Blog

Where does my premium dollar actually go? A tour of an insurer's costs

Follow one hypothetical premium dollar through claims, quality work, administration, taxes and margin, and see what the medical loss ratio can and cannot show.

Picture a first-time buyer, Priya, looking at a $500 monthly premium and wondering how much of it is for her health care and how much stays with the company. The honest answer is that most of it is not "hers" at all. A premium is a share of a pooled fund, and the fund pays for everyone's claims, including claims from people she will never meet. What is left after the claims are paid covers the cost of running the business, taxes, and, at a for-profit company, a margin.

The numbers below are an illustration with round figures. They are not any real company's results, and a real insurer's split changes by market, by year and by the kind of coverage. The point is to show the categories, what sits in each, and how to read the one ratio regulators publish about them.

One hypothetical dollar of premium

Say an insurer collects $1.00 of premium from members in the individual market. Here is one plausible way the dollar could be spent. These are invented, rounded amounts, chosen so the arithmetic is easy to follow.

Where the dollar goes Cents What is in it
Claims paid for care 78 Payments to hospitals, doctors, labs and pharmacies for covered services
Quality improvement 3 Care coordination, patient safety programs, help for people with chronic conditions
Administration 9 Claims processing, customer service, broker commissions, technology, provider contracting, compliance
Taxes and fees 5 Premium taxes and government fees tied to selling coverage
Margin or reserves 5 Profit at a for-profit company, or surplus that a nonprofit or mutual company holds back
Total 100

Check the sum: 78 + 3 + 9 + 5 + 5 = 100. Everything in the table is one pot of money. A change in one row moves another. If claims rise to 82 cents and the premium stays the same, the margin shrinks or the company has to find savings elsewhere. That pressure is why claims costs drive most premium increases, as the guide on why health insurance premiums rise every year explains.

Claims: the biggest slice

The largest share goes to claims, meaning what the insurer pays out for covered care. Two details matter for a buyer.

First, the claims slice is the insurer's payment, not yours. When Priya goes to the hospital, she pays her cost sharing (deductible, copays or coinsurance), and the insurer pays the rest of the allowed amount. Her own cost sharing does not come from the premium dollar. It is a second stream of money that goes straight to the provider. This is why a plan with a high premium and low cost sharing can look very different from one with a low premium and high cost sharing, even if both pay out about the same total in claims across a large group.

Second, the claims slice is set by what care costs and how much of it the members use. Analysts call the year-over-year rise in these costs medical cost trend. It includes the prices hospitals and drug makers charge, how often people use services, and the mix of treatments. An insurer cannot choose these directly. It can negotiate prices with providers, which is one reason networks exist, and it can manage how care is used through tools like prior authorization. Whether those tools help patients, hurt them or do some of each is debated, and the debate is not settled by looking at the premium dollar.

Quality improvement: a small slice that has its own rule

Federal rules let insurers count certain spending as part of the "medical" side of the ledger even though it is not a payment for a specific claim. The category is called quality improvement. It covers activities meant to improve health outcomes, such as programs that help members manage diabetes after a hospital stay, patient safety work and some health information technology.

Why does this matter? Because the rule lets an insurer count real care-coordination spending in the same bucket as claims. Critics sometimes say the category is broad enough to be gamed, and insurers answer that coordination programs do improve outcomes and cost real money. Both statements can be true in different cases. For a buyer the useful point is that "claims" and "quality improvement" together are what regulators treat as spending on members.

Administration: not the same as profit

Administration is the word that causes the most confusion. In everyday talk, "administrative costs" can sound like waste. In the insurance accounts, it is a catch-all for the work required to run a health plan:

  • Processing claims, which means checking that each bill matches a covered service, a network rate and the member's remaining deductible.
  • Customer service, member portals, mailing notices and the paperwork behind a grievance or appeal.
  • Building and keeping the provider network, including contract negotiation and keeping directories current.
  • Broker and agent commissions, which are usually paid by the insurer and built into the premium whether or not a member ever uses a broker.
  • Technology, security, compliance reporting and legal costs.
  • Marketing and enrollment campaigns.

Some of these costs help members directly (a claim paid correctly and quickly), some are required by law, and some are open to reasonable disagreement (how much a company should spend on marketing, for example). None of them is profit. A company with a 9-cent administrative row and a 5-cent margin row, like the example above, is spending almost twice as much on running the plan as it keeps as a margin.

That said, the reverse mistake is also common. Administration is not automatically efficient just because it is not profit. A cost can be non-profit and still be wasteful or reflect complexity the system itself creates, such as the work of checking authorization rules across thousands of plan designs. Supporters of the current system say these controls hold down claims costs. Critics, including some who favor a single national payer, say they add paperwork for both insurers and providers. A premium breakdown cannot settle that argument.

Taxes and fees

Part of the dollar goes to government before it ever reaches the margin. Insurers pay state premium taxes, which vary by state and by type of company, and some federal fees tied to selling coverage. The exact types and rates change with law and by state, so this post does not state any of them. If you want to know a particular state's rules, the state insurance department and the state's page on this site are the places to start.

Taxes matter to the next section because of how regulators measure the "medical" share. They do not count taxes and fees against the insurer when judging whether enough premium went to care.

Margin, surplus and who owns the company

The last row is what is left. At a publicly traded company it is profit that belongs to shareholders, may be reinvested or may be paid out as dividends. At a nonprofit or mutual company, which has no outside shareholders (see mutual insurance company), the same leftover is called surplus and is held to meet future claims and regulatory capital requirements. A company that has a bad year needs reserves in order to keep paying claims, so a margin is not only profit in the everyday sense. It is also the cushion that keeps the plan solvent. The guide on Types of health insurers explained: nationals, Blues and regional plans covers ownership types.

One caution: the margin in a given year can be zero or negative. If claims turn out higher than the insurer assumed when it set the price, the 5 cents disappears. The post on why an insurer can lose money on marketplace plans, with three example insurers walks through three examples.

The medical loss ratio, step by step

The medical loss ratio (MLR) is the number regulators use to ask whether insurers spend enough of premium on members. The rule that applies to the ACA's individual and small-group markets sets a floor of 80%, and for the large-group market the floor is 85%. See medical loss ratio.

The formula is:

MLR = (claims + quality improvement) divided by (premium minus taxes and fees)

Apply it to the hypothetical dollar above:

  • Claims plus quality improvement: 78 + 3 = 81 cents.
  • Premium minus taxes and fees: 100 − 5 = 95 cents.
  • MLR: 81 divided by 95 = 0.8526, or about 85.3%.

That insurer clears the 80% floor for individual coverage. It is also just above 85%, so it would clear a large-group floor too.

Now a second hypothetical insurer. Suppose it paid 70 cents in claims and 2 cents in quality improvement, with the same 5 cents of taxes and fees.

  • Claims plus quality improvement: 70 + 2 = 72 cents.
  • Premium minus taxes and fees: 95 cents.
  • MLR: 72 divided by 95 = 0.7579, or about 75.8%.

That is below 80%. To meet the floor, it needed to spend 80% of 95 cents, which is 76 cents. It spent 72 cents. The shortfall is 76 − 72 = 4 cents per premium dollar, and the insurer owes that amount back as rebates to the customers in that market. On a hypothetical $10 million of premium, a 4-cent shortfall would be $400,000 across all enrollees in that state and market. The mechanics of how the rebate is calculated and paid out, including the fact that results are averaged over several years and measured state by state, are covered in how a medical loss ratio rebate is calculated, with a worked example.

What the MLR does not tell you

An MLR is a useful check, but it is a blunt one. It cannot answer several questions a buyer might think it answers.

  • It does not say prices are fair. If a hospital charges more and the insurer pays more, claims go up and so does the MLR. A high MLR can come from high prices as easily as from generous coverage.
  • It does not measure care quality or the member's experience. A plan with an 88% MLR can still have a thin network or slow approvals.
  • It does not measure profit directly. Two companies with the same MLR can earn different margins depending on how much they spend on administration and what taxes they pay. A higher MLR leaves less room for both.
  • It does not capture every corporate structure well. When an insurer's parent also owns clinics or a pharmacy benefit manager, how payments to affiliated companies are counted is debated. Supporters say integration can coordinate care and lower cost. Critics say it can move margin into places the MLR does not reach. The post on What should I watch for if my insurer also owns doctors and a PBM? looks at that debate.
  • It applies by market and by state, over multiple years. An insurer might meet the floor overall and still owe a rebate in one state's individual market, or the reverse.
  • It is not the same as the risk-adjusted flows between insurers. Money that moves between plans through risk adjustment is accounted for separately and is explained in how risk adjustment moves money between insurers, and why members should care.

How a regulator checks the dollar

The premium itself is not set in a vacuum. In the individual and small-group markets, proposed rate increases go through rate review. The insurer files its assumptions about claims trend, administration and margin, and state or federal reviewers look at whether the numbers hold together. Many states put those filings online. If you want to see an insurer's own breakdown of how it built the rate, the filing is where the information lives, and the post on how state rate review decides whether my premium increase is allowed shows how to read one.

The MLR reports are public too. Insurers report them to the federal government each year, and the government publishes the results by company and state. The state insurance department is the person to ask if a particular company's numbers look odd.

Using the breakdown when you shop

The breakdown does not tell you which plan to buy, but it does give you a few better questions.

  1. Compare the plan's design, not just its price. A low premium with a high deductible shifts more of your own care costs onto you, as the guide on how health insurance works: who pays what, and when shows with examples.
  2. Ask who the insurer is. A nonprofit, a mutual company and a publicly traded company handle margin differently, though none of them is exempt from the MLR floor.
  3. Read the rate filing if a large increase arrives. The insurer has to justify its assumptions in writing, and you can read them.
  4. Do not treat a low administrative number as proof of a better plan. A plan that pays claims badly can look cheap on paper.
  5. Do not treat any margin as proof of a bad one. A company that cannot hold reserves cannot reliably pay your claims.

For questions about your own premium or a specific company's practices, a licensed broker, a navigator or the state insurance department can look at the actual plan and filing.

Key takeaways

  • A premium is a pooled fund. Most of each dollar pays other members' and your own claims, and your own deductible and copays are a separate stream.
  • Administration includes claims processing, broker commissions and compliance. It is not profit, and it is not automatically waste either.
  • The medical loss ratio divides claims plus quality spending by premium after taxes and fees, and the floors are 80% for individual and small-group coverage and 85% for large-group coverage.
  • A low MLR triggers rebates, but a high MLR does not prove prices are fair or the plan is good.
  • Rate filings and published MLR reports are the public records to check when you want evidence rather than impressions.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic