Blog
Mail order or my local pharmacy: which is cheaper for a 90-day supply?
How to compare mail-order, preferred retail and standard retail for a maintenance drug, with a worked table and what else to weigh besides the copay.
Picture a reader, call her Marta, who takes one blood pressure pill and one cholesterol pill every day and has for years. Her plan letter says she can keep filling at her local pharmacy, switch to the plan's mail-order pharmacy, or use a "preferred" retail pharmacy that has a lower copay. Each choice has a 30-day price and a 90-day price. Which is cheapest? The honest answer is that it depends on the plan's price list, and the only way to find out is to read three numbers and multiply. This post shows how, with invented round numbers, and then covers everything besides cost that can tip the choice.
Three kinds of pharmacy in one plan
Many plans sort pharmacies into groups that charge different copays for the same drug.
- Standard retail. Any pharmacy in the plan's network that is not designated preferred. It usually has the highest copay.
- Preferred retail. A smaller set of network pharmacies that agreed to lower reimbursement in exchange for more customers. Your copay is lower there. Which pharmacies count as preferred depends on the plan and can change from year to year.
- Mail order. The plan's mail-order pharmacy, which ships a 90-day supply to your home. Some plans own or contract with it, and the price for a 90-day fill is often set below three times the 30-day price.
Medicare Part D plans use the same structure, and the preferred-pharmacy difference can be large enough to change which plan is cheaper. If you are comparing Part D plans, the How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost and Preferred pharmacies in Part D: why my copay differs across the street cover that angle. The reasoning below works for employer and marketplace plans too.
Step one: get the real price from the plan
Do not guess from last year's receipt, and do not rely on the pharmacy counter alone. The price you pay depends on the formulary tier your drug sits on, the type of pharmacy, the days' supply and whether you have met your deductible. To get the number:
- Log in to the plan's member portal and use its drug price tool, if it has one. Pick the drug, the dose, the quantity and each pharmacy type.
- If the portal is not clear, call member services and ask: "What would I pay for a 30-day and a 90-day supply of this drug, at a standard retail pharmacy, at a preferred retail pharmacy and through mail order, given where I am on my deductible?"
- Ask whether the answer changes when the deductible is met. A drug that costs the full negotiated price in January may be a flat copay in June.
- Write down the date, the representative's name and any reference number, in case the price you pay later is different.
The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet has a place to record these quotes next to your doctors and hospital.
A worked example with invented numbers
Say a plan has the following price list for a generic maintenance drug on its lowest tier. These are illustrations, not real prices.
| Pharmacy type | 30-day copay | 90-day copay | Cost per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard retail, 30-day fills | $10 | not used | 12 fills x $10 = $120 |
| Standard retail, 90-day fills | not used | $30 | 4 fills x $30 = $120 |
| Preferred retail, 90-day fills | not used | $20 | 4 fills x $20 = $80 |
| Mail order, 90-day fills | not used | $20 | 4 fills x $20 = $80 |
In this plan, moving from 30-day fills at a standard pharmacy to 90-day fills there saves nothing, because the plan charges three times the 30-day price. Moving to preferred retail or mail order saves $40 a year per drug. If Marta takes two drugs on this schedule, that is $80 a year.
Now take a brand-name maintenance drug on a middle tier of the same plan.
| Pharmacy type | 30-day copay | 90-day copay | Cost per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard retail, 30-day fills | $45 | not used | 12 fills x $45 = $540 |
| Standard retail, 90-day fills | not used | $135 | 4 fills x $135 = $540 |
| Preferred retail, 90-day fills | not used | $100 | 4 fills x $100 = $400 |
| Mail order, 90-day fills | not used | $90 | 4 fills x $90 = $360 |
Here the gap is wider: $540 against $360 is a $180 difference for one drug. Notice the pattern. The cheaper channels are not cheaper because the drug costs less; they are cheaper because the plan has chosen to steer you to them with a lower copay. If your plan's price list looks like this, the arithmetic favors the 90-day fill at a preferred or mail-order pharmacy. If it looks like the first table, it favors whichever place you already like.
When the deductible changes the math
If you pay the full negotiated price until your deductible is met, a 90-day supply means paying three months of cost at once. Say your drug's negotiated price is $60 for 30 days, and you have a $1,000 deductible you have not yet met. A 90-day fill is $180 at the counter in January, not $60. If you pay the full price either way, the total over the year is the same: 12 x $60 is $720, and 4 x $180 is $720. The difference is cash flow. A big up-front fill can be hard in a tight month.
Two side effects are worth knowing. First, a larger fill counts toward your deductible faster, which is a benefit if you will meet the deductible anyway through other care. Second, if your dose might change, a 90-day fill risks wasted medicine: a leftover three-month supply you cannot use. Ask your prescriber how likely a change is in the coming months.
What to weigh besides the copay
Cost is not the only thing on the table. Here are the other factors, and which way each one cuts.
Urgent changes. Mail order is slow to adjust. If you are on a new drug, a dose that is being adjusted, or a drug your prescriber changes often, you are better off with a pharmacy you can reach by walking in. A reasonable approach is to start on 30-day fills at a local pharmacy, and move to a 90-day supply once the dose is steady.
Refrigerated or sensitive drugs. Some drugs must stay cold, and shipping in summer or winter can be a problem. Mail-order pharmacies ship these with packaging designed for the trip, but you need to be home or have a safe place for the box. Ask what the pharmacy does if a package is delayed or sits in heat or cold.
Shipping delays and missed deliveries. Mail order gives you more rope, and also more ways to run out. If the shipment is late and your last pill is today, the plan may have no quick fix. Reorder when you have a couple of weeks left, not a couple of days.
Pharmacist access. A local pharmacist can answer questions on the spot, check for interactions with an over-the-counter product you picked up, and notice if a refill is out of pattern. Mail-order pharmacies have pharmacists too, usually by phone. People who value that face-to-face contact often accept a higher copay for it, and that is a reasonable choice.
Plan requirements for maintenance drugs. Some plans have a rule that after a certain number of retail fills of a maintenance drug, you must move to mail order or a preferred retail pharmacy or pay more. This is not universal, so check the plan documents or ask member services. The rule is usually written in the benefits summary or the pharmacy section of the plan booklet. Missing it can mean paying full retail cost, or a higher share, without a warning.
Medication synchronization. If you take several drugs, many pharmacies can sync them to refill on the same date. Mail order does this too. A sync reduces trips and the chance of missing one pill, but it can reduce flexibility when one drug changes.
Prior authorization and step therapy. These rules apply no matter where you fill. A mail-order pharmacy cannot fix a missing approval. If a drug requires prior authorization, deal with that first.
Cash alternatives. Sometimes a generic is cheaper through a discount card or a store's cash price than through the plan. That is a separate decision with its own tradeoffs; see Should I use a drug discount card or my insurance at the pharmacy?.
Who each option tends to suit
Standard retail pharmacy tends to suit people who want one place to handle all prescriptions, are on short courses or drugs whose dose changes, and value being able to ask a pharmacist a question in person. It is also the default if the plan does not price the other options differently.
Preferred retail pharmacy tends to suit people who want a local counter and a lower copay and have a preferred pharmacy near them. The catch is that the list of preferred pharmacies can change from year to year, and a pharmacy you like may or may not be on it.
Mail order tends to suit people on stable doses of long-term drugs, people who find it hard to get to a pharmacy, and people for whom the lower 90-day copay adds up across several drugs. The catch is the delivery risk, and that it is poorly suited to drugs that change often.
Many people use more than one. A common pattern is to keep a new or changing drug at the local pharmacy and send stable maintenance drugs to mail order. Nothing stops you from doing this if the plan allows it.
Questions to ask before you switch
- What is my copay for this drug at each pharmacy type, for 30 days and 90 days, today?
- Does the price change after I meet my deductible?
- Does this plan require maintenance drugs to be filled by mail or at a preferred pharmacy after a certain number of fills?
- How long does the first mail-order fill take, and does the pharmacy contact my prescriber for a new prescription or do I?
- What happens if a shipment is delayed, damaged or exposed to heat or cold?
- Is my local pharmacy a preferred pharmacy in the plan this year, and will that be the same next year?
If you are not sure which choice is right, a navigator or the plan's own pharmacist-staffed line can walk through it. For a Medicare drug plan, your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor can compare pharmacies for free.
A short method for any drug
Write the answer to these four questions on one sheet of paper for each drug you take.
- What tier is it on, and is it a generic drug or a brand-name drug?
- What is the 30-day price at each pharmacy type, and the 90-day price?
- Have I met my deductible, and if not, what is the negotiated price?
- Is there a reason I cannot wait for shipping, such as a dose that is still being adjusted or a drug that needs refrigeration?
Multiply the per-fill price by the number of fills in a year for each choice, as in the tables above. If two choices are within a few dollars a year, choose the one that is easier to use. If they are far apart, the lower number is usually worth the small inconvenience, as long as the drug is stable and you can plan around delivery.
Key takeaways
- The cheapest channel is set by the plan's price list, not by the drug. Get the 30-day and 90-day price at each pharmacy type from the portal or member services, and multiply by fills per year.
- Some plans charge exactly three times the 30-day copay for a 90-day fill at a standard pharmacy, and less at preferred or mail-order pharmacies. In that case the saving comes from the channel, not the quantity.
- Before your deductible is met, a 90-day fill moves three months of cost into one payment. The total is the same; the cash flow is not.
- Cost is not the only factor: dose changes, refrigerated drugs, shipping delays, pharmacist access and plan rules for maintenance drugs can all outweigh a modest copay difference.
- Many people split: a local pharmacy for new or changing drugs, mail order or preferred retail for stable ones.