tax credit, what you pay depends on the credit, which is tied to the second-lowest-cost silver plan in your area, the benchmark plan. When the benchmark rises, the credit usually rises too, so a subsidized buyer's cost can change by less than the sticker increase, or by more if the plan chosen is not the benchmark. The details are in How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share. As of November 2026, KFF reported that the average benchmark silver premium rose about 13% for plan year 2027, after about 26% for 2026, and that insurers attributed part of the increase to a sicker risk pool after the enhanced credits expired. Those are averages across the country, not a prediction for any one county.

State programs can change the base. Some states run reinsurance or similar programs that reduce what insurers need to charge, which is covered in how state reinsurance programs lower marketplace premiums.

A short action plan when a renewal letter surprises you

  1. Read the letter for the plan name and the new premium. Note whether the plan changed or only the price did.
  2. Find the filing. Search your state insurance department's website for the insurer and plan year, or ask the department.
  3. Read the summary. Look for the average increase, the trend assumption and any explanation of a change in member mix.
  4. Compare other plans before the enrollment deadline. The post on My marketplace premium jumped at renewal: what should I check first? lists what to check first.
  5. Complain if something looks wrong. If you think an insurer broke a rating rule, a state complaint is the route, covered in how to file a complaint with your state insurance department.
  6. Ask for individual help. A navigator, a licensed broker or a state insurance counselor can look at your plan and income; a tax professional can look at how the credit interacts with your return.

Key takeaways

  • Rate review applies mainly to individual and small-group coverage. It checks whether an insurer's assumptions are reasonable, not whether an increase is pleasant.
  • Pieces of an increase multiply, so 8%, 5% and 2% combine to about 15.7%, and a trimmed assumption flows through the same arithmetic.
  • Regulators can ask questions, reduce unsupported assumptions and reject rule violations, but usually cannot block a well-supported increase.
  • The time to comment on a filing is months before the renewal letter, and the filing itself is usually public.
  • Your own premium depends on age, area, plan and any credit, so the average increase is a starting point for comparison, not your bill.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic