Blog

How do I judge whether a plan's network is big enough where I live?

A walkthrough for counting in-network doctors, hospitals and pharmacies near you, testing real appointment availability, and acting when the numbers are thin.

A network that looks large on a plan's website can be small where you live. The number that matters is not how many providers a plan lists statewide but how many of them are near you, are accepting new patients and will actually see you within a reasonable time. You can measure that with a directory, a notebook and an afternoon of phone calls, and the result is far more informative than a plan's marketing description.

This walkthrough goes from a blank page to a score for each plan you are considering. The illustrations use an invented household and invented counts to show the method, not to describe any real plan or area.

What "network adequacy" means in general terms

Regulators set rules about how big and how accessible a network must be. These rules are called network adequacy standards, and the idea is simple: a plan that sells coverage in an area has to have enough providers there. Typical measures include:

  • Distance or travel time to certain provider types, such as primary care, hospitals and pharmacies, often set differently for urban, suburban and rural areas.
  • Provider counts relative to the number of members.
  • Appointment wait times, such as a maximum time to a routine appointment.
  • Specialty coverage, such as having cardiology, oncology and behavioral health providers available.

The details vary by state and by type of coverage. State insurance regulators enforce standards for many plans. Marketplace plans have to meet the marketplace's certification rules, which may be applied by the federal government or the state. Medicare Advantage plans are measured against federal standards that use time and distance by type of county, and Medicaid managed care plans follow state standards. Employer plans that are self-funded are governed by federal law, and the state's standards may not apply to them at all. This is why the details can differ for two people living in the same town.

What the standards do not do is guarantee that your doctor, your hospital or your short list of specialists is in the network. A plan can meet its standard with a few clinics and still leave out the one you want. Think of the standard as a floor for regulators, and the steps below as the way you check your own situation.

Step 1: write down the care you actually use

List the people and the care.

  • Primary care doctors for each adult, and a pediatrician for each child.
  • Specialists you see now or expect to see (cardiology, dermatology, orthopedics, women's health, mental health).
  • Hospitals you would go to for an emergency, a delivery or surgery.
  • Urgent care centers, labs and imaging centers.
  • Pharmacies, including any specialty or mail-order pharmacy a plan requires.
  • Physical therapy, behavioral health and other recurring services.

Then pick a limit: how far you are willing to travel or how long a drive you will accept, for routine care and for urgent care. Many people choose something like a 20-minute drive for primary care and urgent care and a longer drive for specialists, but the limits are yours. Write them next to each item.

Step 2: count what the directory lists

Open each plan's online provider directory, enter your ZIP code and the plan's exact name, and filter for each type of provider. Record the count within your distance limit. Take a screenshot or note the date, since directories change.

Use this layout, filled in here with invented counts for a household in one ZIP code with two plans:

Need Plan A (listed) Plan B (listed)
Adult primary care 22 9
Pediatrician 8 3
Dermatologist 5 2
Physical therapist 12 4
Urgent care center 6 3
Hospital with an emergency room 2 1
Pharmacy 14 14

A first look says Plan A is bigger. But the directory is a list of claims, and the claims need testing.

Step 3: test the directory by calling

Directories are known to contain errors: providers who left the network, retired, moved, are not taking new patients, or do not accept the plan's particular product. A listing that is not accurate is sometimes called a ghost network problem. The check is a phone call, and a sample is enough.

Pick five listings per plan for each type of provider that matters most to you, starting with primary care. Call the office and say something like:

"I'm considering the [plan name, exact product name] plan. Are you in network with that plan for [year], and are you accepting new patients?"

Ask for the office name, who answered and the date. Then ask: "What is the earliest appointment for a new patient?" Record the answers. The directory lists my doctor as in network. How do I confirm before I enroll? has a longer script and shows what to keep if a directory turns out to be wrong.

For our invented household, here is the result of five calls per plan for adult primary care:

Plan A Plan B
Listings called 5 5
Confirmed in network 4 3
Confirmed and accepting new patients 3 1
Usable rate 3 of 5 = 60% 1 of 5 = 20%

Apply the usable rate to the original counts, as a rough estimate. Plan A: 22 listings times 0.60 is about 13 usable primary care offices. Plan B: 9 listings times 0.20 is about 2. A sample of five is small, and these rates could be higher or lower with more calls, so treat them as a signal, not a measurement. Still, a rough 13 against 2 is a different picture from 22 against 9.

Step 4: test how fast you can get an appointment

A network can be large and still slow. When you call, ask for the first available new-patient appointment and write down the wait in days. Record the average or the typical range.

In our example, the confirmed Plan A offices quoted waits of about three weeks, and the one confirmed Plan B office quoted about nine weeks. If you need a regular primary care doctor and a visit for a chronic condition, a nine-week wait may matter. If you rarely visit a doctor, it may not.

Do the same for the specialists you expect to need. Specialist waits are often longer than primary care waits, and the difference between plans can be large.

Step 5: check the hospital and the hidden pieces

For a hospital, check that:

  • The hospital is in the plan's network for the services you may need (the emergency room, maternity, a children's unit, cancer care).
  • The doctor groups that work in the hospital, such as emergency physicians, anesthesiologists, radiologists and pathologists, are in the network. These groups sometimes contract separately from the hospital. Federal law, the No Surprises Act, protects you from most surprise bills when an out-of-network provider treats you at an in-network facility, but it is better to know before you go. For emergencies, the law also protects you regardless of network.
  • Your labs and imaging center are in network, because a doctor's referral to an out-of-network lab can lead to a bill.

For pharmacies, check the plan's retail network and whether certain drugs must come through a mail-order or specialty pharmacy. For behavioral health, check separately; the network of therapists and psychiatrists is often smaller than the medical network, and see how to find an in-network therapist, and what to do when none exist for how to test it.

Step 6: score the plans

Add a simple score for each need. For example, give each item a rating of 0 (none usable), 1 (a few), 2 (enough). Weight each need by how often you expect to use it. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet provides a worksheet that organizes this, and how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network explains how to verify an individual doctor.

Here is the scoring for the invented household. The weights reflect how much the household expects to use each type of care: primary care 3, pediatrician 3, hospital 3, physical therapy 2, urgent care 2, dermatology 1, pharmacy 1. That is 15 points of weight in all, so the maximum score is 30 (15 times a rating of 2).

Need Weight Plan A rating Plan A score Plan B rating Plan B score
Adult primary care 3 2 6 1 3
Pediatrician 3 2 6 1 3
Hospital 3 2 6 1 3
Physical therapy 2 2 4 1 2
Urgent care 2 2 4 2 4
Dermatology 1 1 1 1 1
Pharmacy 1 2 2 2 2
Total 15 29 of 30 18 of 30

Plan A scores 29 of 30 and Plan B scores 18 of 30, which is 60%. The numbers do not make the decision, because a premium difference, a drug list and a deductible also count. They make the network visible, so the trade-off is stated rather than assumed.

If a plan scores 0 on something you are sure to need, such as the hospital where your child's specialist works, that is a reason to rule it out regardless of premium. A plan with more 2s and a higher premium may be a better value than a cheaper plan that leaves you driving an hour or waiting two months.

What to do if the numbers are thin

You have a few options, and they are not mutually exclusive.

  1. Compare a plan with a wider network. PPOs and POS plans often cost more but have more out-of-network benefits than HMOs and EPOs; see in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill. The extra premium may be the price of access.
  2. Ask whether the plan has a network gap exception. When no in-network provider can see you in a reasonable time or distance, some plans will cover an out-of-network provider at in-network cost sharing. The idea is described as a network gap exception, and the plan's rules govern how to ask. How I ask my plan to cover an out-of-network specialist at in-network rates describes the request.
  3. Check what a regulator can do. If the directory is wrong or the plan will not provide access, a complaint to the state insurance department is the route for most plans; how to file a complaint with your state insurance department shows how.
  4. Ask a navigator, broker or SHIP counselor. They know what plans operate in your area and how they differ. They do not charge you to answer questions, and the state or the marketplace can direct you to them.

A note about directory accuracy rules: in October 2026, CMS proposed a rule for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans starting in 2028 that would require directories to be verified at least every 90 days with accuracy scores published, and would have enrollees pay in-network cost sharing when a directory listing was wrong. As of November 2026 it is a proposal, with a comment period. It does not change anything for your 2027 decision, and plans outside Medicare Advantage are not covered by it. The point of mentioning it is that directory accuracy is a recognized problem, which is why you should test your own plan.

Special cases that change the count

Rural areas. Where there are few providers of any kind, a plan may have only one or two choices in a specialty, and standards for rural counties usually allow longer distances. In that setting, ask about telehealth for the specialties that allow it, and ask what transportation or travel help the plan offers, if any. A plan with a good network three counties away is not necessarily a good plan for you.

A move or a second home. If you split the year between two places, run the same steps for both addresses, because a network built around one region may not reach the other; I live in two states during the year. Which plan type will work for me? covers that situation.

Doctors who see you through a group. Some clinics are in the network as a group, and a doctor within the group may not be. Ask for the individual by name and ask the office which locations take the plan.

Mid-year changes. A network can lose a hospital or a medical group during the year. Ask the plan what its policy is on continuing treatment if a provider leaves, and keep the contract documents you were given when you enrolled.

A shortcut for a quick check

If you have only 30 minutes, do three things: confirm your primary care doctor and your hospital by calling, search the directory for the one specialist you cannot do without, and look at the count of primary care offices near you. A plan that fails any of those three is not worth more of your time.

Key takeaways

  • Network adequacy standards set a regulatory floor that varies by state and plan type; they do not guarantee your own doctors or hospital are included.
  • Count what the directory lists near you, then call a sample to find how many listings are usable and how long the wait is.
  • Check the hospital, the doctors who work there, labs, pharmacies and behavioral health separately.
  • If the numbers are thin, compare plans with wider networks, ask about a network gap exception, and use the state insurance department if a directory was wrong.
  • A navigator, broker or SHIP counselor can help with individual questions about plans in your area.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic